團體帶領者僵局經驗之初探性研究

Group Therapists' Experience of Group Impasse

10.6251/BEP.20110516

林淑君(Shu-Chun Lin)；王麗斐(Li-Fei Wang)；謝珮玲(Pey-Ling Shieh)

團體諮商與心理治療 ； 團體氣氛 ； 團體帶領者／治療者 ； 僵局 ； 質性研究 ； group atmosphere ； group counseling and psychotherapy ； group leaders/therapists ； impasse ； qualitative research

教育心理學報

43卷4期（2012 / 06 / 01）

899 - 919

繁體中文

文獻至今對於團體帶領者僵局經驗的探究仍甚少，基於瞭解團體僵局經驗之目的，本研究以發現取向之質性研究方法，採半結構式一對一深度訪談方式進行，探討團體帶領者僵局經驗之本質。本研究共邀請22位帶領者自願參與研究，分享他們印象最深刻的團體僵局經驗。研究參與者年齡在25－46歲之間，平均年齡34.4歲；團體諮商工作資歷在1個月黑17年之間，平均年資為7.3年：諮商與心理治療相關專業工作年資在1個月至20年之間，平均專業工作年資為9.5年；其中4位男性，18位女性。研究結果發現，國內團體帶領者的僵局經驗主要可區分為五大類型：團體氣氛凝滯、成員反抗帶領者、成員間衝突、成員展現問題特質、以及帶領者間衝突等五類型的僵局經驗。有效的介入方式則包括：涵容自己的負面情緒、聚焦於此時此地，直接面對僵局現象與回應成員的感受與需求等。最後研究將針對上述僵局經驗進行描述與討論，並針對實務與未來研究提出建議。

The current study was to explore the group therapists' experience of group impasse. There were 22 group therapists (4 males and 18 females, age 25-46. mean age=34.4) with mean group counseling experience of 7.3 years and mean counseling experience of 9.5 years. Data were collected by individual in-depth interviews and analyzed by a discovery-oriented qualitative method. The findings indicated that there were five major types of group impasse experience: (a) group atmosphere impasse; (b) members' resistance against group therapists; (c) conflicts between members, (d) members' problematic characteristics, and (e) conflicts among therapists and co-therapists. The effective interventions were: (a) restraining negative feelings, (b) focusing on here and now, (c) directly facing group impasses and members' affects and needs. The detailed results and suggestions for further research and practice were discussed.

