仁慈的雙面刃：仁慈領導對創造力績效的雙路徑模式

The Double-Edged Sword of Benevolence: A Dual Paths Model of Benevolent Leadership and Creative Performance

10.6129/CJP.201803_60(1).0003

王世明(Shih-Ming Wang)；周婉茹(Wan-Ju Chou)；吳宗祐(Tsung-Yu Wu)；鄭伯壎(Bor-Shiuan Cheng)

工作自主性 ； 心理安全 ； 仁慈領導 ； 服從不貳 ； 創造力績效 ； job autonomy ； psychological safety ； benevolent leadership ； obedience ； creative performance

中華心理學刊

60卷1期（2018 / 03 / 01）

57 - 79

繁體中文;英文

本研究主張基於「回報的主動性」與「義務的配合性」，仁慈領導與創造力績效的關係，可能透過心理安全發揮促進作用，亦可能透過服從不貳產生抑制效果。然而，尚無實徵研究同時檢驗這兩種路徑，特別是仁慈領導如何與何時會對創造力績效產生正向與負向的預測作用。為了補足上述缺口，本研究分別以心理安全（正向路徑）與服從不貳（負向路徑）作為中介變項，並探討工作自主性的調節式中介作用。透過跨產業取樣，總計回收有效樣本185筆主管—部屬的對偶資料。結果顯示：仁慈領導會透過心理安全的中介，對創造力績效產生正向預測效果；卻不會透過服從不貳的中介，對創造力績效產生負向預測效果。另外，工作自主性僅會調節（弱化）服從不貳的負向機制；當工作自主性低時，仁慈領導才會透過服從不貳對創造力績效產生負向間接效果。本研究適時地解釋仁慈領導「何時」會透過「哪種機制」預測創造力績效，並提出建議。

Based on the norm of reciprocity and role obligation, this study suggests that benevolent leadership (BL) might not only have positive effect on creative performance (CP) through psychological safety (PS) but also have negative effect on CP through subordinate obedience (SO). However, prior research has only found the positive relationship between BL and CP under certain situation. It is not clear regarding how and when BL influences CP negatively. In order to fill up the research gap, the present study investigated the mediating effect of PS and SO on the relationship between BL and CP as well as identifying job autonomy (JA) as a moderator that influence the mediating effect of PS and SO. Using 185 dyad of supervisors and subordinates as samples, the study found that BL influences CP positively through PS; however, BL does not have negative impact on CP via SO. Furthermore, JA significant moderated the mediating effect of BL on CP via SO. When JA is high, the negative mediating effect of SO is weaker; when JA is low, the negative mediating effect of SO is stronger. This study extends the creativity literature by exploring the mediating process between BL and CP.

