题名

Hierarchical Evaluation Framework for Health and Wellness Destination: A Case in Zhangzhou, China

并列篇名

康養旅遊地評估指標研究－以中國漳州市為例

DOI

10.6130/JORS.202303_36(1).0002

作者

Fu-Yao Liu(劉馥瑤)；Yan-Jia Liou(劉晏嘉)

关键词

Health care ； Health and wellness tourism ； Tourism resources ； 醫療保健 ； 康養旅遊 ； 旅遊資源

期刊名称

戶外遊憩研究

卷期/出版年月

36卷1期（2023 / 03 / 01）

页次

33 - 64

内容语文

英文;繁體中文
中文摘要

Zhangzhou ranks first in Fujian Province in terms of the recreation index and has the potential for recreational tourism development. Although many cities in mainland China are present at this stage, no system for evaluating recreational tourism in cities has been developed. The development of recreational tourism should be in line with local conditions. The present study analyzed the case of Zhangzhou, a city that has favorably developed recreational tourism in terms of its available tourism resources. The elements that enable tourism to meet the needs of the current situation were identified and categorized into resource, environment, and development and construction condition factors. The elements were further divided into 7 criteria and 22 index layers on the basis of their characteristics. An expert panel of five, three, four, and four experts respectively from the tourism, medical care, forestry, and ecology industries made decisions. On the basis of their input, an evaluation system for calculating the relative weight values of indices was established. The results revealed that environment (0.462) is the factor that should be assigned the highest priority. According to a comprehensive weight analysis, vegetation coverage (0.168), forest landscapes (0.121), air quality (0.094), organic agriculture (0.069), climate (0.068), and pastoral landscapes (0.067) should also be prioritized. Therefore, health-focused travel and leisure services suitable for four seasons can be developed by utilizing the natural landscapes, environment, and organic agriculture or foods of Zhangzhou.
英文摘要

