媒介使用與政治資本

Media Use and Political Capital

10.30386/MCR.200607_(88).0003

陳憶寧(Yi-Ning Katherine Chen)；羅文輝(Ven-Hwei Lo)

政治資本 ； 媒介使用內容 ； 媒介使用時間 ； political capital ； media content use ； time spent on media

新聞學研究

88期（2006 / 07 / 01）

83 - 134

繁體中文

本研究主要目的在於建立「政治資本」概念的可能測量指標，並探討媒介使用與其間的關係。研究結果顯示，「政治資本」概念約可分為政治網絡、政治興趣、政治知識、政治信任與政治參與等五個面向。本研究也發現，電視、報紙與網路之使用時間對「政治資本」的預測力有限，媒介使用內容則對政治資本有較高預測力。閱讀報紙新聞可以顯著預測政治網絡、意見表達、選舉參與、政治知識與政治興趣，但無法預測政治信任。觀看電視政治新聞可以顯著預測選舉參與、政治知識與政治興趣，但無法預測政治網絡、意見表達與政治信任。使用網路政治新聞能預測意見表達、政治知識與政治興趣，但對政治資本的其他三個面向則無顯著預測力。整體而言，「媒介使用內容」變項對政治資本的預測力遠超過「媒介使用時間」。另就累積政治資本而言，傳統媒介的功用超過網路。

This study explores the concept of political capital and its relationship with various forms of media use. The results show that political capital is a complex concept that includes five basic dimensions: political networking, political interests, political knowledge, political trust, and political participation. The results of the study also show that time spent on watching TV, reading the newspaper, and surfing the Internet are quite limited in predicting political capital, while the extent of exposure to newspaper political news is a significant predictor for political networking, opinion expression, campaign participation, political knowledge, and political interest. The preceding does not include cultivating political trust. The extent of exposure to TV political news significantly predicts campaign participation, political knowledge, and political interest. Exposure to political news on the Internet can predict opinion expression, political knowledge, and political interests. Overall, this study shows that political content exposure is a better predictor for political capital than overall time spent on viewing media. In addition, the results indicate that tradition media work better than new media in accumulating political capital.

