媒體素養與言論自由的辯證

Dialectic between Media Literacy and Freedom of Speech

10.30386/MCR.200707_(92).0003

賴祥蔚(Weber H. W. Lai)

自由市場 ； 言論自由 ； 素養 ； 媒體 ； 媒體識讀 ； free market ； freedom of speech ； literacy ； media ； media literacy

新聞學研究

92期（2007 / 07 / 01）

97 - 128

繁體中文

2002年10月24日，教育部正式公佈《媒體素養教育政策白皮書》。儘管相關運動的發展非常蓬勃，但是綜觀教育部的政策白皮書，對於理論基礎的陳述其實相當有限，只有區區數十字而已，留下許多討論的空間。對於媒體素養的研究與論述，即便學術界也算不上豐富。在僅有的學術文獻當中最為欠缺的部份，或許也是對於理論基礎的疏於關注。雖然在教育部的《媒體素養教育政策白皮書》中指出其理論基礎是「健康社區」，但是類此媒體議題，必然都可以回歸到言論自由的論述。本文之目的，正是檢視並探討媒體素養現有與應有的理論基礎，試圖進行媒體素養與言論自由的辯證，從言論自由的論述出發，去思索並且回應媒體素養的訴求。

Taiwan's Ministry of Education officially announced its ”Media Literacy Education Policy White Paper” on October 24, 2002. But while vigorous progress has been made in the field, this study is quite limited in its delineation of media literacy's theoretical foundations; This leaves much room for further discussions. In fact, there has been a lack of theoretical literature covering media literacy studies in Taiwan. As this paper points to the concept of a ”healthy community” as its theoretical base, it is suggested that the discussion of such media issues must be related to issues about the concept of freedom of speech. Therefore, the primary purpose of this study is to examine certain aspects of media literacy's theoretical foundations by analyzing the dialectic between media literacy and the freedom of speech.

