會議論文延伸出版為期刊論文其時滯與修改差異之研究：以管理領域學術會議為例

The Differences of Time Lag and Revisions of Conference Papers Extended Publishing to Journal Articles: In Field of Management

10.6120/JoEMLS.201807_55(2).0014.RS.BM

呂昱慧(Yu-Hui Lu)；林雯瑤(Wen-Yau Cathy Lin)

延伸出版 ； 出版時滯 ； 管理領域 ； 會議論文 ； 期刊論文 ； Extended Publication ； Publication lag ； Field of Management ； Conference Paper ； Journal Article

教育資料與圖書館學

55卷2期（2018 / 07 / 01）

139 - 170

繁體中文

本研究主要目的為探討管理領域會議論文延伸出版的現象，以科技部「管理二」學門推薦之行銷、生管、交管、資管領域的九個國際學術會議，於2011年所出版的2,427篇會議論文為研究對象。利用書目計量法，分析延伸出版的數量與比率、文獻類型、延伸出版的時間差距。並比較原始會議論文與延伸為期刊論文的版本在轉投至期刊的出版時滯、作者身份、參考文獻、篇幅、圖表數量等的變化。研究結果顯示，管理領域整體延伸出版的比率平均為17.06%，延伸出版的文獻類型有79.1%為期刊論文，延伸至期刊的平均出版時間為27.99個月，平均投稿時滯為14個月。本研究建議學術出版單位可制訂延伸出版的相關規範，以減少學術傳播的爭議性行為，而研究者與期刊編輯也應確實遵循相關規範，以避免學術不端的行為。

The purpose of this study was to investigate the extended publishing of conference papers in the field of management. The sample examined consisted of a total of 2,427 conference papers that were published in 2011 in nine international conferences spanning four academic fields, which were marketing, production and operations management, transportation management, and information management. This study adopted bibliometrics to analyze the extended publishing rate of the original conference papers, the document types of the extended publications, and the publication lag from the original conference papers to extended versions publishing. The differences between the originals and extended publications were also compared, including the changes in authorship, references, the length of articles, and the number of tables and figures. The results of the study reveal that the average extended publishing rate of the original conference papers was 17.06%, with journal articles being the major category. The average time lag for extended journal articles publishing was 27.99 months, and for submission was 14 months. This study suggested that the academic publishers provide relevant publication policy for extended publication. The journal editors and researchers should follow the guideline for submission and the editorial policy to avoid academic misconduct.