1. 陳陸輝(2003)。政治信任、施政表現與民眾對台灣民主的展望。台灣政治學刊，7(2)，149-188。
   連結：
2. 羅文輝、黃箴威(2000)。2000年總統選舉公民營報紙新聞之比較研究。選擇研究，7(1)，1-20。
   連結：
3. Aberbach, J. D.,Walker, J. L.(1970).Political trust and social ideology.American Political Science Review,64,1199-1219.
4. Abramson, J. B.,Arterton, C. F.,Orren, G. R.(1998).The electronic common wealth: The impact of new media technologies on democratic politics
5. Almond, G.,Verba, S.(1963).The civic culture: Political attitudes and democracy in five nations
6. Atkin, C. K.,Galloway, J.,Nayman, 0. B.(1976).News media exposure, political knowledge and campaign Interest.Journalism Quarterly,53,231-37.
7. Barber, B. R.(1984).Strong democracy
8. Baron, S.,Field, J.,Schuller, T.(2003).Social capital: Critical perspectives
9. Bimber, B.(2001).Information and political engagement in America: The search for effects of information technology at the individual level.Political Research Quarterly,54(1),53-67.
10. Bimber, B.(1998).The Internet and political transformation: Populism, community, and accelerated pluralism.Policy,31,133-160.
11. Bourdieu, P.(1998).Practical reason: On the theory of action
12. Brehm, J.,Rahn, W.(1997).Individual-level evidence for the causes and consequences of social capital.American Journal of Political Science,41,999-1023.
13. Briggs, Xavier de Souza(2004).Social Capital: Easy beauty or meaningful resource?.Journal of the American Planning Association,70(2),151-158.
14. Briggs, Xavier de Souza,In K. Christensen,D. Levinson(2003).Social capital, types of.The encyclopedia of community: From the village to the virtual world, Vol,3,1277-1283.
15. Bybee, C. R.,McLeod, J. M.,Leuscher, W. D.,Garramone, G.(1981).Mass communication and voter volatility.Public Opinion Quarterly,45,69-90.
16. Campbell, A.,Converse, P. E.,Miller, W.,Stokes, D.(1964).The American voter: An abridgement
17. Cappella, J. N.,Jamieson, K. H.(1997).Spiral of cynicism: The press and the public good
18. Chaffee, S. H.,Kanihan, S. F.(1997).Learning about politics from the mass media.Political Communication,14,421-430.
19. Chaffee, S. H.,Zhao, X.,Leshner, G.(1994).Political knowledge and the campaign media of 1992.Communication Research,23(3),305-324.
20. Chanley, V.(2002).Trust in government in the aftermath of 9/11: Determinants and consequences.Political Psychology,23(3),469-83.
21. Citrin, J.(1974).Comment: The political relevance of trust in government.American Political Science Review,68,673-688.
22. Citrin, J.,Muste, C.,In J. P. Robinson, P. R. Shaver,L. S. Wrightsman(1999).Trust in government.Measures of political attitudes,465-532.
23. Converse, P. E.(1964).The nature of belief systems in mass publics. In D. Apter (Ed.).Ideology and discontent,206-261.
24. Converse, P. E.,In A. Campbell,P. E. Converse(1972).Change in the American Electorate.The human meaning of social change,263-337.
25. Conway, M.(1991).Political Participation in the United States
26. Corrado, A.,Firestone, C. M.(1996).Elections in cyberspace: Toward a new era in American politics
27. Dahl, R.(1989).Democracy and its critics
28. Davis, R.(1999).The web of politics: The Internet's impact on the American political system
29. Davis, R.,Owen, D.(1998).New media and American politics
30. Delli Carpini, M. X.(2004).Mediating democratic engagement: The impact of communications on citizens' involvement in political and civic life. In L. L. Kaid (Ed.).Handbook of political communication research,395-434.
31. Delli Carpini, M. X.,Keeter, S.(1996).Stability and change in the U.S. public's knowledge of politics.Public Opinion Quarterly,55,283-612.
32. Eighmey, J.,McCord, L.(1998).Adding value in the information age: Uses and gratifications of sites on the World Wide Web.Journal of Business Research,41,187-194.
33. Eveland, W. P.,Jr.,Journalism,Mass Communication Quarterly(2002).News information processing as mediator of the relationship between motivations and political knowledge.79(1),26-40.
34. Fishkin, J.(1991).Democracy and deliberation: New direction for democratic reform
35. Gore, A.,Jr.(1991).Information superhighways: The next information revolution.Futurist,25(1),21-23.
36. Hallin, D(1992).Sound bite news: Television coverage of election, 1968-1988.Journal of Communication,42,5-24.
37. Hart, R. P.(1996).Easy citizenship: Television curious legacy.The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science,546,109-119.
38. Hart, R. P.,Smith-Howell, D.,Llewellyn, J.(1990).Evolution of presidential news coverage.Political Communication and Persuasion,7,213-230.
39. Inglehart, R.(1997).Modernization and postmodernization: Cultural, economic, and political change in 43 countries
40. Johnson, T. J.,Kaye, B. K.,In T. J. Johnson, C. E. Hays,S. P. Hays(1998).A vehicle for engagement or a haven for the disaffected? Internet use, political alienation and voter participation.Engaging the public: How government and media can reinvigorate American democracy,123-135.
41. Kaye, B.,Johnson, T.(2003).From here to obscurity?: Media substitution theory and traditional media in an on-line world.Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,54(3),260-273.
42. Kern, M.(1997).Social capital and citizen interpretation of political ads, news, and Web site information in the 1996 presidential election.American Behavioral Scientist,40,1238-1249.
