磚造建築拱開口部水平返覆加載行為及補強方法實驗研究

Experimental Study on Behavior of Horizontally Cyclic Loading and Strengthening Methods for Masonry Building with Arch Opening

10.6377/JA.201112.0008

施忠賢(Chung-Hsien Shih)；張嘉祥(Ja-Shian Chang)

歷史建築 ； 砌體 ； 磚拱 ； 補強 ； 層間位移角 ； Historic Building ； Masonry ； Brick Arch ； Strengthen ； Drift Angle

建築學報

78_S期（2011 / 12 / 01）

1 - 24

繁體中文

本研究以實驗來探討磚造歷史建築中，拱開口牆體在水平返覆加載下之完整結構行為以及不同補強工法之效益。執行之試體共五道，試體尺寸均為239cm×203cm（寬×高），兩道（WU1、WU2）無補強之試體中，WU2另外施加垂直加載71.2kN，其他三道分別在牆體施作不同的補強工法。實驗過程採位移控制。實驗結果顯示無補強試體約在2／1000層間位移角時拱肩產生起始裂縫。另加軸壓之試體WU2，其起始開裂強度較WU1提升26%以上，極限加載則提昇14%以上。三種補強工法中，拱下緣嵌扁型不銹鋼之試體WS1在水平耐力提昇以及延緩中度破壞之發生，均較其他兩種工法顯著。綜合實驗結果，本文建議歷史建築結構評估時，針對拱開口磚牆，可以層間位移角2／1000做為起始破壞點，4／1000為性能極限點。在試體實驗之外，本文並以簡化模式推導拱開口牆體之水平耐力估算，此估算與試體極限加載相較，差值在6%以內。

In this study, the structural behavior and the effect of different strengthening method for historic masonry walls with arch openings under horizontally cyclic loading are investigated by experiment. There are five wall specimens manufactured in the size of 239cmx203cm (W×H). Two of which (WU1 and WU2) are un-strengthened. Specimen WU2 takes an additional vertical load of 71.2kN compared to WU1. For the other three strengthened specimens, different wall strengthening methods are employed. The experimental system is controlled by displacement. Results obtained from the two un-strengthened specimens show the initial crack occurred at a drift angle of approximately 2/1000. However, in specimen WU2 there is a 26% increase in initial crack strength, and a 14% increase in ultimate load, compared to specimen WU1. A comparison of the three strengthened specimens reveals that the method (of imbedding steel straps into arch intrados) used to strengthen specimen WS1 is the most effective in increasing the ultimate load as well as delaying the occurrence of medium damage. Based on the test results, we suggest that drift angle 2/1000 could be assigned as the initial damage point, and drift angle 4/1000 to be the ultimate performance point for historic building assessment. In this study, in addition to the specimen test, a method for evaluating the ultimate load of a brick wall with arch opening has been developed from a simplified model. Comparing the ultimate load evaluated and that obtained from test specimens, the difference is less than 6%.

1. 陳拓男、張嘉祥(2009)。磚牆在面內水平加載下之位移推估及其耐震評估應用。建築學報，68(增刊（技術專刊）=Special Issue on Technology)，15-34。
   連結：
2. 陳奕信、許茂雄、劉宜珮(2002)。RC構架內砌磚牆承受面內水平載重之強度與剛度分析。建築學報，41，129-153。
   連結：
3. 張義震(2005)《歷史建築台中州廳修復工程設計書圖》，張義震建築師事務所，台北。Chang, I. (2005) Restoration Design Document of the Former Taichung Prefectural Hall, Chang Ichen Architect and Associates, Taipei, Taiwan.。
4. 韓興興(2007)《台南市市定古蹟原台南縣知事官邸第二期修復工程設計書圖》，韓興興建築師事務所，台中。Han, S. S. (2007) Restoration design document of The Official Residence Building of Former Tainan County Governor: Stage two, Han Sing Sing Architect and Associates, Taichung, Taiwan.。
5. De Luca, A.,Giordano, A.,Mele, E.(2004).A simplified procedure for assessing the seismic capacity of masonry arches.Engineering Structures,26,1915-1929.
6. Giordano, A.,Mele, E.,De Luca, A.(2002).Modelling of historical mastory structures: comparison of different approaches through a case study.Engineering Structures,24(8),1057-1069.
7. Stepanek, P.,Zlamal, M.,Filip, M.(2006).Masonry structures with and additional reinforcement.10th Int'l Conference on Inspection, Appraisal, Repairs & Maintenance of Structures
8. Valluzzi, M. R.,Valdemarca, M.,Modena, C.(2001).Behavior of Brick Masonry Vaults Strengthened by FRP Laminates.J. of Composites for Construction, ASCE,5(3),163-169.
9. 張嘉祥、林裕鈞、胡復凱(2010)。行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告行政院國家科學委員會專題研究計畫成果報告,行政院國家科學委員會=National Science Council。
10. 張嘉祥、陳嘉基、蘇彥豪(2002)。建築物連牆出入口地震力破壞實驗探討。第14屆建築研究成果發表會論文集，台北=Taiepi, Taiwan:
11. 黃斌(2005)。,Tainan, Taiwan.:成大研究發展基金會=NCKU Research and Development Foundation。