以AHP法評估海洋保護區的永續發展策略

Assessing the Sustainable Development of Marine Protected Areas with Analytic Hierarchy Process

10.6181/agec.2010.45.03

楊清閔(Ching-Min Yang)；李展榮(Zhan-Rong Lee)；陳清春(Ching-Chun Chen)

海洋保護區 ； 層級分析法 ； 永續發展 ； Marine protected areas ； AHP ； Sustainable development

農業與經濟

45期（2010 / 12 / 01）

53 - 88

繁體中文

劃設海洋保護區爲兼具保育海洋生物多樣性與永續利用資源的有效方法。但在社會、政治和環境的多樣化條件下，使立意良好的政策措施，因在不同利益群體間未有折衝平衡的考量，以致在執行時極具挑戰性與困難。爲能客觀分析各利益相關群體的立場，本研究運用專家式問卷、層級分析法及深入面訪方式，透過分析管理者、漁民、研究學者、浮／潛水遊客及當地業者等5個主要不同利益相關群組的觀點，用以解析與量化各群組在海洋保護區發展目標上的衝突立場與態度，評價海洋保護區的管理適當性與永續發展的策略。研究結果得知，各群組於保持生態系統的完整性、廢棄物與污染處理、統合管理等因子具有共識，而在法令界定禁止事項及執行管制措施因子上仍有衝突點。因之發展策略上應納入所有利益相關者的需求與利益，減少當地經濟壓力與反對，尋求一個可以被普遍接受的共同管理模式，以使海洋保護區得以永續發展。

Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) is a very effective approach for conservation of marine biological diversity and sustainable use of resources. However, under the varieties of social, political and environmental conditions, a well-intentioned policy of MPAs may be failing for no compromise measures, and the implementation of measures remains challenging. The data was collected through interview and questionnaires from five key stakeholder groups, using the Delphi Method and Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) to define compromise positions between stakeholders. This study analyzed and quantified the attitude of and conflict between the stakeholder groups for the sustainable development of MPAs. We aimed to evaluate the appropriate management and development strategies for MPAs. The results of the study showed that the stakeholder groups have consensus on ”ecosystem integrity maintenance”, ”pollution and waste treatment”, and ”integrated governance”. However,, conflicts exist on ”prohibits by laws” and ”enforcement procedure”. For future success of MPAs management, strategy for sustainable development should incorporate the needs and interests of all stakeholders to eliminate economic pressure for local residents.

