社區強制諮商團體對預防再犯親密暴力的成效探究

The Effectiveness of Court-Mandated Group Counseling in Community for Preventing from the Recidivism of Intimate Partner Violence

10.6251/BEP.201712-49(2).0001

邱獻輝(Hsien-Huei Chiou)

社區強制諮商 ； 施暴者 ； 家庭暴力 ； 團體處遇 ； Community-based mandated counseling ； Domestic violence ； Group treatment ； Wife batterer

教育心理學報

49卷2期（2017 / 12 / 01）

163 - 192

繁體中文

社區強制諮商團體是預防親密暴力再犯的主要處遇之一，然其成效在國外頗具爭議，國內相關諮商訓練與研究有限，故急需建構一套適用於台灣的療效知識。本研究綜合目前主流方案的療效困境與改善意見後，根據性別平權、認知行為療法、團體動力等理念設計並帶領一個12次單元的半結構、開放諮商團體方案，透過混合研究設計、蒐集施暴者與受暴者的質性與量化評估資料，共獲得22對參與者的有效資料；考量共同生活與否可能會影響再犯率，故將同住與分住的伴侶分開進行對偶分析。研究結果顯示在處遇後，除了受暴者的精神受暴分數增加外，其餘暴力向度的分數皆減少；進一步顯著性考驗發現同住組的伴侶溝通已顯著增加、且肢體暴力明顯減少；分住組則在溝通、肢體暴力、精神暴力、性暴力、受傷等皆顯著減少。本研究施暴者暴力減少除了可歸因於團體療效之外，理應還參混著保護令的抑制與分住的隔離效果。

Court-mandated group counseling in community is one of the most important ways to prevent from recidivism of intimate partner violence (IPV). The effectiveness related to this kind of counseling is still debatable generally. Moreover, the related issues are seldom explored in Taiwan train institute and research field. To construct related knowledge, this author reviewed the critical and improved ways for the current court-mandated group counseling. Then, a court-mandated, open-ended, semi-structural group counseling program including 12 sessions within community based on gender equality, cognitive-behavior therapy, and group counseling was designed and conducted by this author. The participants included 22 perpetrators and their victims. The study adopted a mixed method design which collected data from both perpetrators and their victims. Due to whether lived together or not would influence the probability of recidivism of IPV, the data were divided into cohabitating team and separated team, and then analyzed through dyadic analysis approach. The descriptive statistics showed that all the scores of IPV diminished in addition to psychological violence from the victims' perspective. Further analysis indicated that not only perpetrator's couple communication improved but also physical assault decreased significantly after attending court-mandated group counseling in the cohabitating team. On the other hand, the physical, psychological, sexual violence, and injury have decreased significantly, accompanying communicational frequency decreased, in the separated team. The effectiveness of IPV decreasing among participants in this study could partially attribute to attending group counseling in this study, although part of effectiveness should attribute to the inhibiting function of protection order and the result of separating.

