技術型高中與五專工業群科一年級學生之轉出與升學意圖──脈絡化期望價值理論之向度比較觀點

The Intent of Outward Transfer, College Aspiration, and College Expectation of Students in Vocational Education: A Situated Expectancy-Value and Dimensional Comparison Perspective

10.6249/SE.202303_74(1).0004

詹勲育(Hsun-Yu Chan)；陳薏如(Yi-Ju Chen)

技職教育 ； 工業群科 ； 脈絡化期望價值理論 ； 向度比較理論 ； 升學意圖 ； vocational education ； applied engineering program ； situated expectancy-value theory ； dimensional comparison theory ； college aspiration

中等教育

74卷1期（2023 / 03 / 01）

57 - 79

繁體中文;英文

本研究調查技術型高中一年級與五年制專科工業群科一年級學生離開所選科別之意圖、升學志向、升學期望，並依據脈絡化期望價值理論之向度比較觀點，自其數學科、專業科目及實習科目之自我效能、學習興趣和情緒成本探討三種學業規劃意圖之成因。本研究以110學年度就讀技術型高中與五年制專科學校共9間不同學校工業群科之學生為母群體，於110學年度第一與第二學期分別針對171名學生進行縱貫式問卷調查。多元迴歸與機率單位迴歸結果顯示專業課程自我效能與情緒成本對離開所選科別之意圖具有負向關聯；實習課程自我效能信念與情緒成本以及對數學科的學習興趣，與學生的升學志向具有顯著正向關係。研究結果呼籲研究者與實務工作者未來可針對不同類型之課程培養學生的期望價值信念，並進一步了解工業群科學生的期望價值信念與其生涯抉擇之關聯性。

We investigated the intent of outward transfer, college aspiration, and college expectation of first-year students in applied engineering programs in vocational high schools and five-year junior college programs. Adopting a situated expectancy-value and dimensional comparison perspective, we hypothesized that the aforementioned academic and career decisions are related to students' self-efficacy beliefs, learning interest, and emotional cost of math, vocational subjects, and practicums. A total of 171 first-year students enrolled in nine different applied engineering programs and institutions filled out a survey questionnaire in fall 2021 and again in spring 2022. Results from multiple and probit regression indicated that students' self-efficacy beliefs and emotional cost of vocational subjects are negatively related to the intent of outward transfer. In contrast, students' self-efficacy beliefs and emotional cost of practicums, as well as the interest in learning math, are positively related to their college aspiration. The findings call for a concerted effort of instructors and researchers to cultivate students' self-efficacy beliefs and to further understand the relationship between expectancy-beliefs and career choices.

