居室火災致命情境建構與避難安全評估

Model Development of Untenable Conditions and Egress Safety Assessment in Room Fires

10.3966/101632122017030099008

周柏年(Po-Nien Chou)；黃伯全(Po-Chuan Huang)；吳榮平(Zong-Ping Wu)；林元祥(Yuan-Shang Lin)

致命情境 ； 隨機型模式 ； 一氧化碳濃度 ； 一氧化碳血紅蛋白濃度 ； Untenable Conditions ； Stochastic Model ； Carbon Monoxide Concentration ； Carboxyhemoglobin Concentration

建築學報

99_S期（2017 / 03 / 31）

1 - 18

繁體中文

本研究首先以「居室火災致命情境子模式」預測居室火災致命情境屆臨時間，且以「人員避難子模式」估算居室避難所需時間，再結合兩項時間之競合，建立「決定型居室火災人員避難成敗模式」。然後，輔以可靠度為基礎之設計及結構函數概念，建構「隨機型居室火災人員避難成敗模式」，並且界定模式中隨機型參數及其機率分配，運用蒙地卡羅模擬方法，產生參數之隨機亂數值，以估計居室內人員面臨一項或兩項致命情境（一氧化碳濃度達1400 ppm 或一氧化碳血紅蛋白濃度達30 %）導致避難失敗的機率值。模式建構完畢後，本文舉一酒吧場所為例，在容留人數為150 人及200 人等2 種情境下分別實施多次模擬，比較兩項致命情境之危害情形，提出研究結果與建議供消防實務界及後續研究者參考。

A sub-model of untenable situations in room fires was first developed to predict the onset time of untenable situations in this study. Then, a deterministic model of egress safety/failure in room fires was established by integrating the onset time of untenable situations with the required egress time obtained from the sub-model of occupant egress. Based on reliability-based design and structure function, the deterministic model of egress safety/failure in room fires was transformed into ＂the stochastic model of egress safety/failure in room fires＂. Moreover, stochastic parameters and probability distributions of the proposed model were assumed and random numbers of parameters were generated by the Monte Carlo simulation. The failure probabilities of occupant egress due to either one or both of the untenable conditions (when carbon monoxide concentration reaches 1400 ppm or carboxyhemoglobin concentration reaches 30 %) were obtained after simulations. After the model development, a pub is taken as an example to compare both dangerous threats by executing several simulations under 2 situations of 150 occupants and 200 occupants respectively. From the result comparison, some ideas for fire officers and future studies for fire researchers are recommended.

1. Ang, H. S.,Tang, H.(1984).Probability Concepts in Engineering Planning and Design, Volume II-Decision, Risk, and Reliability.NY, USA:John Wiley and Sons Press.
2. DiNenno, P.J.(Ed.)(2002).SFPE Handbook of Fire Protection Engineering.MA, USA:National Fire Protection Association Press.
3. DiNenno, P.J.(Ed.)(2007).The SFPE Handbook of Fire Protection Engineering.MA, USA:National Fire Protection Association Press.
4. Hasofer, A. M.,Qu, J.(2002).Response surface modelling of Monte Carlo fire data.Fire Safety Journal,37(8),772-784.
5. Milke, J. A.,Mowrer, F. W.(1993).,MD, USA:University of Maryland.
6. Nystedt, F.(2003).,Lund, Sweden:Department of Fire Safety Engineering, Lund University.
7. Purser, D. A.(2015).Effects of pre-fire age and health status on vulnerability to incapacitation and death from exposure to carbon monoxide and smoke irritants in Rosepark fire incident victims.Proceeding of 6th International Symposium- Human Behaviour in Fire,Cambridge, UK:
8. Purser, D. A.(2007).The application of exposure concentration and dose to evaluation of the effects of irritants as components of fire hazard.Proceedings of Interflam Conference,London, UK:
9. Ramachandran, G.,Charters, D.(2011).Quantitative Risk Assessment in Fire Safety.London, UK:Spon Press.
10. Rohr, K. D.(2005).Products First Ignited in U. S. Home Fires.MA, USA:National Fire Protection Association Press.
11. Williams, J.(2003).Life Safety Risk Assessment for Firecells with a Single Means of Escape.Christchurch, New Zealand:University of Canterbury.
12. Yamada, T.,Takanashi, K.,Yanai, E.,Suzuki, T.,Sekizawa, A.(2002).An experimental study of ejected flames and combustion efficiency.Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium,MA, USA:
13. 王鵬智(2007)。台北市=Taipei，國立臺灣科技大學建築研究所=Department of Architecture, National Taiwan University of Science and Technology。
14. 田中哮義(1993)。建築物火災安全工學入門。東京都=Tokyo:日本建築????=Building Research Institute of Japan。
15. 何明錦、陳俊勳(2007)。內政部建築研究所研究報告內政部建築研究所研究報告,新北市=New Taipei City:內政部建築研究所=Architecture and Building Research Institute, Ministry of the Interior。
16. 吳秉宸、蕭嘉俊(2007)。內政部建築研究所研究報告內政部建築研究所研究報告,新北市:內政部建築研究所。
17. 姚致平譯、Ang, A. H. S.、Tang, W. H.(1998)。工程或然率（二）：決策、風險與可靠度。台北市=Taipei:科技圖書股份有限公司=Techbook Co., Ltd.。
18. 高學賢、沈子勝、簡賢文(2008)。台灣性能式設計防火設計制度之探討。災害防救學報，9(1)，121-150。
19. 陳建忠、簡賢文(2009)。建築物防火避難安全性能驗證技術手冊。新北市=New Taipei City:內政部建築研究所=Architecture and Building Research Institute, Ministry of the Interior。

1. 盧鏡臣,陳彥仲,吳舒凱(2023)。臺灣中型城市建築火災空間分析－以員林市為例。規劃學報，41(1)，35-59。