1. 林姿葶、鄭伯壎(2012)。華人領導者的噓寒問暖與提攜教育：仁慈領導之雙構面模式。本土心理學研究，37，253-302。
   連結：
2. 林家五、王悅縈、胡宛仙(2012)。真誠領導與仁慈領導對組織公民行為及主管忠誠之差異效果。本土心理學研究，38，205-256。
   連結：
3. 姜定宇、鄭伯壎(2003)。組織忠誠、組織承諾、及組織公民行為研究之回顧與前瞻。應用心理研究，19，175-209。
   連結：
4. 姜定宇、鄭伯壎、鄭紀瑩、周麗芳(2007)。華人效忠主管的概念分析與量表建構。中華心理學刊，49，407-432。
   連結：
5. 彭台光、高月慈、林鉦棽(2006)。管理研究中的共同方法變異：問題本質、影響、測試和補救。管理學報，23，77-98。
   連結：
6. 楊中芳(1999)。人際關係與人際情感的構念化。本土心理學研究，12，105-179。
   連結：
7. 樊景立、鄭伯壎(2000)。華人組織的家長式領導：一項文化觀點的分析。本土心理學研究，13，126-180。
   連結：
8. 鄭伯壎、周麗芳、黃敏萍、樊景立、彭泗清(2003)。家長式領導的三元模式：中國大陸企業組織的證據。本土心理學研究，20，209-250。
   連結：
9. 鄭伯壎、周麗芳、樊景立(2000)。家長式領導：三元模式的建構與測量。本土心理學研究，14，3-64。
   連結：
10. Hayes, A. F. (2012). PROCESS: A versatile computational tool for observed variable mediation, moderation, and conditional process modeling. Retrieved from http://www.afhayes.com/public/process2012.pdf
11. Aiken, L. S.,West, S. G.(1991).Multiple regression: Testing and interpreting interactions.Newbury Park, CA:Sage.
12. Amabile, T. M.(1988).A model of creativity and innovation in organizations.Research in Organizational Behavior,10,123-167.
13. Amabile, T. M.,Conti, R.,Coon, H.,Lazenby, J.,Herron, M.(1996).Assessing the work environment for creativity.Academy of Management Journal,39,1154-1184.
14. Anderson, N.,Potočnik, K.,Zhou, J.(2014).Innovation and creativity in organizations: A state-of-thescience review, prospective commentary, and guiding framework.Journal of Management,40,1297-1333.
15. Bagozzi, R. P.,Edwards, J. R.(1998).A general approach to representing constructs in organizational research.Organizational Research Methods,1,45-87.
16. Bagozzi, R. P.,Heatherton, T. F.(1994).A general approach to representing multifaceted personality constructs: Application to state self-esteem.Structural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary Journal,1,35-67.
17. Bandura, A.(1986).The explanatory and predictive scope of self-efficacy theory.Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology,4,359-373.
18. Basadur, M.,Graen, G. B.,Green, S. G.(1982).Training in creative problem solving: Effects on ideation and problem finding and solving in an industrial research organization.Organizational Behavior and Human Performance,30,41-70.
19. Bass, B. M.(2010).Two decades of research and development in transformational leadership.European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology,8,9-32.
20. Blau, P. M.(1964).Exchange and power in social life.New York, NY:Wiley.
21. Campbell, D. T.(1960).Blind variation and selective retentions in creative thought as in other knowledge processes.Psychological Review,67,380-400.
22. Chan, S. C. H.,Huang, X.,Snape, E.,Lam, C. K.(2013).The Janus face of paternalistic leaders: Authoritarianism, benevolence, subordinates' organization-based self-esteem, and performance.Journal of Organizational Behavior,34,108-128.
23. Chan, S. C. H.,Mak, W.-m.(2012).Benevolent leadership and follower performance: The mediating role of leader-member exchange (LMX).Asia Pacific Journal of Management,29,285-301.
24. Chen, C.-C.(Ed.),Lee, Y.-T.(Ed.)(2008).Leadership and management in China: Philosophies, theories, and practices.Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
25. Chen, X.-P.,Eberly, M. B.,Chiang, T.-J.,Farh, J.-L.,Cheng, B.-S.(2014).Affective trust in Chinese leaders: Linking paternalistic leadership to employee performance.Journal of Management,40,796-819.
26. Cheng, B.-S.,Chou, L.-F.,Wu, T.-Y.,Huang, M.-P.,Farh, J.-L.(2004).Paternalistic leadership and subordinate responses: Establishing a leadership model in Chinese organizations.Asian Journal of Social Psychology,7,89-117.
27. Chiu, W. C.-K.,Lun, V. M.-C.,Bond, M. H.(2018).Engaging in creative work: The influences of personal value, autonomy at work, and national socialization for self-directedness in 50 nations.Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology,49,239-260.
28. Coelho, F.,Augusto, M.(2010).Job characteristics and the creativity of frontline service employees.Journal of Service Research,13,426-438.
29. Cooper, R. B.,Jayatilaka, B.(2006).Group creativity: The effects of extrinsic, intrinsic, and obligation motivations.Creativity Research Journal,18,153-172.
30. de Stobbeleir, K. E. M.,Ashford, S. J.,Buyens, D.(2011).Self-regulation of creativity at work: The role of feedback-seeking behavior in creative performance.Academy of Management Journal,54,811-831.
