「疫」起向前走－後疫情時代的校長意義、正向與韌性領導新思維

Moving Forward from the Pandemic: New Perspectives on the School Principals' Meaningful Leadership, Positive Leadership, and Resilience Leadership in the Post-Pandemic Era

10.6249/SE.202306_74(2).0012

謝傳崇(Chuan-Chung Hsieh)

後疫情時代 ； 校長領導 ； 正向領導 ； 意義領導 ； 韌性領導 ； post-pandemic era ； school principal leadership ； positive leadership ； meaningful leadership ； resilience leadership

中等教育

74卷2期（2023 / 06 / 01）

29 - 45

繁體中文;英文

新冠疫情為教學場域帶來巨大的挑戰，一再考驗學校校長的領導能力。緊急遠距線上教學模式不僅擴大原有的數位鴻溝，更加劇師生身體、心理、社交和情感方面的壓力，損害學校的整體效能。本文探討後疫情期間校長領導所面臨的困境和挑戰，COVID-19疫情期間，線上教學造成教師心理壓力增加、焦慮與倦怠感提升。後疫情時代需要新型態領導思維，能整合學校意義導向、成員正向關係和韌性思維的領導策略。最後分析歸納現時國內外相關的實徵研究，並進一步以意義領導強化教師教學意義、正向領導帶給學校希望與價值以及以韌性領導克服困境與挑戰，以期了解後疫情時代可行的應對領導策略，提供學校領導與決策者相關實務建議作為參考。

The COVID-19 pandemic has brought tremendous challenges to the field of education and repeatedly testing the leadership abilities of school principals. The abrupt shift to distance learning has not only widened the existing digital divide but also intensified the physical, psychological, social, and emotional pressures on teachers and students, impairing the overall effectiveness of schools. This article explores the dilemmas and challenges that school principals face in leadership during the post-pandemic period. During the COVID-19 pandemic, online teaching has increased teachers' psychological pressure, anxiety, and fatigue. The post-pandemic era requires new forms of leadership that integrate meaningful school's goals, positive member relationships, and resilience thinking. Finally, this article analyzes and summarizes current domestic and foreign empirical research, further strengthening the meaning of teachers' teaching through effective leadership, bringing hope and value to schools through positive leadership, and overcoming challenges and difficulties through resilience leadership, in order to understand feasible leadership strategies in the post-pandemic era and provide practical suggestions for school leaders and decision-makers.

