弱勢關懷的新焦點：偏遠地區中小學校長社會正義領導之研究

New Focus on Care for Vulnerable Groups: A Research on Social Justice Leadership of Principals in Primary and Secondary Schools in Remote Areas

10.6249/SE.201809_69(3).0029

張文權(Wen-Chuan Chang)；張臺隆(Tai-Lung Chang)

偏遠地區 ； 校長領導 ； 社會正義 ； 社會正義領導 ； remote areas ； principal leadership ； social justice ； social justice leadership

中等教育

69卷3期（2018 / 09 / 01）

27 - 43

繁體中文

本研究旨在探究偏遠地區中小學校長社會正義領導的實行策略與運作歷程。採用質性訪談法，邀請專家學者和偏遠地區學校中小學教育人員為研究對象。研究結論包括：一、偏遠地區中小學校長社會正義領導的實行策略包括：自身具備批判理性的反省能力、關注弱勢學生學習的公平機會、營造包容尊重與社區共榮情境，可概分為個人、團體與組織面向，三者均有其關聯性；二、在偏遠地區中小學校長實踐社會正義領導的運作歷程中，顯現著重省思溝通、善用弱勢補助資源，以及連結社區與文化等情形。最後，根據結論提出理論與實務的建議。

This study aimed at exploring the implementation strategies and the course of operation by the principals in primary and secondary schools in remote areas behind their social justice leadership, wherein experts, scholars and faculty in primary and secondary schools in remote areas were invited in the qualitative interview as the subjects. The conclusions contain: 1. The implementation strategies for such social justice leadership of those principals in elementary and secondary schools consist of capabilities in critical thinking, rational self-reflection, concerning whether fair opportunity was demonstrated in those disadvantaged students behind learning and building up a scene covering tolerance, respect and co-prosperous inside a community, which are generally divided into three correlated dimensions, i.e. individual, group and organization; 2. During the period of carrying out their social justice leadership, the principals in primary and secondary schools significantly displayed the facts that they emphasized on the reflection and communication, making good use of resources and subsidies for vulnerable groups and linking communities with culture. Finally, both theoretical and practical suggestions were made in accordance with the conclusions hereof.