43. Kim, S. H.,Han, M.(2005).Media use and participatory democracy in South Korea.Mass Communication and Society,8(2),133-153.
44. Klapper, J. T.(1960).The effects of mass communication
45. Kraut, R.,Patterson, M.,Lundmark, V.,Kiesler, S.,Mukopadhyay, T.,Scherlis, W.(1998).Internet paradox: A social technology that reduces social involvement and psychological well-being?.American Psychologist,53,1017-1031.
46. Light, I.(2004).Social capital's unique accessibility.Journal of the American Planning Association,70(2),145-151.
47. Lin, N.(2001).Social capital
48. Lipset, S. M.,Schneider, W.(1983).The decline of confidence in American institutions.Political Science Quarterly,98,379-400.
49. Lo, Ven-hwei.(1994).Media use, involvement and knowledge of the Gulf War.Journalism Quarterly,71(1),45-56.
50. McLeod, J. M.,Daily, K.,Guo, Z.,Eveland, W. P.,Jr.,Bayer, J.,Yang, S.,Wang, H.(1996).Community integration, local media use and democratic processes..Communication Research,23,179-209.
51. McLeod, J. M.,McDonald, D. G.(1985).Beyond simple exposure: Media orientations and their impact on political processes.Communication Research,12,3-33.
52. McQuail, D.,In C. R. Berger,S. H. Chaffee(1987).The functions of communication: A non-functionalist overview.Handbook of communication science,327-346.
53. McQuail, D.,K. E. Rosengren｜L. Wenner,P. Palmgreen(1985).Gratifications research and media theory: Four models or one.Media gratifications research: Current perspectives,149-167.
54. Milbrath, L. W.,Goel, M. L.(1982).Political participation: How and why do people get involved?
55. Moy, P.,Scheufele, D. A.(2000).Media effects on political trust and social trust.Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly,77,744-759.
56. Moy, P.,Scheufele, D. A.,Holbert, R. L.(1999).Television use and social capital: Testing Putnam's time displacement hypothesis.Mass Communication Society,2,27-45.
57. Nie, N.,Erbring, L.(2000).Internet and society: A preliminary report. Retrieved from http://www.stanford.edu/group/siqss/Press_Release/ internetStudy.html
58. Nie, N.,Verba, S.,Petrocik, J.(1976).The changing American voter
59. Norris, P.,Jones, P.(1998).Virtual democracy.Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics,3(2),1-4.
60. Nye, J. S.,Zelikow, P. D.,King, D.(1997).Why people don't trust government
61. Patterson, T.(1993).Out of order
62. Pavlik, J. V.(1996).New media technology: Cultural and commercial perspectives
63. Putnam, R. D.(2000).Bowling alone: The collapse and revival of American community
64. Putnam, R. D.(1993).Making democracy work: Civic traditions in modern Italy
65. Putnam, R. D.(1995).Tuning in, tuning out: The strange disappearance of social capital in America..PS: Political Science and Politics,284,664-683.
66. Robinson, M. J.,Appel, K. R.(1979).Network news coverage of congress.Political Science Quarterly,94,407-48.
67. Robinson, M. J.,Levy, M. R.(1986).The main source: Learning from television news
68. Rosen, J.(1999).What journalists are for
69. Rosenstone, S. J.,Hansen, J. M.(1993).Mobilization, participation, and democracy in America
70. Rueschemeyer, D.(2004).Addressing inequality.Journal of Democracy,15(4),76-90.
71. Scheufele, D. A.,Nisbet, M. C.(2002).Democracy online: New opportunities and dead ends.Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics,7(3),53-73.
72. Scholz, J. T.,Lubell, M.(1998).Trust and taxpaying: Testing the heuristic approach to collective action.American Journal of Political Science,42(2),398-417.
73. Shah, D. V.,Kwak, N.,Holbert R. L.(2001)."Connecting" and "disconnecting" with civic life: Patterns of Internet use and the production of social capital.Political Communication,18,141-162.
74. Stroll, C.(1995).Silicon snake oil
75. Sullivan, J. L.,Piereson, J.,Marcus, G. E.(1982).Political tolerance and American democracy
76. Tidmarch, C. M.,Pitney, Jr.,J. J.(1985).Covering congress.Polity.
77. Tolbert, C. J.,McNeal, R. S.(2003).Unraveling the effects of the Internet on political participation?.Political Research Quarterly.
78. Turkle, S.(1996).Virtuality and its discontents: Searching for community in cyberspace.The American Prospect.
79. Verba, S.,Schlosman, K. L.,Brady, H. E.(1995).Voice and equality: Civic volunteerism in American politics
80. Viles, P.(1993).Hosts, callers trash Clinton on talk radio.Broadcasting and Cable,12,43.
81. Viswanath, K.,Finnegan, J. R.,Jr.,Rooney, B.,Potter, J.(1990).Community ties in a rural Midwest community and use of newspapers and cable TV.Journalism Quarterly,67,899-911.
82. Zhao, X.,Chaffee, S.(1995).Campaign advertisements versus television news as source of political issue information.Public Opinion Quarterly,59,41-65.
83. Zillmann, D.,In K. E. Rosengren, L. A. Wenner,P. Palmgreen(1985).The experimental exploration of gratifications from media entertainment.Selective exposure to communication,225-239.
84. 交通部統計處(2005)。台灣地區民眾使用網際網路狀況調查報告。
85. 盛治仁。台灣民眾民主價值及政治信任感研究：政黨輪替前後的比較。選舉研究，10(1)，7-40。
86. 彭芸。我國大學生的媒介使用、社會資本與政治信任對象之關連性研究。新聞學研究，79，91-133。
87. 羅文輝、鍾蔚文(1992)。報紙與電視如何報尋民國八十年的第二屆國代選擇。亞洲協會專題研究報告
88. 羅文輝、鍾蔚文(1991)。電視新聞對青少年政治知識的影響。新聞學研究，45，81-99。
89. 羅啓宏(1992)。台灣省鄉鎮發展類型之研究。台灣經濟月刊，190，41-68。