31. Deci, E. L.,Connell, J. P.,Ryan, R. M.(1989).Self-determination in a work organization.Journal of Applied Psychology,74,580-590.
32. Detert, J. R.,Burris, E. R.(2007).Leadership behavior and employee voice: Is the door really open?.Academy of Management Journal,50,869-884.
33. Dunnette, M. D.(Ed.)(1976).Handbook of industrial and organizational psychology.Chicago, IL:Rand-McNally.
34. Edmondson, A. C.(1996).Learning from mistakes is easier said than done: Group and organizational influences on the detection and correction of human error.The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science,32,5-28.
35. Edmondson, A. C.(1999).Psychological safety and learning behavior in work teams.Administrative Science Quarterly,44,350-383.
36. Edwards, J. R.,Lambert, L. S.(2007).Methods for integrating moderation and mediation: A general analytical framework using moderated path analysis.Psychological Methods,12,1-22.
37. Fairchild, A. J.,MacKinnon, D. P.(2009).A general model for testing mediation and moderation effects.Prevention Science,10,87-99.
38. Gardner, W. L.,Avolio, B. J.,Luthans, F.,May, D. R.,Walumbwa, F. O.(2005)."Can you see the real me?" A self-based model of authentic leader and follower development.The Leadership Quarterly,16,343-372.
39. George, J. M.,Zhou, J.(2001).When openness to experience and conscientiousness are related to creative behavior: An interactional approach.Journal of Applied Psychology,86,513-524.
40. Graen, G. B.,Uhl-Bien, M.(1995).Relationship-based approach to leadership: Development of leader-member exchange (LMX) theory of leadership over 25 years: Applying a multi-level multi-domain perspective.The Leadership Quarterly,6,219-247.
41. Hackman, J. R.,Oldham, G. R.(1980).Work redesign.Reading, MA:Addison-Wesley.
42. Hayes, A. F.(2013).Introduction to mediation, moderation, and conditional process analysis: A regression-based approach.New York, NY:Guilford.
43. Kahn, W. A.(1990).Psychological conditions of personal engagement and disengagement at work.Academy of Management Journal,33,692-724.
44. Kaiser, R.,Woodruff, B. A.,Bilukha, O.,Spiegel, P. B.,Salama, P.(2006).Using design effects from previous cluster surveys to guide sample size calculation in emergency settings.Disasters,30,199-211.
45. Koen, J.,van Vianen, A. E. M.,van Hooft, E. A. J.,Klehe, U.-C.(2016).How experienced autonomy can improve job seekers' motivation, job search, and chance of finding reemployment.Journal of Vocational Behavior,95-96,31-44.
46. Kramer, R. M.(Ed.),Cook, K. S.(Ed.)(2004).Trust and distrust in organizations: Dilemmas and approaches.New York, NY:Russell Sage Foundation.
47. Lam, W.,Huang, X.,Snape, E.(2007).Feedbackseeking behavior and leader-member exchange: Do supervisor-attributions motives matter?.Academy of Management Journal,50,348-363.
48. Li, J. T.(Ed.),Tsui, A. S.(Ed.),Weldon, E.(Ed.)(2000).Management and organizations in the Chinese context.London, UK:Macmillan.
49. Lin, W.,Ma, J.,Zhang, Q.,Li, J. C.,Jiang, F.(2016).How is benevolent leadership linked to employee creativity? The mediating role of leader-member exchange and the moderating role of power distance orientation.Journal of Business Ethics
50. Marcoulides, G. A.(Ed.),Schmacker, R. E.(Ed.)(2001).New developments and techniques in structural equation modeling.Mahwah, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum.
51. Morgeson, F. P.,Delaney-Klinger, K.,Hemingway, M. A.(2005).The importance of job autonomy, cognitive ability, and job-related skill for predicting role breadth and job performance.Journal of Applied Psychology,90,399-406.
52. Muller, D.,Judd, C. M.,Yzerbyt, V. Y.(2005).When moderation is mediated and mediation is moderated.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,89,852-863.
53. Oldham, G. R.,Cummings, A.(1996).Employee creativity: Personal and contextual factors at work.Academy of Management Journal,39,607-634.
54. Pellegrini, E. K.,Scandura, T. A.(2008).Paternalistic leadership: A review and agenda for future research.Journal of Management,34,566-593.
55. Podsakoff, P. M.,MacKenzie, S. B.,Lee, J.-Y.,Podsakoff, N. P.(2003).Common method biases in behavioral research: A critical review of the literature and recommended remedies.Journal of Applied Psychology,88,879-903.
