具體影像空間教學策略與中學生空間能力之相關研究

Effects of the CISC Instructional Strategy on the Spatial Ability of Junior High Students

10.6251/BEP.20060412

林小慧(Hsiao-Hui Lin)；熊召弟(Chao-Ti Hsiung)；林世華(Sieh-Hwa Lin)

具體影像空間教學策略 ； 心像 ； 空間能力 ； 空間概念 ； Concrete Image Spatial Concepts CISC instructional strategy ； mental image ； spatial ability ； spatial concepts

教育心理學報

37卷4期（2006 / 06 / 01）

393 - 409

繁體中文

本研究旨在探討具體影像空間教學策略(CISC)對中學生空間能力的影響。參與研究對象為台北縣125位國中二年級學生，經由分配成實驗組（CISC教學）及對照組（無CISC教學）。所有學生均接受「空間能力測驗工具」的前測及後測，以檢驗CISC教學策略對中學生空間能力影響的成效。研究結果以單因子共變數分析進行處理。本研究主要發現：l、實驗組受試學生之空間能力表現優於對照組。2、實驗組低、中、高成就組學生其空間能力並無差異。依據統計結果發現，CISC策略不僅能提升學習者心像操作能力，使二維與三維表徵產生互動，並能透過辨認轉換以洞悉複雜抽象之化學分子結構，減少學習者的認知負荷，且能降低抽象概念的複雜度，有助於學生建構正確心像，以利科學概念的理解。

The purpose of this study was to investigate the effect of the Concrete Image Spatial Concepts (CISC) instructional strategy on the spatial ability of junior high students. The sample consisted of 125 junior high eighth-grade students in the Taipei area. The participants were assigned to three groups. The experimental group received a 3-week CISC treatment, whereas the two control groups received a 3-week non-CISC teaching. The Spatial Ability Test was used in the pre- and post-test. The results showed significant difference in spatial ability among the three groups, and the spatial ability of the experiment group was better than the control groups. But no significant difference was found among the low, medium and high achievement students in the experimental group. From the qualitative data collected in field observations, it was observed that CISC not only elevated the learners' operational abilities with mental images but also catalyzed the interactions between 2D/3D representations. It appears that CISC strategy is functional in lowering students' cognitive load and the complexity of abstract concepts. CISC has also demonstrated its effectiveness in elevating students' spatial ability through ease in mental image construction.

