教育型桌遊的設計循環模式之探究

The Loop Mode of Educational Board Game Design

10.6249/SE.2017.68.2.03

林展立(Chan-Li Lin)；賴婉文(Wan-Wen Lai)

教育型桌遊 ； 桌遊設計 ； 使用者中心設計 ； 情境故事法 ； educational board games ； board games design ； user-centered design ； scenario approach

中等教育

68卷2期（2017 / 06 / 01）

29 - 42

繁體中文

隨著桌上遊戲結合教學應用的興起，教師擁有自行開發桌上遊戲的能力，顯得十分重要且需求迫切。本研究以教學者為設計者及遊戲引導者的面向切入，以使用者中心設計（user-centered design）概念作為桌遊設計的方法論，並輔以情境故事法（Scenario）為設計引導，透過「桌遊設計x科普共玩工作坊」的舉行，實踐、檢視此設計流程的執行成效。據此觀察基礎下，進而提出「教育型桌遊設計循環模式」，將桌遊設計畫分為五個設計階段，分別為：任務分析、設計發想、機制創造、原型實作、遊戲測試，對應五目標任務為：觀察、角色設定、情境故事、視覺化、評估。期望作為未來教師進行遊戲設計時的方法參考與建議基礎，並藉此為國內教育型桌遊的發展帶入不同的觀點和經驗。

As the combination of board games and teaching applications emerges, it is both important and urgent for teachers to own the ability to develop board games by themselves. This study presented the entry point of treating teachers as designer or game guiders, adopting the notion of user-centered design as methodology and coupled with Scenario as the design guidance. Through the ＂Board Games Design x Science workshop＂, the effectiveness of this design process will be practiced and reviewed. Thus, according to this basis of observation, the ＂Loop Mode of Educational Board Games Design＂ is prompted to divide the board games design into 5 phases, which are: task analysis, creative design, mechanism creation, prototype implementation and game test. Correspondingly, the five goals of the tasks are: observation, role setting, scenario, visualization and evaluation. This paper is expected as the reference and advice for future teachers to work on game design, and to imbue various viewpoints and experience into the development of Taiwan educational board games.

