宿命與天命──墨子「非命」思想的反思

Fatalism and the Mandate of Heaven-an Reflection on Mozi's "Anti -fatalist" Thought

10.7065/MRPC.201111.0045

孫長祥(Chang-Hsiang Sun)

墨子 ； 非命 ； 三表法 ； 義 ； 天志 ； 兼愛 ； Mozi ； Anti-fatalism ； Method of Three Standards ； Meaning ； Will of Heaven ； Universal Love

哲學與文化

38卷11期（2011 / 11 / 01）

43 - 58

繁體中文

本論文主要以墨子為一位社會改革行動者，如何以非命祛除世界的宿命性，反思行動者應該具有的義務，而為天下興利除害的觀點；全面檢視《墨子》文獻，尋檢其中與非命、立義相關的概念，闡述墨子非命論思想的主要意涵。全文分成三部分，壹、前言：釐清與分辨有關「命」的基本概念。貳、本論：墨子「非命」思想的意涵。下分四段：一、墨子非命思想背景的一般性考察；二、以「三表法」建立批評的標準以非命；三、非命以立義──以天志代天命的主要意涵；四、說明墨子既非命又提倡敬天與明鬼的意義。參、結論：總結前文，對墨子非命論思想再評價。

This article is meant to see how Mozi, as an activist of social reform, deprived the world of fatalism through anti-fatalism, reflected on the obligation of an activist as well as procured benefits and eliminated adversities for the world; we also examine the texts of ”Mozi” allover to seek all the concepts related to both anti-fatalism and the establishment of the standards of judgment and explicate the central meanings of Mozi's anti-fatalist thought. Here we proceed along the foreword, the main body and the conclusion. The foreword is to clarify and compare the fundamental concepts of ”ming” (命, destiny). The main body is the meaning of Mozi's anti- fatalist thought, including four sections: first, a general survey o f the background of Mozi's anti-fatalist thought; second, to condemn fatalism in terms of the ”method of three standards”; third, to establish the standards of judgment by condemning fatalism, that is, to substitute the will of heaven for the mandate of heaven; fourth, to explain the meanings of Mozi's anti-fatalism and his advocacy of respecting heaven and understanding ghosts. The conclusion is to sum up the foregoing parts and re-evaluate Mozi's anti-fatalist thought.

1. 侯外廬主編(1957)。中國思想通史。北京:人民出版社。
2. 唐君毅(1966)。中國哲學原論上冊‧導論篇。九龍:人生出版社。
3. 孫長祥(2005)。思維‧語言‧行動─現代學術視野中的墨辯。臺北:文津出版社。
4. 徐復觀(1984)。中國人性論史。臺北:臺灣商務印書館。
5. 傅斯年(2006)。性命古訓辨證。桂林:廣西師範大學出版社。
6. 錢穆(1962)。中國思想通俗講話。香港:求精印務。
7. 錢穆(1984)。國史大綱。臺北:臺灣商務印書館。

1. Hsiu-Fen HSIEH,Bih-Ching SHU(2019).Factors Associated With Depressive Symptoms in Female Victims of Intimate Partner Violence in Southern Taiwan.The Journal of Nursing Research,27(4),1-6.
2. 龔家琳、趙善如(2016)。少年受虐事件的揭露：從兒童虐待走到少年虐待。臺大社會工作學刊，33，1-42。
3. 張書豪(2022)。試探《墨子．非命》三篇的論證系譜：以「三表法」為核心的考察。淡江中文學報，47，37-71。