地方依附對環境衝擊之影響探討─以北投纜車為例

Exploring the Relationship between Environmental Impacts and Place Attachment: A Case Study of Beitou Gondola

10.6130/JORS.2016.29(2)1

王婷萱(Ting-Hsuan Wang)；鄭佳昆(Chia-Kuen Cheng)

地方依附 ； 纜車衝擊 ； 環境衝擊 ； 鄰避設施 ； Place attachment ； Gondola impact ； Environmental impact ； NIMBY structure

戶外遊憩研究

29卷2期（2016 / 06 / 01）

1 - 26

繁體中文

地方依附是為人地關係的統稱。許多研究已指出衝擊認知跟地方依附有關，但有兩種不同的看法：部份研究認為高地方依附者在遭遇衝擊時感受較強烈，另一部份研究則認為當人具有較高的地方依附時會傾向忽略衝擊。這之間的差異目前尚未有明確定論，故本研究將主要探討可能會造成此兩種極端看法之原因。本研究以照片模擬北投公園纜車衝擊的方式進行，將地方依附、衝擊感受程度與衝擊反應進行比較，現地與網路問卷共回收235份。結果顯示地方認同越高會更容易受到設施衝擊，但同時亦會減緩遊憩環境衝擊；而當地方依賴程度越高，則越易受到遊憩環境衝擊。未來在實用上，可以進一步利用地方依附程度來推斷土地規劃或是建造新的遊憩場所計畫的實行依據。

The human-place relationship has received increasing attention in recent years. Although many researchers have suggested that perceived environmental impacts could be influenced by the level of place attachment, two opposing directions have been observed for such influences. Some studies have indicated that users with a higher degree of local bonding are vulnerable and sensitive to the impacts of depreciative behaviors than those who are less attached (Kaltenborn, 1998), while other researchers have pointed out that people with higher place attachment tend to ignore or rationalize environmental impacts and are inclined to accept them (Bonaiuto, Breakwell, & Cano, 1996). The relationship between bonding to place and perceived environmental impact is thus worthy of further discussion. The purpose of this study is to understand how place attachment influences users' perceptions of different types of environmental impacts. A photo-based experiment was conducted to measure and compare respondents' place attachment, attitudes toward Beitou Gondola, and attitudes toward depreciated behaviors. The photos helped the respondents to imagine how the gondola operated in the park. The results indicated that place identity positively affects attitudes toward the gondola and negatively affects attitudes toward depreciated behaviors. Place dependence positively affects attitudes toward depreciated behaviors. The results also showed that respondents with higher place attachment exhibit different attitudes toward different types of environmental impacts. These results provide a more in-depth explanation of the relationship between people and place, which could be applied to urban planning or environmental design in the future to improve people's lives.

