题名

農地生態系服務價值指標之建構－網路程序分析法之應用

并列篇名

Using Analytical Network Process to Construct the Indicator Framework of Agricultural Land Ecosystem Services

DOI

10.6181/AGEC.202206_(65).0002

作者

謝敬華(Ching-Hua Hsieh)；陳添水(Tien-Shui Chen)；柳婉郁(Wan-Yu Liu)

关键词

農業多功能性 ； 生態系服務 ； 多準則決策分析 ； 網路程序分析 ； 農地價值 ； Agricultural multi-functionality ； Ecosystem services ； Multiple criteria decision making ； Analytic network process (ANP) ； Agricultural land vaule

期刊名称

農業與經濟

卷期/出版年月

65期（2022 / 06 / 01）

页次

27 - 61

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

本研究利用ANP建構臺灣不同種類農地之生態系服務指標架構，其中十二項生態系服務，水資源之水資源蓄存、水質淨化、緩減洪水氾濫；土壤資源之土壤保育、養分循環、植物修復；生物資源之生物多樣性、授粉∕種子傳播、病蟲害防治；大氣資源之空氣淨化、碳吸存∕減碳、調節微氣候。各項生態系服務對應七種土地利用類型，分別為旱田、水田、有機栽培、特用作物、造林地、魚塭地、畜牧地。架構分析各項生態系服務結果顯示，多數農地利用類型皆以生物多樣性與水資源蓄存具有最高權重值，以植物修復權重值最低。
英文摘要

