大學生情侶對“薩堤爾模式”溝通方案的改變知覺及改變影響來源之研究

A Study of the Perceptions of Change on Satir Model Communication Program with University Student Couples

10.6251/BEP.20060203

莊雅婷(Ya-Ting Juang)；陳秉華(Ping-Hua Chen)

大學生情侶 ； 共識分析法 ； 改變的知覺 ； 薩堤爾模式 ； CQR ； Satir Model ； perceptions of change ； university students couples

教育心理學報

37卷3期（2006 / 03 / 01）

297 - 317

繁體中文

本研究旨在探索五對異性戀大學生情侶參加「薩堤爾模式」溝通方案後，成員知覺個人的改變、及其知覺改變的影響來源。五對大學生情侶經由研究者招募，自願報名參加，以連續兩天密集十五小時的工作坊型式進行，於團體結束後一週內以訪談法蒐集成員改變的資料，並以Hill et al. (2005)共識分析研究法進行資料分析。研究結果發現：（一）多數成員知覺自己的改變為「舊有的規則鬆動且增加新的因應方式」、「對過去不當的因應模式有新的覺察」、增加「正向的自我概念」；少數成員知覺自己的改變為「覺察及表達自己的需要」、「對於感情經營有新的決定」、「覺察問題的癥結在自己身上」、「增加尊重和接納」、「以新觀點來看待對方」、「期待控制自己的情緒」等；其中出現「對於感情經營有新的決定」的知覺者均為男性；而出現「以新觀點來看待對方」之知覺者均為女性。（二）少數成員知覺對方的改變為「更主動表達感情」。（三）少數成員知覺兩人關係的改變為「衝突減少」、採取「直接溝通」、彼此間的「安全感增加」，而出現知覺「直接溝通」之改變者均為男性。（四）多數成員知覺「團體中的觀察學習」、「領導者的領導」、「團體活動演練」、「對方的改變牽動關係改變」是出自於自己改變；少數成員知覺「團體提供兩人討論的空間」、「成員的分享與支持回饋」、「團體中的普遍性」為自己改變的因素。（五）少數成員知覺「團體活動的演練」是出自於對方改變。（六）少數成員知覺影響兩人關係的改變來自於「自己的改變而帶動關係改變」。最後根據上述結果加以討論，提出對未來實際應用與進一步研究的建議。

This research examines the personal perceptions of change of University student couples who participated in a Satir Model communication program. This study involved five university student couples as subjects of study. A fifteen hour workshop of communication based on Satir Model was conducted. After the workshop the researcher interviewed the participants individually within a week to collect data about their perceptions of change as caused by the workshop. The Consensus Quality Research (CQR) method of Hill et al. (2005), a qualitative data analysis method, was adopted. Perceptions of change and sources of changes are categorized using the methods and procedures of CQR. The results are as follows: (1)The majority of participants perceived: the shaking of old rules and the increase of new coping approaches, the impropriety of past coping modes, and the enhancement of positive self concepts; (2) Some participants perceived that their mates became more active in expressing themselves; (3) Some participants perceived decreased conflicts in relationships, more direct communication between mates, and an increased sense of security; (4) The majority of participants perceived that their own changes lead to the changes in observational learning in groups, the leadership of the group leader, the group exercises, and the reciprocal changes from the mate; (5) Some participants noted that their mate's changes caused changes in group exercise experiences; (6) Some participants regarded the changes in mate relationships as stemming from their own changes. Finally, the researcher discusses the results and makes some suggestions with regards to the counseling practice and further studies.

