多面向道德情意量表之發展與信效度考驗

Multidimensional Affective Morality Scale: Development and Reliability and Validity Evaluation

10.6251/BEP.202006_51(4).0003

李琪明(Angela Chi-Ming Lee)

多面向道德情意量表 ； 信效度 ； 探索性因素分析 ； 複核效化 ； 驗證性因素分析 ； multidimensional affective morality (MAM) scale ； reliability and validity ； exploratory factor analysis (EFA) ； cross-validation ； confirmatory factor analysis (CFA)

教育心理學報

51卷4期（2020 / 06 / 01）

561 - 583

繁體中文

本研究目的在發展「多面向道德情意量表」（multidimensional affective morality scale,簡稱MAM scale），並考驗其信效度。研究者汲取國內外道德學界既有經驗與成果，針對國中至研究所學生為對象，並奠基臺灣的在地脈絡，以作為情意層面道德範疇概況或成效展現的具體指標，希冀對於國內外道德教育理論與實踐有所助益。本研究方法與歷程包括先行探究理念架構以擬定量表初稿、繼而針對初稿評定其內容效度、再經修改後進行量表預試與正式施測。研究者區分四個階段進行統計分析，並採用IBM SPSS Statistics 23與Amos 25 Graphics為分析軟體：一是將預試樣本（N=585）進行項目分析，計算其內部一致性信度；二是將預試樣本區分為二群，以樣本_1（N=283）進行探索性因素分析；三是以樣本_2（N=302）進行驗證性因素分析；四是以正式施測樣本（N=708）進行複核效化檢驗。本研究發展完成的MAM量表包括詳版與簡版，詳版通過內容效度與內部一致性考驗，包括四則道德故事與四個構面，計有44個題項；簡版則是奠基詳版，並具有良好的模式適配度（二階單因子驗證性分析模式），以及理想的組合信度、建構效度與複核效化檢驗，其內容包括三則道德故事與三個構面，計有12個題項。詳版可顯示道德情意量表的脈絡性與豐富性，簡版則可展現結構性與精簡性。藉此量表的發展，本文綜整結論以彰顯MAM量表的特點：一是本量表凸顯情意層面道德範疇，豐富且具深度的多面向意涵；二是本量表與文獻所探討的量表，有其相似度均凸顯道德情意內涵，亦有其故事所關注道德議題的獨創性與在地關聯；三是本研究嘗試以多種類的信效度，對於道德情意量表進行堅實的考驗。最後，本研究基於道德教育的角度，提供在量表運用與後續研究的建議，以期增進各教育階段學生的多面向道德情意發展。

This study developed the Multidimensional affective morality (MAM) scale by testing its reliabilities and validity. On the basis of both national and global academic experiences and research achievements, this study selected students from junior high school to graduate school in Taiwan as subjects to construct a concrete indicator for affective morality and enhance the theory and practice of moral education. This study first explored the rationale underlying the scale's draft. The researcher then examined the content validity and conducted the pretest and formal survey. Statistical analysis was performed utilizing the IBM SPSS Statistics (version 23) and AMOS Graphics (version 25). In Stage 1, an item analysis was performed and the internal reliability was computed for the pretest group sample (N = 585). Stage 2 comprised an exploratory factor analysis (EFA) for pretest_1 group (N = 283). Stage 3 comprised a confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) for pretest_2 group (N = 302). In Stage 4, the cross-validation for the formal survey_ group was assessed (N = 708). The researcher developed two versions of the MAM scale. The long version, comprising 4 moral stories, 4 constructs, and 44 items, passed the test for content validity and internal consistency. The short version, comprising 3 moral stories, 3 constructs, and 12 items, demonstrated goodness of fit (a one-factor second-order CFA model) and good composite/component/construct reliability, construct validity, and cross-validity. The long version of the MAM scale demonstrated contextualization and richness, whereas the short one demonstrated structure and refinement. Thus, the MAM scale has the following characteristics: (1) The MAM scale has good richness and offered an in-depth understanding of the multiple dimensions of affective morality. (2) Similar to other related scales, the MAM scale demonstrated the concepts of affective morality. In addition, the scale encompassed localization and creativity pertaining to moral issues. (3) The MAM scale's reliability and validity could be tested using various evaluation methods. Finally, the researcher offered several suggestions for the scale's application and further research to improve the development of affective morality among students in different educational levels.

