题名

家庭環境與幼兒社會能力之關係──氣質的調節效果

并列篇名

Relationship between the Family Environment and Social Competence among Young Children in Taiwan: The Moderating Role of Temperament

DOI

10.6251/BEP.202309_55(1).0003

作者

崔新玲(Xin-Ling Cui)；鍾志從(Jyh-Tsorng Jong)；梁進龍(Jin-Long Liang)；吳和堂(Ho-Tang Wu)

关键词

家庭環境 ； 氣質 ； 社會能力 ； family environment ； temperament ； social competence

期刊名称

教育心理學報

卷期/出版年月

55卷1期（2023 / 09 / 01）

页次

47 - 74

内容语文

繁體中文;英文
中文摘要

本研究旨在探討幼兒的氣質於家庭環境與幼兒社會能力關係上的調節效果。氣質可再分為外放性、奮力控制性與負向情緒性等三種氣質，依據文獻分析的結果，提出三條假設，即外放性、奮力控制性與負向情緒性等三種氣質各自於家庭環境與幼兒社會能力之關係具有調節效果，樣本取自「臺灣幼兒發展調查資料庫」（Kids in Taiwan: National Longitudinal Study of Child Development & Care, KIT），抽取48月齡的家庭環境、氣質與社會能力等三量表的數據。統計分析採用偏最小平方法結構方程（PLS-SEM）來分析。結果發現：外放性與負向情緒性氣質等沒有調節效果，但奮力控制性氣質則有。就此發現，建議：1.家長應當營造適宜的家庭環境，以增進幼兒的社會能力。2.家長應注重幼兒奮力控制性氣質之培養。3.幼兒園應營造有利於奮力控制性氣質與社會能力增長之環境。4.未來可整合幼兒內部與外部的影響因素，一併探討對幼兒社會能力的影響。
英文摘要