中國大陸地區雖然現階段有許多的旅居城市，但缺少城市的康養旅遊地的評價體系，而康養旅遊的開發需符合因地制宜。故本研究根據漳州現有的優勢資源分為資源條件、環境條件、開發建設等3個構面，依其性質劃分7個準則及22個指標層。研究採立意及配額的兩段式抽樣，最終由旅遊5人、醫藥護理3人、林業4人、生態學4人等專家篩選出的評價系統，求得各指標間的相對權重值。結果顯示，以環境（0.462）為目前應優先關注的構面；另根據綜合權重的顯示，應優先針對綠視率（0.168）、森林景觀（0.121）、空氣品質（0.094）、有機農業（0.069）、氣候（0.068）、田園景觀（0.067）為主要指標，故可以天然景觀、環境、有機農業／食品等，發展休養和食療等四季皆宜的康養旅遊產品。
主题分类 人文學 > 地理及區域研究
社會科學 > 體育學
参考文献
  1. 張效通, H. T,.劉錫睿, X. R.,張慕恩, M. E.,王常暢, C. C.(2020)。運用影像辨識法探討行人步道綠視率與熱影像溫度之相關性分析。建築學報，114 建築物理環境控制專刊=Special Issue on BuildingPhysical Environment Control，39-57。
    連結：
  2. 劉馥瑤, F. Y.(2019)。鄉村地區發展康養旅遊適宜性評估。島嶼觀光研究，12(2)，25-44。
    連結：
  3. Akers, A.,Barton, J.,Cossey, R.,Gainsford, P.,Griffin, M.,Micklewright, D.(2012).Visual color perception in green exercise: Positive effects on mood and perceivedexertion.Environmental Science and Technology,46(16),8661-8666.
  4. Aoki, Y.(1987).Relationship between perceived greenery and width of visual fields.Journal of the Japanese Institute of Landscape Architects,51(1),1-10.
  5. Baud-Bovy, M.,Lawsonm, F. R.(1998).Tourism and recreation handbook ofplanning and design.London, England:Architectural Press.
  6. Bennett, M.,King, B.,Milner, L.(2003).The health resort in Australia: A positioningstudy.Journal of Vacation Marketing,10(2),122-137.
  7. Bies, W.,Zacharia, L.(2007).Medical tourism: Outsourcing surgery.Mathematicaland Computer Modelling,46(7-8),1144-1159.
  8. Bowler, D. E.,Buyung-Ali, L. M.,Knight, T. M.,Pullin, A. S.(2010).A systematicreview of evidence for the added benefits to health of exposure to natural environments.BMC Public Health,10,456.
  9. Bushell, R.,Sheldon, P.(2009).Wellness and tourism: Mind, body, spirit, place.NewYork, NY:Cognizant Communication Corporation.
  10. Chang, L. C.(2014).The relationship between nature-based tourism and autonomicnervous system function among older adults.Journal of Travel Medicine,21(3),159-162.
  11. Cockerell, N.(1996).Market segments: Spas and health resorts in Europa.Travel andTourism Analysis,1,53-57.
  12. Cohen, M. M.,Elliott, F.,Oates, L.,Schembri, A.,Mantri, N.(2017).Do wellnesstourists get well? An observational study of multiple dimensions of health and well being after a week-long retreat.The Journal of Alternative and ComplementaryMedicine,23(2),140-148.
  13. Connell, J.(2006).Medical tourism: Sea, sun, sun and ⋯surgery.Tourism Management,27(6),1093-1100.
  14. Dalkey, N.,Helmer, O.(1963).An experimental application of the Delphi method tothe use of experts.Management Science,9,458-467.
  15. Delbecq, A. L.,Van De Ven, A. H.,Gustafson, D. H.(1975).Group techniques forprogram planning: A guide to inal group and Delphi processes.New York, NJ:Scott,Forssmann and Company.
  16. Douglas, R. W.(2000).Forest recreation.Prospect Heights, IL:Waveland Press.
  17. Garcia-Altes, A.(2005).The development of health tourism services.Annals of TourismResearch,32(1),262-266.
  18. Gilbert, D. C.,Van De Weerdt, M.(1991).The health care tourism product in WesternEurope.Revue de Tourism,46(2),5-10.
  19. Hall, C. M.(2011).Health and medical tourism: A kill or cure for global public health?.Tourism Review,66(1/2),4-15.
  20. Hamilton, M.(2005).Climate change and international tourism: A simulation study.Global Environmental Change,15(1),253-266.
  21. Hansen, M. M.,Jones, R.,Tocchini, K.(2017).Shinrin-Yoku (forest bathing) andnature therapy: A state-of-the-art review.Environ Res Public Health,14(8),851.
  22. Hartig, T. A.,Mang, M.,Evans, G. W.(1991).Restorative effects of naturalenvironment experiences.Environment and Behavior,23,3-26.