1. Agardy, T.(2000).Effects of Fisheries on Marine Ecosystems: A Conservationist's Perspective.Ices Journal of Marine Science,57(3),761-765.
2. Angulo-Valdes, J. A.,Hatcher, B. G.(2010).A New Typology of Benefits Derived from Marine Protected Areas.Marine Policy,34(3),635-644.
3. Arin, T.,Kramer, R. A.(2002).Divers' Willingness to Pay to Visit Marine Sanctuaries: An Exploratory Study.Ocean and Coastal Management,45(2-3),171-183.
4. Beaumont, J.(1997).Community Participation in the Establishment and Management of Marine Protected Areas: A Review of Selected international Experience.South African Journal of Marine Science-Suid-Afrikaanse Tydskrif Vir Seewetenskap,18,333-340.
5. Boersma, P. D.,Parrish, J. K.(1999).Limiting Abuse: Marine Protected Areas, a Limited Solution.Ecological Economics,31(2),287-304.
6. Bohnsack, J. A.(1998).Application of Marine Reserves to Reef Fisheries Management.Australian Journal of Ecology,23(3),298-304.
7. Brown, K.,Adger, W. N.,Tompkins, E.,Bacon, P.,Shim, D.,Young, K.(2001).Trade-Off Analysis for Marine Protected Area Management.Ecological Economics,37(3),417-434.
8. Castilla, J. C.(2000).Roles of Experimental Marine Ecology in Coastal Management and Conservation.Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology,250(1-2),3-21.
9. Christie, P.,White, A.,Deguit, E.(2002).Starting Point or Solution? Community-Based Marine Protected Areas in the Philippines.Journal of Environmental Management,66(4),441-454.
10. Claudet, J.,Pelletier, D.(2004).Marine Protected Areas and Artificial Reefs: A Review of the Interactions between Management and Scientific Studies.Aquatic Living Resources,17(2),129-138.
11. Cocklin, C.,Craw, M.,McAuley, I.(1998).Marine Reserves in New Zealand: Use Rights, Public Attitudes, and Social Impacts.Coastal Management,26(3),213-231.
12. Crawford, B.,Balgos, M.,Pagdilao, C. R.(2000).Community-Based Marine Sanctuaries in the Philippines: A Report on Focus Group Discussions.Narragansett, R.I.:Coastal Resources Center, University of Rhode Island.
13. Crosby, M. P.,Brighouse, G.,Pichon, M.(2002).Priorities and Strategies for Addressing Natural and Anthropogenic Threats to Coral Reefs in Pacific Island Nations.Ocean and Coastal Management,45(2-3),121-137.
14. Davis, D.,Tisdell, C.(1996).Economic Management of Recreational Scuba Diving and the Environment.Journal of Environmental Management,48(3),229-248.
15. Dixon, J. A.(1993).Economic-Benefits of Marine Protected Areas.Oceanus,36(3),35-40.
16. Dixon, J. A.,Scura, L. F.,Vanthof, T.(1993).Meeting Ecological and Ecological and Economic Goals-Marine Parks in the Caribbean.Ambio,22(2-3),117-125.
17. Done, T. J.,Reichelt, R. E.(1998).Integrated Coastal Zone and Fisheries Ecosystem Management: Generic Goals and Performance Indices.Ecological Applications,8(1),S110-S118.
18. Ehler, C. N.(2003).Indicators to Measure Governance Performance in Integrated Coastal Management.Ocean and Coastal Management,46(3-4),335-345.
19. Elliott, G.,Wiltshire, B.,Manan, I. A.,Wismer, S.(2001).Community Participation in Marine Protected Area Management: Wakatobi National Park, Sulawesi, Indonesia.Coastal Management,29(4),295-316.
20. Francour, P.,Harmelin, J. G.,Pollard, D.,Sartoretto, S.(2001).A Review of Marine Protected Areas in the Northwestern Mediterranean Region: Siting, Usage, Zonation and Management.Aquatic Conservation-Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems,11(3),155-188.
21. Gell, F. R.,Roberts, C. M.(2003).Benefits Beyond Boundaries: The Fishery Effects of Marine Reserves and Fishery Closures.Trends in Ecology and Evolution,18,448-455.
22. Green, E.,Donnelly, R.(2003).Recreational Scuba Diving in Caribbean Marine Protected Areas: Do the Users Pay?.Ambio,32(2),140-144.
23. Hall, C. M.(ed.),Lew, A. A.(ed.)(1998).Sustainable Tourism: A Geographical perspective.UK:Addison Wesley Longman Limited Press.
24. Himes, A. H.(2007).Performance Indicator Importance in MPA Management Using a Multi-Criteria Approach.Coastal Management,35,601-618.
25. Himes, A. H.(2007).Performance Indicators in MPA Management: Using Questionnaires to Aanalyze Stakeholder Preferences.Ocean and Coastal Management,50(5-6),329-351.
26. Hockings, M.,Stolton, S.,Leverington, F.,Dudley, N.,Courrau, J.(2006).Evaluating Effectiveness: A Framework for Assessing Management Effectiveness of Protected Areas.Cambridge, UK:IUCN Press.