1. 黃銘傑(1998)。美國法上的言論自由與商業廣告－兼論司法院大法官會議釋字第414號解釋。臺大法學論叢，27(2)，347-393。
   連結：
2. 賴祥蔚(2005)。從言論自由到傳播權。台灣政治學刊，9(1)，199-231。
   連結：
3. 賴祥蔚(2006)。新聞自由的臨摹與反思。新聞學研究，87，97-129。
   連結：
4. Alstyne, W. V.(1982).A graphic review of the Free Speech clause.California Law Review,70(1),107-150.
5. Aufderheide, P. (Ed.)(1993).Media literacy: A report of the national leadership conference on media literacy,Aspen, CO:
6. Baker, C. E.(1978).Scope of the First Amendment Freedom of speech.UCLA L. Rev,25,967-981.
7. Bazalgette, C.,R. Kubey (Ed.)(1997).Media literacy in the information age.New Brunswick, NJ:Transaction.
8. Brown, J. A.(1991).Television "Critical Viewing Skills" education: Major media literacy projects in the United States and selected countries.Hillsdale, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum.
9. Buckingham, D.(2003).Media Education: Literacy, learning and contemporary culture.Cambridge:Polity.
10. Buckingham, D.(1988).Media education in the UK: Moving beyond protectionism.Journal of Communication,48(1),33-43.
11. Chafee, Z.(1941).Free speech in the United States.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
12. Coase, R. H.(1988).The firm, the market, and the law.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
13. Appalachian State University, Reich College of Education Web site
14. Cosidine, D.,R. Kubey (Ed.)(1997).Media Literacy in the information age.New Brunswick, NJ:Transaction.
15. Debes, E. L.(1969).The loom of visual literacy.Audiovisual Instruction,14(8),25-27.
16. Department of Education and Science(1989).The Cox Report.London:HMSO.
17. Elkind, D.(1981).The hurried child: Growing up too fast too soon.MA:Addison Wesley.
18. Emerson, T. I.(1980).First Amendment Doctrine and the Burger Court.Calif. L. Rev.,68
19. The Freeman
20. Habermas, J.(1989).The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere.London:Polity Press.
21. NYU School of Law, Brennan Center for Justice Web site
22. Hobbs, R.,M. Salvador,P. Sias (Eds.)(1998).The public voice in a democracy at risk.Westport, CT:Praeger.
23. Hocking, W. E.(1947).Freedom of the press, a framework of principle.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
24. Hovland, R.,Wilcox, G.,T. R. Kupferman (Ed.)(1990).Advertising and commercial speech.CT:Meckler.
25. Jenkinson, C.(1992).From Milton to media: Information flow in a free society.Media & Values,58,3-6.
26. Kress, G.,C. Bazalgette,E. Bevort,J. Savino (Eds.)(1992).New directions: Media education worldwide.Lodon:British Film Institute.
27. National Council for the Social Studies Web Site
28. Masterman, L.(1985).Teaching the media.London:Routledge.
29. Masterman, L.,R. Kubey (Ed.)(1997).Media literacy in the information age: Current perspectives.New Brunswick, NJ:Transaction.
30. Meyrowitz, J.(1985).No sense of place: The impact of electronic media on social behavior.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
31. Milne, A. J.(1986).Human Rights and Human Diversity.Hampshire:Mackmillan Press.
32. Milton, J.(1946).Areopagitica and Other Prose Works.London:J. M. Dent & Sons.
33. Morsy, Z. (Ed.)(1984).Media education.Paris:UNESCO.
34. Olson, D. R.,R. Anderson,R. Spiro,W. Montague (Eds.)(1977).Schooling and the acquisition of knowledge.Hillsdale, NJ:Erlbaum.
35. Peterson, T.,F. S. Siebert,W. Schramm (Eds.)(1956).Four theories of the press.Urbana:University of Illinois Press.
36. Postman, N.(1983).The disappearance of childhood.London:W. H. Allen.
37. Potter, W. J.(2005).Media Literacy.New York:Sage.
38. Freedom of the media, effective co-regulation and media literacy
39. Sanders, B.(1995).A is for ox: The collapse of literacy and the rise of violence in as electronic age.New York:Vintage.
40. Scharlott, B.,T. R. Kupferman (Ed.)(1990).Advertising and commercial speech.CT:Meckler Corporation.
41. Schiller, H.(1996).The Mind Managers.Boston:Beacon.
42. Simon, H.(1978).Rationality as process and product of thought.American Economic Review,68(2),1-16.
43. Smith, M. J.(1988).Contemporary communication research methods.Belmont, CA:Wadsworth.
44. Steinberg, S. R.,Kinchelos, J. L.(Eds.)(1997).Kinderculture: The Corporate Construction of Childhood.Colorado-Oxford:Westview Press.
45. La Plaza Telecommunity Web site
46. UNESCO,L. Masterman (Ed.)(1982).Teaching the Media.London:Comedia.
47. Winn, M.(1984).Children Without Childhood.Harmondsworth:Penguin.
48. 王怡紅譯(1996)。思想管理者。台北:遠流出版社。
49. 石之瑜(2002)。另類社會科學知識論：辯證分析與名實相辨。佛光人文社會學刊，3，211-231。
50. 吳翠珍(1996)。媒體教育中的電視素養。新聞學研究，53，39-60。
51. 吳翠珍(1998)。兒童收看電視卡通行爲研究：兼論媒體素養。理論與政策，47，145-163。
52. 吳翠珍、翁秀琪編(2004)。台灣傳播學的想像（下）。台北:遠流。
53. 林子儀(2002)。言論自由與新聞自由。台北:元照。
54. 林子儀(1984)。商業性言論與言論自由。美國月刊，2(8)，23-33。
55. 夏勇、張志銘譯(1995)。人的權利與人的多樣性。北京:中國大百科全書出版社。
56. 媒體素養研究室
57. 曹衛東、王曉玨、劉北城、宋偉傑譯(1999)。公共領域的結構轉型。上海:學林出版社。
58. 梁朝雲(1997)。網路社會素養：電子郵件的禮儀。新聞學研究，54，53-74。
59. 陳世敏、周典芳、陳國明編(2005)。媒介素養概論。台北:五南。
60. 媒體素養研究室
61. 賴祥蔚(2002)。國共政權控制報紙的政治經濟比較。新聞學研究，73，133-165。
62. 賴祥蔚(2005)。媒體發展與國家政策。台北:五南出版社。
63. 賴祥蔚(2004)。公共關係學想像：社群主義觀點。新聞學研究，80，127-158。

1. 李珮瑜(2014)。英國媒體素養教育對臺灣媒體素養教育之啟示。教育傳播與科技研究，107，11-27。
2. 呂傑華、白亦方(2012)。媒體素養教育與課程實踐歷程之再思與展望。課程與教學，15(1)，1-34。