Management and Research on Public Construction Contract Termination and Cancellation - A Case Study of School Building Renovation Project

公共工程終止契約或解除契約之管理與研究－以學校修繕工程為例

10.3966/101632122019060108007

卓逸程(I-Cheng Cho)；曾惠斌(H. P Tserng)；徐景文(Ching-Wen Hsu)

Contract Termination ； Contract Cancellation ； Construction Suspension ； Risk Management ； 終止契約 ； 解除契約 ； 延期 ； 風險管理

建築學報

108_S期：技術專刊（2019 / 06 / 30）

1 - 12

英文

While contract termination or cancellation (hereinafter referred to as ＂termination＂) occurs in public construction projects, it not only postpones the completion date of the contract but also increases the budget due to subsequent re-tendering process. In this case, it has been acting as a waste of government resources and shows no sign of stopping. This study attempts to organize the patterns of mistakes that cause contract termination and focuses on corresponding strategies to recognize high risk factors of contract termination. This is done through literature reviews and professional discussions about the factors of contract termination. In order to reduce the losses caused by contract termination, corresponding strategies should be prepared to deal with high risk factors of contract termination in advance. In addition, this study will propose average time needed for subsequent procedures after termination for organizing party's reference.

公共工程執行若遇終止契約或解除契約（以下統稱解約），除延長履約期限外，也可能因重新發包而增加預算。如此浪費國家資源的行為，未有減少的跡象。本研究經由文獻回顧及專案探討解約的發生原因、整理出解約情事的錯誤樣態，並針對因應對策，建立解約之高風險因子，並回饋給主管權責機關。提供未來在執行計畫時，針對此解約高風險因子，提早針對因應對策作準備，以減少解約時所造成的損失。研究結果將提供錯誤樣態相對應的策略及高風險因子，回饋主管機關可以事先修成錯誤。其研究結果確實可以減少因終止契約或解除契約所造成的損失，並且縮短契約終止後，後續處理程序所需的平均時間，供主管權責機關執行此作業之參考目標值。

1. Chang, C. Y.,Li, P.,Lin, H. T.(2018).Economic benefit analysis on the life cycle cost approach for existing building's lighting retrofit-A case study on green building renovation projects in southern region from 2013 to 2015.Journal of Architecture,104,1-20.
   連結：
2. Abotaleb, I. S.,El-adaway, I. H.(2017).Administering employers' payment obligations under national and international design-build standard forms of contract.Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction,9(2),4517003.
3. Chandramouli, V.,Lingireddy, S.,Brion, G. M.(2007).Robust training termination criterion for back-propagation ANNs applicable to small data sets.Journal of Computing in Civil Engineering,21(1),39-46.
4. Du Plessis, H.,Oosthuizen, P.(2018).Construction project management through building contracts, a South African perspective.Acta Structilia,25(1),152-181.
5. Duffey, M.,Van Dorp, J.(1999).Risk analysis for large engineering projects: Modeling cost uncertainty for ship production activities.Journal of Engineering Valuation and Cost Analysis,2(4),285-301.
6. Liu, J.,Gao, R.,Cheah, C. Y. J.(2017).Pricing mechanism of early termination of PPP projects based on real option theory.Journal of Management in Engineering,33(6),4017035.
7. Long, Z. J.,Lee, S. K.,Choi, H. S.(2010).Risk evaluation of ship dynamic stability in regular waves.Journal of Marine Science and Technology,18(4),530-536.
8. Loulakis, M. C.,McLaughlin, L. P.(2010).Contractor default termination deemed proper after 95 percent completion.Civil Engineering Magazine Archive,80(11),108-108.
9. Loulakis, M. C.,McLaughlin, L. P.(2017).Contractor that overreaches is terminated for default.Civil Engineering Magazine Archive,87(7),88-88.
10. Lu, W.,Zhang, L.,Zhang, L.(2016).Effect of contract completeness on contractors' opportunistic behavior and the moderating role of interdependence.Journal of Construction Engineering and Management,142(6),04016004.
11. Ozkok, M.(2013).Risk assessment in ship hull structure production using FMEA.Journal of Marine Science and Technology
12. Shang, K. C.,Tseng, W. J.(2010).A risk analysis of stevedoring operations in seaport container terminals.Journal of Marine Science and Technology,18(2),201-210.
13. Shi, C.,Chen, Y.,You, J.,Yao, H.(2018).Asset specificity and contractors' opportunistic behavior: Moderating roles of contract and trust.Journal of Management in Engineering,34(5),04016004.
14. Tsai, L. K.,Tserng, H. P.,Liao, H. H.,Chen, P. C.,Wang, W. P.(2012).Integration of accounting-based and option-based models to predict construction contractor default.Journal of Marine Science and Technology,20(5),479-484.
15. Tserng, H. P.,Lin, W. S.,Li, C. C.,Weng, K.W.,Loisel, D. C.(2015).Research on the earned value management system applied in consultancy project performance.Journal of Marine Science and Technology,23(1),21-35.
16. Wang, M. T.,Fan, S. L.,Tsai, C. C.,Chang, L. M.(2015).A comparison of float ownership issues for construction projects between Taiwan and China.Journal of Marine Science and Technology,23(1),69-77.
17. Wu, L.,Jia, G.,Mackhaphonh, N.(2019).Case study on improving the effectiveness of public participation in public infrastructure megaprojects.Journal of Construction Engineering and Management,145(4),05019003.
18. Zhang, S. B.,Fu, Y. F.,Gao, Y.,Zheng, X. D.(2016).Influence of trust and contract on dispute negotiation behavioral strategy in construction subcontracting.Journal of Management in Engineering,32(4),04016001.