  23. Heather, J. G.,Jerome, F. S.(2012).Leisure and aging: Theory and practice.Champaign, IL:Human Kinetics.
  24. Li, Q.,Kawada, T.(2011).Effect of forest therapy on the human psycho neuroendocrino-immune network.Nihonseigaku Zasshi Japanese Journal of Hygiene,66(4),645-650.
  25. Lichtenfeld, S.,Elliot, A. J.,Maier, M. A.,Pekrun, R.(2012).Fertile green: Greenfacilitates creative performance.Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,38(6),784-797.
  26. Lv. J.Wang, W.,Li, Y.(2011).Effect of environmental factors on the longevouspeople in China.Archives of Gerontology and Geriatrics,53(2),200-205.
  27. Miglbauer, M. E.(2002).Health tourism & overseas treatment in England-Analysis oftrend and systems.Vienna,Austria Family and Youth:Federal Ministry of Economy.
  28. Miller, J. W.(2005).Wellness: The history and development of a concept.SpektrumFreizeit,1,84-102.
  29. Mueller, H.,Kaufmann, E. L.(2001).Health and wellness tourism: Market analysisof a special health tourism segment and implications for the hotel industry.Journal ofVacation Marketing,7(1),5-17.
  30. National Tourism Administration of the People’s Republic of China(2016).National Tourism Administration of the People’s Republic of China. (2016). Demonstration destination of health and wellness tourism. Beijing, China: NationalTourism Administration of the People’s Republic of China..
  31. Park, B. J.,Tsunetsugu, Y.,Morikawa, T.(2014).Physiological and psychologicaleffects of walking in stay-in forest therapy.Nihonseigaku Zasshi Japanese Journal ofHygiene,69(2),98-103.
  32. Ramanathan, R. A.(2001).Note on the use of the analytic hierarchy process forenvironmental impact assessment.Journal of Environmental Management,63,27-35.
  33. Ross, K. (2001). Health tourism: An overview. Retrieved from http://www. hospitalitynet.org/news/4010521.html
  34. Saaty, T. L.(1980).The analytic hierarchy process.New York, NY:McGraw-Hill.
  35. Salehi-Esfahani, S.,Ridderstaat, J.,Ozturk, A. B.(2021).Health tourism in adeveloped country with a dominant tourism market: The case of the United States’travellers to Canada.Current Issues in Tourism,24(4),536-553.
  36. Sharkey, J. R.,Giuliani, C.,Haines, P. S.,Branch, L. G.,Busby, W. J.,Zohoori,N.(2003).Summary measure dietary musculoskeletal nutrient (calcium, vitamin Dmagnesium, and phosphorus) intakes is associated with lower extremity physicalperformance in homebound elderly men and women.The American Journal of ClinicalNutrition,77,847.
  37. Spivack, S. E.(1998).Health spa development in the US: A burgeoning component ofsport tourism.Journal of Vacation Marketing,4(1),65-77.
  38. The State Council of the People’s Republic of China (2016). Outline of thehealthy China 2030 plan. Retrieved from http://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2016-10/25/content_5124174.htm
  39. Tsunetsugu, Y.,Park, B. J.,Ishii, H.,Hirano, H.,Kagawa, T.,Miyazaki, Y.(2007).Physiological effects of Shin Rin-yoku (Taking in the atmosphere of the forest) in an old-growth broadleaf forest in Yamagata prefecture, Japan.Journal of Physiological Anthropology,26,135-142.
  40. Ulrich, R. S.,Simons, R. F.,Losito, B. D.,Fiorito, E.,Miles, M. A.,Zelson, M.(1991).Stress recovery during exposure to natural and urban environments.Journal of Environmental Psychology,11(3),201-230.
  41. Vaidya, O. S.,Kumar, S.(2006).Analytic hierarchy process: An overview ofapplications.European Journal of Operational Research,169(1),1-29.
  42. Velarde, M. D.,Fry, G.,Tveit, M.(2007).Health effects of viewing landscapes Landscape types in environmental psychology.Urban Forestry and Urban Greening,6(4),199-212.