27. Indab, J. D.,Suarez-Aspilla, P. B.(2004).Community-Based Marine Protected Areas in the Bohol (Mindanao) Sea, Philippines.NAGA, WorldFish Center Quarterly,27(1&2),4-8.
28. IUCN(1994).Guidelines for Protected Areas Management Categories.Cambridge, UK:IUCN Press.
29. Kelleher, G.(1999).Guidelines for Marine Protected Areas.Cambridge, UK:IUCN Press.
30. Ko, T. G.(2005).Development of a Tourism Sustainability Assessment Procedure: A Conceptual Approach.Tourism Management,26(3),431-445.
31. Leung, P. S.,Muraoka, J.,Nakamoto, S. T.,Pooley, S.(1998).Evaluating Fisheries Management Options in Hawaii Using Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP).Fisheries Research,36(2-3),171-183.
32. Lin, T. Y.(2010).Role of Leadership in MPA Enforcement Success.MPA News,11(6),3.
33. Mardle, S.,Pascoe, S.,Herrero, I.(2004).Management Objective Importance in Fisheries: An Evaluation Using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP).Environmental Management,33(1),1-11.
34. Mendoza, G. A.,Prabhu, R.(2003).Qualitative Multi-Criteria Approaches to Assessing Indicators of Sustainable Forest Resource Management.Forest Ecology and Management,174(1-3),329-343.
35. Miller, G.(2001).The Development of Indicators for Sustainable Tourism: Results of a Delphi Survey of Tourism Researchers.Tourism Management,22(4),351-362.
36. Nielsen, J. R.,Mathiesen, C.(2006).Stakeholder Preferences for Danish Fisheries Management of Sand Eel and Norway Pout.Fisheries Research,77(1),92-101.
37. Pascoe, S.,Bustarnante, R.,Wilcox, C.,Gibbs, M.(2009).Spatial Fisheries Management: A Framework For multi-Objective Qualitative Assessment.Ocean and Coastal Management,52(2),130-138.
38. Pelletier, D.,Garcia-Charton, J. A.,Ferraris, J.,David, G.,Thebaud, O.,Letourneur, Y.(2005).Designing Indicators for Assessing the Effects of Marine Protected Areas on Coral Reef Ecosystems: A Multidisciplinary Standpoint.Aquatic Living Resources,18(1),15-33.
39. Pendleton, L. H.(1995).Valuing Coral-Reef Protection.Ocean and Coastal Management,26(2),119-131.
40. Pollnac, R. B.,Crawford, B. R.,Gorospe, M. L. G.(2001).Discovering Factors that Influence the Success of Community-Based Marine Protected Areas in the Visayas, Philippines.Ocean and Coastal Management,44(11-12),683-710.
41. Roberts, C. M.,Bohnsack, J. A.,Gell, F.,Hawkins, J. P.,Goodridge, R.(2001).Effects of Marine Reserves on Adjacent Fisheries.Science,294(5548),1920-1923.
42. Saaty, T. L.(1980).The Analytic Hierarchy Process.New York:McGraw Hill Press.
43. Sant, M.(1996).Environmental Sustainability and the Public: Responses to a Proposed Marine Reserve at Jervis Bay, New South Wales, Australia.Ocean and Coastal Management,32(1),1-16.
44. Scholz, A.,Bonzon, K.,Fujita, R.,Benjamin, N.,Woodling, N.,Black, P.(2004).Participatory Socioeconomic Analysis: Drawing on Fishermen's Knowledge for Marine Protected Area Planning in California.Marine Policy,28(4),335-349.
45. Soma, K.(2003).How to Involve Stakeholders in Fisheries Management-A Country Case Study in Trinidad and Tobago.Marine Policy,27(1),47-58.
46. Sumaila, U. R.,Guenette, S.,Alder, J.,Chuenpagdee, R.(2000).Addressing Ecosystem Effects of Fishing Using Marine Protected Areas.Ices Journal of Marine Science,57(3),752-760.
47. Suman, D.,Shivlani, M.,Milon, J. W.(1999).Perceptions and Attitudes Regarding Marine Reserves: A Comparison of Stakeholder Groups in the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary.Ocean and Coastal Management,42(12),1019-1040.
48. Tsaur, S. H.,Lin, Y. C.,Lin, J. H.(2006).Evaluating Ecotourism Sustainability from the Integrated Perspective of Resource, Community and Tourism.Tourism Management,27(4),640-653.
49. Wattage, P.,Mardle, S.(2005).Stakeholder Preferences towards Conservation Versus Development for a Wetland in Sri Lanka.Journal of Environmental Management,77(2),122-132.
50. 丁國桓(2004)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立臺灣海洋大學環境生物與漁業科學研究所。
51. 刀根薰(1993)。競賽式決策制定法─AHP入門。台北:建宏出版社。
52. 林佩蓉(2008)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立中山大學海洋事務研究所。
53. 張魁峰(2009)。Super Decisions軟體操作手冊─以ANP突破AHP的研究限制。台北:鼎茂圖書。
54. 黃書禮、翁瑞豪、陳子淳(1997)。台北市永績發展指標系統之建立與評估。都市與計劃，24(1)，23-42。
55. 黃國平、林振國、許慶祥(2004)。模糊理論與層級分析法之結合與應用。第一屆台灣作業研究學會學術研討會暨2004年科技與管理學術研討會論文集，台北:
56. 楊維楨(2009)。系統分析在經營決策上的應用。台北:五南圖書。
57. 鄧振源、曾國雄(1989)。層級分析法（AHP）的內涵與應用（上）。中國統計學報，27(6)，5-22。
58. 簡禎富(2005)。決策分析與管理。台北:雙葉書廊。

1. 劉明憲,曾憲郎(2019)。環境不確定下之海洋保護區長期均衡的模擬評估。應用經濟論叢，106，39-66。