At the age of 4, children undergo major changes in their mentality and their potential starts to develop rapidly; these changes result in new psychological characteristics, such as fearlessness, seamless communication, independence, and self-confidence, as well as varying levels of quietness and activity. They evidently become more acquainted with their immediate surroundings and become more active, flexible, and persistent as they accumulate additional experiences. According to Kaya and Deniz (2020), the age of 4 years, which is the formal age for entering kindergarten, represents a peak in development. Therefore, many researchers include 4-year-old children as their research sample. When young children exhibit fearlessness, effective communication, self-reliance, and self-confidence, these manifestations collectively indicate social competence. Achieving social competence is regarded as a major developmental milestone for young children. During early childhood, deficits in social competence are strongly associated with externalized behaviors, such as anger, aggression, selfishness, and hostility, and internalized behaviors, such as depression, anxiety, isolation, and dependency (Huber et al., 2019). Therefore, social competence plays a pivotal role in the psychological development of children. Many studies have indicated that the family environment of children affects their social competence (Xie et al., 2022), including their cognitive development (Razza et al., 2010) and social and emotional development (Baker, 2017). Social competence stems from long-term development, age-related changes, and environmental requirements (Quinn & Hennessy, 2010). According to Taborsky (2021), the presence of a family environment that is conducive to sociality can help foster individuals with increased social competence, thus indicating the effect of family environment on social competence. Temperament affects social competence, as reported by Dollar et al. (2018), who indicated that negative emotional traits such as anger at the age of 2 years influence social skills at the age of 7 years, with positive emotional temperament exerting an opposite effect. Eisenberg et al. (2003) argued that the presence of effortful control temperament enables young children to make more positive choices when confronted with challenges such as obedience and empathy. According to Huber et al. (2019), young children with extraversion and effortful control temperament tend to exhibit reduced internalized and externalized behavioral problems. Because these externalized behavioral problems impede social interactions and cooperation, they inevitably affect social competence. According to the aforementioned analysis, both family environment and temperament affect social competence. Therefore, temperament may play a moderating role in the relationship between family environment and social competence. Previous Taiwanese studies have included young children as research samples to examine the correlations between family environment, social competence, and temperament. For instance, Chen (1996) examined the correlations between early childhood, temperament, and social competence by using statistical methods such as Pearson's correlation and canonical correlation analyses. Lue (2010) investigated the correlations between parental emotional socialization behaviors, emotional regulation, and peer interactions in young children and analyzed the differences between fathers and mothers in this context. However, few studies have investigated the moderating role of temperament in the relationship between family environment and social competence, thus necessitating further research regarding the correlations between these three variables. The findings of such research would guide parents in fostering an appropriate family environment and identifying the type of temperament that can act as an effective moderator. These findings may contribute to enhancing young children's temperament and strengthening the relationship between family environment and social competence. They can also provide valuable insights for future research. In accordance with the literature, the following hypothesis was proposed: Effortful