以層級程序分析法應用在玻璃建材評選之決策分析

Multicriteria Evaluation of the Selection of Glazing Systems by Using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP)

10.6377/JA.201203.0069

陳振誠(Cheng-Chen Chen)；江哲銘(Che-Ming Chiang)；陳文亮(Wen-Liang Chen)；王佑萱(Yu-Hsuan Wang)；李訓谷(Shin-Ku Lee)

玻璃建材 ； 分析層級程序法 ； 建築節能 ； Glazing System ； Analytic Hierarchy Process ； Energy Saving

建築學報

79期（2012 / 03 / 01）

67 - 83

繁體中文

玻璃建材因能提供好的景觀視野以及設計美學上的特性而成為被廣泛應用的建築材料。然而，玻璃建材的使用所延伸出防火安全、節能與環境上的問題卻也引發相當多的討論。故以全面性的角度來探討玻璃建材在使用上對於生活品質、環境、經濟發展等因素之影響為本研究之目的。本研究利用AHP法對玻璃建材選用建構一層級架構，以提出一套評價決策方法，並且透過40份產官學界的問卷，獲得分析層級程序法中的對偶比對評估與因素之優勢比重值，最後決定評估準則與項目的優先順序。再者，本研究針對三種玻璃建材選擇方案進行綜合權值與排序探討。在評定準則優先順序中，「性能」為玻璃建材選用時之首要考量，而「外觀」則是最後被考慮因素，再者，在三種玻璃建材替代方案排序中，則是由建築整合型太陽光電系統（BIPV）為首要考量因素。

The window glazing system can provide the high visible light transmittance for a better view, better environmental contribution and the esthetics of the architectural design. However, the application of such a window glazing system can cause the rise of the fire resistance, energy saving and environmental protection problems. This paper presents an analytic hierarchy process (AHP) based modeling framework for the prioritization of the glazing system selection. Both positive and negative impacts of the glazing system selection are considered in AHP survey. The results based on 40 expertise questionnaires indicated that ”performance” was perceived to be most important core selection criterion for the glazing system, ”appearance” was regarded as minor factor to be considered in selecting the glazing system. In addition, the BIPV alternative ranked in the first position regardless of criteria weight variations. The proposed results are expected to provide a valuable reference to building material manufacturers, architects and interior designers in utilizing the glazing system.