1. 范熾文(2007)。教育績效責任：市場模式及其啟示。中等教育，58(3)，26-41。
   連結：
2. 趙士瑩(2016)。偏遠國民中學校長學校經營困境之因應策略。學校行政，106，141-156。
   連結：
3. 蔡金田(2014)。國民小學校長領導實現社會正義的現況與策略探究─來自八位校長的經驗。新竹教育大學教育學報，31(1)，47-76。
   連結：
4. Allen, J. G.,Harper, R. E.,Koschoreck, J. W.(2017).Social justice and school leadership preparation: Can we shift beliefs, values, and commitments?.International Journal of Educational Leadership Preparation,12(1),34-54.
5. Boske, C.(Ed.),Diem, S.(Ed.)(2012).Global leadership for social justice: Taking it from the field to practice.England:Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
6. Brooks, J. S.(Ed.),Brooks, M. C.(Ed.)(2015).Urban educational leadership for social jutice: International perspectives.Charlotte, NC:Information Age.
7. Brown, K. M.(2004).Leadership for social justice and equity: Weaving a transformative framework and pedagogy.Educational Administration Quarterly,40(1),77-108.
8. Cirik, İ.(2015).Psychometric characteristics of the social justice scale's Turkish form and a structural equation modeling.Eurasian Journal of Educational Research,61,23-44.
9. DeMatthews, D.,Izquierdo, E.,Knight, D. S.(2017).Righting past wrongs: A superintendent's social justice leadership for dual language education along the U.S.-Mexico border.Education Policy Analysis Archives,25(1),1-32.
10. DeMatthews, D.,Mawhinney, H.(2014).Social justice leadership and lnclusion.Educational Administration Quarterly,50(5),844-881.
11. Fietzer, A. W.,Ponterotto, J.(2015).A psychometric review of Instruments for social justice and advocacy attitudes.Journal for Social Action in Counseling and Psychology,7(1),19-40.
12. Fraser, K.(2012).Department of Leadership Studies, Organizational and Leadership Program University of San Francisco.
13. Furman, G.(2012).Social justice leadership as praxis: Developing capacities through preparation programs.Educational Administration Quarterly,48(2),191-229.
14. Gause, C. P.(2008).From social justice to collaborative activism: Changing the landscape of academic leadership.Academic Leadership Journal,6(3),38-43.
15. Heslop, J.(1996).A model for the development of teachers in a remote area of Western Australia.Australian Journal of Teacher Education,21(1),1-15.
16. Jean-Marie, G.,Normore, A. H.,Brooks, J. S.(2009).Leadership for social justice: Preparing 21st century school leaders for a new social order.Journal of Research on Leadership Education,4(1),1-31.
17. Jones, L. C.,Webb, P. T.,Neumann, M.(2008).Claiming the contentious: Literacy teachers as leaders of social justice principles and practices.Issues in Teacher Education,17(1),7-15.
18. Krefting, L.(1991).Rigor in qualitative research: The assessment of trustworthiness.The American Journal of Occupational Therapy,45(3),214-222.
19. Larrabee, t. G.,Morehead, P.(2010).Broadening views of social justice and teacher leadership: Addressing LGB Issues in teacher education.Issues in Teacher Education,19(2),37-52.
20. Marshall, C.(ed.),Oliva, M.(ed.)(2011).Leadership for social justice democracy in our schools.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
21. Ozdemir, M.(2017).Examining the relations among social justice leadership, attitudes towards school and school engagement.Egitim Ve Bilim,42(191),267-281.
22. Taylor, S. J.,Bogdan, R.(1984).Introduction to qualitative research methods.New Yory, NY:John Wiley & Sons.
23. Theoharis, G.(2007).Social justice educational leaders and resistance: Toward a theory of social justice leadership.Educational Administration Quarterly,43(2),221-258.
24. Theoharis, G.(2008).Woven in eeply Identity and eadership of rban ocial justice principals.Education and Urban Society,41(1),3-25.
25. Zembylas, M.,Iasonos, S.(2017).Social justice leadership in multicultural schools: The case of an ethnically divided society.International Journal of leadership in Education,20(1),1-25.
26. 吳清山(2017)。未來教育發展。臺北:高等。
27. 范熾文(2008)。教育行政研究─批判取向。臺北:五南。
28. 范熾文、張文權(2016)。當代學校經營與管理新興議題：個人、團體與組織的連結。臺北:高等。
29. 張德銳編、丁一顧編(2016)。攜手走向專業：教學輔導教師的故事。臺北:教育部。
30. 許添明、陳俞琪(2011)。偏遠地區國中家長在學校、家庭與社區夥伴關係之研究。教育行政研究，1(2)，211-242。
31. 陳成宏(2013)。學校領導的「冪次法則」：理論的詮釋與實務的因應。教育行政研究，3(1)，171-195。
32. 陳奕筑(2017)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。臺北，國立臺北教育大學。
33. 黃乃熒(2009)。教育領導之社會正義實踐。教育研究，181，5-15。
34. 溫明麗編(2016)。教育機會均等。新北:國家教育研究院。
35. 劉鎮寧(2015)。國民小學校長領導行為、教師專業表現與學校組織文化之關聯性研究。屏東教育大學學報─教育類，42，67-102。
36. 蔡金田(2012)。從社會正義領導理論探究「攜手計劃─課後扶助」政策之實施。教育行政論壇，4(2)，35-66。
37. 簡良平(2009)。偏遠國小學校課程實踐脈絡分析：教育促成社會正義之觀點。初等教育學刊，34，1-24。

1. (2018)。校長社會正義領導的理論與實踐：以臺灣中部一所小學為例。臺灣教育社會學研究，18(2)，89-134。
2. (2019)。超越文化欣賞的社會正義課程：美國一所小學的非正式課程探究。臺灣教育社會學研究，19(2)，1-45。