1. 鄭佳昆、蘇玲玉、周紓帆(2014)。地方依附、使用經驗與環境敏感度對環境衝擊之影響。戶外遊憩研究，27(2)，67-92。
   連結：
2. Spalding, D. A. (1873). Instinct, with original observations on young animals. Macmillan's Magazine, 27, 282-293.
3. 新北市觀光旅遊網(2015)。北投公園。下載日期：104年8月3日，取自：http://tour.ntpc.gov.tw/page.aspx?wtp=1&wnd=136&id=C1_382000000A_012470 New Taipei City Travel. (2015). Beitou Park. Retrieved August 3, 2015, from http://tour.ntpc.gov.tw/page.aspx?wtp=1&wnd=136&id=C1_382000000A_012470
4. Adevi, A. A.,Grahn, P.(2011).Preferences for landscapes: A matter of cultural determinants or innate reflexes that point to our evolutionary background?.Landscape Research,3(1),27-49.
5. Altman, I.(Ed.),Low, S. M.(Ed.)(1992).Place attachment.New York:Springer.
6. Bickerstaff, K.(2004).Risk perception research: Socio-cultural perspectives on the public experience of air pollution.Environment International,30(6),827-840.
7. Bickerstaff, K.,Walker, G.(2001).Public understandings of air pollution: The 'localisation' of environmental risk.Global Environmental Change,11(2),133-145.
8. Bonaiuto, M.,Breakwell, G. M.,Cano, I.(1996).Identity processes and environmental threat: The effects of nationalism and local identity upon perception of beach pollution.Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology,6(3),157-175.
9. Bricker, K. S.,Kerstetter, D. L.(2000).Level of specialization and place attachment: An exploratory study of whitewater recreationists.Leisure Sciences,22(4),233-257.
10. Bush, J.,Moffatt, S.,Dunn, C.(2001).'Even the birds round here cough': Stigma, air pollution and health in Teesside.Health & Place,7(1),47-56.
11. Cheng, C. K.,Kuo, H. Y.(2015).Bonding to a new place never visited: Exploring the relationship between landscape elements and place bonding.Tourism Management,46,546-560.
12. Cloquell-Ballester, V. A.,del Carmen Torres-Sibille, A.,Cloquell-Ballester, V. A.,Santamarina-Siurana, M. C.(2012).Human alteration of the rural landscape: Variations in visual perception.Environmental Impact Assessment Review,32(1),50-60.
13. Devine-Wright, P.(2013).Think global, act local? The relevance of place attachments and place identities in a climate changed world.Global Environmental Change,23(1),61-69.
14. Devine-Wright, P.(2009).Rethinking NIMBYism: The role of place attachment and place identity in explaining place-protective action.Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology,19(6),426-441.
15. Devine-Wright, P.(2011).Place attachment and public acceptance of renewable energy: A tidal energy case study.Journal of Environmental Psychology,31(4),336-343.
16. Devine-Wright, P.,Howes, Y.(2010).Disruption to place attachment and the protection of restorative environments: A wind energy case study.Journal of Environmental Psychology,30(3),271-280.
17. Farrell, T.,Hall, T. E.,White, D. D.(2001).Wilderness campers' perception and evaluation of campsite impacts.Journal of Leisure Research,33(3),229-250.
18. Gibson, J. J.(1986).The ecological approach to visual perception.Abingdon-on-Thames, UK:Taylor & Francis Group.
19. Hammitt, W. E.,Backlund, E. A.,Bixler, R. D.(2004).Experience use history, place bonding and resource substitution of trout anglers during recreation engagements.Journal of Leisure Research,36(3),356-378.
20. Hammitt, W. E.,Kyle, G. T.,Oh, C. O.(2009).Comparison of place bonding models in recreation resource management.Journal of Leisure Research,41(1),57-72.
21. Hammitt, W. E.,Mcdonald, C. D.(1983).Notes: Past on-site experience and its relationship to managing river recreation resources.Forest Science,29(2),262-266.
22. Ibitayo, O. O.,Virden, R. J.(1996).Visitor and manager perceptions of depreciative behaviors in urban park settings.Journal of Park and Recreation Administration,14(4),36-51.
23. Kaltenborn, B. P.(1998).Effects of sense of place on responses to environmental impacts: A study among residents in Svalbard in the Norwegian high arctic.Applied Geography,18(2),169-189.