1. Bagayozzi, D. A.,Bagayozzi, J. I.(1982).A theoretically derived model of premarital intervention: The building of family system.Clinical Social Work Journal,10(1),52-64.
2. Banmen, J.(2002).Introduction: Satir model today.Contemporary Family Therapy,24(1),7-22.
3. Banmen, J.(2002).Yesterday and today.Contemporary Family Therapy: An International Journal,24(1),7-22.
4. Bitter, J. R.(1993).Communication styles, personality priorities, and social interest: Strategies for helping couples build a life together.Individual Psychology Journal of Adlerian Theory, Research and Practice,49(3-4),330-350.
5. Boisvert, J. M.,Ladoucdur, R.,Freeston, M. H.,Tu rgeno, L.,Tardif, C.,Roussy, A.,Loranger(1994).Perception of marital problems and of their prevention by Quebec young adults.The Journal of Genetic Psychology,156(1),33-44.
6. Bozeman, J. C.(1985).An investigation of Virginia Satir`s concept of communication to determine possible implications for education in marital communication.Dissertation Abstracts International,46(3),663.
7. Brian, D. D.,Lorelei, E. S.,Anderw C.(2004).Why do couples seek marital therapy?.Professional Psychology: Research and Practice,35(6),608-614.
8. Chan, P.(1996).The application of the Satir model of family therapy to the families in Hong Kong: A personal reflection.Contemporary Family Therapy,18(4),489-505.
9. Chen, P.,Tsai, S.,Lai, N.(2001).The construction of a process-change model of unmet expectations based on the Satir model.Asian Journal of Counselling,8(1),5-34.
10. Chopman, A. H.(1974).Satisfaction with various aspects of marriage over the life sample.Journal of Marriage and the Family,26(2),29-37.
11. Elizabeth, A. S.,Donald, H. B.,Charles, K. B.,Elizebeth S. A.,Lynelle R.(2003).Altering the course of marriage: The effect of PREP communication skills acquisition on couples` risk of becoming martially distressed.Journalof Family Psychology,17(1),41-53.
12. Englander-Golden, P.,Golden, E. D.(1996).The impact of Virginia Satir on prevention of destructive behaviors and promotion of wellness.Journal of Couples Therapy,6(3/4),69-93.
13. Englander-Golden, P.,Satir, V.(1991).Say is straight: From compulsion to choices.Palo Alto, CA:Science & Behavior Books.
14. Epstein, N.,Pretzer, J. L.,Heming., B.(1982).Cognitive therapy and communication training: Comparison of effects with distressed couples.Paper presented at the meeting of the Association of Advancement of Behavior Therapy,Los Angeles:
15. Feld, B. G.(2003).Phases of couples group therapy: A consideration of therapeutic action.Group,27(1),5-19.
16. Fowers, B. J.,Olson, D. H.(1986).Predicting martial success with PRER: A predictive validity study.Jounrnal of Marital and the Family Therapy,12,403-413.
17. Geiss, S. K.,O`Leary, K. D.(1981).Therapist ratings of frequency and severity of marital problems: Implications for research.Journal of Marital of Family Therapy,7,515-520.
18. Gross, J. S.(1994).The process of chang: Variation a theme by Virginia Satir.Journal of Humanistic Psychology,34(3),87-110.
19. Guerney, B. G.(1977).Relationship Enhancement.San Francisco:Jossey-Bass.
20. Hahlweg, K.,Markman H. J.(1988).Effectiveness of behavioral marital therapy: Empirical status of behavioral techniques in preventing and alleviating martial distress.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,56,440-447.
21. Halford, W. K.,Sanders, M. R.,Behrens,Brett, C.(2001).Can skills training prevent relationship problems in at-risk couples? Four-year effects of a behavioral relationship education program.Journal of Family Psychology,15(4),750-768.