1. 邱美虹、高淑芬(1999)。類比對應對學生建構“原子結構”心智表徵之影響。師大學報，44(1、2)，31-59。
   連結：
2. Baker, S. R.,Talley, L.(1972).The relationship of visualization skills to achievement in freshman chemistry.Journal of Chemistry Education,49(11),775-777.
3. Barke, H. D.(1993).Chemical education and spatial ability.Journal of Chemical Education,70,968-971.
4. Barke, H. D.,Engida, T.(2001).Structural chemistry and spatial ability different cultures.Chemistry Education: Research and practice in Europe,2(3),227-239.
5. Bishop, J. E.(1978).Developing students` spatial ability.Science Teacher,45(8),20-23.
6. Bodner, G. M.,Cutler, A. R.,Greenbowe, T. J.,Robinson, W. R.(1984).Multi-images or lap-dissolve slide techniques and visual images in the large lecture section.Journal of Chemical Education,61(5),447-449.
7. Bodner, G. M.,Guay, R. B.(1997).The purdue visualization of rotations test.The Chemical Educator,2(4),118.
8. Carter, C. S.,LaRussa, M. A.,Bonder, G. M.(1987).A study of two measures of spatial ability as predictors of success in different levels of general chemisty.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,24(7),645-657.
9. Coleman, S. L.,Gotch, A. J.(1998).Spatial perception skills of chemistry students.Journal of Chemical Education,75(2),206-209.
10. Gabel, D. L.,Sherwood, R. D.(1980).The effect of student manipulateion of molecular model on chemistry achievement according to piagetian level.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,17(1),75-81.
11. Gibson, E. J.(1971).The information available in pictures.Leonardo,4,27-35.
12. Goodman, N.(1968).Languages of art: An approach to a theory of symbols.Indianapolis, IN:Bobbs-Merrill.
13. Holford, D. G.,Kempa, R. F.(1970).The effectiveness of stereoscopic viewing in the learning of spatial relationships in structural chemistry.Joural of Research in Science Teaching,7(3),265-270.
14. Kosslyn, S. M.(1981).Research on mental imagery: Some goals and direction.Cognition,10,173-179.
15. Lohman, D. F.(1979).Spatial abilities: A review and re-analysis of the correlateional literature (Technical Report No. 8).Standford University, Aptitude Research project, Stanford, CA..
16. Lohman, D. F.,R. J. Sternberg (Ed.)(1988).Advances in the psychology of human intelligence 4.Hillsdale, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum.
17. Lord, T. R.(1985).Enhancing the visuo-spatial aptitude of students.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,22(5),395-405.
18. Lord, T. R.(1987).A look at spatial abilities in undergraduate women science majors.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,24(8),757-767.
19. Macnab, W.,Johnstone, A. H.(1990).Spatial skills which contribute to competence in the biological science.Journal of Biological Education,24(1),37-41.
20. McGee, M.(1979).Human spatial abilityies, psychometric studies and environmental, genetic, hormonal, and neurological influences.Psychological Bulletin,86,889-918.
21. Nicholson, J. R.,Seddon, G. M.,Worsnop, J. G.(1977).Teaching the understanding of pictorial spatial relationships to Nigerian secondary school students.Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology,8,401-414.
22. Pallrand, G. J.,Seeber, F.(1984).Spatial ability and achievement in introductory physics.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,22(5),507-516.
23. Pellegrino, J. W.,Kail, R.,R. J. Sternberg (Eds.)(1982).Advances in the psychology of human intelligence.Hillsdale, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum.
24. Pribyl, J. R.,Bodner, G. M.(1987).Spatial ability and its role in organic chemistry: A study of four organic courses.Journal of Research in Science Teaching,24(3),229-240.
25. Rochford, K.(1987).Underachievement of spatially handicapped chemistry students in an academic support program.Paper presented the staff of the Department of Education, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY.
26. Rohr, M.,Reimann, P.,van M. W. Someren,P. Reimann,H. P. A. Boshuizen,T. de. Jong (Eds.)(1998).Advances in learning and instruction series learning with multiple representations.Oxford, England:Elsevier Science Ltd.
27. Rozzelle, A. A.,Rosenfeld, S. M.(1985).Stereoscopic projection in organic chemistry: Bridging the gap between two and three dimensions.Journal of Chemical Education,61(12),1084-1085.
28. Sedden, G. M.,Eniaiyeju, P. A.,Jusoh, I.(1984).The visualization of rotation in diagrams of threedimensional structures.American Education Research Journal,21(1),25-38.
29. Seddon, G. M.,Moore, R. G.(1986).The structure of abilities in visualizing the rotation of threedimensional structures presented as models and diagrams.British Journal of Educational Psychology,56,138-149.
30. Shepard, R. N.(1978).The mental image.American Psychologist,33,125-137.
31. Siemonkowski, F.,Macknight, F.(1971).Spatial cognition: Success prognosticator in college science courses.Journal of College Science Teaching,1(1),56-59.
32. Talley, L. Y.(1973).The use of three-dimensional visualization as a moderator in the higher cognitive learning of concepts in college level chemistry.Joural of Research in Science Teaching,10(3),263-269.
33. Zoller, U.(1990).Students` misunderstanding and misconception in college freshman chemistry (General and Organic).Journal of Research in Science Teaching,27(10),1053-1065.
34. 吳文如(2004)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立台北師範學院數理教育研究所。
35. 邱美虹、翁雪琴(1995)。國三學生「四季成因」之心智模式與推論歷程之探討。科學教育學刊，3(1)，23-68。
36. 邱美虹、陳英嫻(1995)。月相盈虧之概念改變。師大學報，40，509-548。
37. 邱美虹、傅化文(1993)。分子模型與立體化學的解題。科學教育月刊，1(2)，161-188。
38. 廖焜熙(1999)。博士論文(博士論文)。國立台彎師範大學科學教育研究所。
39. 廖焜熙、邱美虹(1996)。三維度視覺在技能與化學學習上的探討。科學教育月刊，189，14-35。

1. 陳立庭(2017)。3D繪圖軟體SketchUp融入生活科技展開圖學習活動之行動研究。科技與人力教育季刊，3(4)，14-25。
2. 林小慧(2008)。CISC 教學策略與國中生微粒概念學習成效之相關研究。教育心理學報，39(4)，533-554。
3. (2017)。科技化學習模組對於國小數學歸納課程之應用效益探究。教育研究學報，51(1)，43-70。