1. 李娟娟、張達人、謝宏林、王梅麗、張芳榮(2005)。婚姻暴力加害人認知教育與情緒支持性團體之療效探討。中華團體心理治療，13(3)，1-18。
   連結：
2. 林明傑、沈勝昂(2004)。婚姻暴力加害人分類之研究。中華心理衛生學刊，17(2)，67-92。
   連結：
3. 邱獻輝、葉光輝(2014)。臉面在教唆殺妻歷程的心理意涵：華人臉面理論的應用。人文及社會集刊，26(3)，483-523。
   連結：
4. 陳富美、利翠珊(2004)。不同情感組行夫妻在家事分工上的差異：對偶資料的分析。應用心理研究，24，95-115。
   連結：
5. 楊連謙、董秀珠、龍佛魏(2013)。婚姻暴力夫妻完成婚姻治療的分析。台灣精神醫學，27(4)，295-05+3。
   連結：
6. 嚴欣怡、卓紋君(2013)。大學生情侶之愛情風格、溝通姿態、關係滿意度及關係承諾度之探討─對偶分析研究。中華心理衛生學刊，26(3)，443-485。
   連結：
7. 全國法規資料庫（2016）：家庭暴力防治法。取自於全國法規資料庫網站：http://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?PCode=D0050071，2016 年4 月25 日。[Laws & Regulation Database of The Republic China (2015). The Domestic Violence Prevention Act. Retrieved April 25, 2016, from http://law.moj.gov.tw/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?PCode=D0050071]
8. 衛生福利部（2016）：統計資訊。取自於衛生福利部網站：http://www.mohw.gov.tw/cht/DOPS/DM1_P.aspx?f_list_no=157&fod_list_no=1093&doc_no=2616，2016 年4 月25 日。[Ministry of Health and Welfare (2016). Statistics information. Retrieved April 25, 2016, from http://www.mohw.gov.tw/cht/DOPS/DM1_P.aspx?f_list_no=157&fod_list_no=1093&doc_no=2616]
9. 王麗斐、林美珠（2006）：團體治療性因素量表與團體反治療性因素量表之簡式量表的編製。未出版。[Wang, L. F. & Lin, M. J. (2006). Development and validation of the group therapeutic factor inventory and anti-therapeutic factor (short form). Unpublished paper.]
10. Minnesota Center Against Violence and Abuse. (1997). Guidelines for men who batter programs. Retrieved on April 25, 2016, from Mincava Electronic Clearinghouse Website: http://www.mincava.umn.edu/documents/pwwmwb2/pwwmwb2.html.
11. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2014). Intimate partner violence: Definitions. Retrieved November 8, 2016 from http://www.cdc.gov/ViolencePre-vention/intimatepartnerviolence/definitions.html
12. Alexander, P. C.,Morris, E.,Tracy, A.,Frye, A.(2010).Stages of change and the group treatment of batterers: A randomized clinical trial.Violence and Victims,25(5),571-587.
13. Archer, J.(2000).Sex differences in aggression between heterosexual partners: A meta-analytic review.Psychological Bulletin,126,651-680.
14. Babcock, J. C.,Green, C. E.,Robie, C.(2004).Does batterer's treatment work? A meta-analytic review of domestic violence treatment.Clinical Psychology Review,23,1023-1053.
15. Boira, S.,del Castillo, M. F.,Carbajosa, P.,Marcuello, C.(2013).Context of treatment and therapeutic alliance: Critical factors in court-mandated batterer intervention programs.The Spanish Journal of Psychology,16,E40.
16. Cavanaugh, M. M.,Gelles, R. J.(2005).The utility of male domestic violence offender typologies: New directions for research, policy, and practice.Journal of Interpersonal Violence,20(2),155-166.
17. Chan, K. L.(2004).Correlates of wife assault in Hong Kong Chinese families.Violence Victims,19(2),189-201.
18. Chang, H.,Saunders, D. G.(2002).Predictors of attrition in two types of group programs for men who batter.Journal of Family Violence,17,273-292.
19. Corey, M. S.,Corey, G.,Corey, C.(2014).Groups: Process and practice.Singapore:Cengage Learning.
20. Corsini, R. J.(Ed.),Wedding, D.(Ed.)(2011).Current psychotherapies.Belmont, CA:Thomson Learning.
21. Daly, J. E.,Pelowski, S.(2000).Predictors of dropout among men who batter: A review of studies with implications for research and practice.Violence and Victims,17,137-160.
22. Daly, M.,Wilson, M.(1988).Homicide.Hawthorne, NY:Aldine de Gruyter.
23. Davis, R. C.,Taylor, B. G.(1999).Does batterer treatment reduce violence? A synthesis of the literature.Women and criminal justice: An Interdisciplinary Approach,10(2),63-93.
24. Davis, R. C.,Taylor, B. G.,Maxwell, C. D.(2000).Does batterer treatment reduce violence? A randomized experiment in Brooklyn.Washington, DC:National Institute of Justice.
25. Day, A.,Bowen, E.(2015).Offending competency and coercive control in intimate partner violence.Aggression and Violent Behavior,20,62-71.
26. Denzin, N. K.(Ed.),Lincoln, Y.S.(Ed.)(2005).The Sage handbook of qualitative research.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
27. Dobash, R. E.,Dobash, R. P.(1979).Violence against wives: A case against the patriarchy.New York:Free Press.
