上市建設公司ESG報告環境指標揭露程度分析

Disclosure Level Analysis of Environmental Indicators of ESG Reports of Listed Developers

10.53106/101632122023030123006

張行道(A. S. Chang)；陳宥任(Y. J. Chen)；蔡雅雯(C. Y. Tsai)

ESG報告書 ； 永續 ； 建設公司 ； 環境指標 ； 揭露程度 ； ESG Reports ； Sustainability ； Developer ； Environmental Indicators ； Disclosure Level

建築學報

123期（2023 / 03 / 31）

109 - 124

繁體中文;英文

近年來永續成為全球議題，企業陸續出版ESG（environment, social and governance）或永續報告書，展現永續績效與作為。然而文獻指出，永續報告書的揭露有待加強。本研究分析建設公司ESG報告書環境指標，檢視國內十家上市建設公司的2020永續報告書的揭露，與國外五家優秀建設公司的比較。研究結果顯示，於32個指標中，十家公司平均揭露9個、揭露率29%，揭露程度17%，約為國外五家公司揭露的一半；揭露邊界多在公司辦公室，較少工地資訊，而國外公司於公司及工地資訊都揭露。揭露率不高的原因有：政府以前未強制規定、揭露未有標準，及公司考量費用。ESG報告編製人員需詳讀GRI準則，了解環境指標要求的資料，定期蒐集與分析，以提高環境指標之揭露率。

Sustainability has become a global issue in recent years. More companies publish ESG (environment, social and governance) or sustainability reports to show their sustainable performances and actions. However, literature points out that the disclosure of the report needs improvement. This research analyzed the environmental disclosures of sustainability reports of ten domestic listed developers. The results were compared with the disclosures of excellent sustainability reports of five foreign developers. The research results showed that, among the 32 indicators, the ten companies disclosed nine indicators or 29% on average, and the average disclosure level was 17%. These numbers are about half of the disclosures of the foreign companies. The boundary of disclosure was more limited to the company's office buildings and the information of construction jobsites was less addressed. But the information of both office buildings and jobsites was disclosed by the foreign companies. The reasons for low disclosures can be non-mandatory publication of ESG reports, no standards for disclosures, and the company cost of ESG report preparation. The people who prepare ESG reports need to read the GRI requirements, know the required data, regularly collect and analyze them to raise the disclosure rates of environmental indicators.

