從都市企業化主義的觀點探討在全球化過程中的城鄉均衡發展課題

Balancing Urban-Rural Development in The Process of Globalizaion-From The Viewpoint of Urban Entrepreneurialism

廖石(Su Liao)

都市企業化主義 ； 城際合作 ； 城際競爭 ； 都市行銷 ； 都市政權 ； Urban entrepreneurialism ； Inter-city cooperation ； Inter-city competition ； City marketing ； Urban regime.

都市與計劃

28卷2期（2001 / 08 / 01）

155 - 170

繁體中文

在現代資本流動全球化及去工業化的時期,都市已逐漸取代國家,成為全球市場競爭的主體,加上新自由主義興起,強調減少管制,著重市場機能,在此一趨勢下,「都市企業化主義」興起,成為地方在「城際競爭」壓力下追求發展的典範，但是公、私部門的本質及目的不同,鄉村地區相對於都市又處於弱勢地位,除非有城鄉計畫體系的配合,一昧追求發展而強調「企業化」，反而可能導致資源的濫用與鄉村經濟的惡化,因此,未來的城鄉規劃必須以「城際合作」為基礎,強調區域整合、城鄉聯結、區域財政收支自主、順應市場機制及人才吸引,才可能增進 計畫的效能,維持城鄉的均衡發展。

In the wake of de-industrialization and globalization, cities are emerging as the major players in the world market. The rising neo-liberalism that emphasizes on de-regulation, privatization, and free market mechanism, has caused ever more intensive inter-city competition. To struggle for growth in this place war, most places have adopted more pro-active growth strategy-from traditional managerialism to new entrepreneurialism. However, considering the different features and purposes between the public sector and the private sector, and the difficulties of rural areas to compete with urban areas in the economic arena, applying urban entrepreneurialism in rural areas without appropriate planning system may worsen the economic condition in rural areas and cause more spatial disparity problems. This paper therefore suggests that the future city and country planning should be based on inter-city cooperation. Also, it should focus more on regional integration, urban-rural solidarity, and regional financial planning so as to balance urban-rural development.