control temperament, extraversion temperament, and negative emotional temperament moderate the relationship between family environment and social competence. Data were collected from the Kids in Taiwan: National Longitudinal Study of Child Development & Care (KIT) database established by Chang (2021). Structured interviews were conducted to collect data regarding 48-month-old children from their main caregivers, yielding a total of 2,031 valid samples, including 1,029 boys (50.7%) and 1,002 girls (49.3%). In accordance with the aforementioned moderating model, data on three variables, namely, family environment, social competence, and temperament, were extracted from the KIT database. Initially, a cohort of 280 children aged 2–7 years underwent a pretest involving the three variables. The results of this pretest confirmed the reliability of the database. Because this study exclusively included 48-month-old children as the sample, retesting the reliability of the database was mandatory. Given that the three variables have clear dimensions, 100 individuals were randomly selected from the KIT database and partial least squares confirmatory factor analysis was conducted using SmartPLS (version 3.0), which is suitable for small samples (30–100 individuals). The results indicated that the three variables exhibited appropriate reliability. In this study, a moderating model of temperament was introduced. In this model, family environment serves as an exogenous variable, temperament serves as a moderating variable, and social competence serves as an endogenous variable. To identify a potential moderating effect, cross-product analysis was conducted. Specifically, family environment was multiplied by three temperaments. Identifying any cross-product reaching a significant level implied a moderating effect of temperament . In this study, our first step was to test for normality. However, our results revealed a violation of the assumption of normal distribution. Given that this study involved a complex model, subsequent analyses were conducted through partial least squares structural equation modeling. The model was also adjusted for the gender of young children and the educational level of their parents. First, we used the unmeasured latent method construct proposed by Lindell and Whitney (2001) to investigate the effect of common method variance. The results indicated that common method variance did not constitute a serious problem. Second, we examined the goodness of fit value. The results revealed the suitability of both the measurement and structural models. Third, we tested the coefficients of each path. The results revealed significant positive correlations between the path coefficients of family environment to social competence, extraversion temperament, effortful control, and negative emotional temperament. Unlike negative emotional temperament, extraversion and effortful control temperament exhibited significant positive correlations with social competence. In terms of moderating effects, neither moderating effect 1 (family environment multiplied by extraversion temperament) nor moderating effect 3 (family environment multiplied by negative emotional temperament) played a significant role in the path to social competence. However, moderating effect 2 (family environment multiplied by effortful control temperament) played a significant role in the path to social competence, with a positive β value of .35. Therefore, when the score of effortful control temperament increased by 1 standard deviation, the correlation between family environment and social competence became stronger. Unlike extraversion temperament and negative emotional temperament, effortful control temperament moderates the relationship between family environment and social competence. Accordingly, the following recommendations should be considered. First, parents should foster an appropriate family environment to enhance the social competence of their children. Second, parents should focus on cultivating their children's effortful control temperament. Third, kindergartens should create an environment conducive to effortful control temperament and social competence. Finally, future studies should focus on the observational indicator of conditional discipline as an independent latent variable and explore its relationship with other variables. Researchers should also integrate the internal and external factors influencing young children and explore their effects on social competence.
