北宋題人像畫詩析論

An Analytic Discussion of Portraiture Poetry in Northern Sung Colophons

10.6351/BICLP.199809.0121

衣若芬(Lo-Fen I)

北宋 ； 題畫詩 ； 人像畫 ； 自題像 ； 睢陽五老圖 ； Northern Sung ； portraiture poetry ； portraiture ； self-inscribed portraiture of oneself ； Picture of the Five Elders of Sui-yang

中國文哲研究集刊

13期（1998 / 09 / 01）

121 - 173

繁體中文

本文以北宋題人像畫詩為討論範圍，旨在分析北宋文人題寫人像畫之創作旨趣及其義涵，依畫作性質與書寫內容釐為三部分︰「自題像」、「題時人像－以睢陽五老圖為例」和「題古人像」。筆者發現︰北宋文人在題寫個人畫像時，未必著眼於畫家傳神摹擬的功力，而是「我看我，我亦非我」，兩我相映，感嘆吾身本為須臾，畫像亦非金石，興起對畫中自我如真似幻的迷惘。在題時人像部分，以當時題詠篇什最多的「睢陽五老圖」次韻詩組為例，考察出以杜衍為首的睢陽五老之會宴集的時間大約在一○四七至一○五○年之間，一○五一年已經有「睢陽五老圖」面世，與五老會相去不遠。題寫「睢陽五老圖」的作者群大多與五老或其後人有交情，五老致仕榮歸，福壽綿延，是作者所崇敬與歆羨之處，也是環繞「睢陽五老圖」的集體思維。至於題古人像，以詠文學家畫像最多，陶淵明、李白、杜甫是其最愛，畫家善於採取富於象徵意義的圖像元素營造文學氛圍，作者則妙筆生花，將文學氛圍再以文字示現，凝煉畫中人畢生的文學成就，表達對前輩文人的仰慕與追隨。

This essay aims to analyze the creative intentions and implied meanings of literary people in the Northern Sung as they wrote inscriptions on portraiture. On the basis of the nature of the painting and the content of the writings, the essay is divided into three parts: inscriptions for portraiture of oneself; inscriptions for portraiture of contemporaries (taking the case of the Five Elders of Sui-yang as an example); and inscriptions for portraits of men of antiquity. The author has discovered that when the literary men of the Northern Sung wrote inscriptions for portraits of themselves, they did not necessarily focus on whether painterly skills had succeeded in representing the subject accurately and thereby conveying his spirit, but rather dealt with it in terms of ”looking at myself, I am not really myself.” When two ”I's” reflect upon each other, the writer sighs about the transience of personal, bodily existence. Painting, too, is not made of stone or metal but is relatively transient. These sentiments inspire an imaginative network on the themes of the simultaneous semblance of portrayed individual existence to reality and to illusion. The part about inscriptions for contemporaries uses for its main example the ”Picture of the Five Elders of Sui-yang,” a group of verses which was used most often in the colophonic poetry of the time. It can be discovered through investigation that the time of the feast at which the Five Elders of Sui-yang, headed by Tu Yen, gathered was somewhere between 1047 and 1050. By 1051, there already was a ”Picture of the Five Elders of Sui-yang,” not long after this meeting took place. The authors of the colophon to this ”Picture of the Five Elders of Sui-yang” probably had personal acquaintance with these five elders or their descendants. The themes of continuing prosperity and longevity associated with the five elders resigning their official position and returning home in glory was what the authors respected and admired. This is the idea that surrounds the ”Picture of the Five Elders of Sui-yang.” As for writing inscriptions about men of antiquity, most colophons were written about portraits of literary people; with such favorities as T'ao Yuan-ming, Li Pai and Tu Fu, the painters were good at extracting graphic elements rich in symbolic meaning in order to create a literary atmosphere. The authors indulge in language full of flowery virtuoso, so that the literary atmosphere can be represented in written language, casting into fixed form the literary achievements of the entire life of the person portrayed, and expressing veneration and devotion to their literary predecessors.

1. (1991)。全宋文。
2. 北宋王安石(1983)。王荊公詩注。
3. 宋王闢之(1985)。澠水燕談錄。
4. 宋何薳(1990)。春渚紀聞。
5. 宋胡仔(1978)。笤溪漁隱叢話。
6. 宋范仲淹(1985)。范文正公文集。
7. 宋梅堯臣(1980)。梅堯臣集編年校注。
8. 宋郭若虛(1962)。圖畫見聞誌。
9. 宋陳思(1983)。兩宋名賢小集。
10. 宋歐陽修(1997)。居士集。
11. 宋歐陽修(1986)。歐陽修全集。
12. 宋蘇軾(1990)。蘇軾文集。
13. 宋蘇頌(1983)。蘇魏公文集。
14. 明趙琦美(1970)。鐵網珊瑚。
15. 東漢王充(1962)。論衡集解。
16. 唐王維(1962)。王右丞集箋注。
17. 唐白居易(1985)。白居易集。
18. 唐張彥遠(1962)。歷代名畫記。
19. 魏曹植(1973)。曹集詮評。
20. 二十五史刊行委員會(1974)。二十五史補編。
21. 王水照(1984)。論蘇軾創作的發展階段。社會科學戰線，1984(1)，259-269。
22. 北京大學古文獻研究所(1991)。全宋詩。
23. 石守謙(1996)。風格與世變。
24. 衣若芬(1990)。鄭板橋題畫文學研究。
25. 吳雨生、倪魏國(1988)。宋代繪畫研究。朵雲：中國繪畫研究季刊，1988(16)，51-67。
26. 李栖(1993)。題畫詩散論。
27. 李德身(1987)。王安石詩文繫年。
28. 李霖燦(1987)。中國美術史稿。
29. 李霖燦(1953)。論中國之肖像畫。大陸雜誌，6(10)，7-11。
30. 李霖燦(1973)。中國名畫研究。
31. 佘城(1989)。繁複之美─談宋代人物畫之欣賞。故宮文物月刊，6(12)，14-35。
32. 袁行霈(1997)。陶淵明研究。
33. 馬德富(1991)。國際宋代文化研討會論文集。
34. 張薔(1981)。宋人物畫管窺。美術史論，1981(1)，65-82。
35. 莊申(1956)。睢陽五老圖補述。大陸雜誌，13(3)，83-90。
36. 陳文華(1987)。杜甫傳記唐宋資料考辨。
37. 齊益壽(1968)。陶淵明的政治立場與政治理想。
38. 劉芳如(1996)。論兩宋人物畫的形質之變〈下〉。故宮文物月刊，14(2)，69-83。
39. 劉芳如(1996)。論兩宋人物畫的形質之變〈上〉。故宮文物月刊，14(12)，26-41。
40. 鍾優民(1991)。陶學史話。

1. 毛文芳(2006)。一則文化扮裝之謎：清初〈楓江漁父圖〉題詠研究。清華學報，36(2)，465-521。