1. Bassett, K.(1996).Partnerships, business elites and urban politics: new forms of governance in an English city?.Urban Studies,33(3)
2. Cumings, B.(1987).The Political Economy of the New Asian Industrialism.Ithaca:Cornell University Press.
3. Dunford, M., Kafkalas, G.(1992).Cities and Regions in the New Europe: the Global-Local Interplay and Spatial Development Strategies.London:Belhaven Press.
4. Esser, J., Hirsch(1994).Post-Fordism: A Reader.Oxford:Blackwell.
5. Friedmann, J.、 杜歆穎 Duh, Charlotte S. Y.(1997)。世界城市之未來：都市與區域政策在亞太區域的角色 World City Futures: The Role of Urban and Regional Policies in the Asia Pacific Region。城市與設計學報 Cities and Design，2006/2/3
6. Giarratani, F., Houston, D. B.(1989).Structural change and economic policy in a declining metropolitan region: implications of the Pittsburgh experience.Urban Studies,26(6)
7. Harvey, D.(1989).From managerialism to entrepreneurialism: the transformation in urban governance in late capitalism.Geografiska Annaler, B,71(1)
8. Hatsopoulos, G. N., Krugman, P. R., Summers, L. H.(1988).U. S. competitiveness: beyond the trade deficit.Science,241
9. Hirschman, A. O.(1970).Exit, Voice, and Loyalty: Responses to Decline in Firms, Organizations, and States.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
10. Hsu, H. H.(1994).Changing Trade Environment after GATT: A Case Study of Taiwan.Taipei:The Council of Agriculture, Executive Yuan.
11. Johnson, Chalmers(1987).The Political Economy of the New Asian Industrialism.Ithaca, NY:Cornell University Press.
12. Kantor, P., Savitch, H. V., Haddock, S. V.(1997).The political economy of urban regimes: a comparative perspective.Urban Affairs Review,32(3)
13. Komminos, N.(1992).Cities and Regions in the New Europe: the Global-Local Interplay and Spatial Development Strategies.London:Belhaven Press.
14. Kotler, P., Haider, D., Rein, I.(1994).There's no place like our place.Public Management,76(2)
15. Landes, D. S.(1998).The Wealth and Poverty of Nations - Why Some Are so Rich and Some So Poor.New York:W. W. Norton ＆ Company.
16. Marsden, T.(1998).New rural territories: regulating the differentiated rural spaces.Journal of Rural Studies,14(1)
17. Michell, C. J. A.(1998).Entrepeneurialism, commodification and creative destruction: a model of post-modern community development.Journal of Rural Studies,14(3)
18. Motte, M. T., Weil, L. A.(2000).Of railroads and regime shifts-downtown renewal in Providence, Rhode Island.Cities,17(1)
19. Munton, R.(1995).Regulating rural change: property rights, economy and environment - a case study from Cumbria, U. K..Journal of Rural Studies,11(3)
20. Osborne, D., Gaebler, T.(1992).Reinventing Government: How the Entrepreneurial Spirit is Transforming the Public Sector.Reading, MA:Addison-Wesley Publishing Company.
21. Paddison, R.(1993).City marketing, image reconstruction and urban regeneration.Urban Studies,30(2)
22. Razin, E.(1998).Policies to control urban sprawl: planning regulations or changes in the 'rules of the game'?.Urban Studies,35(2)
23. Rondinelli, D. A.(1983).Secondary Cities in Developing Countries - Policies for Diffusing Urbanization.Beverly Hills:Sage Publication, Inc..
24. Rubin, S. I., Rubin, H. J.(1987).Economic development incentives - the poor (cities) pay more.Urban Affairs Quarterly,23(1)
25. Scitovsky, T.(1985).Economic development in Taiwan and South Korea: 1965-1981.Food Research Institute Studies,19(3)
26. Skocpol, T.(1985).Bringing the State Back in.London:Cambridge University Press.
27. Stoker, G., Mossberger, K.(1994).Urban regime theory in comparative perspective.Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy,12
28. Terry, L. D.(1990).Leadership in the administrative state: the concept of administrative conservatorship.Administration ＆ Society,21(4)
29. Tiebout, C. M.(1956).A pure Theory of Local Expenditures.Journal of Political Economy,64(5)
30. Wade, R.(1990).Governing the Market: Economic Theory and the Role of Government in East Asian Industrialization.Princeton, New Jersey:Princeton University Press.
31. 江岷欽 Chiang, Min-Chin(1997)。公共管理的新思維－行政革新與企業型政府。公訓報導 Taipei Public Service Quarterly，72
32. 李恒瑞 、 廖石 Liao, Su、 洪志強(1998)。還原支離的地區文化經濟合作系統以進行都市再開發－以北投溫泉觀光遊憩區為例。第一屆青年環境共生論壇論文發表研討會論文集，台北市:
33. 林文玲 Lin, Wen-Ling(1996)。縣市特色競爭－1996年民情報告。遠見雜誌 Global Views Monthly，126
34. 洪綾君(1997)。國立中山大學公共事務管理研究所。
35. 夏鑄九 Hsia, Chu-Joe、 王志宏 、 殷寶寧 、 溫蓓章 、 黃麗玲 、 魏慶嘉(1998)。網絡社會之崛起 The Rise of Network Society。台北:唐山出版社。
36. 陳佩君(1999)。國立政治大學公共行政學系。
37. 廖石 Liao, Su(2001)。從農業在鄉村經濟體系中的角色變遷探討台灣鄉村地區「三生環境」的建構 Planning a Sustainable Rural Environment through Rural Industrial Restructuring。臺灣土地金融季刊 Journal of the Land Bank of Taiwan，38(2)
38. 廖石 Liao, Su(1999)。從城鄉互動觀點探討台灣農村產業發展的課題 A Study of Rural Industrial Development from the Viewpoint of Urban-Rural Interaction in Taiwan。臺灣土地金融季刊 Journal of the Land Bank of Taiwan，36(4)
39. 劉坤億 Liu, Kun-I(1996)。國立中山大學公共事務管理研究所。
40. 劉健哲 Liu, Chien-Zer(1997)。農漁村規劃建設之內涵及其問題與對策之探討。臺灣土地金融季刊 Journal of the Land Bank of Taiwan，34(1)
41. 潘仁霖(2001)。以BOT模式辦理地方公共建設之研究。2001年第四屆青年環境共生論壇論文發表研討會論文集，台北市:
42. 盧建旭 Lu, Lancelot(1995)。公共企業精神：公共企業家的角色與批判。空大行政學報 Open Public Administration Review，4
43. 謝宏昌 Hsieh, Horng-Chang(1998)。論重構地方識別作為永續鄉村發展基礎 On Reconstructing Local Identity as the Basis for Sustainable Rural Development。農業推廣學報 Review of Agricultural Extension Science，14

1. 紀俊臣(2003)。永續發發展與行政區域設計。中國地方自治，56(11)，4-36。
2. 紀俊臣(2003)。永續發發展與行政區域設計。中國地方自治，56(11)，4-36。
3. 藍逸之、李承嘉(2015)。作為制度舒緩的三生農業臺灣農地新自由化、調節過程與農業體制再結構。地理學報，76，25-68。
4. 藍逸之(2007)。評析高高屏都市區域治理策略中的在地永續性定著：一個新自由主義空間的視角。建築與規劃學報，8(2)，115-137。
5. 蘇淑娟、蕭力偉(2017)。高速鐵路車站特定區空間開發之結構歷程分析－新自由主義都市治理案例研究。地理學報，84，55-88。
6. 鄭育芬、翁註重(2013)。販賣服務 戰後台北市街道家具營造的歷史分析。臺灣社會研究季刊，90，115-162。
7. (2005)。全球經濟變遷、發展型國家與台灣城鄉規劃之重探都市企業主義適用性的地理探查及其治理危機。地理學報，40，69-97。