主题分类 社會科學 > 心理學
社會科學 > 教育學
参考文献
  1. 王珮玲, P.-L.(2014)。嬰幼兒氣質回顧與前瞻：1980—2011。應用心理研究，61，55-112。
    連結：
  2. 林佳慧, C.-H.,劉惠美, H.-M.,張鑑如, C.-J.(2019)。家庭脈絡下的親子共讀與幼兒發展關係—臺灣幼兒發展調查資料庫的應用與分析。教育心理學報，51，135-159。
    連結：
  3. 林惠雅, H.-Y.(2008)。家庭互動型態、子女性別與幼兒社會能力之探討。中華心理衛生學刊，21，351-377。
    連結：
  4. 張萬烽, W.-F.(2020)。保護因子對於不同復原力類型學習障礙學生之影響。特殊教育研究學刊，45(1)，65-96。
    連結：
  5. 程景琳, C.-L.,涂妙如, M.-J.,陳虹仰, H.-Y.,張鑑如, C.-J.(2016)。學齡前嬰幼兒之社會情緒能力—與嬰幼兒語言能力及父母教養之關聯。當代教育研究季刊，24(3)，1-27。
    連結：
  6. 楊婧, C.,張鑑如, C.-J.(2021)。臺灣幼兒電子產品的使用及對幼兒發展的影響 : 臺灣幼兒發展調查資料庫之運用。教育心理學報，53，257-284。
    連結：
  7. 謝妮娜, N.-N.,王珮玲, P.-L.,趙家琛, C.-C.(2018)。兒童氣質與焦慮及憂鬱傾向之關聯。中華心理衛生學刊，31，1-28。
    連結：
  8. Anderson, V.(Ed.),Beauchamp, M. H.(Ed.)(2012).Developmental social neuroscience and childhood brain insult: Theory and practice.The Guilford Press.
  9. Anthonysamy, A.,Zimmer-Gembeck, M. J.(2007).Peer status and behaviors of maltreated children and their classmates in the early years of school.Child Abuse & Neglect,31(9),971-991.
  10. Arsenio, W. F.,Cooperman, S.,Lover, A.(2000).Affective predictors of preschoolers’ aggression and peer acceptance: Direct and indirect effects.Developmental Psychology,36(4),438-448.
  11. Baker, C. E.(2017).Father-son relationships in ethnically diverse families: Links to boys’ cognitive and social emotional development in preschool.Journal of Child and Family Studies,26(8),2335-2345.
  12. Baron, R. M.,Kenny, D. A.(1986).The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,51(6),1173-1182.
  13. Bates, C. R.,Buscemi, J.,Nicholson, L. M.,Cory, M.,Jagpal, A.,Bohnert, A. M.(2018).Links between the organization of the family home environment and child obesity: A systematic review.Obesity Reviews,19(5),716-727.
  14. Belsky, J.,Bakermans-Kranenburg, M. J.,van IJzendoorn, M. H.(2007).For better and for worse: Differential susceptibility to environmental influences.Current Directions in Psychological Science,16(6),300-304.
  15. Blair, B. L.,Perry, N. B.,O’Brien, M.,Calkins, S. D.,Keane, S. P.,Shanahan, L.(2015).Identifying developmental cascades among differentiated dimensions of social competence and emotion regulation.Developmental Psychology,51(8),1062-1073.
  16. Bond, M. H.(Ed.)(2010).The Oxford handbook of Chinese psychology.Oxford University Press.
  17. Bradley, R. H.,Corwyn, R. F.,Burchinal, M.,McAdoo, H. P.,García Coll, C.(2001).The home environments of children in the United States Part II: Relations with behavioral development through age thirteen.Child Development,72(6),1868-1886.
  18. Burton-Jones, A.(2009).Minimizing method bias through programmatic research.MIS Quarterly,33(3),445-471.
  19. Carducci, B. J.(Ed.),Nave, C. S.(Ed.),Mio, J. S.(Ed.),Riggio, R. E.(Ed.)(2020).The Wiley encyclopedia of personality and individual differences: Models and theories.John Wiley & Sons.
  20. Chen, N.,Deater-Deckard, K.,Bell, M. A.(2014).The role of temperament by family environment interactions in child maladjustment.Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology,42(8),1251-1262.
  21. Cloninger, C. R.(1994).Temperament and personality.Current Opinion in Neurobiology,4(2),266-273.
  22. Cloninger, C. R.,Cloninger, K. M.,Zwir, I.,Keltikangas-Järvinen, L.(2019).The complex genetics and biology of human temperament: A review of traditional concepts in relation to new molecular findings.Translational Psychiatry,9,290.
  23. Conger, R. D.,Donnellan, M. B.(2007).An interactionist perspective on the socioeconomic context of human development.Annual Review of Psychology,58,175-199.
  24. Corapci, F.(2008).The role of child temperament on Head Start preschoolers’ social competence in the context of cumulative risk.Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology,29(1),1-16.
  25. Dearing, E.,Taylor, B. A.(2007).Home improvements: Within-family associations between income and the quality of children’s home environments.Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology,28(5-6),427-444.
