921災區新建校舍工程品質評估之研究

An Evaluation on the Quality of Newly-Constructed Campus Buildings in 921 Disastrous Areas

10.6377/JA.200609.0143

曾俊達(Chun-Ta Tzeng)；龔峰祥(Feng-Hsiang Kung)

921地震 ； 校園重建 ； 工程品質 ； 用後評估 ； 921 earthquake ； campus reconstruction ； construction quality ； post occupancy evaluation

建築學報

57期（2006 / 09 / 28）

143 - 159

繁體中文

921地震之後，政府面臨災區震害學校重建時程縮短的社會期盼，校園重建規劃設計及工程發包作業時程確實緊促。災區各校重建所營造的「新校園」校舍空間，是否能符合使用者需求與確實的反映教育改革，亦將成為檢視校園重建成果的重要指標。 研究過程除調查災區26所重建校舍個案於重建各階段之滿意度外，並於個案現場採「用後評估」方式，從問卷調查及現場訪查兩方面檢視同一校舍基地，歷經不同時空及重建工程實施機制，所呈現的校園空間工程品質。 研究成果顯示重建工程引進專業營建管理之制度或由教育部委託具工程專業團隊協助校方工程品質控管之成效顯著；但是於遴選民間專業營建工程團隊時，除經費考量外，更應評估協辦團隊之專業性與人力，以避免品質控管對策流於形式。

In the aftermath of the 921 earthquake, the government was seen to have hastened its reconstruction planning and contract distribution operations in response to public calls for a speedy recovery of damaged schools in the disastrous areas. Under these urgent circumstances, whether the reconstructed campus of each school in the disastrous area meets the needs of educational reform and users serves as an important indicator for the evaluation of the quality of campus reconstruction. A total of 26 rebuilt schools have been treated as the subjects of the study. In the research course, they went through a questionnaire survey concerning their satisfaction during the reconstruction period. A post occupancy evaluation was then undertaken in the investigation and evaluation of reconstruction quality. It was intended to review the engineering quality of the reconstruction of the same campus sites going through different temporal, spatial and engineering mechanisms. The results indicate that the professional construction management systems or the MOE-commissioned construction teams have achieved significant effectiveness on the quality control of campus construction. However, it is advisable that specialty and manpower, apart from budget, be taken into consideration in the selection of construction teams to effectively avoid the practice of quality control as a matter of formality.

1. (2001)。921災後校園重建報告
2. Chen, Ko-li(1991).A Review of Current Architecture Post-Occupancy Evaluation|Theory and Application of Post-occupancy Evaluation Research in Built Environment.Conference on Sino-Japan Architectural Projects and Academic Exchanges,91-104.
3. Coleman, James S.,Yu Fang(1999).Foundations of Social Theory(Ⅰ)(Ⅱ).
4. Coleman, James S.、郁方(1999)。〈社會理論基礎〉（上、下），3-29。
5. Department of Statistics,Ministry of Education(2000).Statistics of the 921 and 1022 Earthquake Disaster Relief and Reconstruction.
6. Huang, Hsin-hua(2002).Implementing the Professional Construction Management in 921 elementary and junior high school reconstruction.Thesis
7. Lin, Yao-huang(1994).Architectural Construction Quality Control.Architecture and Building Research Institute
8. Ministry of Education(2001).The Post-921 Campus Reconstruction ReportThe Post-921 Campus Reconstruction Report,Taipei:.
9. Tzeng, Chun-Ta,Cheng, Wen-Lung(1983).A Study of Building Materials and Facilities Classification System.Architectural Management Report 71-003|Construction and Planning Agency, Ministry of the Interior, and Research Report TR-7201.
10. Tzeng, Chun-Ta,Kung, Feng-hsiang(2004).Investigation and Assessment on Campus Reconstruction in Disastrous Areas.The Second Paper Presentation of the Sixteenth Conference and A Conference on Ecological Community and Safe Cities and Countries, H10, Architectural Institute of the ROC
11. Wang, Lung-Chuang,Chang, Fei-chun(2001).A Study on Developing the Optimal Procuring Model for Earthquake Restoration in Taiwan.Civil and Hydraulic Engineering, Issue,27(4),28-43.
12. Statistics
13. Williams, Anderson Sweeney、周福興、陳可杰、黃聯海、李宗倚、李婉怡、陳益昌(2003)。統計學。台中:滄海書局。
14. 王隆昌、常斐春(2001)。台灣地區災後重建工程最適採購方式之研究–以災區學校重建工程為例。土木水利，27(4)，28-43。
15. 林耀煌(1994)。建築工程施工之品質管理
16. 教育部統計處彙(2000)。921及1022大地震教育部救災及復健統計
17. 陳格理(1991)。現階段建築用後評估研究工作的檢討。建成環境用後評估研究之理論與應用研討會論文集|中日建築計畫學術交流研討會，中華經濟研究院:
18. 曾俊達、鄭文隆、林耀煌、許美惠、陳乃城(1982)。建材與建築設備之分類系統。內政部營建署建築管理研究報告71-003，195-201。
19. 曾俊達、龔峰祥、巫佳芸(2004)。災區重建校舍工程品質調查及評估。中華民國建築學會第十六屆建築研究成果發表會論文集，H10
20. 黃新發(2002)。南投，國立暨南大學碩士論文。

1. 陳博亮、陳昭勳、莊慶福(2015)。苗栗地區山坡地校園損壞之田野調查與分析─以苗栗縣僑文國小為例。聯大學報，12(1)，179-194。
2. 林曜輝,官美卉(2023)。一位校長的校園重建經驗敘說研究。休閒運動健康評論，12(2)，29-51。