空間型構法介入古民居新增衛浴空間位置推測研究－以閩南蔡氏古民居「德棣厝」為例

Research on the Speculation of New Bathroom Position in Traditional Residential Buildings through Space Syntax - A Case Study of ＂De Di House＂ of Cai-Clan Traditional Residential Buildings

10.3966/101632122020120114004

傅游磊(You-Lei Fu)；梁桂嘉(Kuei-Chia Liang)

古民居建築 ； 官式大厝 ； 真實性 ； 活態性 ； 空間型構法 ； 衛浴空間 ； Traditional Residential Buildings ； Official Buildings ； Authenticity ； Liveness ； Space Syntax ； Bathroom Space

建築學報

114期（2020 / 12 / 30）

61 - 81

繁體中文

本研究基於對閩南官式古民居建築保護的真實性與活態性原則，以蔡氏古民居「德棣厝」為例經由文獻與田野調查獲取建築空間格局、文化習俗、引排水狀況和居住現狀，結合居民和專家訪談分析出影響新增衛浴空間位置的四限制條件以及選擇範圍，但其結果為表層且模糊。而空間型構分析法從可以通過凸空間、軸線以及視域分析以預測人的自然行為模式，分析結果為內在且具體。通過兩類分析之結果對比互證，逐步細化選擇、推導與篩選，以確定適合選擇的位置。研究結果包括：（1）歸納出影響新增衛浴空間的文化、建築、環境和居住四個限制條件；（2）選擇出12個新增衛浴空間可選位置；（3）分析出3個較適合作為公共衛浴空間的位置，以及3個適合私密衛浴空間的位置；（4）分析出7個適合程度高的選擇位置。本研究之結果與方法對於其它閩南「官式大厝」新增衛浴空間位置選擇議題具有一定參考作用。

The research is based on the principles of the authenticity and liveliness of the protection on the official ancient residential buildings of Southern Fujian. Cai-Clan traditional residential buildings ＂De Di House＂ is taken as an example to obtain some information about the architectural spatial pattern, the cultural customs, the drainage conditions and the living conditions through literature review and field survey. Four restrictions affecting the new bathroom spatial location as well as the related selection scope are analyzed through the interviews of residents and experts. The result is shallow and fuzzy. The Space Syntax can be adopted to predict the natural behavior pattern of people through convex space, axis and visibility graph analysis. The analysis result is internal and specific. The suitable site is determined through the comparison, interoperability certification, refinement, derivation and selection of two kinds of analysis results. The results of the research mainly include: (1) Four restrictions of culture, architecture, environment and residence that affect new bathroom space are summed up. (2) Twelve optional positions for new bathroom space are selected. (3) Three positions that are very suitable for public bathroom space as well as three positions that are suitable for private bathroom space are analyzed. (4) Seven positions that are very suitable for private bathroom space are analyzed. The results and methods of the research can be used as a reference for other issues on the site selection of new bathroom space in the ＂official building＂ of Southern Fujian.

