题名

學校圖書館對學生閱讀投入及學科成績影響之研究：以湖南雙峰縣偏鄉小學為例

并列篇名

The Effectiveness of School Libraries on Students' Reading Engagement and Learning Achievement: A Case of Rural Schools in Hunan, China

DOI

10.6120/JoEMLS.202103_58(1).0057.RS.AM

作者

李宗曄(Tsung-Yeh Lee)；陳昭珍(Chao-Chen Chen)；梁偉明(Wai-Ming Leung)；梁鴻栩(Hong-Shiu Liang)

关键词

學校圖書館 ； 閱讀計畫 ； 閱讀投入 ； 學科成績 ； 差異中的差異分析法 ； School libraries ； Reading program ； Reading engagement ； Learning achievement ； Difference-in-difference approach

期刊名称

教育資料與圖書館學

卷期/出版年月

58卷1期（2021 / 03 / 01）

页次

7 - 46

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

學校圖書館對學生的學科成績是否有影響，過去在已開發與開發中國家進行的研究其結果往往相左，此為一有趣現象，也需不斷被實證與探討的問題。本研究以大陸湖南省雙峰縣16間偏鄉小學為研究對象，經兩年的追蹤調查，以獨立樣本t檢定及差異中的差異DID檢定，進行學生的閱讀投入及縣級集中考試之學科成績差異分析。研究結果發現，設立學校圖書館且進行閱讀計畫的有無，在閱讀投入構面有顯著差異，顯示學校圖書館及閱讀計畫對於培養學生閱讀興趣、閱讀態度及閱讀策略的價值。但在學科成績方面，t檢定有顯著差異，但DID檢定則無一致之顯著差異。本研究對象除設立學校圖書館外也同時推動閱讀計畫，研究結果可補充過去在開發中國家進行相關研究所缺之論述。
英文摘要