1. 江哲銘、陳星皓、潘智謙(2009)。永續校園實質環境評估指標之研究—以台灣國民小學為例。建築學報，67，1-23。
   連結：
2. 張桂鳳、江哲銘、周伯丞(2007)。永續建築評估工具GBTool2005本土適用性之研究。建築學報，60，177-196。
   連結：
3. 陳星皓、江哲銘、黃貞燕(2008)。班群教室室內物理環境綜合評估之研究—以高雄市國民小學為例。建築學報，63，25-46。
   連結：
4. British Federation Rating Council (BFRC) (2007). Use of the BFRC A-G energy window label. BFRC Guidance Note. London: British Federation Rating Council..
5. Avasoo, D.(2004).Energy transparency for energy efficiency.Future buildings forum event Cooling Buildings in a Warming Climate,Sophia Antipolis, France:
6. Benemann, J.,Chehab, O.,Schaar-Gabriel, E.(2001).Building-integrated PV modules.Solar Energy Materials & Solar Cells,67(1-4),345-354.
7. Bertolini, M.,Braglia, M.,Carmignani, G.(2006).Application of the AHP methodology in making a proposal for a public work contract.International Journal of Project Management,24(5),422-430.
8. Cai, Z. G.,Li, H. L.,Chen, L. Y.,Cai, B.,Liao, G. X.,Shen, L. G.(2004).Experimental studies on flow field diagnosis and thermal radiation blockage of water curtain.Fire Safety Science,13(4),224-230.
9. Chaiyapinunt, S.,Phuakphongsuriya, B.,Mongkornsaksit, K.,Khomporn, N.(2005).Performance rating of glass windows and glass windows with films in aspect of thermal comfort and heat transmission.Energy and Buildings,37(7),725-738.
10. Chang, K. F.,Chiang, C. M.,Chou, P. C.(2007).Adapting aspects of GBTool 2005 - Searching for suitability in Taiwan.Building and Environment,42(1),310-316.
11. Chatzimouratidis, A.I.,Pilavachi, P. A.(2007).Objective and subjective evaluation of power plants and their non-radioactive emissions using the analytic hierarchy process.Energy Policy,35(8),4027-4038.
12. Chiang, C. M.,Lai, C. M.(2002).A study on the comprehensive indicator of indoor environment assessment for occupants' health in Taiwan.Building and Environment,37(4),387-392.
13. Citherlet, S.,Guglielmo, F. D.,Gay, J. B.(2000).Window and advanced glazing systems life cycle assessment.Energy and Buildings,32(3),225-234.
14. Collins, R. E.,Simko, T. M.(1998).Current status of the science and technology of vacuum glazing.Solar Energy,62(3),189-213.
15. Ismail, K. A. R.,Henriquez, J. R.(2002).Parametric study on composite and PCM glass systems.Energy Conversion and Management,43(7),973-993.
16. Karami, E.(2006).Appropriateness of farmers' adoption of irrigation methods: the application of the AHP model.Agricultural Systems,87(1),101-119.
17. Keski-Rahkonen, O.(1988).Breaking of window glass close to fire.Fire and Material,12(2),61-69.
18. Menzies, G. F.,Wherrett, J. R.(2005).Windows in the workplace: Examining issues of environmental sustainability and occupant comfort in the selection of multi-glazed windows.Energy and Buildings,37(6),623-630.
19. Ozdemir, M. S.(2005).Validity and inconsistency in the analytic hierarchy process.Applied Mathematics and Computation,161(3),707-720.
20. Park, C. S.,Han, I.(2002).A case-based reasoning with the feature weights derived by analytic hierarchy process for bankruptcy prediction.Expert Systems with Applications,23(3),255-264.
21. Ramanathan, R.,Ganesh, L. S.(1995).Energy resource allocation incorporating qualitative and quantitative criteria: an integrated model using goal programming and AHP.Socio-Economic Planning Sciences,29(3),197-218.
22. Richardson, J. K.,Oleszkiewicz, I.(1987).Fire tests on window assemblies protected by automatic sprinklers.Fire Technology,23(3),115-132.
23. Russo, D.,McKown, C.,Roger, C.,Brotzman, J.,Stricker, J.(2001).The influence of film composition on the optical and thermal properties of solar control coatings.Thin Solid Films,398-399(1),65-70.
24. Saaty, T. L.(1980).The Analytic Hierarchy Process.New York:McGraw-Hill.
25. Sottile, G. M.(2005).2004 Survey of United States architects on the subject of switchable glazings.Materials Science and Engineering B,119(3),240-245.
26. Tiwari, M.K.,Banerjee, R.(2001).A decision support system for the selection of a casting process using analytic hierarchy process.Production planning & Control,12(7),689-694.
27. U.S. Department of Energy (DOE)(2009).,Washington D. C.:U.S. Department of Energy.
28. Vaidya, O. S.,Kumar, S.(2006).Analytic hierarchy process: An overview of applications.European Journal of Operational Research,169(1),1-29.
29. Wedley, W. C.(1990).Combining qualitative and quantitative factors-An analytic hierarchy approach.Socio-Economic Planning Sciences,24(1),57-64.
30. Wong, J. K. W.,Li, H.(2008).Application of the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) in multi-criteria analysis of the selection of intelligent building systems.Building and Environment,43(1),108-125.
31. Zhu, X.,Dale, A. P.(2001).JavaAHP: A wed-based decision analysis tool for natural resource and environmental management.Environmental Modelling & Software,16(3),251-262.
32. 內政部建築研究所、Chiang, C. M.(2007)。綠建材解說與評估手冊。新北市=Taiwan:內政部建築研究所=The Architecture and Building Research Institute, Ministry of The Interior。
33. 曾國雄、鄧振源(1989)。層級分析法（AHP）的內涵特性與應用（上）。中國統計學報，27(6)，1-20。

1. 王麗卿(2021)。台灣大學院校室內設計教育課程指標權重研究。設計學研究，24(1)，1-24。