This study uses ANP to construct an ecosystem service index framework for different types of farmland in Taiwan, including the following 12 ecosystem services: water storage of water resources, water quality purification, and flood mitigation; conservation of soil resources, nutrient cycling, and restoration of plants; biodiversity of biological resources, pollination/seed propagation, and pest control; air purification of atmospheric resources, carbon sequestration/carbon reduction, and microclimate regulation. Each ecosystem service corresponds to seven types of land use, including dry land, paddy field, organic cultivation, special crops, afforestation land, fish farm land, and livestock land. The results of structural analysis of various ecosystem services show that most types of farmland use have the highest weighted value for biodiversity and water storage, and the lowest weighted value for phytoremediation.
主题分类 生物農學 > 農業
生物農學 > 森林
生物農學 > 畜牧
生物農學 > 漁業
社會科學 > 經濟學
参考文献
  1. 王俊豪,方珍玲,陳美芬(2012)。農地多功能利用指標系統之建構。臺灣土地研究，15(1)，31-71。
    連結：
  2. 李承嘉,廖麗敏,陳怡婷,王玉真,藍逸之(2009)。多功能農業體制下的農地功能與使用方案選擇。臺灣土地研究，12(2)，135-162。
    連結：
  3. Affek, A.,Degórski, M.,Wolski, J.,Solon, J.,Kowalska, A.,Roo-Zielińska, E.,Grabińska, B.,Kruczkowska, B.(2020).Ecosystem Service Potentials and Their Indicators in Postglacial Landscapes.Amsterdam, Netherlands:Elsevier Press.
  4. Alhameid, A.,Tobin, C.,Maiga, A.,Kumar, S.,Osborne, S.,Schumacher, T.(2017).Intensified Agroecosystems and Changes in Soil Carbon Dynamics.Soil Health and Intensification of Agroecosytems,Cambridge:
  5. Alilou, H.,Rahmati, O.,Singh, V. P.,Choubin, B.,Pradhan, B.,Keesstra, S.,Ghiasi, S. S.,Sadeghi, S. H.(2019).Evaluation of Watershed Health Using Fuzzy-ANP Approach Considering Geo-Environmental and Topo-Hydrological Criteria.Journal of Environmental Management,232,22-36.
  6. Antognelli, S.,Vizzari, M.(2016).Ecosystem and Urban Services for Landscape Liveability: A Model for Quantification of Stakeholders’ Perceived Importance.Land Use Policy,50,277-292.
  7. Arsić, S.,Nikolić, D.,Mihajlović, I.,Fedajev, A.,Živković, Ž.(2018).A New Approach Within ANP-SWOT Framework for Prioritization of Ecosystem Management and Case Study of National Park Djerdap, Serbia.Ecological Economics,146,85-95.
  8. Avnery, S.,Mauzerall, D. L.,Liu, J.,Horowitz, L. W.(2011).Global Crop Yield Reductions Due to Surface Ozone Exposure: 1. Year 2000 Crop Production Losses and Economic Damage.Atmospheric Environment,45,2284-2296.
  9. Barnaud, C.,Couix, N(2020).The Multifunctionality of Mountain Farming: Social Constructions and Local Negotiations Behind an Apparent Consensus.Journal of Rural Studies,73,34-45.
  10. Bech, J.,Abreu, M. M.,Pérez-Sirvent, C.,Poschenrieder, C.(2012).Phytoremediation of Polluted Soils.Journal of Geochemical Exploration,123,1-2.
  11. Cheng, E. W.,Li, H.(2007).Application of ANP in Process Models: An Example of Strategic Partnering.Building and Environment,42(1),278-287.
  12. Chou, C. C.(2018).Application of ANP to The Selection of Shipping Registry: The Case of Taiwanese Maritime Industry.International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics,67,89-97.
  13. de Graaff, M. A.,Hornslein, N.,Throop, H. L.,Kardol, P.,van Diepen, L. T. A.(2019).Effects of Agricultural Intensification on Soil Biodiversity and Implications for Ecosystem Functioning: A Meta-Analysis.Advances in Agronomy,155,1-44.
  14. De Moraes Sá, J. C.,Lal, R.,Cerri, C. C.,Lorenz, K.,Hungria, M.,de Faccio Carvalho, P. C.(2016).Low-Carbon Agriculture in South America to Mitigate Global Climate Change and Advance Food Security.EnvironmentInternational,98,102-112.
  15. Dwivedi, P.,Alavalapati, J. R.(2009).Stakeholders’ Perceptions on Forest Biomass-Based Bioenergy Development in the Southern US.Energy Policy,37(5),1999-2007.