  26. Delgado, B.,Carrasco, M. A.,González-Peña, P.,Holgado-Tello, F. P.(2018).Temperament and behavioral problems in young children: The protective role of extraversion and effortful control.Journal of Child and Family Studies,27(10),3232-3240.
  27. Dennis, T. A.,Brotman, L. M.,Huang, K.-Y.,Gouley, K. K.(2007).Effortful control, social competence, and adjustment problems in children at risk for psychopathology.Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology,36(3),442-454.
  28. Dollar, J. M.,Perry, N. B.,Calkins, S. D.,Keane, S. P.,Shanahan, L.(2018).Temperamental anger and positive reactivity and the development of social skills: Implications for academic competence during preadolescence.Early Education and Development,29(5),747-761.
  29. Eisenberg, N.(Ed.),Damon, W.(Ed.),Lerner, R. M.(Ed.)(2006).Handbook of child psychology: Social, emotional, and personality development.John Wiley & Sons.
  30. Eisenberg, N.(Ed.),Fabes, R. A.(Ed.)(1992).Emotion and its regulation in early development.Jossey-Bass.
  31. Eisenberg, N.,Sadovsky, A.,Spinrad, T. L.,Fabes, R. A.,Losoya, S. H.,Valiente, C.,Reiser, M.,Cumberland, A.,Shepard, S. A.(2005).The relations of problem behavior status to children’s negative emotionality, effortful control, and impulsivity: Concurrent relations and prediction of change.Developmental Psychology,41(1),193-211.
  32. Eisenberg, N.,Zhou, Q.,Losoya, S. H.,Fabes, R. A.,Shepard, S. A.,Murphy, B. C.,Reiser, M.,Guthrie, I. K.,Cumberland, A.(2003).The relations of parenting, effortful control, and ego control to children’s emotional expressivity.Child Development,74(3),875-895.
  33. Erikson, E. H.(1994).Identity: Youth and crisis.W. W. Norton & Company.
  34. Fornell, C.,Larcker, D. F.(1981).Evaluating structural equation models with unobservable variables and measurement error.Journal of Marketing Research,18(1),39-50.
  35. Foster, M. A.,Lambert, R.,Abbott-Shim, M.,McCarty, F.,Franze, S.(2005).A model of home learning environment and social risk factors in relation to children’s emergent literacy and social outcomes.Early Childhood Research Quarterly,20(1),13-36.
  36. Gerardi-Caulton, G.(2000).Sensitivity to spatial conflict and the development of self-regulation in children 24–36 months of age.Developmental Science,3(4),397-404.
  37. Hair、 J. F., Jr.,Hult, G. T. M.,Ringle, C. M.,Sarstedt, M.,湯家偉（譯）, J.-W.(Trans.)(2016).結構方程模式：偏最小平方法 PLS-SEM.高等教育=Higher Education.
  38. Hosokawa, R.,Katsura, T.(2017).A longitudinal study of socioeconomic status, family processes, and child adjustment from preschool until early elementary school: The role of social competence.Child and Adolescent Psychiatry and Mental Health,11,62.
  39. Hubbard, J. A.,Coie, J. D.(1994).Emotional correlates of social competence in children’s peer relationships.Merrill-Palmer Quarterly,40,1-20.
  40. Huber, L.,Plötner, M.,Schmitz, J.(2019).Social competence and psychopathology in early childhood: A systematic review.European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry,28(4),443-459.
  41. Jolliffe, D.(Ed.),Farrington, D. P.(Ed.)(2021).Empathy versus offending, aggression, and bullying.Routledge.
  42. Jung, C. G. (1916). Analytical psychology. Moffat Yard and Company.
  43. Kaya, İ.,Deniz, M. E.(2020).The effects of life skills education program on problem behaviors and social skills of 4-year-old preschoolers.lköğretim Online,19(2),612-623.
  44. Kochanska, G.,Aksan, N.(2006).Children’s conscience and self‐regulation.Journal of Personality,74(6),1587-1617.
  45. Lam, C. B.,Tam, C. Y. S.,Chung, K. K. H.,Li, X.(2018).The link between coparenting cooperation and child social competence: The moderating role of child negative affect.Journal of Family Psychology,32(5),692-698.
  46. Lamb, M. E.(Ed.),Brown, A. L.(Ed.)(1981).Advances in developmental psychology.Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers.
  47. Lindell, M. K.,Whitney, D. J.(2001).Accounting for common method variance in cross-sectional research designs.Journal of Applied Psychology,86(1),114-121.
