高低迴避傾向嬰兒的挫折反應之比較

A Comparison of the Reactions between Infants with High-versus Low-avoidance Tendency in Induced Frustrations

10.6251/BEP.20131028

黃世琤(Shih-Tseng Huang)；李麗雯(Li-Wen Lee)

心跳速率 ； 挫折 ； 氣質 ； frustration ； heart rate ； temperament

教育心理學報

45卷4期（2014 / 06 / 01）

539 - 554

繁體中文

本研究共58名（6至12個月）嬰兒與母親參與，分別由陌生人與母親經實驗程序引發嬰兒挫折經驗，藉由測量嬰兒生理反應與負向行為，以瞭解高低迴避傾向嬰兒之反應差異。結果顯示，嬰兒在挫折階段之哭泣行為顯著高於餅乾餵食階段。分析心跳速率變化量則發現迴避傾向與互動對象間之顯著交互作用，面對陌生人情境時，高迴避傾向嬰兒心跳速率變化量顯著大於低迴避傾向嬰兒，面對母親情境時高低迴避傾向嬰兒間則無差異。結果亦發現迴避傾向與實驗階段間之顯著交互作用，挫折階段中，高迴避傾向嬰兒心跳速率變化量顯著大於低迴避傾向嬰兒，餅乾餵食階段中高低迴避傾向嬰兒間則無差異。高迴避傾向嬰兒於面對陌生人情境以及於挫折階段中之心跳速率變化量均顯著大於低迴避傾向嬰兒之研究發現有助於瞭解高低迴避氣質傾向嬰兒於挫折反應之差異，並對高迴避傾向嬰兒之教養具參考價值。

The present study attempted to compare the reactions of infants with high- and low-avoidance tendency in induced-frustration conditions. Fifty-eight six- to twelve-months-old infants and their mothers participated. In the experimental procedure, half of the infants were assigned to a session where they experienced his/her mother first followed by a stranger, and the other half in a session with reverse encounter order. In each session, infants' heart rates and crying behaviors were recorded in the baseline, cookie-offering, frustration induction, and recovery phases. Results found that infants cried more during frustration phase than cookie-offering phase. For the heart rates, a significant interaction was found between the avoidance and person who induced the frustration. Compared to infants with low-avoidance, infants with high avoidance tendency had more changes changed heart rates when facing strangers. A significant interaction between the avoidance and experimental phases was found. Follow-up analysis found that infants with high avoidance tendency had greater changes in their heart rates during frustration than infants with low avoidance. These findings suggested that in a mild frustration induction procedure, infants with high avoidance tendency exhibited greater changes in heart rates than those with low-avoidance in frustration, particularly in the stranger induced frustration. Understanding the reactions of infants with high avoidance tendency in frustration situation may have important implications for parenting.