  16. Foley, J. A.,Ramankutty, N.,Brauman, K. A.,Cassidy, E. S.,Gerber, J. S.,Johnston, M.,Mueller, N. D.,O’Connell, C.,Ray, D. K.,West, P. C.,Balzer, C.,Bennett, E. M.,Carpenter, S. R.,Hill, J.,Monfreda, C.,Polasky, S.,Rockström, J.,Sheehan, J.,Siebert, S.,Tilman, D.,Zaks, D. P. M.(2011).Solutions for A Cultivated Planet.Nature,478,337-342.
  17. Food and Agriculture Organization(2020).FAOSTAT Analytical BriefFAOSTAT Analytical Brief,未出版
  18. Giannadaki, D.,Giannakis, E.,Pozzer, A.,Lelieveld, J.(2018).Estimating Health and Economic Benefits of Reductions in Air Pollution from Agriculture.Science of The Total Environment,622-623,1304-1316.
  19. Harkness, C.,Areal, F. J.,Semenov, M. A.,Senapati, N.,Shield, I. F.,Bishop, J.(2021).Stability of Farm Income: The Role of Agricultural Diversity and Agri-Environment Scheme Payments.Agricultural Systems,187,103009.
  20. Hatt, S.,Lopes, T.,Boeraeve, F.,Chen, J.,Francis, F.(2017).Pest Regulation and Support of Natural Enemies in Agriculture: Experimental Evidence of Within Field Wildflower Strips.Ecological Engineering,98,240-245.
  21. IPBES(2019).Global Assessment Report on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services.
  22. Jeevanantham, S.,Saravanan, A.,Hemavathy, R. V.,Kumar, P. S.,Yaashika, P. R.,Yuvaraj, D.(2019).Removal of Toxic Pollutants from Water Environment by Phytoremediation: A Survey on Application and Future Prospects.Environmental Technology and Innovation,13,264-276.
  23. Latif, A.,Malik, S. A.,Saeed, S.,Iqbal, N.,Saeed, Q.,Khan, K. A.,Ting, C.,Ghramh, H. A.(2019).Diversity of Pollinators and Their Role in the Pollination Biology of Chickpea, Cicer arietinum L. (Fabaceae).Journal of Asia-Pacific Entomology,22,597-601.
  24. López-Baucells, A.,Puig-Montserrat, X.,Torre, I.,Freixas, L.,Mas, M.,Arrizabalaga, A.,Flaquer, C.(2017).Bat Boxes in Urban Non-Native Forests: A Popular Practice That Should Be Reconsidered.Urban Ecosystems,20(1),217-225.
  25. Luo, Y. H.,Cadotte, M. W.,Burgess, K. S.,Liu, J.,Tan, S. L.,Zou, J. Y.,Xu, K.,Li, D. Z.,Gao, L. M.(2019).Greater Than the Sum of the Parts: How the Species Composition in Different Forest Strata Influence Ecosystem Function.Ecology Letters,22(9),1449-1461.
  26. Margles, S. W.,Masozera, M.,Rugyerinyange, L.,Kaplin, B. A.(2010).Participatory Planning: Using SWOT-AHP Analysis in Buffer Zone Management Planning.Journal of Sustainable Forestry,29(6),613-637.
  27. Maund, P. R.,Irvine, K. N.,Dallimer, M.,Fish, R.,Austen, G. E.,Davies, Z. G.(2020).Do Ecosystem Service Frameworks Represent People’s Values?.Ecosystem Services,46,1-10.
  28. Muralidharan, C.,Anantharaman, N.,Deshmukh, S. G.(2002).A Multi-Criteria Group Decisionmaking Model for Supplier Rating.Journal of Supply Chain Management,38(4),22-33.
  29. Nekhay, O.,Arriaza, M.,Luc, B.(2009).Evaluation of Soil Erosion Risk Using Analytic Network Process and GIS: A Case Study from Spanish Mountain Olive Plantations.Journal of Environmental Management,90(1),3091-3104.
  30. Ollerton, J.,Winfree, R.,Tarrant, S.(2011).How Many Flowering Plants Are Pollinated by Animals?.Oikos,120(3),321-326.
  31. Ozkaya, G.,Erdin, C.(2020).Evaluation of Smart and Sustainable Cities Through a Hybrid MCDM Approach Based on ANP and TOPSIS Technique.Heliyon,6(10),1-22.
  32. Peiris, C.,Gunatilake, S. R.,Wewalwela, J. J.,Vithanage, M.(2019).Biochar for Sustainable Agriculture: Nutrient Dynamics, Soil Enzymes, and Crop Growth.Biochar from Biomass and Waste,Amsterdam:
  33. Portillo, L. A. F.,Nekhay, O.,Mohedano, L. E.(2019).Use of the ANP Methodology to Prioritize Rural Development Strategies Under the LEADER Approach in Protected Areas. The case of Lagodekhi, Georgia.Land Use Policy,88(10),1-7.
  34. Saaty, T. L.(1996).Decision Making with Dependence and Feedback: The Analytic Hierarchy Process.Pittsburgh:RWS Press.
  35. Saaty, T. L.(2001).Decision-Making with Dependence and Feedback: The Analytic Network Process.Pittsburgh:RWS Press.