1. 李琦華, C. H.,林峰田, F. T(2007)。台灣聚落的空間型構法則分析。建築學報，60，27-45。
   連結：
2. 劉秉承, P. C.(2018)。「城市診脈」動線系統之模擬與預測——一種基於空間型構理論動線區段分析之都市空間結構研究。設計學報，23(3)，1-21。
   連結：
3. (1994).The Computer Stimulation of Social Phenomena.London, UK:UCL Press.
4. Bafna, S.(2003).Space syntax: A brief introduction to its logic and analytical techniques.Environment and behavior,35(1),17-29.
5. Batty, M.(2004).A New Theory of Space Syntax. (CASA Working Papers).London, UK:UCL Press.
6. Benedikt, M. L.(1979).To take hold of space: isovists and isovist fields.Environment and Planning B: Planning and design,6(1),47-65.
7. Braaksma, J. P.,Cook, W. J.(1980).Human orientation in transportation terminals.Transportation engineering journal of the American Society of Civil Engineers,106(2),189-203.
8. Hall, E. T.(1966).The Hidden Dimension.Garden City, NY:Doubleday.
9. Hillier, B.(2007).Space is the Machine: A Configurational Theory of Architecture.London, UK:UCL Press.
10. Hillier, B.,Hanson, J.(1984).The Social Logic of Space.Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press.
11. Hillier, B.,Hanson, J.,Peponis, J.(1987).Syntactic analysis of settlements.Architecture et Comportement/Architecture and Behaviour,3(3),217-231.
12. Jiang, B.,Christophe Claramunt, C.,Klarqvist, B.(2000).Integration of space syntax into GIS for modelling urban spaces.International Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation,2(3-4),161-171.
13. Klarqvist, B.(1993).A space syntax glossary.Nordic Journal of Architectural Research,2,11-12.
14. Mottram, C.,Penn, A.(1999).Slugfest.Proceedings of Generative Art ‘99,Milan, Italy:
15. Mottram, C.,Penn, A.,Conroy, R.(1999).Virtual beings: Emergence of population levelmovement behaviours from individual rulesets.Proceedings of the Second International Space Syntax Symposium, I(1.10),Brasilia, BRA:
16. Penn, A.(2003).Space syntax and spatial cognition: or why the axial line?.Environment and Behavior,35(1),30-65.
17. Peponis, J.,Zimring, C.,Choi, Y. K.(1990).Finding the building in wayfinding.Environment and Behavior,22(5),555-590.
18. Turner, A.(2001).Depthmap: a program to perform visibility graph analysis.Proceedings of the 3rd International Symposium on Space Syntax,Georgia, USA:
19. Turner, A.(2004).Depthmap 4: A Researcher's Handbook.London, UK:Bartlett School of Graduate Studies, University College London.
20. Turner, A.,Penn, A.(1999).Making isovists syntactic: isovist integration analysis.Proceedings of the 2nd International Symposium on Space Syntax,Brasilia, BRA:
21. Wineman, J.,Peponis, J.,Dalton, R.(2006).Exploring, engaging, understanding in museums.Proceedings of the Workshop of Space Syntax and Spatial Cognition,Bremen, GER:
22. 中國國家文物局（2015）。關於國保省保集中成片傳統村落漳州寮村蔡氏古民居建築群保護工程立項的批復。引用於 2015 年 4 月 13 日，取自http://www.sach.gov.cn/art/2015/4/17/art_1324_119261.html。National cultural heritage administration (2015). The Approval of the Project for the Protection of Cai-Clan Traditional Residential Buildings in Zhangzhou Liao Village, A Cluster of Traditional Villages in National Conservation Province. Retrieved Apr 13, 2015 from http://www.sach.gov.cn/art/2015/4/17/art_1324_119261.html
23. 李乾朗, Q.(2000)。臺灣古民居排水法。建築創作，4，63-65。
24. 阮儀三, Y.,林林, L.(2003)。文化遺產保護的原真性原則。同濟大學學報（社會科學版），14(2)，1-5。
25. 郭璇, X.(2007)。中國歷史建成遺產真實性中的非物質維度——兼論整體性保護策略的可能性。新建築，6，74-79。
26. 傅游磊, Y.(2016)。閩南民居建築水循環特徵研究——以泉州蔡氏古民居為例。湖北第二師範學院學報，7，38-41。
27. 傅游磊, Y.(2017)。與閩南古民居建築相適應的現代生活設施設計探究——以泉州蔡氏古民居「德棣厝」為例。2017 設計創價感性實踐論文集，台北市=Taipei:
28. 費迎慶, Y.,秦樂, L.,郭銳, R.(2011)。蔡氏古民居的居住方式及其再利用研究。南方建築，1，44-49。
29. 黃瑞菘, J. S,曾思瑜, S. Y.(2009)。醫院門診空間型態與標示影響尋路路徑選擇之研究—以空間型構法則與實測分析南部一家醫學中心為例。建築學報，68，123-146。
30. 楊滔（譯）, T.,張倍（譯）, B.,王曉京（譯）, X.,Hillier, Bill(2008).空間是機器——建築組構理論.北京市=Beijing:中國建築工業出版社=China Architecture & Building Press.
31. 楊鴻勳, H.(2007)。關於歷史城市與歷史保護的基本觀點。建築知識，1，24-28。
32. 劉秉承, P. C.(2015)。台中市=Taichung, Taiwan，東海大學工業工程與經營資訊學系=Tunghai University。
33. 蘇智鋒, C. F.(1999)。空間形態之內在組構邏輯——Space Syntax（空間型構法則分析）之介紹。建築向度─設計與理論，創刊號=The First Issue，43-53。