1. 呂昱慧、林雯瑤(2016)。從學術會議論文到期刊論文的延伸出版：以資訊管理領域為例。圖書資訊學刊，14(2)，155-179。
   連結：
2. 蔡明月、鄭琚媛(2005)。台灣地區生命科學國際會議文獻生產力研究。圖書與資訊學刊，53，1-17。
   連結：
3. American Physiological Society. (2018). APS ethics policy. Retrieved from https://www. physiology.org/author-info.ethical-policies
4. Bar-Ilan, J.(2010).Web of Science with the conference proceedings citation indexes: The case of computer science.Scientometrics,83(3),809-824.
5. Carraro, C.,Lanza, A.,Papponetti, V.(2004).One thousand working papers.SSRN Electronic Journal
6. Eckmann, M.,Rocha, A.,Wainer, J.(2012).Relationship between high-quality journals and conferences in computer vision.Scientometrics,90(2),617-630.
7. Elsevier. (2016). Scopus: Content. Retrieved from https://www.elsevier.com/solutions/scopus/content
8. Fortnow, L.(2009).Viewpoint: Time for computer science to grow up.Communications of the ACM,52(8),33-35.
9. Franceschet, M.(2010).The role of conference publications in CS.Communications of the ACM,53(12),129-132.
10. Frandsen, T. F.,Wouters, P.(2009).Turning working papers into journal articles: An exercise in microbibliometrics.Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,60(4),728-739.
11. Freyne, J.,Coyle, L.,Smyth, B.,Cunningham, P.(2010).Relative status of journal and conference publications in computer science.Communications of the ACM,53(11),124-132.
12. Godoy, D.,Zunino, A.,Mateos, C.(2015).Publication practices in the Argentinian Computer Science community: A bibliometric perspective.Scientometrics,102(2),1795-1814.
13. Halpern, J. Y.,Parkes, D. C.(2011).Journals for certification, conferences for rapid dissemination.Communications of the ACM,54(8),36-38.
14. Harvey, S. A.,Wandersee, J. R.(2010).Publication rate of abstracts of papers and posters presented at medical library association annual meetings.Journal of the Medical Library Association,98(3),250-255.
15. Hendrickson, C.,McNeil, S.,Chang, G.-L.,Agrawal, A.(2011).Conference papers and prior publication.Journal of Infrastructure Systems,17(4),137.
16. Information Systems Research. (2018). Submission guidelines. Retrieved from https://pubsonline.informs.org/page/isre/submission-guidelines
17. Johnson, K. A.(2015).Prior publication of papers.Veterinary and Comparative Orthopaedics and Traumatology,28(2),V.
18. Johnson, K. A.(2009).Redundant, duplicate or dual publication?.Veterinary and Comparative Orthopaedics and Traumatology,22(4),III-IV.
19. Lisée, C.,Larivière, V.,Archambault, É.(2008).Conference proceedings as a source of scientific information: A bibliometric analysis.Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,59(11),1779-1784.
20. Medical Library Association. (2017). How to convert an oral presentation to a manuscript. Retrieved from http://www.mlanet.org/page/how-to-convert-an-oral-presentation-to-a-manuscript
21. MIS Quarterly. (2016). Manuscript guidelines. Retrieved from https://misq.org/manuscript-guidelines
22. Montesi, M.,Owen, J. M.(2008).From conference to journal publication: How conference papers in software engineering are extended for publication in journals.Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,59(5),816- 829.
23. Nolan, J. F.,Smith, E. G.,van Kooten, G. C.,Wilson, J. R.(2010).What constitutes prior publication? An editorial opinion.Canadian Journal of Agricultural Economics,58(1),1-3.
24. Pertile, S. D. L.,Moreira, V. P.,Rosso, P.(2016).Comparing and combining content-and citation-based approaches for plagiarism detection.Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology,67(10),2511-2526.
25. SAGE Publishing. (2016). Prior publication. Retrieved from https://uk.sagepub.com/en-gb/asi/prior-publication
26. Scherer, R. W.,Langenberg, P.,von Elm, E.(2007).Full publication of results initially presented in abstracts.Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews,2
27. Shaw, C. E.,Szwajcer, A. L.(2016).Publication rate of presentation abstracts presented at the canadian health libraries association (CHLA/ABSC) annual meetings from 2004-2009.Performance Measurement and Metrics,17(3),252-262.
28. Tierney, H. L.,Hammond, P.,Nordlander, P.,Weiss, P. S.(2012).Prior publication: Extended abstracts, proceedings articles, preprint servers, and the like.ACS Nano,6(9),7543-7544.
29. University of Sheffield. (2018). Publishing work prior to submission. Retrieved from https://www.sheffield.ac.uk/rs/code/publishing
30. Wainer, J.,Valle, E.(2013).What happens to computer science research after it is published? Tracking CS research lines.Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,64(6),1104-1111.
31. Zhang, L.(2011).Proceeding papers or journal articles? A comparative analysis on computer science versus economics, business and management.Proceedings of the 2011 2nd International Conference on Artificial Intelligence, Management Science and Electronic Commerce (AIMSEC)
32. Zhang, L.(2015).Studying the publication pattern of Canadian computer scientists.Canadian Journal of Information and Library Science,39(1),60-78.
33. Zhang, Y. H.,Jia, X.(2013).Republication of conference papers in journals?.Learned Publishing,26(3),189196.
34. 大專體育學刊（2015）。「大專體育學刊」稿約。檢索自http://aspers.airiti.com/aspers/ webHome.aspx?jnliid=J0017【Sports & Exercise Research. (2015). Sports & Exercise Research gaoyue. Retrieved from http://aspers.airiti.com/aspers/webHome. aspx?jnliid=J0017 (in Chinese)】
35. 科技部人文及社會科學研究發展司（2016）。管理學。檢索自https://www.most.gov. tw/hum/ch/detail?article_uid=99cc7e9d-d94f-41bd-a1fc-1cc3bea933ad&menu_id=96c12199-c4e0-46a6-9fb6-7b00dba2b600&content_type=P&view_mode=listView 【Department of Humanities and Social Sciences, Ministry of Science and Technology. (2016). Management. Retrieved from https://www.most.gov.tw/hum/ch/detail?article_ uid=99cc7e9d-d94f-41bd-a1fc-1cc3bea933ad&menu_id=96c12199-c4e0-46a6-9fb6- 7b00dba2b600&content_type=P&view_mode=listView (in Chinese)】
36. 科技部人文及社會科學研究發展司（2015）。科技部人文司管理二學門國際學術會議參考名單。檢索自https://www.most.gov.tw/most/attachments/add16492-afbc-4c95-917d-77dfb4b75228【Department of Humanities and Social Sciences, Ministry of Science and Technology. (2015). Management (II), Department of Humanities and Social Sciences, Ministry of Science and Technology xuemen guoji xueshu huiyi cankao mingdan. Retrieved from https://www.most.gov.tw/most/attachments/add16492-afbc-4c95-917d-77dfb4b75228 (in Chinese)】
37. 黃秀琴(2001)。會議文獻作者生產力與其延續出版品之研究：以國防科技學術研討會為例。台北縣=Taipei:淡江大學資訊與圖書館學系=Department of Information and Library Science, Tamkang University。
38. 傳播研究與實踐（2016）。徵稿啟事。檢索自http://aspers.airiti.com/aspers/webHome. aspx?jnliid=J0014【Journal of Communication Research and Practice. (2016). Zhenggao qishi. Retrieved from http://aspers.airiti.com/aspers/webHome.aspx?jnliid=J0014 (in Chinese)】
39. 翟自洋、張月紅(2013)。國際期刊界如何看待會議論文集再發表：基於對78種國際期刊及120位編輯的調查。中國出版，14，16-18。
40. 臺灣建築學會（2016）。建築學報徵稿啟事。檢索自http://www.airoc.org.tw/StudioNews.php?dir=74【Architectural Institute of Taiwan. (2016). Journal of Architecture zhenggao qishi. Retrieved from http://www.airoc.org.tw/StudioNews.php?dir=74 (in Chinese)】
41. 裴世保、夏玉良(2013)。計算機學科會議論文重要性分析與探討。科技管理研究，8，241-245。
42. 蔡明月、鄭琚媛(2005)。臺灣地區生命科學國際會議文獻延續出版之研究。中華民國圖書館學會會報，75，145-159。
43. 顧東蕾、鄭曉南(2014)。會議論文在學術期刊上發表之研究。中國科技期刊研究，25(1)，57-64。

1. 周倩(2023)。將研討會論文延伸至期刊論文的相關規範與建議作法：學術倫理之觀點。教育資料與圖書館學，60(2)，189-216。