1. 張行道, A. S.,陳怡伶, Y. L.,蔡雅雯, C. Y.(2021)。建設公司 CSR 報告書環境指標揭露程度與品質之研究。建築學報，118，69-88。
   連結：
2. Ali, W.,Frynas, J. G.,Mahmood, Z.(2017).Determinants of corporate social responsibility (CSR) disclosure in developed and developing countries: A literature review.Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management,24(4),273-294.
3. Bernaciak, A.,Halaburda, M.,Bernaciak, A.(2021).The construction industry as the subject of implementing corporate social responsibility (the case of Poland).Sustainability,13(17),23-40.
4. Beske, F.,Haustein, E.,Lorson, P.(2020).Materiality analysis in sustainability and integrated reports.Sustainability Accounting, Management and Policy Journal,11(1),162-186.
5. Caputo, F.,Pizzi, S.,Ligorio, L.,Leopizzi, R.(2021).Enhancing environmental information transparency through corporate social responsibility reporting regulation.Business Strategy and the Environment,30(8),3470-3484.
6. CDP (2022). https://www.cdp.net/en. 2022 年 5 月 13 日上網資料。
7. Chang, A. S.,Canelas, C.,Chen, Y. L.(2021).Relationships between environmental initiatives and impact reductions for construction companies.Sustainability,13(14)
8. Chang, A. S.,Li, Z. Y.,Chen, Y. L.(2017).Environmental performance disclosure in the CSR reports of construction companies.International Journal of Trade, Economics and Finance,8(3),158-164.
9. City Development Limited (2021). Integrated Sustainability Report. https://cdlsustainability.com/, accessed on September 15, 2021.
10. Covivio (2021). Sustainability Performance Report. https://www.covivio.immo/csr/. accessed on September 15, 2021.
11. Dexus (2021). Sustainability Report 2020. https://www.dexus.com/investor-centre/results-and-reporting/sustainability-reports, accessed on September 15, 2021.
12. Duman, D. U.,Giritli, H.,McDermott, P.(2016).Corporate social responsibility in construction industry: a comparative study between UK and Turkey.Built Environmental Project and Asset Management,6(2),218-231.
13. Evangelinos, K.,Skouloudis, A.,Jones, N.,Isaac, D.,Sfakianaki, E.(2016).Exploring the status of corporate social responsibility disclosure in the UK building and construction industry.International Journal of Global Environmental Issues,15(4),377-399.
14. Fonseka, M.,Tian, G.L.,Farooque, O. A.(2020).Impact of environmental information disclosure and real estate segments on cost of debt: Evidence from Chinese real estate industry.Economics of Transition and Industrial Change,28(1),195-221.
15. Gerged, A. M.,Beddewela, E.,Cowton, C. J.(2021).Is corporate environmental disclosure associated with firm value? A multicountry study of Gulf Cooperation Council firms.Business Strategy and the Environment,30(1),185-203.
16. Göçmen, Z. A.(2014).Exploring land developer perspectives on conservation subdivision design and environmentally sustainable land development.Environmental Management,54(5),1208-1222.
17. GRI (2020). Global Reporting Initiatives.https://www.globalreporting.org/. accessed on May 25, 2022。
18. Habek, P.,Wolniak, R.(2016).Assessing the quality of corporate social responsibility reports: the case of reporting practices in selected European Union member states.Quality and Quantity,50(1),390-420.
19. Hu, X.,Xia, B.,Skitmore, M.,Buys, L.,Hu, Y.(2017).What is a sustainable retirement village? Perceptions of Australian developers.Journal of Cleaner Production,164,179-186.
20. Huang, C. F.,Lu, W. H.,Lin, T. T.,Wu, E. J.(2017).The current conditions of CSR Implementation in construction industry: A lesson from Taiwan.Applied Ecology and Environmental Research,15(2),67-80.
21. International Energy Agency=IEA(2018).,未出版
22. Jiang, Y.,Xue, X.(2018).The overview and tendency of corporate environmental responsibility in the construction industry of China.MATEC Web of Conferences
23. KPMG(2020).The KPMG Survey of Sustainability Reporting 2020.Amsterdam:KPMG Global Sustainability Services.
24. Liao, P. C.,Tsenguun, G.,Liang, L. W.(2016).Development of social responsibility evaluation framework of construction projects: A multi-stakeholders perspective.Procedia Engineering,145,234-241.
25. Loosemore, M.,Lim, B. T. H.(2018).Mapping corporate social responsibility strategies in the construction and engineering industry.Construction Management and Economics,36(2),67-82.
26. Lubis, H.,Pratama, K.,Pratama, I.,Pratami, A.(2019).A systematic review of corporate social responsibility disclosure.International Journal of Innovation Creativity and Change,6(13),415-428.
27. Pratama, I.,Adam, N. C.,Kamardi, H.(2019).Corporate social responsibility disclosure (CSRD) quality in Indonesian public listed companies.Polish Journal of Management Studies,20(1),359-371.
28. Rashidfarokhi, A.,Toivonen, S.,Vitanen, K.(2018).Sustainability reporting in the Nordic real estate companies: empirical evidence from Finland.International Journal of Strategic Property Management,12(1),51-63.
29. Simon Property Group (2021).Sustainability Report 2020. https://investors.simon.com/sustainability. accessed on September 15, 2021.
30. Somachandra, V.(2016).Critical factors of corporate social responsibility in Sri Lankan construction industry.International Conference on Sustainable Built Environment,Sri Lanka, Kandy:
31. Sonae Sierra (2021). Economic, Environmental and Social Report 2020. https://www.sonaesierra.com/corporate/en-gb/sustainability/portfolio-benchmark-reporting.aspx, accessed on September 15, 2021.
32. Tsalis, T. A.,Nikolaou, I.E.,Konstantakopoulou, F.,Zhang, Y.,Evangelinos, K. I.(2020).Evaluating the corporate environmental profile by analyzing corporate social responsibility reports.Economic Analysis and Policy,66,63-75.
33. Ufere, K. J.,Alias, B.,Uche, A. G.,Onu, U. J.(2017).The level of environmental disclosure in listed property sector companies.International Journal of Real Estate Studies,11(2),85-91.
34. World Economic Forum=WEF(2021).The Global Risks Report 2021.Geneva Switzerland:
35. Wu, B.,Tian, F.,Zhang, M.,Zeng, H.,Zeng, Y.(2020).Cloud services with big data provide a solution for monitoring and tracking sustainable development goals.Geography and Sustainability,1(1),25-32.
36. Yam, S.(2013).The practice of corporate social responsibility by Malaysian developers.Property Management,31(1),76-91.
37. 天下雜誌 (2021)。兩千大企業調查排名資料庫。https://www.cw.com.tw/article/5114865，2021 年 6 月5 日上網資料。CommonWealth Magazine (2021). Two thousand largest enterprise survey ranking database. https://www.cw.com.tw/article/5114865, accessed on June 5, 2021.
38. 太子建設開發股份有限公司 (2021)。2020 企業社會責任報告書。https://www.prince.com.tw/csr.php，2021年 10 月 1 日上網資料。Prince Housing and Development Corporation (2021). 2020 Corporate Social Responsibility Report. https://www.prince.com.tw/csr.php, accessed on October 1, 2021.
39. 日勝生活科技股份有限公司 (2021)。2020 企業社會責任報告書。https://www.radium.com.tw/download，2021 年 10 月 1 日上網資料。Radium Life Tech. Co., Ltd (2021). 2020 Corporate Social Responsibility Report. https://www.radium.com.tw/download, accessed on October 1, 2021.
40. 台灣永續能源研究基金會 (2021)。2021 第 14 屆台灣企業永續獎成果專刊 。https://tcsaward.org.tw/uploads/files/2021/2021tcsa_publications/2021%20tcsa.pdf，2022 年 3 月 13 日上網資料。Taiwan Institute of Sustainable Energy (2021). 2021 14th Special issue of Taiwan Enterprise Sustainability Award. https://tcsaward.org.tw/uploads/files/2021/2021tcsa_publications/2021%20tcsa.pdf, accessed on March 13, 2022.
41. 行政院主計總處 (2021)。國內生產毛額(名目金額)之構成比 - 按行業分 。https://dmz26.moea.gov.tw/GA/common/Common.aspx?code=A&no=7，2021 年 6 月 1 日上網資料。The Directorate General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics (DGBAS) of Executive Yuan (2021). Composition ratio of gross domestic product (nominal value) by industry. https://dmz26.moea.gov.tw/GA/common/Common.aspx?code=A&no=7, accessed on June 1, 2021.
42. 金融監督管理委員會 (2020)。公司治理 3.0-永續發展藍圖 。 https://www.sfb.gov.tw/ch/home.jsp?id=992&parentpath=0,8,882,884，2021 年 10 月 5 日上網資料。Financial Supervisory Commission R.O.C. (2020). Corporate Governance 3.0- Sustainable Development Roadmap. https://www.sfb.gov.tw/ch/home.jsp?id=992& parentpath=0,8,882,884, accessed on October 5, 2021.
43. 冠德建設股份有限公司 (2021)。2020 企業社會責任報告書。https://csr.kindom.com.tw/csrreport/，2021 年10 月 1 日上網資料。Kindom Construction Corporation (2021). 2020 Corporate Social Responsibility Report. https://csr.kindom.com.tw/csrreport/, accessed on October 1, 2021.
44. 國泰建設股份有限公司 (2021)。2020 永續報告書。http://cathayred-csr.com/download.html，2021 年 10 月1 日上網資料。Cathay Real Estate Development Co., Ltd (2021). 2020 Sustainability Report. http://cathayred-csr.com/download.html, accessed on October 1, 2021.
45. 國揚實業股份有限公司 (2021)。2020 企業社會責任報告書。https://www.kycc.com.tw/tw/kuoyang_2.php，2021 年 10 月 1 日上網資料。Kuo Yang Construction (2021). 2020 Corporate Social Responsibility Report. https://www.kycc.com.tw/tw/kuoyang_2.php, accessed on October 1, 2021.
46. 鄉林建設事業股份有限公司 (2021)。2020 企業社會責任報告書。http://www.shininggroup.com/，2021 年 10月 1 日上網資料。Shining Building Business Co., Ltd (2021). 2020 Corporate Social Responsibility Report. http://www.shininggroup.com/, accessed on October 1, 2021.
47. 新美齊股份有限公司 (2021)。2020 企業社會責任報告書。https://www.jean.com.tw/tw/sustainable，2021 年10 月 1 日上網資料。Jean Co., Ltd (2021). 2020 Corporate Social Responsibility Report. https://www.jean.com.tw/tw/sustainable, accessed on October 1, 2021.
48. 臺灣證券交易所 (2021) 。 公司治理評鑑 。https://cgc.twse.com.tw/evaluationCorp/listCh ， 2022年 3 月 13 日上網資料。Taiwan Stock Exchange (2021). Corporate Governance Evaluation, https://cgc.twse.com.tw/evaluationCorp/listCh, accessed on March 13, 2022.
49. 遠雄建設事業股份有限公司 (2021)。2020 企業社會責任報告書。https://www.farglory-land.com.tw/csr/，2021 年 10 月 1 日上網資料。Farglory Land Development Co., Ltd (2021). 2020 Corporate Social Responsibility Report. https://www.farglory-land.com.tw/csr/, accessed on October 1, 2021.
50. 潤泰創新國際股份有限公司 (2021)。2020 企業社會責任報告書 。 https://www.rt-develop.com.tw/tw/CSR/report，2021 年 10 月 1 日上網資料。Ruentex Development Co., Ltd (2021). 2020 Corporate Social Responsibility Report. https://www.rt-develop.com.tw/tw/CSR/report, accessed on October 1, 2021.
51. 興富發建設股份有限公司 (2021)。2020 企業社會責任報告書 。https://www.highwealth.com.tw/responsibility.php ，2021 年 10 月 1 日上網資料。Highwealth Construction Co., Ltd (2021). 2020 Corporate Social Responsibility Report. https://www.highwealth.com.tw/responsibility.php, accessed on October 1, 2021.