  48. Luteijn, E. F.,Serra, M.,Jackson, S.,Steenhuis, M. P.,Althaus, M.,Volkmar, F.,Minderaa, R.(2000).How unspecified are disorders of children with a pervasive developmental disorder not otherwise specified? A study of social problems in children with PDD-NOS and ADHD.European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry,9(3),168-179.
  49. Maholmes, V.(Ed.),King, R. B.(Ed.)(2012).The Oxford handbook of poverty and child development.Oxford University Press.
  50. Maszk, P.,Eisenberg, N.,Guthrie, I. K.(1999).Relations of children’s social status to their emotionality and regulation: A short-term longitudinal study.Merrill-Palmer Quarterly,45(3),468-492.
  51. Matheson, S. L.,Kariuki, M.,Green, M. J.,Dean, K.,Harris, F.,Tzoumakis, S.,Tarren-Sweeney, M.,Brinkman, S.,Chilvers, M.,Sprague, T.,Carr, V. J.,Laurens, K. R.(2017).Effects of maltreatment and parental schizophrenia spectrum disorders on early childhood social-emotional functioning: A population record linkage study.Epidemiology and Psychiatric Sciences,26(6),612-623.
  52. Mathieson, K.,Banerjee, R.(2010).Pre-school peer play: The beginnings of social competence.Educational and Child Psychology,27(1),9-20.
  53. McClowry, S. G.(1995).The development of the School-Age Temperament Inventory.Merrill-Palmer Quarterly,41(3),271-285.
  54. McDougall, W. (1929). The chemical theory of temperament applied to introversion and extroversion. The Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 24(3), 293–309. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0075883
  55. Mendez, J. L.,Fantuzzo, J.,Cicchetti, D.(2002).Profiles of social competence among low-income African American preschool children.Child Development,73(4),1085-1100.
  56. Moos, R. H.,Moos, B. S.(1981).Manual for the Family Environment Scale.Consulting Psychologist Press.
  57. Neuman, S. B.,Koh, S.,Dwyer, J.(2008).CHELLO: The Child/Home Environmental Language and Literacy Observation.Early Childhood Research Quarterly,23(2),159-172.
  58. Orth, U.(2018).The family environment in early childhood has a long-term effect on self-esteem: A longitudinal study from birth to age 27 years.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,114(4),637-655.
  59. Padilla, C. M.,Ryan, R. M.(2019).The link between child temperament and low‐income mothers’ and fathers’ parenting.Infant Mental Health Journal,40(2),217-233.
  60. Piaget, J.,Inhelder, B.(2008).The psychology of the child.Basic Books.
  61. Plomin, R.(Ed.),Dunn, J.(Ed.)(1986).The study of temperament: Changes, continuities, and challenges.Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Publishers.
  62. Posner, M. I.,Rothbart, M. K.(2000).Developing mechanisms of self-regulation.Development and Psychopathology,12(3),427-441.
  63. Pulkkinen, L.(Ed.),Caspi, A.(Ed.)(2002).Paths to successful development: Personality in the life course.Cambridge University Press.
  64. Quinn, M.,Hennessy, E.(2010).Peer relationships across the preschool to school transition.Early Education and Development,21(6),825-842.
  65. Razza, R. A.,Martin, A.,Brooks-Gunn, J.(2010).Associations among family environment, sustained attention, and school readiness for low-income children.Developmental Psychology,46(6),1528-1542.
  66. Rose-Krasnor, L.(1997).The nature of social competence: A theoretical review.Social Development,6(1),111-135.
  67. Rothbart, M. K.(2007).Temperament, development, and personality.Current Directions in Psychological Science,16(4),207-212.
  68. Rothbart, M. K.,Ellis, L. K.,Rosario Rueda, M.,Posner, M. I.(2003).Developing mechanisms of temperamental effortful control.Journal of Personality,71(6),1113-1144.
  69. Rubin, K. H.,Burgess, K. B.,Dwyer, K. M.,Hastings, P. D.(2003).Predicting preschoolers’ externalizing behaviors from toddler temperament, conflict, and maternal negativity.Developmental Psychology,39(1),164-176.
  70. Rusby, J. C.,Jones, L. B.,Crowley, R.,Smolkowski, K.(2013).The Child Care Ecology Inventory: A domain-specific measure of home-based child care quality to promote social competence for school readiness.Early Childhood Research Quarterly,28(4),947-959.
  71. Rydell, A.-M.,Hagekull, B.,Bohlin, G.(1997).Measurement of two social competence aspects in middle childhood.Developmental Psychology,33(5),824-833.
  72. Saunders, S. A.,Green, V.(1993).Evaluating the social competence of young children: A review of the literature.Early Child Development and Care,87(1),39-46.