28. Draper, T.(Ed.),Marcos, A.(Ed.)(1990).Family variables.Newbury, Park, CA:Sage.
29. Dunford, F. W.(2000).The San Diego navy experiment: An assessment of interventions for men who assault their wives.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,68,468-476.
30. Dutton, D. G.,Corvo, K.(2006).Transforming a flawed policy: A call to revive psychology and science in domestic violence research and practice.Aggression and Violent Behavior,11(5),457-483.
31. Dutton, D. G.,Corvo, K.(2007).The Duluth model: A data-impervious paradigm and a failed strategy.Aggression and Violent Behavior,12(6),658-667.
32. Eckhardt, C. I.,Murphy, C. M.,Whitaker, D. J.,Sprunger, J.,Dykstra, R.,Woodard, K.(2013).The effectiveness of intervention programs for perpetrators and victims of intimate partner violence.Partner Abuse,4(2),196-231.
33. Feder, L.,Wilson, D. B.(2005).A meta-analytic review of court-mandated batterer intervention programs: Can courts affect abusers' behavior?.Journal of Experimental Criminology,1,239-262.
34. Gondolf, E. W.(2012).The future of batterer programs: Reassessing evidence-based practice.Boston, MA:Northeastern University Press.
35. Gondolf, E. W.(1997).Patterns of reassault in batterer programs.Violence and Victims,12,373-387.
36. Gorski T. T.(1996).Relapse prevention counseling workbook: Practical exercises for managing high-risk situations.Independence, MO:Herald Publication House.
37. Graham-Kevan, N.,Archer, J.(2003).Physical aggression and control in heterosexual relationships: The effect of sampling.Violence and Victims,18(2),181-196.
38. Gray, R.,Lewis, P.,Mokany, T.,O'Neill, B.(2014).Peer discussion and client motivation in men's domestic violence programs: An Australian qualitative interview study.Australian Social Work,67,390-404.
39. Hamel, J.(2010).Do we want to be politically correct, or do we want to reduce partner violence in our communities?.Partner Abuse,1,82-91.
40. Hanson, R. K.,Wallace-Capretta, S.(2000).A multi-site study of treatment for abusive men.Ottawa, Canada:Department of the Solicitor General Canada.
41. Healey, K. M.,Smith, C.,O'Sullivan, C. S.(1998).Batterer intervention: Program approaches and criminal justice strategies.Washington, DC:U. S. Dept. of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, National Institute of Justice.
42. Heron, J.,Reason, P.(1997).A participatory inquiry paradigm.Qualitative inquiry,3(3),274-294.
43. Hiles, D.(2008).Participatory Perspectives on Counselling Research.NCCR Conference
44. Hill, C. E.(2014).Helping skills: Facilitating exploration, insight, and action.Washington, DC:American psychological association.
45. Holllin, C.(Ed.),Palmer, E.(Ed.)(2006).Offending behavior programs: Development, application, and controversies.Chichester, England:John Wiley & Sons.
46. Holtrop, K.,Scott, J. C.,Parra-Cardona, J. R.,Smith, S. M.,Schmittel, E.,Larance, L. Y.(2015).Exploring factors that contribute to positive change in a diverse, group-based male batterer intervention program: Using qualitative data to inform implementation and adaptation efforts.Journal of Interpersonal Violence,32(8),1267-1290.
47. Holtzworth-Munroe, A.,Stuart, G. L.(1994).Typologies of male batters: Three subtypes and the differences among them.Psychological Bulletin,116,476-497.
48. Johnson, M. P.(2008).A typology of domestic violence: intimate terrorism, violent resistance, and situational couple violence.Lebanon, New Hampshire:Northeastern University Press.
49. Kelly, L.,Westmarland, N.(2015).Domestic violence perpetrator programmes: Steps towards change. Project Mirabal final report.London, England:London Metropolitan University.
50. Labriola, M.,Rempel, M.,Davis, R. C.(2008).Do batterer programs reduce recidivism? Results from a randomized trial in the Bronx.Justice Quarterly,25(2),252-282.
51. Levesque, D. A.,Gelles, R. J.,Velicer, W. F.(2000).Development and validation of a stages of change measure for men in batterer treatment.Cognitive Therapy and Research,24(2),175-199.
52. Levesque, D. A.,Velicer, W. F.,Castle, P. H.,Greene, R. N.(2008).Resistance among domestic violence offenders measurement development and initial validation.Violence Against Women,14(2),158-184.