1. 甘孟龍, M.-L.,黃秀霜, H.-S.,劉峯銘, F.-M.(2016)。「國中生憤怒反應量表」之發展與信效度考驗。測驗學刊，63(1)，1-30。
   連結：
2. 李琪明, C.-M.(2017)。我國中小學道德情意發展之課程模式建構。課程與教學季刊，20(3)，1-26。
   連結：
3. 林慧慈, H.-T.,林文瑛, W.-Y.,王震武, J.W.(2017)。從局部統合到整體統合的發展－以道德思考為例。教育心理學報，48(3)，329-349。
   連結：
4. 程姿螢, T.-Y.,張詠婷, Y.-T.,宋曜廷, Y.-T.(2016)。大專學生工作價值組合量表之編製及信效度研究。教育心理學報，48(1)，91-112。
   連結：
5. Aquino, K.,Reed, A., II(2002).The self-importance of moral identity.Journal of Personality & Social Psychology,83(6),1423-1440.
6. Bandura, A.,Barbaranelli, C.,Caprara, G. V.,Pastorelli, C.(1996).Mechanisms of moral disengagement in exercise of moral agency.Journal of Personality & Social Psychology,71(2),364-374.
7. Byrne, B. M.(2010).Structural equation modelling with AMOS: Basic concepts, applications, and programming.Routledge.
8. Casali, G. L.(2011).Developing a multidimensional scale for ethical decision making.Journal of Business Ethics,104,485-497.
9. Chambers, D.W.(2011).Developing a self-scoring comprehensive instrument to measure Rest’s four-component model of moral behavior: The moral skills inventory.Journal of Dental Education,75(1),23-35.
10. Cheek, J. M. & Briggs, S. R. (2013). Aspects of identity questionnaire (AIQ-IV). Measurement Instrument Database for the Social Science. http://dx.doi.org/10.13072/midss.562
11. Colby, A.,Kohlberg, L.(1987).The measurement of moral judgment.Cambridge University Press.
12. Davis, M. H.(1980).A multidimensional approach to individual differences in empathy.JSAS Catalog of Selected Documents in Psychology,10,85.
13. Doolittle, A.,Faul, A. C.(2013).Civic engagement scale: A validation study.SAGE Open,July-September,1-7.
14. Durlak, J. A.(Ed.),Domitrovich, C. E.(Ed.),Weissberg, R. P.(Ed.),Gullotta, T. P.(Ed.)(2015).Handbook of social and emotional learning: Research and practice.The Guilford Press.
15. Eisenberg, N.(2000).Emotion, regulation, and moral development.Annual Review of Psychology,51(1),665-697.
16. Habermas, J.,McCarthy, T.(Trans.)(1979).Communication and the evolution of society.Beacon Press.
17. Hagen, E. (2014). Resources for measuring social and emotional learning. Retrieved Dec. 20, 2015 from https://conservancy.umn.edu/bitstream/handle/11299/195179/issue-brief-measurement-resource.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y
18. Haggerty, K., Elgin, J., & Woolley, A. (2011). Social-emotional learning assessment measures for middle school youth. Retrieved Dec. 19, 2015, from http://www.search-institute.org/sites/default/files/a/DAP-Raikes-Foundation-Review.pdf
19. Held, V.(2006).The ethics of care: Personal, political, and global.Oxford University.
20. Hoffman, M. L.(2000).Empathy and moral development: Implications for caring and justice.Cambridge University.
21. Kurtines, W. M.(Ed.),Gewirtz, J. L.(Ed.)(1991).Handbook of moral behavior and development.Erlbaum.
22. Kurtines, W. M.(Ed.),Gewirtz, J. L.(Ed.)(1984).Morality, moral behavior, and moral development.Wiley.
23. Lee, C.-M.,Taylor, M. J.(2013).Moral education trends over 40 years: A content analysis of the Journal of Moral Education (1971-2011).Journal of Moral Education,42(4),399-429.
24. Lee, C.-M.,Thoma, S. J.(2018).Developing and testing a scale of moral thinking and communication (MTC) functioning: a preliminary study and its implications for moral development and education.Asia Pacific Journal of Education,38(1),32-50.
25. Levesque, R. J. R.(Ed.)(2012).Encyclopedia of adolescence.Springer.
26. Lietz, C. A.,Gerdes, K. E.,Sun, F.,Geiger, J. M.,Wagaman, A. M.,Segal, E. A.(2011).The empathy assessment index (EAI): A confirmatory factor analysis of a multidimensional model of empathy.Journal of the Society for Social Work Research,2(2),104-124.
27. Noddings, N.(2005).Educating citizens for global awareness.Teachers College.
28. Nussbaum, M. (2008). Morality and emotions. Retrieved Dec. 21, 2015, from http://virtueethicsinfocentre.blogspot.tw/2008/02/morality-and-emotions.html
29. Nussbaum, M.(2013).Political emotions: Why love matters for justice.Harvard University.
30. Reed, A.,Aquino, K.,Levy, E.(2007).Moral identity and judgments of charitable behaviors.Journal of Marketing,71(1),178-193.
31. Rest, J.,Narvaez, D.,Bebeau, M. J.,Thoma, S. J.(1999).Postconventional moral thinking: A neo-Kohlbergian approach.Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
32. Segal, E. A.,Wagaman, M. A.,Gerdes, K. E.(2012).Developing the social empathy index: An exploratory factor analysis.Advances in Social Work,13(3),541-560.
33. Tangney, J. P.,Stuewig, J.,Mashek, D. J.(2007).Moral emotions and moral behavior.Annual Review of Psychology,58,345-372.
34. Thoma, S. J.,Dong, Y.(2014).The defining issues test of moral judgment development.Behavior Development Bulletin,19(3),55-61.
35. Yacker, N.,Weinberg, S. L.(1990).Care and justice moral orientation: A scale for its assessment.Journal of Personality Assessment,55(1-2),18-27.
36. 沈六, L.(1986).道德發展與行為之研究.水牛=Buffalo Plaza.
37. 陳寬裕, K.-Y.,王正華, Z.-H.(2016).結構方程模型分析實務：AMOS 的運用.五南=Wunan.
38. 單文經, W.-J.(1982).道德教育初探.復文=Fuhwen.

1. 陳俊瑋(2022)。「中文版俄亥俄州教師效能感量表」於國小教師之驗證性研究。教育心理學報，53(4)，853-878。
2. 徐慶帆(2021)。休閒與教育兼具的國防知性之旅：量表模型建構與驗證。軍事社會科學專刊，19，103-129。
3. 詹雨臻,陳學志,張益慈(2021)。繁體中文版「簡式暗黑四特質量表」之發展與信效度考驗。測驗學刊，68(4)，287-316。