美國的主要檔案鑑定思想與理論

The Development of Archival Appraisal Theory in America

10.6120/JoEMLS.200706_44(4).0173.RS.BM

林素甘(Su-Kan Lin)

檔案鑑定 ； 檔案價值 ； 美國 ； Archival appraisal ； Archival values ； America

教育資料與圖書館學

44卷4期（2007 / 06 / 01）

435 - 454

繁體中文

美國檔案界自1940年代開始論述其檔案鑑定思想，歷經多位學者的努力已發展出一套完整的鑑定理論與架構，不僅成為當今鑑定理論的主流思想，更對許多國家的鑑定實務工作產生重大的影響。本文以美國檔案鑑定思想之發展先後，依序陳述各個時期重要學者之鑑定理論或觀點，藉以了解這些鑑定理論的特點以及對近代檔案鑑定的影響。

Since 1940, many archivists in America have devoted their effort to build up the theory of archival appraisal and make significant contribution. Their viewpoint are not only the mainstream of the discussion of appraisal, but also influence the practical work in archives in many countries. This paper aims to introduce and discuss the development of archival appraisal viewpoints in America in order to understand their characteristics and its impact on the work of archival appraisal.

1. Abraham, T.(1991).Collection policy or documentation strategy: Theory and practice.American Archivist,54(1),44-52.
2. Alexander, P. N.,Samuels, H. W.(1987).The route of 128: A hypothetical documentation strategy.American Archivist,50(4),518-531.
3. Bailey, C.(1997).From the top down: The practice of macro-appraisal.Archivaria,43,89-128.
4. Bellardo, L.,Bellardo, L. L. (Eds.)(1992).A glossary of archivists, manuscript curators, and records managers.Chicago:Society of American Archivists.
5. Boles, F.,Greene, M. A.(1996).Et Tu Schellengerg? Thoughts on the dagger of American appraisal theory.American Archivist,59(3),298-310.
6. Boles, F.,Young, J. M.(1985).Exploring the black box: The appraisal of university administrative records.American Archivist,48(2),121-140.
7. Boles, F.,Young, J. M.(1991).Archival appraisal.New York:Neal-Schuman.
8. Brichford, M. J.(1977).Archives & manuscripts: Appraisal & accessioning.Chicago:Society of American Archivists.
9. Brooks, P. C.(1940).The selection of records for preservation.American Archivist,3(4),221-234.
10. Committee of Intrinsic Value.,M. F. Maneils,T. Walch, (Eds.)(1984).A modern archives reader: Basic readings on archival theory and practice.Washington, DC:National Archives & Records Service.
11. Cook, M.(1977).Archives administration: A manual for intermediate and small organizations and for local government.England:Dawson.
12. Cook, T.(1997).What is past is prologue: A history of archival ideas since 1898, and the future paradigm shift.Archivaria,43,17-63.
13. Cox, R. J.(1989).A documentation strategy case study: Western New York.American Archivist,52(2),192-200.
14. Cox, R. J.(1996).The archival documentation strategy and its implications or the appraisal of architectural records.American Archivist,59(2),144-154.
15. Duranti, L.(1994).The concept of appraisal and archival theory.American Archivist,57(2),328-345.
16. Thinking on archival appraisal in the Europe and North America: A critical analysis
17. Ericson, T. L.(1997).To approximate June pasture: The documentation strategy in the real world.Archival Issues,22(1),5-20.
18. Hackman, L. J.,Warnow-Blewett, J.(1987).The documentation strategy process: A model and a case study.American Archivist,50(1),12-46.
19. Ham, F. G.(1993).Selecting and appraising archives and manuscripts.Chicago:Society of American Archivists.
20. Iacovino, L.(1989).The development of the principles of appraisal in the public sector and their application to business records.Archives and Manuscripts,17(2),197-218.
21. Klumpenhouwer, R.(1988).Vancouver,University of British Columbia.
22. Maher, W. J.(1992).The management of college and university archives.Metuchen, NJ:Scarecrow.
23. Marshall, J. A.(1998).Documentation strategies in the twenty-first century? Rethinking institutional priorities and professional limitations.Archival Issues,23(1),59-74.
24. McRanor, S.(1996).A critical analysis of intrinsic value.American Archivist,59(4),400-411.
25. Mitchell, T. W.(1970).New viewpoints of establishing permanent values of state archives.American Archivist,33,163-174.
26. Norton, M. C.(1944).The disposal of records.Illinois Libraries,26,120-124.
27. Rapport, L.(1981).No grandfather clause: Reappraising accessioned records.American Archivist,44(2),143-150.
28. Reed, B.,Judith Ellis, (Ed.)(1993).Keeping archives.Port Melbourne:Thorpe.
29. Samuels, H. W.(1986).Who controls the past.American Archivist,49(2),109-124.
30. Schellenberg, T. R.(1956).Modern archives: Principles and techniques.Chicago:The University of Chicago Press.
31. Schellenberg, T. R.,M. F. Maneils,T.Walch, (Eds.)(1956).A modern archives reader: Basic readings on archival theory and practice.Washington, DC:National Archives & Records Service.
32. Theories of appraisal
33. Walters, T. O.(1996).Contemporary archival appraisal methods and preservation decisionmaking.American Archivist,59(3),322-338.
34. 張聰明(2001)。美國檔案保存價值鑑定制度之研究。台北市:檔案管理局。

1. 陳政宏(2009)。臺灣科技檔案的存放、研究與鑑選特性。檔案季刊，8(1)，4-17。