1. 范熾文(2022)。VUCA 時代─面對防疫期間校長領導的焦點。學校行政，139，36-54。
   連結：
2. 謝傳崇,蕭文智,王玉美(2015)。國民小學教師正向領導與學生學習表現關係之研究。學校行政，95，81-101。
   連結：
3. Badger, J. K.(2019).Perspective: Increasing officer resilience through servant leadership.FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin,1-7.
4. Bennett, N. J.,Lemoine, G. J.(2014).What a difference a word makes: Understanding threats to performance in a VUCA world.Business Horizons,57(3),311-317.
5. Chatzipanagiotou, P.,Katsarou, E.(2023).Crisis management, school leadership in disruptive times and the recovery of schools in the post COVID-19 era: A systematic literature review.Education Sciences,13(2),118.
6. Cherkowski, S.,Kutsyuruba, B.,Walker, K.(2020).Positive leadership: Animating purpose, presence, passion and play for flourishing in schools.Journal of Educational Administration,58(4),401-415.
7. Cleavenger, D.,Munyon, T. P.(2013).It’s how you frame it: Transformational leadership and the meaning of work.Business Horizons,56(3),351-360.
8. Conner, D. R.(1993).Managing at the speed of change: How resilient managers succeed and prosper where others fail.Villard Books.
9. Duman, L.(2017).Leadership and Change Program of Antioch University.
10. Flach, F.(1988).Resilience: Discovering a new strength at times of stress.Columbine.
11. Frémeaux, S.,Pavageau, B.(2022).Meaningful leadership: How can leaders contribute to meaningful work?.Journal of Management Inquiry,31,54-66.
12. Grayson, J. W.,Alvarez, H. K.(2008).School climate factors relating to teacher burnout: A mediator model.Teaching and Teacher Education,24(5),1349-1363.
13. Harris, A.,Jones, M.(2020).COVID 19 - school leadership in disruptive times.School Leadership & Management,40(4),243-247.
14. Hatler, C.,Sturgeon, P.(2013).Resilience building: A necessary leadership competence.Nurse Leader,11(4),32.
15. Henderson, N.,Milstein, M. M.(1996).Management of organizational behavior: Utilizing human resources.Corwin Press.
16. Herrman, H.,Stewart, D. E.,Diaz-Granados, N.,Berger, E. L.,Jackson, B. E.,Yuen, T. J.(2011).What is resilience?.The Canadian Journal of Psychiatry,56(5),258-265.
17. Higgins, G. O.(1994).Resilient adults: Overcoming a cruel past.Jossey-Bass.
18. Hsieh, C.,Li, H.,Liang, J.,Sun, X.(2022).Do teachers perceive "a shared sense of us"? - social identity leadership of kindergarten principals in Mainland China.International Journal of Chinese Education,11(3),2212585X2211409.
19. Hsieh, C.C.,Ho, S. S. H.,Li, H. C.,Liang, J. K.(2021).Mindfulness as moderator against emotional exhaustion due to online teaching during COVID-19 pandemic: An investigation using Job Demands-Resources model and Conservation of Resource Theory.Frontiers in Psychology,12,781804.
20. Janet, L.(2014).Conceptual frameworks and research models on resilience in leadership.SAGE Open.
21. Karakose, T.,Yirci, R.,Papadakis, S.(2022).Examining the associations between COVID-19-related psychological distress, social media addiction, COVID-19-related burnout, and depression among school principals and teachers through structural equation modeling.International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,19(4),1951.
22. Kaufman, J. H.,Diliberti, M. K.,Hamilton, L. S.(2022).How principals’ perceived resource needs and job demands are related to their dissatisfaction and intention to leave their schools during the COVID-19 pandemic.AERA Open,8,233285842210812.
23. Kohlrieser, G.(2014).Resilient leadership: Navigating the pressures of modern working life.Insights@IMD,42,1-4.
24. Kouhsari, M.,Navehebrahim, A.,Zeinabadi, H.,Abbasian, H.(2022).Exploring positive school leadership practices in Iranian primary schools.International Journal of Leadership in Education,1-21.
25. Ku, Y. -R.,Stager, C.(2022).Rethinking the multidimensionality of growth mindset amid the COVID-19 pandemic: A systematic review and framework proposal.Frontiers in Psychology,13,572220.
26. Lombardi, S.,Cunha, M. P. E.,Giustiniano, L.(2021).Improvising resilience: the unfolding of resilient leadership in COVID-19 times.International Journal of Hospitality Management,95,102904.
27. Manuti, A.,Giancaspro, M. L.,Gemmano, C. G.,Morrelli, F.(2022).Coping with the unexpected: A job demands/resources study exploring Italian teachers’ remote working experience during the COVID ‐ 19 lockdown.Teaching and Teacher Education: Leadership and Professional Development,1,100010.