Regarding whether school libraries have an effect on students' learning achievement, previous findings in empirical studies are inconsistent across different developing and developed countries. This is an interesting phenomenon, which is still an important research topic that needs to be further tested and explored. In this study, a total of 16 rural primary schools in Shuangfeng County, Hunan Province were selected as the research subjects. After two years of follow-up survey investigation and data collection, the independent t-test and the difference-in-differences (DID) approach were used to analyze the differences of students' reading engagement and the countywide standardized test scores. The result shows that there were significant differences in the aspect of reading engagement between the students at the schools with and without a school library and the reading program. The result also indicates the value of school library and reading program in cultivating students' reading interest, reading attitude and reading strategies. The t-test reveals that there were significant differences in the aspect of standardized test scores, however, there was no consistent significant difference in DID test. The intervention in this study included the implementation of a reading program in addition to setting up a physical school library, thus, the results of this study may complement some previous empirical studies conducted in developing countries.
主题分类 人文學 > 圖書資訊學
参考文献
  1. 宋曜廷, Yao-Tin,劉佩雲, Pei-Yun,簡馨瑩, Hsin-Yin(2003)。閱讀動機量表的修訂及相關因素研究。測驗學刊，50，47-72。
    連結：
  2. 樊家忠, Elliott(2018)。尋找平行世界─Differences-in-Differences 之方法與應用。會計審計論叢，8(1)，1-13。
    連結：
  3. 閱讀夢飛翔文化關懷慈善基金（無日期）。https://readingdreams.org.hk【Reading Dreams. (n.d.). https://readingdreams.org.hk (in Chinese)】
  4. Achterman, D. L.(2008).University of North Texas.
  5. Adeyemi, T. O.(2010).The school library and students’ learning outcomes in secondary schools in Ekiti State, Nigeria.Asian Journal of Business Management,2(1),1-8.
  6. Adkins, D.,Brendler, B. M.(2015).Libraries and reading motivation: A review of the programme for international student assessment reading results.International Federation of Library Associations and Institutions,41(2),129-139.
  7. Alvarado, E. S.,Adriatico, C.(2019).Reading motivation vis-s-vis academic performance.Open Journal of Social Sciences,7(6),92.
  8. Anderson, R. (2013). Interrogating the American Library Association’s “core values” statement: Peer to peer review. Library Journal. http://lj.libraryjournal.com/2013/01/opinion/peer-to-peer-review/interrogating-the-american-library-associations-core-values-statement-peer-to-peer-review
  9. Baker, L.(Ed.),Afflerbach, P.(Ed.),Reinking, D.(Ed.)(1996).Developing engaged readers in school and home communities.Routledge.
  10. Baxter, S. J.,Smalley, A. W.(2004).,Metronet.
  11. Borkum, E.,He, F.,Linden, L. L.(2012).,National Bureau of Economic Research.
  12. Brozo, W. G.,Shiel, G.,Topping, K.(2007).Engagement in reading: Lessons learned from three PISA countries.Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy,51(4),304-315.
  13. Buckley, J.,Shang, Y.(2002).Estimating policy and program effects with observational data: The "differences-in-differences" estimator.Practical Assessment, Research, and Evaluation,8,Article 24.
  14. Burton, L.(2007).Childhood adultification in economically disadvantaged families: A conceptual model.Family Relations,56(4),329-345.
  15. Connell, J. P.,Klem, A. M.(2006).First things first: A framework for successful secondary school reform.New Directions for Youth Development,2006(111),53-66.
  16. Cuesta, A.,Glewwe, P.,Krause, B.(2016).School infrastructure and educational outcomes: A literature review, with special reference to Latin America.Economia,17(1),95-130.
  17. Deschacht, N.,Goeman, K.(2015).The effect of blended learning on course persistence and performance of adult learners: A difference-in-differences analysis.Computers & Education,87,83-89.
  18. Donahue, P. L.,Daane, M. C.,Grigg, W. S.(2003).The nation's report card: Reading highlights 2003.Education Statistics Quarterly,5(4),40-45.
  19. Dow, M. J.,McMahon-Lakin, J.(2012).School librarian staffing levels and student achievement as represented in 2006-2009 Kansas annual yearly progress data.School Library Research,15
  20. Greenwald, R.,Hedges, L. V.,Laine, R. D.(1996).The effect of school resources on student achievement.Review of Educational Research,66(3),361-396.
  21. Guthrie, J. T.,Anderson, E.,Alao, S.,Rinehart, J.(1999).Influences of concept-oriented reading instruction on strategy use and conceptual learning from text.The Elementary School Journal,99(4),343-366.
  22. Guthrie, J. T., Cambria, J., & Wigfield, A. (2008). Motivations for reading information books school questionnaire (MRIB-S) and motivations for reading information books nonschool questionnaire (MRIB-N). http://www.cori.umd.edu/measures/MRIB-S.pdf
  23. Guthrie, J. T.,Klauda, S. L.,Ho, A. N.(2013).Modeling the relationships among reading instruction, motivation, engagement, and achievement for adolescents.Reading Research Quarterly,48(1),9-26.
  24. Haycock, K.(1995).Research in teacher-librarianship and the institutionalization of change.School Library Media Quarterly,23(4),227-233.
  25. Haycock, K.(1995).Research imperatives for information professionals: Developing foundations for effectiveness.School Library Media Annual,13,113-126.
  26. Hughes, H.,Bozorgian, H.,Allan, C.,Dicinoski, M.(2013).,School Library Association of Queensland, Queensland University of Technology.
