探究小組協作資訊尋求的成功與困難因素

Exploring factors for Collaborative Group Investigation

10.6120/JoEMLS.200912_47(2).0293.RS.AM

吳美美(Mei-Mei Wu)；Jonathan Foster

合作學習 ； 合作資訊搜尋 ； 小組調查 ； 主題聚焦 ； Collaborative learning ； Collaborative information seeking ； Group investigation ； Focus formation

教育資料與圖書館學

47卷2期（2009 / 12 / 01）

123 - 146

繁體中文

合作學習是近來教育實踐很重視的課題，其中很重要的活動之一，就是合作搜尋資訊、研讀、討論，形成學習的焦點。本論文採用Shah(2008)的協作膠囊說理論，區別合作和協作，用以強調合作是資源分享，而協作是協同和合作，既分享資源，還須共同完成任務。本研究採行動研究設計，利用研究方法課程，將同學分組，進行協作文獻收集、檢索、評閱、組織、整合，寫成小組海報，並發表。教師於小組討論時參與觀察，撰寫教師日誌，同學亦撰寫學習日誌和小組學習心得，學期結束後，將各項文本進行分析。本研究進行小組合作資訊搜尋的過程研究，期望了解小組合作搜尋資訊有哪些有效策略。搜尋資訊是資訊技能之一，除了需要相關知識，包括對於資源、檢索引擎、關鍵詞或分類體系的了解之外，也涉及一些頗有難度的心智活動，例如檢索策略的研擬、相關資訊的篩選、主題聚焦等；對於小組合作檢索資訊而言，建立一致的目標、共同尋求主題聚焦，更須要借助人際溝通技能的幫助，例如表達能否達意、分享知識是否使小組人員都能理解。這些似乎普通的概念，若能妥適加以整合，應可以形成有效的小組合作資訊搜尋策略。

Collaborative information seeking (CIS) turns out to be a focus of research in the Internet environment. How collaborative information seeking can be successfully performed in a Research Methods class is a concern of this study. A successful CIS means the team members reach the mutual goal and accomplish the class project. This paper attempts to identify the elements for successful CIS as well as the obstacles. An action research in a class setting was designed and data for teachers' observation as well as students' journals for the collaborative processes were collected. Students' team projects were analyzed. Barriers as well as key elements for successful CIS were identified and discussed. New model for CIS instruction was proposed and recommended for future implementation.

1. Foster, J.(2009).Understanding interaction in information seeking and use as a discourse: a dialogic approach.Journal of Documentation,65(1),83-105.
2. Foster, J.,B. Cronin (Ed.)(2006).Annual Review of Information Science and Technology.Medford, NJ:Information Today.
3. Collaborative information behavior (CIB): Current challenges and future research directions
4. Hertzum, M.(2008).Collaborative information seeking: The combined activity of information seeking and collaborative grounding.Information Processing & Management,44(2),957-962.
5. Kuhlthau, C.C.(2004).Seeking Meaning: A Process Approach to Library and Information Services.London:Libraries Unlimited.
6. Kuhlthau, C.C.(1991).Inside the search process: Information seeking from the user's perspective.Journal of the American Society for Information Science,42,361-371.
7. Information Research
8. Toward collaborative information seeking (CIS)
9. Vakkari, P.(2001).A theory of the task-based information retrieval process: A summary and generalization of a longitudinal study.Journal of Documentation,57(1),44-60.

1. 蔡天怡,莊竣顯(2019).Individual Differences in Undergraduate Students' Collaborative Information Seeking Behavior When Working on Group Projects: A Study on Willingness to Collaborate and Sources Used.圖書資訊學刊,17(2),103-129.
2. 蔡天怡、楊琬琳(2018)。合作學習情境中師資培育生教案發展之協作資訊行為。圖書資訊學刊，16(1)，109-139。
3. 蔣世寶(2023)。大專班級組織成員對於課程活動之參與態度研究－以視覺傳達設計專業為例。教育研究與實踐學刊，70(1)，49-76。
4. 王明旭(2023)。協作學習理論發展團隊協作四部曲之跨域教學成效評估：以設計思考課程為例。教育實踐與研究，36(1)，73-120。
5. 薛招治(2021)。農學院學生專利資訊素養建構：課程設計與實踐。科學教育學刊，29(3)，267-298。