28. Morrison, G.,Allen, M.(2007).Promoting student resilience in school contexts.Theory. Into Practice,46,162-169.
29. Mullen, C. A.,Badger, S. C.(2023).Leadership support in a pandemic: Middle school teacher perceptions of emergency remote teaching.RMLE Online,46(4),1-15.
30. O’Leary, V. E.,Ickovics, J. R.(1995).Resilience and thriving in response to challenge: An opportunity for a paradigm shift in women’s health.Women’s Health: Research on Gender, Behavior, and Policy,1(2),121-142.
31. Panthalookaran, V.(2022).Education in a VUCA-driven world: Salient features of an entrepreneurial pedagogy.Higher Education for the Future,9(2),234-249.
32. Patterson, J. L.,Patterson, J.,Collins, L.(2002).Bouncing back: How your school can succeed in the face of adversity.Eye on Education.
33. Pokhrel, S.,Chhetri, R.(2021).A literature review on impact of COVID-19 pandemic on teaching and learning.Higher Education for the Future,8(1),133-141.
34. Raghunathan, S.,Singh, A. D.,Sharma, B. N.(2022).Study of resilience in learning environments during the Covid-19 pandemic.Frontiers in Education,6,677625.
35. Reed, D. E.,Blaine, B.(2015).Resilient women educational leaders in turbulent times: Applying the leader resilience profile® to assess women's leadership strengths.Planning and Changing,46(3-4),459-468.
36. Reyes-Guerra, D.,Maslin-Ostrowski, P.,Barakat, M.,Stefanovic, M. A.(2021).Confronting a compound crisis: The school principal’s role during initial phase of the COVID-19 pandemic.Frontiers in Education,6,617875.
37. Sarwar, U. N.,Tariq, R.,Yong, Q.(2022).Principals’ leadership styles and its impact on teachers’ performance at college level.Frontiers in Psychology,13,919693.
38. Singh, K.,Billingsley, B. S.(1998).Professional support and its effects on teachers’ commitment.Journal of Educational Research,91(4),229-239.
39. Steiner, E. D.,Woo, A.(2021).,RAND Corporation.
40. Steward, J.(2014).Sustaining emotional resilience for school leadership.School Leadership & Management,34(1),52-68.
41. Suárez, M. I.,Wright, K.(2019).Investigating school climate and school leadership factors that impact secondary STEM teacher retention.Journal for STEM Education Research,2(1),55-74.
42. Tan, C. L.,Gao, L.,Shi, M.(2020).Second-order meta-analysis synthesizing the evidence on associations between school leadership and different school outcomes.Educational Management Administration & Leadership,50(3),469-490.
43. Taun, K.,Sánchez, M. L. Z.,Cuberos, R. C.(2022).Management skills and styles of school principals during the COVID-19 pandemic.Education Sciences,12(11),794.
44. Thornton, K.(2021).Leading through COVID-19: New Zealand secondary principals describe their reality.Educational Management Administration & Leadership,49(3),393-409.
45. Truebridge, S.(2014).Resilience begins with beliefs: Building on student strengths for success in school.Teachers College Press.
46. Urdan, T.,Schoenfelder, E.(2006).Classroom effects on student motivation: Goal structures, social relationships, and competence beliefs.Journal of School Psychology,44(5),331-349.
47. Urick, A.,Carpenter, B. W.,Eckert, J.(2021).Confronting COVID: Crisis leadership, turbulence, and self-care.Frontiers in Education,6,642861.
48. Van Knippenberg, D.(2020).Meaning-based leadership.Organizational Psychology Review,10(1),6-28.
49. Weeks, K.,Schaffert, C.(2019).Generational differences in definitions of meaningful work: A mixed methods study.Journal of Business Ethics,156(4),1045-1061.
50. Werner, E. E.,Smith, R. S.(2001).Journeys from childhood to midlife: Risk resilience and recovery.Cornell University Press.
51. 林和春(2023)。新世代校長創新領導三部曲。臺灣教育，739，19-27。
52. 林香吟,江姮姬,林明地(2022)。中小學校長運用系統思考處理社會情緒學習議題之分析：校長課啟領導實踐舉隅。臺灣教育，737，38-50。
53. 陳信豪,沈俞君(2022)。國小校長正向領導之探討。臺灣教育評論月刊，11(8)，132-136。
54. 廖純英(2022)。後疫情時代數位轉型在跨領域教學領導的實踐與反思。臺灣教育評論月刊，11(4)，105-111。
55. 謝傳崇(2012).校長正向領導：理念、研究與實踐.高等教育.
56. 謝傳崇(2021).變革時代的校長領導：理論與實踐.高等教育.
57. 謝傳崇(2020)。臺灣正向領導的研究成果分析。教育研究月刊，317，19-34。
58. 謝傳崇(2023)。讓教學有意義：校長意義領導的意涵與發展。教育研究月刊，348，49-60。

1. (2024)。國民小學校長韌性領導實踐之個案研究。學校行政，152，238-268。
2. (2024)。因應少子化衝擊：一所國民小學發揮組織韌性之個案研究。學校行政，153，55-85。