第三人效果與父母介入子女電視收視行為

The Third-Person Effect and Parental Mediation of Children's Television Viewing

10.30386/MCR.200910_(101).0008

陳佳宜(Chia-Yi Chen)；王嵩音(Song-In Wang)

電視負面影響 ； 第三人效果 ； 父母介入子女收視行為 ； antisocial effects of television ； third-person effect ； parental mediation of children's television viewing

新聞學研究

101期（2009 / 10 / 01）

279 - 310

繁體中文

本研究的主要研究問題在探討父母認知電視負面影響是否出現第三人效果現象？若父母對電視負面影響子女與其他兒童的情形產生認知差異時，又會和何種介入子女電視收視行為的類型有關？本研究以台南市公立國小五、六年級普通班學生之父母為研究對象進行調查。研究結果證實父母在認知收看電視對兒童的負面影響上，存在有第三人效果現象。研究結果也發現第三人效果認知愈強的父母，愈傾向以「評價型」以及「無目的型」的方式介入子女的電視收視行為。

The present study aimed to examine the third-person effect and parental mediation of children's television viewing. The data was collected by asking the parents of the fifth and sixth graders of Tainan City Elementary schools to fill in a survey. The hypotheses were proposed to test the relationships between the third-person perception on the antisocial effects of television and the parental mediation of their children's television viewing. The results indicated that the third-person effect is able to predict the evaluation type and the unfocused type, but not the restrictive mediation. In addition, theoretical and methodological implications for future research are also discussed in this study.