1. 陳雅玫(2016)。學生臉書使用與政治參與：以太陽花學運為例。中國行政評論，22(4)，61-91。
2. 陳祥(2008)。鎖定特定時空情境變數以提升資料品質：情境研究的理論與實務操作。資訊社會研究，15，233-248。
3. 林正士、周軒逸(2014)。總統大選電視辯論對於首投族之政治傳播效果：以2012 年台灣總統選舉為例。選舉研究，21(1)，47-87。
4. 劉嘉薇、黃紀(2010)。持續與變遷—政治資訊對大學生政治信任感影響之定群追蹤研究。政治學報，50，111-146。
5. 羅彥傑(2018)。從媒體近用到ICT 近用：偏鄉志工老人的傳播實踐。傳播研究與實踐，8(2)，281-315。
6. 申佳健(2023)。政黨選擇性暴露視角下大眾傳媒對台灣民眾政治信任的意義探究。行政暨政策學報，76，101-130。
7. 孫榮光(2020)。2016年總統選舉桃竹苗客家／非客家選民支持蔡英文的因素比較。人文社會科學研究，14(2)，73-93。
8. 王嵩音(2010)。台灣選民媒介使用對於候選人形象與評價之影響：傳統媒介vs.新媒介。傳播與管理研究，10(1)，3-36。
9. 張春炎(2009)。媽媽的革命與正義的消費者文化？台灣綠色消費運動初探。傳播與管理研究，9(1)，95-158。
10. 張郁敏(2012)。跨媒介新聞資訊處理模型：資訊來源擴大理論在新聞研究上的應用。新聞學研究，110，85-124。
11. (2013)。聲望與領導：媒體與民眾眼中的總統。傳播管理學刊，14(2)，26-61。