Discussion on Indoor Air Quality in Different Space Plan in Dental Clinics

不同空間形式牙醫診所之室內空氣品質探討

10.3966/101632122019120110010

李孟杰(M. C. Jeffrey Lee)；施吳珍(Wu-Chen Shih)

Indoor Air Quality ； Dental Clinics ； Different Space Plan ； Ventilation ； Space Renovation ； 室內空氣品質 ； 牙醫診所 ； 不同空間形式規劃 ； 通風換氣 ； 空間改善

建築學報

110期_S期：創新低碳與綠建築專刊Ⅱ（2019 / 12 / 30）

33 - 48

英文

In hospitals and clinics, the air pollutants diffusion by medical treatment, medical materials and the ingredients of cleaning supplies affects indoor air quality, especially in the dental clinics. The air-conditioning design without fresh air ventilation causes the air pollutants circulated in the medical space to impact the human health. This study surveyed the indoor air quality in dental clinic and analyzed the impacts in different interior space plan and decoration. The result shows three types of space plan, such as (1) Non-partition separation space, (2) Partition separation space with connecting route, (3) Partition separation space without connecting route. The significant high air pollutants concentration was measured in Non-partition separation space because of airborne infection. Therefore, this study submits the solution from ventilation, equipment remodel, and space renovation.

醫療行為、醫療材料和清潔用品的成分，會因為擴散空氣污染物而造成醫院和診所的室內空氣品質，尤其在牙醫診所。由於診所內的冷氣系統常屬於內循環型式，缺乏對外通風換氣而使得空氣汙染物蓄積在室內而影響人體健康。本研究調查牙醫診所內不同空間形式的空氣品質並分析其影響。調查結果大致上可歸類成三種形式，分別為（1）非分區分隔空間（開放式），（2）有連接動線但分隔空間（半開放式），（3）沒有連接動線的分隔空間（獨立式）。由於空氣傳播的感染，在非分區分隔空間（開放式）中測量到高濃度的空氣污染物。因此，本研究提出了通風換氣、設備改善與空間改造的解決方案。

1. Chiang, C. M.,Yang, W. T.,Lee, C. C.,Ho, M. C.,Chen, J. L.,Lo, S. C.(2009).A study on optimum methods for measurement of indoor air quality-implementation in office buildings and temples.Journal of Architecture,70,93-110.
   連結：
2. Lin, W. T.,Wu, M. D.,Liang, C. L.(2007).Research on the test method of the formaldehyde and VOCs emitting from wood building material conversion to CNS standards.Journal of Architecture,62,149-162.
   連結：
3. Bremer, J.,White, E.,Schneider, D.(1993).Measurement and characterization of emissions from PVC materials for indoor use.Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate 2,Heisinki, Finland:
4. Cox, S. S.,Little, J. C.,Hodgson, A. T.(2005).Effect of glass transition temperature on volatile emissions from polymer materials.Proceedings of Indoor Air II
5. Eberlein, K. B.,Przybilla, B.,Kuhnl, P.,Pechak, J.,Gebefugi, I.,Klenschmidt, J.,Ring, J.(1998).Influence of airborne nitrogen dioxide or formaldehyde on parameters of skin function and cellular activation in patients with atopic eczema and control subjects.Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology,101(1),141-143.
6. Environmental Protection Administration., Executive Yuan, R.O.C (Taiwan) (2012). Indoor Air Quality Act. Nov 23, 2012. Order No: Huan-Shu-Kong 1010105620D.
7. Fabao Medical Association Magazine(2012).Fabao Medical Association Magazine,110(10),567-571.
8. Gerberding, J. L.(1996).Infectious organisms.Occupational and environmental respiratory disease,St. Louis, MO:
9. Hodgson, A. T.,Beal, D.,Mcllvaine, J. E. R.(2002).Sources of formaldehyde, other aldehydes and terpenes in a new manufactured house.Indoor Air,12(4),35-42.
10. IARC(2006).Formaldehyde. 2-butoxyethanol and 1-tertbutoxypropan-2-ol.IARC.
11. Jeffrey Lee, M. C.,Shih, W. C.(2018).Analysis on indoor air pollution in the dental clinics.Proceedings of the 15th International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate,Philadelphia, PA, USA.:
12. Kelly, T.,Smith, D.,Satola, J.(1999).Emission rates of formaldehyde from materials and consumer products found in California homes.Environmental Science & Technology,33(1),81-88.
13. Li, L. S.,Huang, F. C.(2012).An Integrated Study for the Evaluation of Occupational Hazard by Electronic Communication Devices.New Taipei City:Institute of Labor, Occupational Safety and Health, Ministry of Labor.
14. Lin, J. L. (2018). Formaldehyde Pollution in Daily Life. Retrieved Dec. 4 2018 from http://www.greencross.org.tw/enviroment/formalin.htm.
15. Mário, C.,Luís, G.,Luís, T.,Casimiro, P.(2013).Formaldehyde and acetaldehyde emissions from residential wood combustion in Portugal.Atmospheric Environment,72,171-176.
16. Shih, B. C.(2011).Tainan,Department of Architecture, National Cheng Kung University.
17. Sollinger, S.,Levsen, K.,Wunsch, G.(1993).Indoor air pollution by organic emissions from textile floor coverings. Climate chamber studies under dynamic conditions.Atmospheric Environment,27(2),183-192.
18. Vaughan, T. L.,Strader, C.,Davis, S.(1986).Formaldehyde and cancers of the pharynx, sinus and nasal cavity: 1. Occupational exposures.Int J Cancer,38(5),677-683.
19. World Health Organization, International Programme on Chemical Safety.Basic Analytical Toxicology.
20. Zhang, Y. P.,Luo, X. O.,Wang, X. K.(2007).Influence of Temperature on Formaldehyde Emission Parameters of Dry Building Materials.Atmospheric Environment,41(15),3203-3216.