  43. World Health Organization (1986). Ottawa charter for health promotion. Retrievedfrom https://www.euro.who.int/_data/assets/pdf_file/0004/129532/Ottawa_Charter.pdf
  44. World Health Organization (2021). Health topics: Food safety. Retrieved from https://www.who.int/health-topics/food-safety
  45. World Tourism Organization (2013). Accessible Tourism for All. Retrieved from http://www.keroul.qc.ca/DATA/PRATIQUEDOCUMENT/24_frp
  46. Yamada, Y.(2006).Soundscape-based forest planning for recreational and therapeuticactivities.Urban Forestry & Urban Greening,5(3),131-139.
  47. 中國旅行社協會=China Association of Travel Services(2021)。中國旅行社協會(2021)。康養旅遊基地設施與服務規範(T/CATS003-2021)。北京：中國旅行社協會。China Association of Travel Services (2021). Specification for facilities and service on health and wellness tourism base (T/CATS003-2021). Beijing: China Association of Travel Services.。
  48. 中國氣象局(2011)。居環境氣候舒適度評價(GB/T27963 )。北京：中國氣象局。China Meteorological Administration (2011). The comfortable degree evaluation of human settlements base (GB/T27963 ). Beijing: China Meteorological Press.
  49. 中華人民共和國文化和旅遊部(2016)。國家康養旅遊示範基地。上網日期：2021年1月21日。網址：https://www.mct.gov.cn/Ministry of Culture and Tourism of the People’s Republic of China (2016). Demonstration Destination of Health and wellness. Retrieved January 21, 2021, from https://www.mct.gov.cn/
  50. 毛曉莉, X. L,薛群慧, Q. H.(2012)。國外健康旅遊發展進程研究。學術探索，11，47-51。
  51. 王少華, S. H,王璐, L.,王夢茵, M. Y.,王偉, W.(2020)。新冠肺炎疫情對河南省旅遊業的衝擊表徵及影響機理研究。地域研究與開發，39(2)，1-7。
  52. 王玲, L.(2020).康養旅遊策劃.杭州=Hangzhou:浙江大學出版社=ZhejiangUniversity Press.
  53. 包戰雄, Z. X.,祁新華, X. H,袁書琪, S. Q.(2019)。天氣和氣候與旅遊需求關係的研究進展。亞熱帶資源與環境學報，14(3)，60-67。
  54. 何莽, M.(2018).康養藍皮書.北京=Beijing:社會科學文獻出版社=Social Sciences Literature Press.
  55. 折原夏志(2006)。緑景観の評価に関する研究—良好な景観形成に向けた緑の評価手法に関する考察。調查研究期報 Seasonal Research Report ofUR，142，4-13。
  56. 李正泉, Z. Q.,賀忠華, Z. H.,胡中民, Z. M.(2020)。氣候與健康及氣候康養研究進展。海洋氣象學報，40(1)，107-116。
  57. 李智堯, C. Y,馬成瑉, C. M.(2014)。親子參與高齡保健旅遊之研究。醫療資訊雜誌，23(3)，25-40。
  58. 李濟任, J. R.,許東, D.(2018)。基於AHP與模糊綜合評價法的森林康養旅遊開發潛力評價—以遼東山區為例。中國農業資源與區劃，39(8)，135-142+169。
  59. 肖希, X.,韋怡凱, Y. K.,李敏, M(2018)。日本城市綠視率計量方法與評價應用。國際城市規劃，32(2)，98-103。
  60. 林敏, M.,柴可夫, K. F(2019)。閩南脾胃飲食養生方法探析。中華中醫藥雜誌，34(4)，1640-1642。
  61. 林雪蘭, H. L,陳建和, C. H.(2014)。銀髮族海外旅遊安全需求。觀光與休閒管理期刊，2(S)，44-59。
  62. 高丹丹, D. D.,劉鵬, P,李順龍, S. L(2017)。伊春市發展森林康養產業的潛力挖掘與品牌建設。東北林業大學學報，45(8)，101-104。
  63. 郭廣會, G. H.,徐莉, L,周彬, B.(2011)。海濱氣候療法應用進展。中國療養醫學，20(8)，673-675。
  64. 郭魯芳, L. F,虞丹丹, D. D.(2005)。健康旅遊探析。北京第二外國語學院學報，3，63-66。
  65. 陳純, C.(2019)。國內外康養旅遊研究綜述。攀枝花學院學報，36(4)，43-47。
  66. 陸曉梅, X. M.,張鑫, X.,高淑春, S. C.(2017)。森林養生旅遊開發潛力評價研究。林業經濟問題，37(1)，44-49+104。
  67. 曾日秋, R. X.,蔡建興, J. X.,江志鵬, Z. P.,洪建基, J. J.(2015)。漳州市中藥材產業歷史、現狀及發展思路。特種經濟動植物，18(9)，20-23。
  68. 程雲, Y.,殷傑, J.(2022)。新冠肺炎疫情是否激發了康養旅遊意願？一個條件過程模型的檢驗。旅遊學刊，37(7)，119-132。
  69. 黃俐琳, L. L.(2020)。福建=Fujian，福建農林大學園藝學院=Department of Horticulture, Fujian Agriculture and Forestry University。
  70. 黃俐琳, L. L.,袁媛, Y,陳清西, Q. X.(2020)。漳州郊野公園綠道康養指標評價分析。南方農業，14(22)，59-66。
  71. 雷銘, M.(2017)。醫療旅遊研究現狀及啟示。中國衛生政策研究，10(7)，65-70。
  72. 漳州市人民政府 (2021)。漳州概況。上網日期：2021年1月21日。網址：http://www.zhangzhou.gov.cn/Zhangzhou Municipal People’s Government (2021). Overview of Zhangzhou. RetrievedJanuary 21, 2021, from http://www.zhangzhou.gov.cn/
  73. 劉朝望, C. W,王道陽, D. Y.,喬永強, Y. Q.(2017)。森林康養基地建設探究。林業資源管理，2，93-95+156。
  74. 蘇大成, T. C.(2016)。空氣汙染與心血管健康。台灣醫學，20(4)，377-386。
  75. 鐘暉, H.,王媛, Y.(2020)。健康旅遊研究綜述。昆明理工大學學報（社會科學版），20(5)，109-115。
被引用次数
  1. (2024)。基於需求預測與應用對臺灣觀光產業品質分析的選擇研究。品質學報，31(3)，151-177。
print cancel