56. Proudfoot, D.,Kay, A. C.,Koval, C. Z.(2015).A gender bias in the attribution of creativity: Archival and experimental evidence for the perceived association between masculinity and creative thinking.Psychological Science,26,1751-1761.
57. Redding, S. G.(1990).The spirit of Chinese capitalism.New York, NY:de Gruyter.
58. Ryan, R. M.,Connell, J. P.(1989).Perceived locus of causality and internalization: Examining reasons for acting in two domains.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,57,749-761.
59. Shalley, C. E.(1995).Effects of coaction, expected evaluation, and goal setting on creativity and productivity.Academy of Management Journal,38,483-503.
60. Shalley, C. E.,Gilson, L. L.,Blum, T. C.(2009).Interactive effects of growth need strength, work context, and job complexity on self-reported creative performance.Academy of Management Journal,52,489-505.
61. Shalley, C. E.,Zhou, J.,Oldham, G. R.(2004).The effects of personal and contextual characteristics on creativity: Where should we go from here?.Journal of Management,30,933-958.
62. Silin, R. H.(1976).Leadership and values: The organization of large-scale Taiwanese enterprises.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
63. Spector, P. E.(1986).Perceived control by employees: A meta-analysis of studies concerning autonomy and participation at work.Human Relations,39,1005-1016.
64. Spreitzer, G. M.(1995).Psychological empowerment in the workplace: Construct definition, measurement, and validation.Academy of Management Journal,38,1442-1465.
65. Stamper, C. L.,Masterson, S. S.(2002).Insider or outsider? How employee perceptions of insider status affect their work behavior.Journal of Organizational Behavior,23,875-894.
66. Sun, L.-Y.,Pan, W.,Chow, I. H. S.(2014).The role of supervisor political skill in mentoring: Dual motivational perspectives.Journal of Organizational Behavior,35,213-233.
67. Tierney, P.,Farmer, S. M.(2002).Creative self-efficacy: Its potential antecedents and relationship to creative performance.Academy of Management Journal,45,1137-1148.
68. Triandis, H. C.(Ed.),Berry, J. W.(Ed.)(1980).Handbook of cross-cultural psychology.Boston, MA:Allyn & Bacon.
69. Tröster, C.,van Knippenberg, D.(2012).Leader openness, nationality dissimilarity, and voice in multinational management teams.Journal of International Business Studies,43,591-613.
70. Tyler, T. R.,Lind, E. A.(1992).A relational model of authority in groups.Advances in Experimental Social Psychology,25,115-191.
71. Ukoumunne, O. C.,Gulliford, M. C.,Chinn, S.,Sterne, J. A.,Burney, P. G.(1999).Methods for evaluating area-wide and organization-based interventions in health and health care: A systematic review.Health Technology Assessment,3(5),iii-92.
72. Wang, A.-C.,Cheng, B.-S.(2010).When does benevolent leadership lead to creativity? The moderating role of creative role identity and job autonomy.Journal of Organizational Behavior,31,106-121.
73. Wang, A.-C.,Chiang, J. T.-J.,Tsai, C.-Y.,Lin, T.-T.,Cheng, B.-S.(2013).Gender makes the difference: The moderating role of leader gender on the relationship between leadership styles and subordinate performance.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,122,101-113.
74. Westwood, R.(1997).Harmony and patriarchy: The cultural basis for 'paternalistic headship' among the overseas Chinese.Organization Studies,18,445-480.
75. Wu, T.-Y.,Hu, C.,Jiang, D.-Y.(2012).Is subordinate's loyalty a precondition of supervisor's benevolent leadership? The moderating effects of supervisor's altruistic personality and perceived organizational support.Asian Journal of Social Psychology,15,145-155.
76. Zhou, J.(2003).When the presence of creative coworkers is related to creativity: Role of supervisor close monitoring, development feedback, and creative personality.Journal of Applied Psychology,88,413-422.
77. Zhou, J.,George, J. M.(2001).When job dissatisfaction leads to creativity: Encouraging the expression of voice.Academy of Management Journal,44,682-696.
78. 李怡璇(2003)。台北=Taipei，國立政治大學地政研究所=National Chengchi University。
79. 沈伊默、周婉茹、魏麗華、張慶林(2017)。仁慈領導與員工創新行為：內部人身份感知的中介作用和領導—部屬交換關係差異化的調節作用。心理學報，49，1100-1112。
80. 陳明璋(1984)。家族文化與企業管理。中國式管理研討會論文集，台北=Taipei:
81. 鄭伯壎(1995)。家長權威與領導行為之關係：一個台灣民營企業主持人的個案研究。中央研究院民族學研究所集刊，79，119-173。

1. 簡忠仁,林昱錡,林姿葶(2022)。仁慈領導雙構面模式之再探：內涵釐清與量表建構。本土心理學研究，58，3-59。
2. 簡忠仁,林昱錡,林姿葶(2023)。「施恩」與「報恩」：仁慈領導的回顧與展望。中華心理學刊，65(4)，299-325。
3. (2021)。就業職能與職業距離對薪資之影響：社工勞力市場之檢視。臺灣教育社會學研究，21(2)，1-59。