沙遊治療與其相關研究之分析

Analysis of Sandplay Therapy and Its Relevant Research

10.6251/BEP.20090707

吳櫻菁(Yin-Ching Wu)；高淑貞(Shu-Chen Kao)

沙遊治療 ； 沙盤治療 ； 沙圖分析 ； sandplay therapy ； sandtray therapy ； sand picture analysis

教育心理學報

42卷2期（2010 / 12 / 01）

277 - 295

繁體中文

本文主要是對沙遊治療與其相關領域的研究進行文獻分析，主要在探討此領域的多元性與獨特性。本文主要分析從1981年到2007年沙遊治療與其相關領域的研究的發展與趨勢。主要的分析結果：(1)此領域常見的研究方法是質性研究、個案研究法、實驗法。(2)此主題的研究是以兒童與青少年爲研究對象居多。1990年前以發展診斷工具爲目的研究占多數，但1991至2000年在研究目的轉向以探討特殊個案沙圖的特徵篇數較多。2001年後研究目的轉向以歷程及成效研究篇數較多。從研究年代與研究目的可以看出歷程及成效的研究是逐漸的趨勢。(3)國內在此主題不論研究年代、篇數及研究對象多元性都不及國外的發展。(4)根據研究對象特質，非臨床個案、失落與創傷個案占最多。針對研究結果對未來此領域的研究發展提出建議。

In this paper, literature pertaining to the development of sandplay therapy and its relevant research between 1981 to 2007 are analyzed to identify the diversity and uniqueness of the approach as well as the research trend. Results of the literature review indicated: (1) The common research methods of these fields are qualitative research methods, case study, and experiment design. (2) research participants were mostly children and teenagers. (3) Research in Taiwan lagged behind those in other countries in terms of research periods, quantities, and diversity. (4) Research participants were mostly nonclinical case as well as loss and traumatic case. According to the findings, future research development in this field are discussed and offered.