1. 黃世琤、高淑凌(2011)。六至十二個月嬰兒在挫折情境中情緒反應之研究。應用心理研究，51，149-170。
   連結：
2. Alessandri, S. M.,Sullivan, M. W.,Lewis, M.(1990).Violation of expectancy and frustration in early infancy.Developmental Psychology,26(5),738-744.
3. Bates, J. E.(Ed.),Wachs, T. D.(Ed.)(1994).Temperament: Individual differences at the interface of biology and behavior.
4. Braungart-Rieker, J. M.,Stifter, C. A.(1996).Infants' response to frustrating situations: Continuty and change in reactivity and regulation.Child Development,67,1767-1779.
5. Buss, K. A.,Goldsmith, H. H.(1998).Fear and anger regulation in infancy: Effects on the temporal dynamics of affective expression.Child Development,69(2),359-374.
6. Calkins, S. D.(2002).Does aversion behavior during toddlerhood matter? The effects of difficult temperament on maternal perceptions and behavior.Infant Mental Health Journal,23(4),381-402.
7. Calkins, S. D.,Dedmon, S. E.,Gill, K. L.,Lomax, L. E.,Johnson, J. L.(2002).Frustration in infancy: Implications for emotion regulation, physiological processes, and temperament.Infancy,3(2),175-197.
8. Calkins, S. D.,Johnson, M. C.(1998).Toddler regulation of distress to frustration events: Temperamental and maternal correlates.Infant Behavior and Development,21(3),379-395.
9. Carey, W. B.,McDevitt, S. D.(1978).Revision of the Infant Temperament Questionnaire.Pediatrics,61,735-739.
10. Coll, C. G.,Kagan, J.,Reznick, J. S.(1984).Behavioral inhibition in young children.Child Development,55(3),1005-1019.
11. Crossman, A.,Sullivan, M.,Hitchcock, D.,Lewis, M.(2009).When frustration is repeated: Behavioral and emotion responses during extinction over time.Emotion,9(1),92-100.
12. Degnan, K. A.,Fox, N. A.(2007).Behavioral inhibition and anxiety disorders: Multiple levels of a resilience process.Development and Psychopathology,19(3),729-746.
13. Diamond, A.,Churchland, A.,Cruess, L.,Kirkham, N. Z.(1999).Early developments in the ability to understand the relation between stimulus and reward.Developmental psychology,35(6),1507.
14. Dinehart, L.,Messinger, D.,Acosta, S.,Cassel, T.,Ambadar, Z.,Cohn, J.(2005).Adult perceptions of positive and negative infant emotional expressions.Infancy,8(3),279-303.
15. Fracasso, M.,Porges, S.,Lamb, M.,Rosenberg, A.(1994).Cardiac activity in infancy: Reliability and stability of individual differences.Infant Behavior and Development,17(3),277-284.
16. Hill, W. L.,Borovsky, D.,Rovee‐Collier, C.(1988).Continuities in infant memory development.Developmental Psychobiology,21(1),43-62.
17. Hill-Soderlund, A. L.,Braungart-Rieker, J. M.(2008).Early individual differences in temperamental reactivity and regulation: Implications for effortful control in early childhood.Infant Behavior and Development,31(3),386-397.
18. Hsu, C.,Soong, W.,Stigler, J. W,Hong, C.,Liang, C.(1981).The temperamental characteristics of Chinese babies.Child Development,53,1337-1340.
19. Izard, C. E.,Hembree, E. A.,Huebner, R. R.(1987).Infants' emotion expressions to acute pain:Developmental change and stability of individual differences.Development Psychology,23(1),105-113.
20. Izard, C. E.,Porges, S. W.,Simons, R. F.,Hyde, C.,Parisi, M.,Cohen, B.(1991).Infant cardiac activity: Developmental changes and relations with attachment.Developmental Psychology,27(3),432-439.
21. Kagan, J.(1989).Temperamental contributions to social behavior.American Psychologist,44(4),668-674.
22. Kagan, J.,Reznick, J. S.,Snidman, N.,Gibbons, J.,Johnson, M. O.(1988).Childhood derivatives of inhibition and lack of inhibition to the unfamiliar.Child Development,59,1580-1589.
23. Kagan, J.,Snidman, N.,Arcus, D. M.(1992).Initial reactions to unfamiliarity.Current Directions in Psychological Science,1(6),171-174.
24. Kopp, C. B.(1989).Regulation of distress and negative emotions: A developmental view.Developmental Psychology,25(3),343-354.
25. Lewis, M.,Hitchcock, D. F. A.,Sullivan, M. W.(2004).Physiological and emotional reactivity to learning and frustration.Infancy,6(1),121-143.
26. Lewis, M.,Ramsay, D.(2005).Infant emotional and cortisol responses to goal blockage.Child Development,76(2),518-530.
27. Ricard, M.,Décarie, T. G.(1993).Distance-maintaining in infants' reaction to an adult stranger.Social Development,2(2),145-165.
28. Robinson, J. L.,Kagan, J.,Reznick, J. S.,Corley, R.(1992).The heritability of inhibited and uninhibited behavior: A twin study.Developmental Psychology,28(6),1354-1376.
29. Rothbart, M.(1986).Longitudinal observation of infant temperament.Developmental Psychology,22(3),356-365.
30. Ruff, H.,Rothbart, M. K.(1996).Attention in early development.New York, NY:Oxford University Press.
31. Schwartz, C. E.,Wright, C. I.,Shin, L. M.,Kagan, J.,Rauch, S. L.(2003).Inhibited and uninhibited infants "Grown Up": Adult amygdalar response to novelty.Science,300,1952-1953.
32. Sroufe, L. A.(1977).Wariness of strangers and the study of infant development.Child Development,48,731-746.
33. Stenberg, C. R.,Campos, J. J.,Emde, R. N.(1983).The facial expression of anger in seven-month-old infants.Child Development,54,178-184.
34. Stifter, C. A.,Grant, W.(1993).Infant responses to frustration: Individual differences in the expression of negative affect.Journal of Nonverbal Behavior,17(3),187-204.
35. Stifter, C. A.,Jain, A.(1996).Psychophysiological correlates of infant temperament: Stability of behavior and autonomic patterning from five to eighteen months.Developmental Psychobiology,29,379-391.
36. Sullivan, M.,Lewis, M.(2003).Contextual determinants of anger and other negative expressions in young infants.Developmental Psychology,39(4),693-705.
37. Vaughn, B. E.,Kopp, C. B.,Krakow, J. B.(1984).The emergence and consolidation of self-control from eighteen to thirty months of age: Normative trends and individual differences.Child Development,55,990-1004.
38. von Salisch, M.(2001).Children's emotional development: Challenges in their relationships to parents, peers, and friends.International Journal of Behavioral Development,25(4),310-319.
39. Waters, E.,Matas, L.,Sroufe, L.(1975).Infants' reactions to an approaching stranger: Description, validation, and functional significance of wariness.Child Development,46(2),348-356.
40. 徐澄清(1992)。因材施教—從出生的第一天開始。台北=Taipei:健康世界雜誌社=World Health Magazine。
41. 蔡旻錡(2006)。Chiayi, Taiwan，國立中正大學心理學研究所=Department of Psychology, National Chung-Chang University。