53. Lindsay, J.,Roy, V.,Turcotte, D.,Montminy, L.(2006).Therapeutic factors in the first stage of men's domestic violence groups: Men talk about universality and how it becomes operational in the group.Groupwork,16(1),29-47.
54. Maiuro, R. D.,Eberle, J. A.(2008).State standards for domestic violence perpetrator treatment: Current status, trends, and recommendations.Violence and Victims,23,133-155.
55. Morrison. P. K.,Cluss, P. A.,Miller, E. P.,Fleming. R.,Hawker, L.,Bicehouse, T.,Chang, J.(2016).Elements needed for quality batterer intervention programs: Perspectives of professionals who deal with intimate partner violence.Journal of family violence,32(5),481-491.
56. Norcross, J. C.(Ed.)(2011).Psychotherapy relationships that work: Evidence-based responsiveness.New York, NY:Oxford University Press.
57. Parra-Cardona, J. R.,Escobar-Chew, A. R.,Holtrop, K.,Carpenter, G.,Guzman, R.,Hernandez, D.,Ramirez, D. G.(2013)."En el grupo tomas conciencia (In group you become aware)": Latino immigrants' satisfaction with a culturally informed intervention for men who batter.Violence Against Women,19,107-132.
58. Pence, E.,Paymar, M.(1993).Education groups for men who batter: the Duluth model.Duluth, Minnesota:Minnesota Program Development Inc.
59. Price, B. J.,Rosenbaum, A.(2009).Batterer intervention programs: A report from the field.Violence and Victims,24(6),757-770.
60. Prochaska, J. O.,DiClemente, C. C.(1982).Transtheoretical therapy: Toward a more integrative model of change.Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, and Practice,19(3),276-288.
61. Schopler, J. H.,Galinsky, M. J.(1984).Meeting practice needs: Conceptualizing the open-ended group.Social Work with Groups,7(2),3-21.
62. Schwartz, J. P.,Waldo, M.(1999).Therapeutic factors in spouse-abuse group treatment.Journal for Specialists in Group Work,24(2),197-207.
63. Scott, K. L.,Wolfe, D. A.(2000).Change among batterers: Examining men's success stories.Journal of Interpersonal Violence,15,827-842.
64. Shamai, M.,Buchbinder, E.(2010).Control of the self: Partner-violent men's experience of therapy.Journal of Interpersonal Violence,25,1338-1362.
65. Smedslund, G.,Dalsbo, T. K.,Steiro, A.,Winsvold, A.,Clench-Aas, J.(2012).Cognitive behavioral therapy for men who physically abuse their female partner.Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews,8,CD006048.
66. Stith, S. M.,McCollum, V. T.,Amanor-Boadu, Y.,Smith, D.(2012).Systemic perspectives on intimate partner violence treatment.Journal of Marital and Family Therapy,38(1),220-240.
67. Straus, M.(2011).Gender symmetry and mutuality in perpetration of clinical-level partner violence: Empirical evidence and implications for prevention and treatment.Aggression and Violent Behavior,16,279-288.
68. Straus, M. A.(1979).Measuring intrafamily conflict and violence: The conflict tactics scales.Journal of Marriage and the Family,41,75-88.
69. Straus, M. A.,Hamby, S. L.,McCoy, S.,Sugarman, D.(1996).The revised conflict tactics scales (CTS2).Journal of Family Issue,17(3),283-316.
70. Sue, D. W.,Sue, D.(2013).Counseling the culturally different: Theory & practice.N.Y.:John Wiley & Sons.
71. Sun, K.(2008).Correctional counseling : A cognitive growth perspective.Sudbury, Mass.:Jones and Bartlett Publishers.
72. Taft, C. T.,Murphy, C. M.,King, D. W.(2003).Process and treatment adherence factors in group cognitive-behavioral therapy for partner violent men.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,71(4),812-820.
73. Wilson, D.,Bouffard, L.,MacKenzie, D.(2005).A quantitative review of structured group-oriented, cognitive-behavioral programs for offenders.Criminal Justice and Behavior,32,172-204.
74. Yalom, I. D.,Leszcz, M.(2005).The theory and practice of group psychotherapy.New York, NY:Basic Books.
75. 王麗斐、林美珠(2000)。團體治療性因素量表之發展與編製。中華輔導學報，9，1-24。
76. 李雅琪(2007)。家庭暴力加害人參與認知輔導團體後行為改變之探索性研究。亞洲家庭暴力與性侵害期刊，3(1)，57-94。
77. 邱惟真、邱思潔(2012)。家庭暴力受保護管束人團體處遇模式之建立與成效評估。亞洲家庭暴力與性侵害期刊，8(1)，51-68。
78. 邱獻輝(2016)。強制處遇男性親密暴力者的分類建構：關係主義的觀點。中華輔導與諮商學報，46，93-126。

1. 許育光,刑志彬(2021)。新手團體諮商師領導能力發展探究：歷程追蹤、分項比較與學習類型叢集分析。教育心理學報，53(1)，1-36。
2. 鍾易廷,劉素華,陳筱萍,林耿樟(2020)。家庭暴力加害人之認知扭曲量表。輔導季刊，56(3)，13-32。