1. 沈玉培、史蒂芬·阿姆斯壯(2008)。人本取向團體沙箱治療對美國七年級青少女自尊的影響。國中華心理學刊，50(2)，147-165。
   連結：
2. 周惠君、王萬清(2007)。一位選擇性緘默症兒童在沙遊治療之歷程研究。輔導與諮商學報，29(2)，15-40。
   連結：
3. 曾仁美(2005)。走出暗夜：未成年亂倫受害者自我療癒之旅─以沙遊治療為例。中華心理衛生學刊，18(1)，1-23。
   連結：
4. 黃宗堅(2005)。創傷與復原：沙遊治療中的療癒象徵。輔導季刊，41(2)，12-21。
   連結：
5. 劉豐榮(2004)。視覺藝術創作研究方法之理論基礎探析：以質化研究觀點為基礎。藝術教育研究，8，73-94。
   連結：
6. Aoki, S.(1981).The retest reliability of the sandplay technique.British Journal of Projective Psychology and Personality Study,26(2),25-33.
7. Armstrong, S. A.(2008).Sandtray Therapy: A humanistic approach.Dallas, TX:Ludic Press.
8. Arnold, C. P.(2002).Disease awareness in the sandtrays of pediatric AIDS and HIV patients.Dissertation Abstracts International,61(9A),524.
9. Artico, C. I.(2001).Perceptions and memories of Latino adolescents separated in childhood due to piecemeal patterns of immigration.Dissertation Abstracts International,61(9A),3472.
10. Bainum, C. K.,Schneider, M. F.,Stone, M. H.(2006).An Adlerian model for sandtray therapy.The Journal of Individual Psychology,62(1),36-46.
11. Beggs, M. A.(2004).KS,Kansas State University.
12. Berman, B.(1994).Symbols in the sand: An exploration of the initial sandworlds of female incest survivors.Dissertation Abstracts international,54(9),4907.
13. Bonds, M. S.(1995).Sandplay with inner-city Latino and African-American adolescents.Dissertation Abstracts international,56(6-B),3433.
14. Borkan, T. G.(1992).The world procedure: Application to persons diagnosed with mental retardation.Dissertation Abstracts international,52(8-B),4459.
15. Bower, D. W.(ed.)(2001).The person-centered approach applications for living.Lincoln, NE:IUniverse.com Inc..
16. Bradway, K.,McCoard, B.(1997).Sandplay: Silent workshop of the psyche.New York:Routledge.
17. Brock, M. A.(2004).Sandplay as a rite of passage experience for girls at puberty.Dissertation Abstracts International,65(1),428.
18. Burke, V. J.(1997).Sandplay characteristics of school children by gender, ages seven through eleven.Masters Abstracts International,35(1),204.
19. Cameron, S. L.(2002).CA,Alliant International University.
20. Caprio, B.(1989).CA,Loyola-Marymount University.
21. Caproni, P. M.(1989).Sandplay: Window on the representational world. A projective adaptation of Lowenfeld's world technique.Dissertation Abstracts International,49(11-A),3305.
22. Carey, L.(1999).Sandplay therapy with children and families.New Jersey:Jason Aronson.
23. Carroll, J.(2000).Evaluation of therapeutic play: A challenge for research.Child and Family Social Work,5,11-22.
24. Chiaia, M. E.(1999).CA,California Institute of Integral Studies.
25. Clouiter, C. A.(2000).Exploring personal symbolism through sandplay and art therapy.Masters Abstracts International,38(4),1103.
26. Cockle, S.(1993).Sandplay: A comparative study.International Journal of Play Therapy,2(2),1-17.
27. Cohn, D. P.(2000).Gender differences among children during the struggle stage sandtray therapy.Dissertation Abstracts international,61(5-B),2749.
28. Cunningham, L. K.(2003).CA,California Institute of Integral Studies.
29. de Domenico, G. S.(1988).Sand tray world play: A comprehensive guide to the use of the sand tray in psychotherapeutic and transformational settings.Oakland, CA:Vision Quest Image.
30. Dean, J. E.(2001).Sandtray consultation: A method of supervision appied to couple's therapy.The Arts in Psychotherapy,28(3),175-180.
31. Denkers, G. C.(1985).CA,Pacific Graduate School of Psychology.
32. do Domenico, G. S.(1987).The Lowenfeld world apparatus: A methodological contribution towards the study and the analysis of the sand tray play process.Dissertation Abstracts international,48(5-B),1510.
33. Donelan, J. A.(2000).Alameda, CA,California School of Professional Psychology-Berkeley.
34. Enns, C. E.,Kasai, M.(2003).Hakoniwa: Japanese sandplay therapy.The Counseling Psychologist,31(1),93-112.
35. Erdem, T.(2001).Exploring hope with children who have been sexually abused and participating in therapy.Dissertation Abstracts International,62(5),2482.