22. Hill, C. E.,Knox, S.,Thompson, B. J.,Williams, E. N.,Hess, S. A.,Ladany, N.(2005).Consensual qualitative research: An update.Journal of Counseling Psychology,52(2),196-205.
23. Hill, C. E.,Thompson, B. J.,Williams, E. N.(1997).A guide to conducting consensual qualitative research.The Counseling Psychologist,25,517-572.
24. Honeycutt, J. M.(1986).A model of marital functioning based an attractive paradigm and social penetration dimension.Journalof Marriage and the Family,48,651-663.
25. Markman, J. H.,Renick, R. J.,Floyd, J. F.,Stanley, M. S.,Clements, M.(1993).Preventing marital distress through communication and conflict management training: A 4-and 5-year follow-up.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,16(1),70-77.
26. McLananhan, P.(1988).Family strucure and dependency: Reproducing the femaleheaded family.Demography,25,1-17.
27. Neff, L. A.,Karney, B. R.(2005).To know you is to love you: The implications of global adoration and specific accuracy for marital relationships.Journal of Personality & Social Psychology,88(3),480-497.
28. Ohlsen, M. M.(1979).Marriage Counseling in Groups.Champaign Reseach Press.
29. Pan, J. D.(2000).The effectiveness of structured and semistructured Satir model groups on family relationships with college students in Taiwan.Journal for Specialists in Group Work,25(3),305-318.
30. Russell, H.(2002).Virginia Satir: An intergratied, humanistic approach family therapy.Contemporary Family Therapy,24(1),23-34.
31. Sanders, M. R.,Halford, W. K.,Behrens, B. C.(1999).Parental divorce and premarital couple communication.Journal of Family Psychology,13,60-74.
32. Satir, V.(1988).The new peoplemaking.Palo Alto, CA:Science & Behvior Books.
33. Satir, V.,Baldwin, M.(1983).Satir sep by step: A guide to creating change in families.Pato Alto, CA:Science & Behavior Books.
34. Satir, V.,Banmen, J.,Gerber, J.,Gomori, M.(1991).The Satir model-Family therapy and beyond.CA:Science and Behavior Books, Inc.
35. Stahman R. F.,Hiebert(1987).Premarital counseling: The professional handbook.Lexington, MA:Lexington Books.
36. Stahmann, R. F.(2000).Premarital counseling: A focus for family therapy.Journal of Family Therapy,22,104-116.
37. Wach, K. H.(1992).Early marriage enrichment.Dissertation Abstracts International,55(11),5052.
38. Weiss, R. L.,Heyman, R. E.,W. K. Halford,H. J. Markman (Eds.)(1997).Clinical handbook of marriage and couples interventions.ChiChester, OK:Wiley.
39. Wiener, D. J.(1999).Beyond talk therapy: Using movement and expressive techniques in clinical practice.Washington, DC:American Psychological Association.
40. Willett, L. C.(1996).Using instructional videotape to teach couples communication, conflict-resolution, and problem-solving.Dissertation Abstracts International,57(12),5067.
41. Worthington, L. E.,McCullough, E. M.,Shortz. M. J.,Mindes, J. E.,Sandage, J. S.,Chartrand, M. J.(1995).Handbook of psychotherapy and behavior change.New York:Wiley.
42. 生命線全球資訊網
43. 台灣師範大學學輔中心(2004)。國立台灣師範大學學輔中心九十二學度工作報告。
44. 吳就君譯、SATIR, V.(1993)。與人接觸。台北:張老師文化。
45. 卓紋君(2000)。從兩性關係發展的模式談兩性親密關係的分與合。輔導季刊，36(2)，31-44。
46. 教育部全球資訊網
47. 莊雅婷(1999)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立台灣師範大學教育心理與輔導研究所。
48. 陳秉華(2000)。諮商中未滿足期待轉換歷程的建構。學生輔導通訊雙月刊，68，84-97。
49. 陳奕良(2001)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立高雄師範大學。
50. 楊雅惠(1995)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立台灣師範大學教育心理與輔導研究所。
51. 楊蓓(1997)。自在溝通－EQ成長的泉源活水。台北:洪建全教育文化基金會。
52. 賴念華(2001)。薩堤爾模式－治療師探索案主冰山的引導方式。輔導季刊，37(1)，46-50。

1. 陳奕吟、卓紋君(2017)。夫妻原生家庭溝通姿態、婚姻溝通姿態、婚姻調適策略與婚姻滿意度之對偶分析。諮商心理與復健諮商學報，31，7-51。
2. 劉芷萱,高于涵,李郁婷(2021)。從「茉莉的最後一天」看家庭溝通型態。諮商與輔導，424，34-37+16。
3. 孫頌賢(2019)。愛情練習曲：未婚伴侶在情緒取向伴侶諮商的經驗研究。應用心理研究，71，137-181。