1. 陳志賢、陳志萍(2007)。電視改革的第三人效果與新社會運動模式－以大高雄地區民眾意見調查爲例。新聞學研究，91，35-83。
   連結：
2. Abelman, R.,Pettey, G. R.(1989).Child attributes as determinants of parental television-viewing mediation.Journal of Family Issues,10(2),251-266.
3. Austin, E. W.(1993).Exploring the effects of active parental mediation of television content.Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media,37,147-158.
4. Austin, E. W.,Knaus, C.(1997).Who talks how to their kids about TV: A clarification of demographic correlates of parental mediation patterns.Communication Research Reports,14(4),418-430.
5. Banning, S. A.(2007).Third-person perceptions and political participation.Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly,83(4),785-800.
6. Buckingham, D.(2000).After the death of childhood: growing up in the age electronic media.London:Blackwell.
7. Buijzen, M.,Van der Molen, J. H. M.,Sondiji, P.(2007).Parental mediation of children's emotional responses to a violent news event.Communication Research,34(2),212-230.
8. Bybee, C.,Robinson, D.,Turow, J.(1982).Determinants of parental guidance of children's television viewing for a special subgroup: Mass media scholars.Journal of Broadcasting and Electronic Media,26(3),697-710.
9. Chan, K.,McNeal, J. U.(2002).Parental concern about television viewing and children's advertising in China.International Journal for Opinion Research,15(2),151-166.
10. Chia, S. C.,Lu, K. H.,Mcleod, D. M.(2004).Sex, lies, and video compact disc: A case study on third-person perception and motivations for media censorship.Communication Research,31(1),109-130.
11. Davison, W. P.(1983).The third-person effect in communication.Public Opinion Quarterly,4,1-15.
12. Dens, N.,De Pelsmacker, P.,Eagle, L.(2007).Parental attitudes toward advertising to children and restrictive mediation of children's television viewing in Belgium.Young Consumers,8(1),7-18.
13. Dorr, A.(1986).Television and children.CA:Sage.
14. Dorr, A.,Kovaric, P.,Doubleday, C.(1989).Parent-child coviewing of television.Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media,33,35-51.
15. Fujioka, Y.,Austin, E. W.(2002).The relationship of family communication patterns to parental mediation styles.Communication Research,29(6),642-665.
16. Golan, G.,Banning, S.,Lundy, L.(2008).Likelihood to vote, candidate choice the third-person effect: Behavioral implications of political advertising in the 2004 presidential election.American Behavioral Scientist,52(2),278-290.
17. Gunther, A. C.(1995).Overrating the x-rating: The third-person perception and support for censorship of pornography.Journal of Communication,45(1),27-38.
18. Gunther, A. C.,Storey, J. D.(2003).The influence of presumed influence.Journal of Communication,53(2),199-215.
19. Hoffner, C.,Buchanan, M.(2002).Parent's responses to television violence: The third person perception, parental mediation and support for censorship.Media Psychology,4,231-252.
20. Jensen, J. D.,Hurley, R. J.(2005).Third-person effects and the environment: Social distance, social desirability, and presumed behavior.Journal of Communication,55(2),242-256.
21. Koolstra, C. M.,Lucassen, N.(2004).Viewing behavior of children and TV guidance by parents: A comparison of parent and child reports.The European Journal of Communication Research,29,179-198.
22. Lo, V. H.,Paddon, A. R.(2001).Third-person effect, gender differences, pornography exposure and support for restriction of pornography.Asian Journal of Communication,11(1),120-142.
23. Lo, V. H.,Wei, R.(2002).Third-person effect, gender and pornography on the Internet.Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media,46(1),13-33.
24. McLeod, D. M.,Detenber, B. H.,Eveland, W. P.(2001).Behind the third-person effects: Differentiating perceptual for self and other.Journal of Communication,51,678-695.
25. McLeod, D. M.,Eveland, W. P.,Nathanson, A. I.(1997).Support for censorship of violent and misogynic rap lyrics: An analysis of the third-person effect.Communication Research,24(2),153-174.
26. Nathanson, A. I.(1999).Identifying and explaining the relationship between parental mediation and children's aggression.Communication Research,26(2),124-143.
27. Nathanson, A. I.(2001).Parental and child perspectives on the presence and meaning of parental television mediation.Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media,45(2),201-220.
28. Nathanson, A. I.,Eveland, W. P.,Park, H. S.,Paul, B.(2002).Perceived media influence and efficacy as predictors of caregivers' protective behaviors.Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media,46(3),385-410.
29. Perloff, R. M.(1993).Third-person effect research 1983-1992: A review and synthesis.International Journal of Public Opinion Research,5,167-184.
30. Rojas, H.,Shah, D. V.,Faber, R. J.(1996).For the good of others: Censorship and the third-person effect.International Journal of Public Opinion Research,8(2),163-186.
31. Salwen, M. B.,Dupagne, M.(2001).Third-person perception of television violence: The role of self-perceived knowledge.Media Psychology,3,211-236.
32. Salwen, M. B.,Dupagne, M.(1999).The third-person effect: Perceptions of the media's influence and immoral consequences.Communication Research,26(5),523-549.
33. Sun, Y.,Shen, L.,Pan, Z.(2008).On the behavioral component of the third-person effect.Communication Research,35(2),257-278.
34. Tsfati, Y.,Cohen, J.(2003).On the effect of the "third-person effect": Perceived influence of media coverage and residential mobility intentions.Journal of Communications,53(4),711-727.
35. Tsfati, Y.,Ribak, R.,Cohen, J.(2005).Rebelde Way in Israel: Parental perceptions of television influence and monitoring of children's social and media activities.Mass Communication & Society,8(1),3-22.
36. Valkenburg, P. M.,Krcmar, M.,Peeters, A. L.,Marseille, N. M.(1999).Developing a scale to assess three styles of television mediation: 'Instructive mediation', 'restrictive mediation' and 'social coviewing'.Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media,43(1),52-66.
37. Van den Bulck, J.,Van den Bergh, B.(2000).The influence of perceived parental guidance patterns on children's media use: Gender differences and media displacement.Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media,44(3),329-348.
38. Van der Voort, T. H. A.,Nikkens, P.,Van Lil, J. E.(1992).Determinants of parental guidance of children's television viewing: A Dutch replication study.Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media,36,61-74.
39. Warren, R.,Gerke. P.,Kelly, M. A.(2002).Is there enough time on the clock? Parental Involvement and mediation of children's television viewing.Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media,46(1),87-111.
40. Wei, R.,Lo, V. H.(2007).The third-person effects of political attack ads in the 2004 U.S. presidential election.Media Psychology,9(2),367-388.
41. Wei, R.,Lo, V. H.,Lu, H. Y.(2008).Third-person effects of health news: Exploring the relationships among media exposure, presumed media influence, and behavioral intentions.American Behavioral Scientist,52(2),261-277.
42. Weinstein, N. D.(1980).Unrealistic optimism about future life events.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,39(5),805-820.
43. Youn, S.,Faber, R. J.,Shah, D. V.(2000).Restricting gambling advertising and the third-person effect.Psychology and Marketing,17(7),633-649.
44. 王浩然(2001)。國立政治大學新聞研究所。
45. 台南市全市國小學生人數統計表
46. 吳明清(1991)。教育研究－基本觀念與方法之分析。台北:五南。
47. 吳知賢(1998)。兒童與電視。台北:桂冠。
48. 李秀美(2007)。陪孩子善用媒體。台北:慈濟傳播文化志業基金會。
49. 李嘉峰(2006)。嘉義大學家庭教育研究所。
50. 兒童福利聯盟(2006)。「收視孤兒幫幫忙？」－2006年台灣兒童傳播權調查報告。
51. 兒童福利聯盟(2005)。「TV哪裡有問題？」－2005年台灣兒童傳播權調查報告。
52. 周芊、吳知賢、沈文英(2004)。媒介與兒童。台北:空大。
53. 張春興(2001)。現代心理學。台北:東華。
54. 楊雅婷譯(2003)。童年之死：在電子媒體時代下長大的孩童。台北:巨流。
55. 廖瑞鳳(1995)。收視行爲與親子互動的關係研究報告。
56. 蔡菁秤(2000)。兒童電視識讀能力與父母介入兒童收視行爲。台中師範學院國民教育研究所。
57. 聯合晚報(2006/12/20)
58. 羅文輝(2000)。媒介負面內容與社會距離對第三人效果認知的影響。新聞學研究，65，95-129。
59. 羅文輝、牛隆光(2003)。自尊、第三人效果與對限制媒介支持的關連性研究。新聞學研究，75，141-167。

1. 何慧卿(Huei-Chin Ho);高旭繁(Shu-Fang Kao)(2021)。高中生遊戲沉迷、網路沉迷與生活整體滿意度之研究－以家長對子女上網行為管教態度為調節變項。教育科學研究期刊。66(4)。35-67。