36. Farris, T. A.(1990).The personality profile and subjective experiences of adult Sandplay user's.Dissertation Abstracts international,51(1-B),427.
37. Flahive, M. W.(2005).TX,University of North Texas.
38. Freedle, L. R.(2007).Sandplay therapy and the individuation process in adults with moderate to severe traumatic brain injury: An exploratory qualitative study.Dissertation Abstracts International,67(7),4103B.
39. Fujii, S.(1979).Restest reliability of the sandplay technique.British Journal of Projective Psychology and Personality Study,24,21-25.
40. Graham, V. B.(2007).Sandwerk as an individual spiritual practice.Dissertation Abstracts International,67(10),6095B.
41. Grand, I. J.(1999).Ohio,Union Institute and University.
42. Grubbs, G. A.(1995).A comparative analysis of the sandplay process of sexually abused and nonclinical children.The Arts in Psychotherapy,22(5),429-446.
43. Haebel, G. A.(2004).Art therapy sandplay as a technique to address body image and mourning in women with mastectomies.Masters Abstracts International,42(5),1678.
44. Harper, J.(1991).Children's play: The differential effects of intrafamily physical And sexual abuse.Child Abuse and Neglect,15,89-98.
45. Hiramatsu, K.,Yamaguchi, S.(1998).A review of fundamental studies of sand-play in Japan.Bulltein of Educational Sciences of Okayama University,109,39-51.
46. Homeyer, L. E.,Sweeney, D. S.(1998).Sandtray: A practical manual.TX:Lidan Press.
47. Howell, R. L.(1999).Children's concerns about danger and death: The influence of cognitive ability and bereavement.Dissertation Abstracts International,59(9-B),5137.
48. Hughes, S. C.(2004).Ohio,Union Institute and University.
49. Hunter, L. B.(1995).Ohio,Union Institute and University.
50. James, L.,Martin, D.(2002).Sand tray and group therapy, helping parents cope.Journal for specialists in group work,27(4),390-405.
51. Jones, L. B.(1983).The development of structure in the world of expression: A cognitive-development analysis's "sand worlds".Dissertation Abstracts International,43(9B),3052.
52. Kalff, M.(2007).Twenty-one points to be considered in the interpretation of a sandplay.Journal sandplay therapy,16(1),51-71.
53. Kawahara, T.(1998).Dependent/Independent images of the early adolescent boys-Case studies through "sandplay technique" and dream work.international conference counseling in the 21st century,Australia:
54. Keating, M. C.(1995).Sandtray worlds: Dynamic images by two men with mental Retardation.Masters Abstracts International,33(5),1375.
55. Knott, B. J.(1995).A study of sandplay as a drama therapy technique.Dissertations Abstracts International,55(9-A),2722.
56. Lee, P.(1997).CA,Pacifies Graduate Institute.
57. Lewis, C. W.(1996).A study of the compensatory relationship of ego and self: The ego-self dialogue explored through Jungian sandplay and Taoist philosophy.Dissertations Abstracts International,57(4),2872.
58. Mandelbaum, D. D.(2007).CA,Institute of Transpersonal Psychology.
59. Markos, P. A.,Hyatt, C. J.(1999).Play or supervision? Using sandtray with beginning practicum students.Guidance and counseling,14(4),3-7.
60. Mason, L. B.(1987).Assessing couple interaction with the sandplay method.Dissertations Abstracts International,47(8-B),3531.
61. Mathis, C. R.(2001).VA,Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University.
62. Mayes, C.,Mayes, P. B.,Williams, E.(2004).Messages in the sand: Sandtray therapy techniques with graduate students in an educational leadership program.International Journal of Leadership in Education,7(3),257-284.
63. McNiff, S.(1998).Art-based research.Philadelphia:Kingsley.
64. Mejia, X. E.(2005).FL,University of Central Florida.
65. Metzl, E. S.(2008).Systematic analysis of art therapy research published in art therapy: Journal of AATA between 1987-2004.The Art in Psychotherapy,35,60-73.
66. Miller, R. R.(1982).Investigation of a psychotherapeutic tool for adults: The sandtray.Dissertation Abstracts International,43(1-B),257.