1. 毛菁華,周富美,許鶯珠(2008)。技職院校女大學生生涯發展歷程模式之研究。諮商輔導學報，19，105-139。
   連結：
2. 張國保,李寶琳(2014)。我國技職人才培育的問題與前瞻。教育資料與研究，112，53-76。
   連結：
3. 楊淑涵,田秀蘭,吳欣倫,朱惠瓊(2015)。職場工作者生涯自我效能、生涯調適力與工作適應之因素模式驗證。輔導與諮商學報，37(1)，21-42。
   連結：
4. Baraldi, A. N.,Enders, C. K.(2010).An introduction to modern missing data analyses.Journal of School Psychology,48(1),5-37.
5. Bong, M.(1997).Generality of academic self-efficacy judgments: Evidence of hierarchical relations.Journal of Educational Psychology,89(4),696-709.
6. Bong, M.(2001).Between- and within-domain relations of academic motivation among middle and high school students: Self-efficacy, task-value, and achievement goals.Journal of Educational Psychology,93(1),23-34.
7. Boxer, P.,Goldstein, S. E.,DeLorenzo, T.,Savoy, S.,Mercado, I.(2011).Educational aspiration-expectation discrepancies: Relation to socioeconomic and academic risk‐related factors.Journal of Adolescence,34(4),609-617.
8. Brown, S. D.,Lent, R. W.(2019).Social cognitive career theory at 25: Progress in studying the domain satisfaction and career self-management models.Journal of Career Assessment,27(4),563-578.
9. Carnevale, A. P.,Smith, N.,Strohl, J.(2013).Recovery: Projections of jobs and education requirements through 2020.Center on Education and the Workforce, Georgetown University.
10. Chan, H.-Y.,Wang, X.(2018).Momentum through course-completion patterns among 2-year college students beginning in STEM: Variations and contributing factors.Research in Higher Education,59(6),704-743.
11. Chow, C. M.,Tan, C. C.,Buhrmester, D.(2015).Interdependence of depressive symptoms, school involvement, and academic performance between adolescent friends: A dyadic analysis.British Journal of Educational Psychology,85(3),316-331.
12. Conley, A. M.(2012).Patterns of motivation beliefs: Combining achievement goal and expectancy-value perspectives.Journal of Educational Psychology,104(1),32-47.
13. Gaertner, M. N.,Kim, J.,DesJardins, S. L.,McClarty, K. L.(2013).Preparing students for college and careers: The causal role of Algebra II.Research in Higher Education,55(2),143-165.
14. Gaspard, H.,Wigfield, A.,Jiang, Y.,Nagengast, B.,Trautwein, U.,Marsh, H. W.(2018).Dimensional comparisons: How academic track students’ achievements are related to their expectancy and value beliefs across multiple domains.Contemporary Educational Psychology,52,1-14.
15. Gaspard, H.,Wille, E.,Wormington, S. V.,Hulleman, C. S.(2019).How are upper secondary school students’ expectancy-value profiles associated with achievement and university STEM major? A cross-domain comparison.Contemporary Educational Psychology,58,149-162.
16. Graham, J. W.(2009).Missing data analysis: Making it work in the real world.Annual Review of Psychology,60(1),549-576.
17. Groenwold, R. H. H.,White, I. R.,Donders, A. R. T.,Carpenter, J. R.,Altman, D. G.,Moons, K. G. M.(2012).Missing covariate data in clinical research: When and when not to use the missing-indicator method for analysis.Canadian Medical Association Journal,184(11),1265-1269.
18. Hellenga, K.,Aber, M. S.,Rhodes, J. E.(2002).African American adolescent mothers’ vocational aspiration-expectation gap: Individual, social and environmental influences.Psychology of Women Quarterly,26(3),200-212.
19. Horton, N. J.,Lipsitz, S. R.(2001).Multiple imputation in practice.The American Statistician,55(3),244-254.
20. Hsieh, H.(1987).Ability stratification in urban Taiwanese secondary schools.Bulletin of the Institute of Ethnology,64,205-252.
21. Jansen, M.,Becker, M.,Neumann, M.(2021).Dimensional comparison effects on (gendered) educational choices.Journal of Educational Psychology,113(2),330-350.
22. Jansen, M.,Schroeders, U.,Lüdtke, O.,Marsh, H. W.(2015).Contrast and assimilation effects of dimensional comparisons in five subjects: An extension of the I/E model.Journal of Educational Psychology,107(4),1086-1101.
23. Jiang, Y.,Rosenzweig, E. Q.(2021).Using cost to improve predictions of adolescent students’ future choice intentions, avoidance intentions, and course grades in mathematics and English.Learning and Individual Differences,86,101978.
24. Kim, J.,Kim, J.,DesJardins, S. L.,McCall, B. P.(2015).Completing Algebra II in high school: Does it increase college access and success?.Journal of Higher Education,86(4),628-662.
25. Lazarides, R.,Dicke, A.-L.,Rubach, C.,Oppermann, E.,Eccles, J. S.(2021).Motivational profiles across domains and academic choices within Eccles et al.’s situated expectancy-value theoretical framework.Developmental Psychology,57(11),1893-1909.
26. Lent, R. W.,Hackett, G.(1987).Career self-efficacy: Empirical status and future directions.Journal of Vocational Behavior,30,347-382.
27. Little, R. J. A.(1988).A test of missing completely at random for multivariate data with missing values.Journal of the American Statistical Association,83(404),1198-1202.
28. Möller, J.,Köller, O.(2001).Dimensional comparisons: An experimental approach to the internal/external frame of reference model.Journal of Educational Psychology,93(4),826-835.
29. Möller, J.,Marsh, H. W.(2013).Dimensional comparison theory.Psychological Review,120(3),544-560.
30. Peng, C.-Y. J.,So, T.-S. H.,Stage, F. K.,John, E. P. S.(2002).The use and interpretation of logistic regression in higher education journals: 1988-1999.Research in Higher Education,43(3),259-293.
31. Rosenzweig, E. Q.,Wigfield, A.(2016).STEM motivation interventions for adolescents: A promising start, but further to go.Educational Psychologist,51(2),146-163.
32. Rosenzweig, E. Q.,Wigfield, A.,Eccles, J. S.(2019).Expectancy-value theory and its relevance for student motivation and learning.The Cambridge handbook of motivation and learning
33. Rosenzweig, E. Q.,Wigfield, A.,Hulleman, C. S.(2020).More useful or not so bad? Examining the effects of utility value and cost reduction interventions in college physics.Journal of Educational Psychology,112(1),166-182.
34. Sax, L. J.,Blaney, J. M.,Lehman, K. J.,Rodriguez, S. L.,George, K. L.,Zavala, C.(2018).Sense of belonging in computing: The role of introductory courses for women and underrepresented minority students.Social Sciences,7(122)
35. Vriesema, C. C.,Gehlbach, H.(2021).Assessing survey satisficing: The impact of unmotivated questionnaire responding on data quality.Educational Researcher,50(9),618-627.
36. Wang, M.-T.,Willett, J. B.,Eccles, J. S.(2011).The assessment of school engagement: Examining dimensionality and measurement invariance by gender and race/ethnicity.Journal of School Psychology,49(4),465-480.
37. Wang, X.,Lee, S. Y.(2019).Investigating the psychometric properties of a new survey instrument measuring factors related to upward transfer in STEM fields.The Review of Higher Education,42(2),339-384.
38. Wang, X.,Lee, Y.,Zhu, X.,Ozdemir, A. O.(2022).Exploring the relationship between community college students’ exposure to math contextualization and educational outcomes.Research in Higher Education,63,309-336.
39. Wang, X.,Sun, N.,Wickersham, K.(2017).Turning math remediation into "homeroom" Contextualization as a motivational environment for community college students in remedial math.The Review of Higher Education,40(3),427-464.
40. Wigfield, A.,Eccles, J. S.(2000).Expectancy-value theory of achievement motivation.Contemporary Educational Psychology,25(1),68-81.
41. 李隆盛,李懿芳,張維容(2020)。技職教育課題與政策之重要性評估。臺灣教育研究期刊，2，13-28。
42. 教育部（2021）。十二年國民基本教育課程綱要（修正版）。教育部。
43. 教育部（2022）。教育統計進階查詢。檢索自 https://eds.moe.gov.tw/edust/webmain.aspx?sys=210&funid=edufld&clear=1
44. 饒達欽,聶華明,賴慕回,陳培基(2021)。面向工業 4.0 的技職教育課程發展之道。臺灣教育研究期刊，2(3)，59-86。