1. 翁令珍(2007)。治療團體中的衝突及其管理之初探。輔導季刊，43(2)，31-38。
   連結：
2. Atwood, G. E.,Stolorow, R. D.,Trop, J. L.(1989).Impasses in psychoanalytic therapy: A royal road.Contemporary Psychoanalysis,25,554-573.
3. Billow, R. M.(2001).The therapist's anxiety and resistance to group therapy.International Journal of Group Psychotherapy,51(2),2001.
4. Billow, R. M.(2003).Rebellion in group.lnlernalional Journal 01 Group Psychology,53(3),331-351.
5. Brabender, V.(2007).The ethical group psychotherapist: A coda.International Journal of Group Psychotherapy,57(1),41-47.
6. Brown, S. D.(Ed.),Lent, R. W.(Ed.)(2000).Handbook of counseling psychology.New York, NY:John Wiley & Sons.
7. Conyne, R. K.,Wilson, F. R.,Tang, M.,Shi, K.(1999).Cultural similarities and differences in group work: Pilot study of a U.S.-Chinese group comparison.Group Dynamics,3(1),40-50.
8. DeLucia-Waack, J. L.(Ed.),Gerrity, D. A.(Ed.),Kalodner, C. R.(Ed.)(2004).Handbook of group counseling.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
9. DeLucia-Waack, J. L.(Ed.),Gerrity, D. A.(Ed.),Kalodner, C. R.(Ed.),Riva, M. T.(Ed.)(2004).Group counseling and psychotherapy.London, UK:Sage.
10. Elkind, S. N.(1992).Resolving impasses in therapeutic relationships.New York, NY:Guilford Press.
11. Fuhriman, A.(Ed.),Burlingame, G. M.(Ed.)(1994).Handbook of group psychotherapy: An empirical and clinical synthesis.New York, NY:John Wiley & Sons.
12. Hassan, S.,Cinq-Mars, C.,Sigman, M.(2000).Conflict in group therapy of chronic schizophrenics: Coping with aggression.American Journal of Psychotherapy,54,243-256.
13. Hill, C. E.,Nutt-Williams, E.,Heaton, K. J.,Thompson, B. J.,Rhodes, R. H.(1996).Therapist retrospective recall of impasses in long-term psychotherapy: A qualitative analysis.Journal of Counseling Psychology,43(2),207-217.
14. Hill, C. E.,Thompson, B. J.,Williams, E. N.(1997).A guide to conducting consensual qualitative research.The Counseling Psychologist,25,517-572.
15. Hines, P.,Stockton, R.,Morran, D. K.(1995).Self-talk of group therapists.Journal of Counseling Psychology,42(2),242-248.
16. Hoag, M. J.,Burlingame, G. M.(1997).Child and adolescent group psychotherapy: A narrative review of effectiveness and the case for meta-analysis.Journal of Child and Adolescent Group Therapy,7(2),51-68.
17. Holmes, S. E.,Kivlighan, D. M., Jr.(2000).Comparison of therapeutic factors in group and individual treatment processes.Journal of Counseling Psychology,47(4),478-484.
18. Josephs, L.(2003).The analysis of meaninglessness.Psychoanalytic Psychology,20(4),649-659.
19. Lambert, M. J.(Ed.)(2004).Bergin and Gargield's handbook of psychotherapy and behavior change.New York, NY:John Wiley & Sons.
20. Lincoln, Y. S.,Guba, E. G.(1985).Naturalistic inquiry.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage.
21. Mishler, E. G.(1990).Validation in inquiry-guided research: The role of exemplars in narrative studies.Harvard Educational Review,60(4),415-442.
22. Nathanson, D. L.(1992).The nature of therapeutic impasse.Psychiatric Annals,22,509-513.
23. Okech, J. E. A.,Kline, W. B.(2005).A qualitative exploration of group co-leader relationships.The Journal for Specialists in Group Work,30(2),173-190.
24. Omer, H.(2000).Troubles in therapeutic relationship: A pluralistic perspective.Psychotherapy in Practice,56(2),201-210.
25. Pulver, S. E.(1992).Impasses in psychodynamic psychotherapy.Psychiatric Annals,22,514-519.
26. Rhodes, R. H.,Hill, C. E.,Thompson, B. J.,Elliott, R.(1994).Client retrospective recall of resolved and unresolved misunderstanding events.Journal of Counseling Psychology,41,473-483.
27. Rosenfeld, H.、林玉華譯、樊雪梅譯(1998)。僵局與詮釋─精神病、邊緣人格與精神官能症的心理治療。台北:五南。
28. Roth, B.(Ed.),Kibel, H.(Ed.)(1990).The difficult patient in group therapy.Madison, CT:International Universities Press.
29. Rustin, M.(2008).Observational study of community mental health terams.身心醫學和心理治療國際研討會,台北:
30. Weiner, M. F.(1983).The assessment and resolution of impasse in group psychotherapy.International Journal of Group Psychotherapy,33(3),313-331.
31. Yalom, I. D.,Leszcz, M.(2005).The theory and practice of group psychotherapy.New York, NY:Basic Book.
32. 王麗斐、林美珠(2000)。團體治療性因素量表之發展與編製。中華輔導學報，9，1-24。
33. 沈慶鴻(1996)。團體的僵局─團體成員流失的處理。學生輔導通訊，44，114-121。
34. 周鼎文(2008)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。淡江大學教育心理與諮商研究所。
35. 林美珠、王麗斐(1998)。團體治療性與反治療性重要事件之分析。中華輔導學報，6，35-59。
36. 黃秀惠(2006)。國立台灣師範大學教育心理與輔導研究所在職進修碩士班。
37. 謝珮玲、林淑君、王麗斐(2009)。團體帶領者在團體僵局中之介入方式研究。中華團體心理治療，15(1)，1-27。

1. 王麗雲(2015)。失智症家庭主要照顧者失落之經驗。慈惠學報，11，33-43。
2. 魏嘉伶,周彥伶(2019)。新手領導者帶領青少年團體的僵局經驗。中華團體心理治療，25(1)，4-17。
3. 蕭淑華(2017)。團隊的成長。諮商與輔導，384，28-30。
4. 謝麗紅,蔡佩珊(2022)。希望理論融入團體諮商課程教學之效果研究。教育心理學報，54(1)，27-52。
5. 張玉茹,方寶億(2021)。支持性團體對國小輔導教師自我照顧之影響。臺中教育大學學報：人文藝術類，35(2)，1-20。
6. (2024)。非結構諮商團體領導者帶領困境之探究。輔導季刊，60(1)，71-85。