67. Mitchell, R. R.,Friedman, H. S.(1994).Sandplay: Past, present and future.London:Routledge.
68. Pennington, Y. V.(1996).The sandtray assessment of development: A refinement of Bowyer's research into Lewin's theory of development.Dissertation Abstracts International,B4(57),2910.
69. Petti, P. V.(1991).CA,Alliant International University.
70. Schaefer, E. C.(ed.)(2003).Play therapy with adults.New Jersey:John Wiley & Sons.
71. Segal, J.(1990).Sandplay: A validation study of sandplay as a projective technique.Dissertation Abstracts International,51(6-B),3146-3147.
72. Shafarman, G.(1993).The image of grief: An investigation of first sandtrays of mothers of disabled infant.Dissertation Abstracts International,54(4-B),2223.
73. Shaia, A. J.(1992).Images in the sand: The initial sandworlds of men molested as children.Dissertation Abstracts International,52(12),6670.
74. Shen, Y. P.(2006).TX,Texas A & M University-Commerce.
75. Shuell, M. E.(1996).CA,Alliant International University.
76. Simourd, D. W.(1999).Cystic fibrosis: Issues from the sibling perspective.Masters Abstracts International,37(6),192.
77. Sparling, B. W.(2003).From healing into life to healing into death: The sandplay project. a clinical study utilizing Jungian psychology to complement conventional breast or ovarian cancer treatment.Dissertation Abstracts International,63(10),4925.
78. Spooner, L. C.,Lyddon, W. J.(2007).Sandtray therapy for inpatient sexual addiction treatment: An application of constructivist change principles.Journal of Constructivist Psychology,20,53-85.
79. Stemberg, A.(1996).Psychological assessment of the child patient using Sandplay.Dissertation Abstracts International,57(3-B),2166.
80. Tennessen, J.,Strand, D.(1998).A comparative analysis of directed sandplay therapy and principles of Ericksonian psychology.The Arts in Psychotherapy,25(2),109-114.
81. Turner, B. A.(1998).CA,California Institute of Integral Studies.
82. Vaz, K. M.(2000).When is a sandplay psychotherapy process completed?.International Journal of Action Methods,33(2),60-85.
83. Vinturella, L.,James, R.(1987).Sandplay: A therapeutic medium with children.Elementary School Guidance end Counseling,21(3),229-238.
84. Zarzaur, M. C.(2005).TN,University of Memphis.
85. Zinni, V. R.(1997).Differential aspects of sandplay with 10-and 11-year-oldchildren.Child Abuse and Neglect,21(7),657-668.
86. 王萍、黃鋼(2007)。沙盤遊戲應用於臨床心理評估的研究進展。中國健康心理學雜誌，15(9)，862-864。
87. 申荷永(2004)。心理分析入門。台北:心靈工坊。
88. 吳珍梅(2002)。博士論文(博士論文)。國立彰化師範大學輔導興諮商學系。
89. 吳櫻菁(2006)。從台灣地區沙遊治療研究中建構未來相關研究之趨勢。台灣遊戲治療年會暨遊戲治療多元與創新學術研討會，新竹:
90. 李湘屏(1986)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立台灣師範大學輔導研究所。
91. 林明清(2001)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。台南師範學院教師在職進修輔導教學。
92. 施玉麗(2003)。博士論文(博士論文)。國立彰化師範大學輔導與諮商學系。
93. 紀彩鳳(2004)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立台北大學社會工作學系。
94. 耿柳娜、張日昇、趙會春(2004)。箱庭在心理諮詢實踐和實踐中的應用。心理發展與教育，20(1)，83-86。
95. 梁信惠(2007)。沙遊治療研究與案例。台北:五南。
96. 梁健行(2002)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立台南大學教育學系。
97. 陳淑珍(2002)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立台南師範學院。
98. 陳瑀婕(2006)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。私立中國文化大學心理輔導研究所。
99. 陳碧玲譯、陳信昭譯、Boik, B. L.、Goodwin, E. A.(2001)。沙遊治療：不同取向心理治療師的逐步學習手冊。台北:心理。
100. 陳慧鴻(1999)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立台南師範學院國民教育研究所。
101. 曾仁美(2007)。表達性沙盤督導歷程受督導諮商員之知覺經驗分析初探。表達性藝術治療學術研討會，台北:
102. 游春茹(2005)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立屏東師範學院教育心理與輔導學系。
103. 黃宗堅譯、朱惠英譯、Kalff, D. M.(2007)。沙遊─通往靈性的心理治療取向。台北:五南。
104. 劉志如、邱敏麗、謝曜任(2001)。國科會研究計劃成果手冊國科會研究計劃成果手冊,國科會。
105. 鄭夙寗(2001)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立台南師範學院教師在職進修輔導教學。

1. 蔡美香,張婉慈(2021)。沙盤創作促進國小新進正式教師自我覺察工作壓力及其壓力因應之探究。諮商心理與復健諮商學報，36，7-30。
2. 黃敬傑、陳盈穎(2012)。ADHD-C型學童之人格探究─以沙遊評估為例。諮商與輔導，314，2-7。
3. 賴念華(2013)。臺灣心理劇文獻回顧1968-2011：看心理劇的發展與轉變。中華輔導與諮商學報，36，33-66。
4. (2024)。從榮格心理學探討沙遊治療－在童年逆境經驗個案之應用。諮商與輔導，460，28-30。