  27. IEA. (2016). School composition and resources: Size of school library. TIMSS & PIRLS International Study Center. https://pirls2016.org/pirls/school-composition-and-resources/school-library/
  28. Krashen, S.(2009).Anything but reading.Knowledge Quest,37(5),18-25.
  29. Krashen, S.(2004).The power of reading: Insights from the research.Libraries Unlimited.
  30. Krashen, S.(2016).The purpose of education, free voluntary reading, and dealing with the impact of poverty.School Libraries Worldwide,22(1),1-7.
  31. Krashen, S.(2011).Free voluntary reading.Libraries Unlimited.
  32. Krashen, S.,Lee, S.,McQuillan, J.(2012).Is the library important? Multivariate studies at the national and international level.Journal of Language and Literacy Education,8(1),26-36.
  33. Kuon, T.,Flores, J.,Pickett, J.(2014).The biggest classroom in the building.Phi Delta Kappan,95(7),65-67.
  34. Lance, K. C.,Kachel, D. E.(2018).Why school librarians matter: What years of research tell us.Phi Delta Kappan,99(7),15-20.
  35. Lance, K. C.,Rodney, M. J.,Hamilton-Pennell, C.(2001).Good schools have school librarians: Oregon school librarians collaborate to improve academic achievement.Oregon Educational Media Association.
  36. Lance, K. C.,Rodney, M. J.,Hamilton-Pennell, C.(2005).Powerful libraries make powerful learners: The Illinois study.Illinois School Library Media Association.
  37. Lance, K. C., & Schwarz, B. (2012). How Pennsylvania school libraries pay off: Investments in student achievement and academic standards (PA School Library Project). HSLC.
  38. Lance, K. C.,Welborn, L.,Hamilton-Pennell, C.(1993).The impact of school library media centers on academic achievement.Hi Willow Research and Publishing.
  39. Lee, J.-W.,Barro, R. J.(2001).Schooling quality in a cross-section of countries.Economica, New Series,68(272),465-488.
  40. Lonsdale, M.(2003).Impact of school libraries on student achievement: A review of the research.
  41. OECD(2019).PISA 2018 assessment and analytical framework.OECD Publishing.
  42. Rodney, M. J.,Lance, K. C.,Hamilton-Pennell, C.(2003).The impact of Michigan school librarians on academic achievement: Kids who have libraries succeed.Library of Michigan.
  43. Schleicher, A.,Zimmer, K.,Evans, J.,Clements, N.(2009).PISA 2009 assessment framework: Key competencies in reading, mathematics and science.OECD Publishing.
  44. Small, R. V.,Shanahan, K. A.,Stasak, M.(2010).The impact of New York’s school libraries on student achievement and motivation: Phase III.School Library Research,13
  45. Smith, E. G. (2001). Texas school libraries: Standards, resources, services, and students’ performance. Texas State Library and Archives Commission. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED455850.pdf
  46. Soemer, A.,Schiefele, U.(2018).Reading amount as a mediator between intrinsic reading motivation and reading comprehension in the early elementary grades.Learning and Individual Differences,67,1-11.
  47. Sprietsma, M.(2012).Computers as pedagogical tools in Brazil: A pseudo-panel analysis.Education Economics,20(1),19-32.
  48. Suryadarma, D.,Suryahadi, A.,Sumarto, S.,Rogers, F. H.(2006).Improving student performance in public primary schools in developing countries: Evidence from Indonesia.Education Economics,14(4),401-429.
  49. Swan, E. A.(2003).Concept-oriented reading instruction: Engaging classrooms, lifelong learners.The Guilford Press.
  50. Sweet, A. P.(Ed.),Snow, C. E.(Ed.)(2003).Rethinking reading comprehension.Guilford Press.
  51. Todd, R. J.(2007).School administrators’ support for school libraries: The impact on student academic achievement.Learning and Media,35(1),13-16.
  52. Tonne, I.,Pihl, J.(2012).Literacy education, reading engagement, and library use in multilingual classes.Intercultural Education,23(3),183-194.
  53. Wigfield, A.(1997).Reading motivation: A domain-specific approach to motivation.Educational Psychologist,32(2),59-68.
  54. Wigfield, A.,Guthrie, J. T.(1995).Reading Research ReportReading Research Report,National Reading Research Center.
  55. Wigfield, A.,Guthrie, J. T.(1997).Relations of children’s motivation for reading to the amount and breadth of their reading.Journal of Educational Psychology,89(3),420-432.
  56. Wigfield, A.,Guthrie, J. T.,Perencevich, K. C.,Taboada, A.,Klauda, S. L.,Mcrae, A.,Barbosa, P.(2008).Role of reading engagement in mediating effects of reading comprehension instruction on reading outcomes.Psychology in the Schools,45(5),432-445.
  57. Wigfield, A.,Guthrie, J. T.,Tonks, S.,Perencevich, K. C.(2004).Children’s motivation for reading: Domain specificity and instructional influences.Journal of Educational Research,97(6),299-309.
  58. Williams, D. A.,Wavell, C.,Coles, L.(2001).,Robert Gordon University.
  59. Williams, D.,Wavell, C.,Morrison, K.(2013).,Robert Gordon University.
  60. Zhao, M.,Glewwe, P.(2010).What determines basic school attainment in developing countries? Evidence from rural China.Economics of Education Review,29(3),451-460.
  61. 于斌斌, Binbin(2013)。國外中小學圖書館對學生學習表現的影響研究綜述。中國圖書館學報，2013(05)，98-108。
  62. 于斌斌, Binbin,楊利清, Liqing(2013)。中學圖書館利用對中學生學業表現的影響研究—以蘇州市A中學為案例。圖書情報工作，57(12)，60-66。
  63. 巫文娟, Wen-Chuan(2017)。國立臺灣師範大學圖書資訊學研究所=Graduate Institute of Library and Information Studies, National Taiwan Normal University。
  64. 陳昭珍, Chao-Chen,林吟燕, Yin-Yen,陳雅萍, Ya-Ping,高榛澧, Zhen-Li,張羽芳, Yu-Fang,梁鴻栩, Hong-Shiu(2017)。概念導向閱讀教學（CORI）對國中生閱讀投入影響之研究。圖書資訊學研究，12(1)，37-78。
  65. 賴苑玲, Yuang-Ling(2007)。從推廣閱讀活動檢視彰化市國小六年級學童閱讀行為與圖書館館藏使用之研究。社會科教育研究，12，1-40。
  66. 駱淑萍, Shu-Ping(2014)。國立臺灣師範大學圖書資訊學研究所=Graduate Institute of Library and Information Studies, National Taiwan Normal University。
print cancel