磚牆在面內水平加載下之位移推估及其耐震評估應用

Displacement of Masonry Wall under Horizontal In-Plane Loading and It's Seismic Assessment Application

10.6377/JA.200906.0015

陳拓男(To-Nan Chen)；張嘉祥(Ja-Shian Chang)

磚牆 ； 砌體造 ； 耐震評估 ； P-△曲線 ； 軟化效應 ； Brick Wall ； Masonry ； Seismic Assessment ； P-△ Curve ； Softening Effect

建築學報

68_S期（2009 / 06 / 01）

15 - 34

繁體中文

磚砌古蹟及歷史建築如何在地震前之修復過程適切掌握每道牆體之結構行爲，並進而評估整體結構系統之耐震能力，對古蹟及歷史建築保存而言，實爲相當重要之基礎工作。 爲使磚牆在水平力作用下之面內變形行爲得到更合理之預測及耐震評估應用，本文將垂直主壓應力方向之軟化效應納入位移估算。經由實例之計算及比較，發現當牆體不考慮此軟化效應時，牆體水平加載－位移推估曲線與實驗曲線有相當大之差異，而考慮軟化效應時，此推估曲線與實驗曲線大致相近，因此建築師或設計者以壓力斜撐來模擬分析磚牆在水平力下之面內行爲時，主拉應變對於主壓方向之強度衰減及軟化效應不容加以忽略。 爲說明水平加載－位移推估曲線之評估應用，本文以台南市市定古蹟「原台灣總督府專賣局台南支局（台南出張所）」來進行實例操作。基本上，依本文方式所建立之水平加載－位移推估曲線，可有效評估各道受面內水平力牆體之安全指標及檢討是否合乎空間性能等級需求，並進一步對牆體相垂直之橫向壁體之面外安全性做評估檢討。

In Taiwan, the wall element is the most important part that provides the earthquake resistance for a masonry historic building. Thus, during conservation design, the complete behavior of the wall under earthquake is needed to assess the resistant capacity of the structure. To predict the behavior of the brick wall under in-plane loading reasonably, the softening of principal compressive stress was counted in the calculation of the load-displacement relationship curve (P-△curve). By comparing the computation with test results, it shows that the calculated load-displacement curves without considering the softened effect are quite different from the test curves. However, the calculated curves considering the softened effect obtain good agreement with the test results. This comparison also shows the softening of principal compressive stress due to the principal tensile strain should not be ignored when using the compressive truss model to analyze the masonry shear wall. For explaining the seismic assessment application of the load-displacement relationship curve, the Historical Site of Tainan City, Suboffice of Taiwan Tobacco and Wine Monopoly Bureau in Japanese Colonial Period, is chosen to run the seismic assessment. The P-△ curve calculated by using the formula established in this paper can effectively assess the in-plane safe index of the wall and whether the seismic performance reaches the legal standard. Besides, it also can use to assess the out-of-plane safe of the wall which is perpendicular to the assess in-plane wall.

1. 施忠賢、張嘉祥(2008)。古蹟建築磚砌牆體現地面外加載試驗及評估應用－以兩個磚造古蹟爲例。文化資產保存學刊，3，27-40。
   連結：
2. Berto, Luisa,Saetta, Anna,Scotta, Roberto,Vitaliani, Renato(2004).Shear Behaviour of Masonry Panel: Parametric FE Analyses.International Journal of Solids and Structures,41(16-17),4383-4405.
3. Chaimoon, Krit,Attard, Mario M.(2006).Modeling of unreinforced masonry walls under shear and compression.Engineering Structures,29(9),2056-2068.
4. Ganz, H.R,Thurlimann, B.(1984).Tests on masonry walls under normal and shear loading.Report No.7502-4, ETH Zurich Institute of Structural Engineering.
5. Jai, John,Springer, George S.,Kollár Láseló P.,Krawinkler Helmut(2000).Reinforcing Masonry Walls with Composite Materials-Model.Journal of Composite Materials,34(18),1548-1581.
6. Kaushik Hemant B.,Rai Durgesh C.,Jain Sudhir K.(2007).Stress-Strain Characteristics of Clay Brick Masonry under Uniaxial Compression.Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering,19(9),728-739.
7. Lourenco, P.B.(1996).The Netherlands,Delft University of Technology.
8. Pietruszczak, S.,Ushaksaraei, R.(2003).Description of Inelastic Behaviour of Structural Masonry.International Journal of Solids and Structures,40(15),4003-4019.
9. Roca, Pere(2006).Assessment of masonry shear-wall by simple equilibrium models.Construction and Building Material,20(4),229-238.
10. Thomas, T.C. Hsu,Mo, Y.L.(1985).Softening of Concrete in Low-Rise Shearwalls.ACI Journal,82(6),883-889.
11. Vermeltfoort, ATh,Raijmakers, ThMJ,Janssen, HJM(1993).Shear tests on masonry walls.Proceeding of the 6th North American masonry conference
12. Yokel, Felix Y.,Fattal, S. George(1976).Failure Hypothesis for Masonry Shear Walls.Journal of the Structural Division,102(3),515-532.
13. 建築物耐震設計規範及解說
14. 施楚賢(1992)。砌體結構理論與設計。中國建築工業出版社。
15. 張文德(1997)。國立成功大學建築系。
16. 陳奕信(2003)。國立成功大學建築系。
17. 陳嘉基(2007)。原台灣總督府專賣局台南支局台南出張所磚牆試驗報告。
18. 曾凱瀚(1994)。國立成功大學建築系。

1. 陳拓男、張嘉祥、林耀宗(2011)。石灰砂漿砌磚牆體面內加載實驗及水平耐力估算。建築學報，78，39-61。
2. 陳拓男、張嘉祥、林裕鈞(2014)。磚造古蹟歷史建築耐震評估方法。文化資產保存學刊，28，7-35。
3. 黃漢翔、陳拓男、張嘉祥(2013)。歷史建築物具開口部磚牆面內水平加載實驗及牆體耐力估算。建築學報，86，51-69。
4. 劉彥志、陳拓男、張嘉祥(2014)。碳纖維補強清水磚牆加載實驗及水平─位移關係計算。建築學報，87，83-101。
5. 謝鎮宇、陳拓男、張嘉祥(2009)。清水磚牆貼附鋼絲網補強在水平加載下之分析計算及實驗比較。建築學報，70(S)，1-20。
6. 張嘉祥、施忠賢(2011)。磚造建築拱開口部水平返覆加載行為及補強方法實驗研究。建築學報，78(S)，1-24。