24. Kyle, G.,Graefe, A.,Manning, R.,Bacon, J.(2004).Effects of place attachment on users' perceptions of social and environmental conditions in a natural setting.Journal of Environmental Psychology,24(2),213-225.
25. Lewicka, M.(2011).Place attachment: How far have we come in the last 40 years?.Journal of Environmental Psychology,31(3),207-230.
26. Lima, M. L.,Marques, S.(2005).Towards successful social impact assessment follow-up: A case study of psychosocial monitoring of a solid waste incinerator in the North of Portugal.Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal,23(3),227-233.
27. Lynn, N. A.,Brown, R. D.(2003).Effects of recreational use impacts on hiking experiences in natural areas.Landscape and Urban Planning,64(1),77-87.
28. Moore, R. L.,Scott, D.(2003).Place attachment and context: Comparing a park and a trail within.Forest Science,49(6),877-884.
29. Roggenbuck, J. W.,Williams, D. R.,Watson, A. E.(1993).Defining acceptable conditions in wilderness.Environmental Management,17(2),187-197.
30. Scannell, L.,Gifford, R.(2010).Defining place attachment: A tripartite organizing framework.Journal of Environmental Psychology,30(1),1-10.
31. Schreyer, R.,Lime, D. W.,Williams, D. R.(1984).Characterizing the influence of past experience on recreation behavior.Journal of Leisure Research,16(1),34-50.
32. Shafer, C. S.,Hammitt, W. E.(1995).Purism rvisited: Specifying recreationalconditions of concern according to resource intent.Leisure Sciences,17(1),15-30.
33. Shelby, B.,Bregenzer, N. S.,Johnson, R.(1988).Displacement and product shift: Empirical evidence from oregon rivers.Journal of Leisure Research,20(4),274-288.
34. Sheldon, P. J.,Var, T.(1984).Resident attitudes to tourism in North Wales.Tourism Management,5(1),40-47.
35. Soini, K.,Vaarala, H.,Pouta, E.(2012).Residents' sense of place and landscape perceptions at the rural-urban interface.Landscape and Urban Planning,104(1),124-134.
36. Stedman, R. C.(2002).Toward a social psychology of place: Predicting behaviour from place-based cognitions, attitude, and identity.Environment and Behaviour,34(5),561-581.
37. Tuan, Y. F.(1977).Space and place: The perspective of experience.Minneapolis, MN:University of Minnesota Press.
38. Venables, D.,Pidgeon, N. F.,Parkhill, K. A.,Henwood, K. L.,Simmons, P.(2012).Living with nuclear power: Sense of place, proximity, and risk perceptions in local host communities.Journal of Environmental Psychology,32(4),371-383.
39. Vorkinn, M.,Riese, H.(2001).Environmental concern in a local context: The significance of place attachment.Environment and Behavior,33(2),249-263.
40. Wakefield, S. E. L.,Elliott, S. J.,Cole, D. C.,Eyles, J. D.(2001).Environmental risk and (re)action: Air quality, health, and civic involvement in an urban industrial neighborhood.Health & Place,7(3),163-177.
41. White, D. D.,Hall, T. E.,Farrell, T. A.(2001).Influence of ecological impacts and other campsite characteristics on wilderness visitors' campsite choices.Journal of Park and Recreation Administration,19(2),83-97.
42. White, D. D.,Virden, R. J.,van Riper, C. J.(2008).Effects of place identity, place dependence, and experience-use history on perceptions of recreation impacts in a natural setting.Environmental Management,42(4),647-657.
43. Williams, D. R.,Patterson, M. E.,Roggenbuck, J. W.,Watson, A. E.(1992).Beyond the commodity metaphor: Examining emotional and symbolic attachment to place.Leisure Sciences,14(1),29-46.
44. Williams, D. R.,Vaske, J. J.(2003).The measurement of place attachment: Validity and generalizability of a psychometric approach.Forest Science,49(6),830-840.
45. 何雍慶、蔡青姿(2009)。運用PLS方法探討價值創新導入新產品開發之調節角色。中華管理評論，12(2)，1-24。
46. 原友蘭、劉俊志(2004)。地方依附初探：一個實驗性的測量。第六屆休閒、遊憩、觀光學術研討會論文集，台北=Taipei:

1. 陳錦玉(2021)。影響離島居民觀光發展態度之研究－以金門為例。島嶼觀光研究，13(3)，48-82。
2. 甘唐沖(2023)。古蹟觀光社會經濟文化、環境衝擊、歸屬感與遊客體驗之影響。戶外遊憩研究，36(2)，1-30。
3. 張燕雲,王鑫(2023)。地方依附的縫補－以921大地震後的台中市霧峰區為例。華岡地理學報，35，60-83。
4. 鄭萱,鄭佳昆,郭怡君(2022)。被忽略的背景環境：不同活動對周邊環境注意程度之影響。造園景觀學報，26(1)，24-38。