  73. Schmidt, L. A.(Ed.),Schulkin, J.(Ed.)(1999).Extreme fear, shyness, and social phobia: Origins, biological mechanisms, and clinical outcomes.Oxford University Press.
  74. Shean, M. B.,Pike, L. T.,Murphy, P. T.(2005).The acquisition of social competence: An examination of factors influencing children’s level of social competence.The Educational and Developmental Psychologist,22(2),29-46.
  75. Shiner, R. L.(2000).Linking childhood personality with adaptation: Evidence for continuity and change across time into late adolescence.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,78(2),310-325.
  76. Smith, P. K.(Ed.),Hart, C. H.(Ed.)(2002).Blackwell handbook of childhood social development.Blackwell Publishing.
  77. Strelau, J.(1996).The regulative theory of temperament: Current status.Personality and Individual Differences,20(2),131-142.
  78. Taborsky, B.(2021).A positive feedback loop between sociality and social competence.Ethology,127(10),774-789.
  79. Thomas, A.,Chess, S.(1977).Temperament and development.Brunner/Mazel.
  80. Tuerk, C.,Anderson, V.,Bernier, A.,Beauchamp, M. H.(2021).Social competence in early childhood: An empirical validation of the SOCIAL model.Journal of Neuropsychology,15(3),477-499.
  81. Vasta, R.(Ed.)(1992).Six theories of child development: Revised formulations and current issues.Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
  82. Vaughan Van Hecke, A.,Mundy, P. C.,Acra, C. F.,Block, J. J.,Delgado, C. E. F.,Parlade, M. V.,Meyer, J. A.,Neal, A. R.,Pomares, Y. B.(2007).Infant joint attention, temperament, and social competence in preschool children.Child Development,78(1),53-69.
  83. Vohs, K. D.(Ed.),Baumeister, R. F.(Ed.)(2011).Handbook of self-regulation: Research, theory, and applications.The Guilford Press.
  84. Watson, D.,Clark, L. A.,Khoo, S.(2022).The temperamental basis of extraversion and its implications for psychopathology.Personality and Individual Differences,185,111302.
  85. Xie, S.,Wu, D.,Liang, L.(2022).Family environment profile in China and its relation to family structure and young children’s social competence.Early Education and Development,33(3),469-489.
  86. Yeo, L. S.,Ong, W. W.,Ng, C. M.(2014).The home literacy environment and preschool children’s reading skills and interest.Early Education and Development,25(6),791-814.
  87. Zeigler-Hill, V.(Ed.),Shackelford, T. K.(Ed.)(2017).Encyclopedia of personality and individual differences.Spring International Publishing.
  88. Zhou, Q.,Eisenberg, N.,Wang, Y.,Reiser, M.(2004).Chinese children’s effortful control and dispositional anger/frustration: Relations to parenting styles and children’s social functioning.Developmental Psychology,40(3),352-366.
  89. 丁燾, T.,倪俊毅, J.-Y.,徐決平, J.-P.,沈瑾, J.,葉桂雲, G.-Y.,陳柳, L.,劉曉青, X.-Q.(2014)。上海崇明地區學齡前兒童社會能力與氣質類型的關係。臨床兒科雜誌，32，551-554。
  90. 王珮玲, P.-L.(1992)。兒童氣質理論之探討。臺北市立師範學院學報，23，397-413。
  91. 王珮玲, P.-L.(1995)。幼兒氣質類型與幼兒社會行為關係之探討。臺北市立師範學院學報，26，117-144。
  92. 王珮玲, P.-L.(2011).幼兒發展評量與輔導.心理出版社=Psychological Publishing.
  93. 幼兒教育網（2016）：〈幼兒教師必看：4 歲兒童心理特徵及教育要領〉。每日頭條。https://kknews.cc/zh-tw/baby/mabkmv9.html [Youer jiaoyu wang. (2016). Youer jiaoshi bi kan: 4 sui ertong xinli tezheng ji jiaoyu yaoling. KKnews. https://kknews.cc/zh-tw/baby/mabkmv9.html]
  94. 呂翠夏, T.-S.(2010)。母親與父親的情緒社會化行為及幼兒的情緒調節與同儕互動的關係。教育研究學報，44(2)，1-29。
  95. 李雪瑩, X.-Y.,李楊卓, Y.-Z.(2018)。父親情緒表達與嬰幼兒社會情緒能力的關係：嬰幼兒氣質的調節作用。學前教育研究，4，28-39。
  96. 邱皓政, H.-J.(2000).量化研究與統計分析—SPSS（PASW）資料分析範例.五南=Wu-Nan.
  97. 馬信行, H.-H.(1990)。論教育評鑑指標之選擇。現代教育，19，39-54。
  98. 張鑑如, C.-J.(2021)。,中央研究院人文社會科學研究中心調查研究專題中心學術調查研究資料庫=Survey Research Data Archive, Academia Sinica。
  99. 張鑑如, C.-J.(2019)。,中央研究院人文社會科學研究中心調查研究專題中心學術調查研究資料庫=Survey Research Data Archive, Academia Sinica。
  100. 梁宗保, Z.-B.,張光珍, G.-Z.,陳會昌, H.-C.,張萍, P.(2011)。學前兒童情緒理解的發展及其與父母元情緒理念的關係。心理發展與教育，27，233-240。
  101. 陳聖謨, S.-M.(1996)。兒童早期境遇與其氣質、社會能力關係之研究。幼兒教育年刊，9，181-212。
  102. 黃春香, C.-X.,蘇林雁, L.-Y.,李雪榮, X.-R.,倪明, M.(2001)。嬰幼兒氣質與家庭環境的關係。中國臨床心理學雜誌，3，184-186。
  103. 黃毅志, Y.-J.(1997)。職業、教育階層論與子女管教：論 Kohn 的理論在臺灣的適用性。臺東師院學報，8，1-26。
  104. 榮泰生, T.-S.(2007).AMOS 與研究方法.五南=Wu Nan.
  105. 謝育伶, Y.-L.,陳若琳, J.-L.(2008)。母親教養行為、幼兒行為調節和幼兒社會能力之相關研究。幼兒教育，290，5-21。
print cancel