  36. Saaty, T. L.(2009).Applications of Analytic Network Process in Entertainment.Iranian Journal of Operations Research,1(2),41-55.
  37. Sandhu, H.,Wratten, S.,Cullen, R.(2007).From Poachers to Gamekeepers: Perceptions of Farmers Towards Ecosystem Services on Arable Farmland.International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability,5(1),1-12.
  38. Schaller, L.,Targetti, S.,Villanueva, A. J.,Zasada, I.,Kantelhardt, J.,Arriaza, M.,Bal, T.,Fedrigotti, V. B.,Giray, F. H.,Häfner, K.,Majewski, E.,Malak-Rawlikowska, A.,Nikolov, D.,Paoli, J.,Piorr, A.,Rodríguez-Entrena, M.,Ungaro, F.,Verburg, P. H.,van Zanten, B.,Viaggi, D.(2018).Agricultural Landscapes, Ecosystem Services and Regional Competitiveness-Assessing Drivers and Mechanisms in Nine European Case Study Areas.Land Use Policy,76,735-745.
  39. Starr, M.,O. Joshi,R. E. Will,C. B. Zou(2019).Perceptions Regarding Active Management of the Cross-Timbers Forest Resources of Oklahoma, Texas, and Kansas: A SWOT-ANP Analysis.Land Use Policy,81,523-530.
  40. Tang, H.,Takigawa, M.,Liu, G.,Zhu, J.,Kobayashi, K.(2013).A Projection of Ozone-Induced Wheat Production Loss in China and India for the Years 2000 and 2020 with Exposure-Based and Flux-Based Approaches.Global Change Biology,19(9),2739-2752.
  41. Telles, T. S.,Reydon, B. P.,Maia, A. G.(2018).Effects of No-Tillage on Agricultural Land Value in Brazil.Land Use Policy,76,124-129.
  42. The Economics of Ecosystems and Biodiversity(2018).United Nations Environment Programme ReportUnited Nations Environment Programme Report,未出版
  43. Ungaro, F.,Schwartz, C.,Piorr, A.(2021).Ecosystem Services Indicators Dataset for the Utilized Agricultural Area of the Märkisch-Oderland District-Brandenburg, Germany.Data in Brief,34,1-11.
  44. Veisi, H.,Liaghati, H.,Alipour, A.(2016).Developing an Ethics-Based Approach to Indicators of Sustainable Agriculture Using Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP).Ecological Indicators,60,644-654.
  45. Villanueva, A. J.,Gómez-Limón, J. A.,Arriaza, M.,Nekhay, O.(2014).Analysing the Provision of Agricultural Public Goods: The Case of Irrigated Olive Groves in Southern Spain.Land Use Policy,38,300-313.
  46. Wan, X.,Liu, X.,Du, Z.,Du, Y.(2021).A Novel Model Used for Assessing Supply Chain Sustainability Integrating the ANP and ER Approaches and Its Application in Marine Ranching.Journal of Cleaner Production,279,1-24.
  47. Wang, D.,Li, C.,Parikh, S. J.,Scow, K. M.(2019).Impact of Biochar on Water Retention of Two Agricultural Soils - A Multi-Scale Analysis.Geoderma,340,185-191.
  48. Wilhelm, J. A.,Smith, R. G.,Jolejole-Foreman, M. C.,Hurley, S.(2020).Resident and Stakeholder Perceptions of Ecosystem Services Associated with Agricultural Landscapes in New Hampshire.Ecosystem Services,45,1-10.
  49. Willot, P. A.,Aubin, J.,Salles, J. M.,Wilfart, A.(2019).Ecosystem Service Framework and Typology for an Ecosystem Approach to Aquaculture.Aquaculture,512,734260.
  50. Wolfslehner, B.,Vacik, H.,Lexer, M. J.(2005).Application of the Analytic Network Process in Multi-Criteria Analysis of Sustainable Forest Management.Forest Ecology and Management,207(1-2),157-170.
  51. World Bank Group (2020), “Agriculture and Food, Understanding Poverty,” https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/agriculture.
  52. Zolfaghary, P.,Zakerinia, M.,Kazemi, H.(2021).A Model for the Use of Urban Treated Wastewater in Agriculture Using Multiple Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) and Geographic Information System (GIS).Agricultural Water Management,243,1-11.
  53. 行政院農業委員會(2019).「農業及農地資源盤查結果查詢圖台，盤查資料項目清單」。https://map.coa.gov.tw/farmland/data/datalist.html。
  54. 張魁拳(2017).Super Decisions軟體操作手冊一以ANP突破AHP的研究限制.臺北:鼎茂圖書出版股份有限公司.
  55. 簡禎富(2015).決策分析與管理─紫式決策分析以全面提升決策品質.臺北:雙葉書廊有限公司.
  56. 蘇暐竣(2018)。國立屏東大學文化創意產業學系。
print cancel