1. 盧秀琴、施慧淳(2016)。玩「昆蟲大富翁」遊戲培養國小學童的科學過程技能。科學教育學刊，24(1)，1-30。
   連結：
2. 楊智傑 (2014)。原型製作如何應用於遊戲設計教學—課程架構版。取自http:/wwwslideshare.net/scatjay/stustgameprototypingcourse
3. 池曉 (2016)。用遊戲的四大規則重塑教育。取自http://mp.weixin.qq.com/s?_biz=MzA5MDM5NDEwNQ==&mic=400840603&idx=1&sn=64cab84ec3c939632e314f79a1c5a9aa&scene=21
4. 蔡明欣 (2016)。創意桌遊設計。取自http://www.pmai.tn.edu.tw/df_ufiles/b/20160921%E6%A1%8C%E9%81%8A%E5%A6%82%E4%BD%95%E8%A8%AD%E8%A8%88.pdf
5. Laurie, L. (2014). How to play test: Part 1"set the stage". Retrieved from http://www.leagueofgamemakers.com/how-to-playtest-part-1-set-the-stages/
6. Beest, M. V. (2010). What is the multimedia design process?. Retrieved from http://www.ehow.com/about_6307785_multimedia-design-process.html
7. Evensen, E. A., Chan, P. K., Sanders, E. B.-N., & Nini, P. J. (2009). Crafting a design concept prototype for an educational game design. Retrieved from http://www.erikevensen.com/uploads/7/0/3/4/7034222/erik_evensen_iasdr2009.pdf
8. 劉忠岳 (2015)。歐式桌上遊戲。取自http://www.slideshare.net/scandinavik/ss-55122021
9. Zimmerman, E. (2013). Lesson 1: The game design process, How I Teach Game Design. Retrieved from http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/Ericzimmerman/20131019/202710/How_I_Teach_Game_Design_Lesson_1_The_Game_Design_Process.php
10. Brown, T.(2009).Change by design: How design thinking transforms organizations and inspires innovation.New York:HarperBusines.
11. Campbell, R. L.(1992).Will the real scenario please stand up?.ACM SIGCHI Bulletin,24(2),6-8.
12. Creswell, J. W.(1998).Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five traditions.Thousands Oaks, CA:Sage.
13. Garris, R.,Ahlers, R.,Driskell, J.(2002).Games, motivation, and learning: A research and practice model.Simulation & Gaming,33(4),441-467.
14. Hainey, T.,Connolly, T. M.,Boyle, E. A.,Wilson, A.,Razak, A.(2016).A systematic literature review of games-based learning empirical evidence in primary education.Computers & Education,102,202-223.
15. Kobzeva, N.(2015).Scrabble as a tool for engineering students' critical thinking skills development.Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences,182,369-374.
16. McGonigal, J.(2011).Reality is broken: Why games make us better and how they can change the world.NY:Brilliance Audio.
17. Osterwalder, A.,Pigneur, Y.,Bernarda, G.,Smith, A.,Papadakos, T.(2015).Value proposition design: How to create products and services customers want.Journal of Business Models,3(1),81-92.
18. Paris, TNST,Yussof, R. L.(2012).Enhancing grammar using board game.Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences,68,213-221.
19. Pearrow, M.(2000).WebSite usability handbook.Rochkand, MA:Charles River Media Inc..
20. Rubin, J.,Chisnell, D.,Spool, J.(2008).Handbook of Usability Testing: How to plan, design, and conduct effective tests.NY:John Wiley & Sons, Inc..
21. Sears, A.(Ed.),Jack, J.A.(Ed.)(2009).Human-computer interaction: Development process.NY:CRC Press.
22. Shneiderman, B.(2002).Creativity support tools.Communications of the ACM,45
23. Tory, M.,Möller, T.(2004).Human factors in visualization research.IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics,10(1),72-84.
24. Verplank, B.,Fulton, J.,Black, A.,Moggridge, B.(1993).Observation and invention: Use of scenarios in interaction design.Tutorial at INTERCHI'93,Amsterdam:
25. Wilson, A.,Hainey, T.,Connolly, T. M.(2013).Using scratch with primary school Children: An evaluation of games constructed to gauge understanding of programming concepts.International Journal of Games-Based Learning,3(1),93-109.
26. 林榮泰(2006)。訴說故事•營造情境—文化創意設計的情境故事。藝術欣賞，2(5)，4-10。
27. 邱美虹(2014)。創刊詞。臺灣化學教育，1
28. 侯惠澤(2014)。愈玩愈愛學，達人教你挑「桌遊」。親子天下，60，208-211。
29. 侯惠澤、周逸璇、陳昊暐(2014)。科技部專題研究計畫成果報告科技部專題研究計畫成果報告,科技部。
30. 侯惠澤、劉力君(2015)。桌上遊戲輔助歷史教學：結合認知鷹架之桌遊「走過台灣」於中學歷史科教學之學習者心流、接受度與學習成效分析。Global Chinese Conference on Innovation & Applications in Inquiry Learning 2015
31. 洪榮昭(2005)。遊戲的教育意義。國民教育，45(3)，9-16。
32. 孫銘賢、林榮泰、楊世暐、蕭文信(2007)。文化產品設計的教學成果研究。96年數位典藏資訊融入教學研討會論文集，臺北市:
33. 溫明輝(2009)。博士論文(博士論文)。新竹，國立交通大學。
34. 盧姝如、朱慶雄、盧昉暄(2013)。數位化桌上遊戲創新學習模式之開發設計—以國小中年級生海洋教育為例。國民教育，53(4)，45-55。
35. 謝淑玲、黃國豪、李聖瑋、楊哲嘉、吳幸樺(2011)。應用精熟學習理論於電腦遊戲教學—以「資料庫理論與實務」課程為例。第七屆台灣數位學習發展研討會（TWELF 2011），臺北市:
36. 蘇照彬(1994)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。新竹，國立交通大學。

1. 簡梅瑩,曾泓硯(2021)。蛻變遊戲：以桌上遊戲提升大學生復原力與生活適應之研究。學校行政，133，101-120。
2. 賴光真、張民杰(2017)。大學班級經營課程運用桌上遊戲的設計與實施。大學教學實務與研究學刊，1(2)，95-124。
3. 施盈佑(2022)。「口語表達訓練」融入「經典文學與桌遊設計」微學分課程之研究。臺中教育大學學報：人文藝術類，36(2)，33-58。
4. (2024)。小學生感興趣的桌遊研究。運動與遊憩研究，19(2)，76-90。