雙面向社區依附概念的確立：一個模式比較的研究

Confirming the Two Dimensions of Community Attachment: A Model Comparison Study

10.6128/CP.39.3.327

洪立三(Li-San Hung)；許嘉恩(Jia-En Sheu)

社區依附 ； 地方依附 ； 模式比較 ； 多元迴歸 ； 保護區 ； Community attachment ； Place attachment ； Model comparison ； Multiple regression ； Protected area

都市與計劃

39卷3期（2012 / 09 / 01）

327 - 347

繁體中文

近期社區依附的研究，強調在既有的社會面向社區依附外，也應有自然面向的依附。然而，仍缺少社會面向社區依附與雙面向社區依附之間在應用上的比較研究。本研究透過模式比較，確立社區依附內涵除了社會面向外，也應包含自然面向，並且需要區隔兩個面向。本研究以三個包含不同社區依附概念指標（社會面向社區依附、混合社會與自然面向的社區依附、雙獨立面向社區依附）之模式預測居民對關渡自然公園看法，並進行模式比較，結果發現包含兩個獨立面向社區依附的模式解釋力不僅優於僅包含社會面向的模式，也優於包含混合面向社區依附的模式；包含混合面向社區依附的模式解釋力優於僅包含社會面向社區依附的模式。本研究成果有助於社區依附概念的釐清與理論建構，也回應過去研究中，人對於地方的情感投入影響到居民對保護區看法的論述。

Several recent studies have argued that community attachment should have not only the social dimension but the natural dimension. However, few studies have compared the social dimension model and two-dimension model when predicting, for example, local attitudes toward protected areas. The importance of the natural community attachment can be confirmed by this comparison. In this study, three models, which include the social dimension indicator, social and natural dimension indicators (two separate indicators), and mixed community attachment indicator (combining natural and social dimension attachment indicators into one attachment indicator), are constructed and are used to predict local attitudes toward the Guandu Nature Park, Taipei, Taiwan. Statistical results show that, in predicting local attitudes toward the park, two-indicator model is better than the social-dimension model and mixed-indicator model. Furthermore, the mixed-indicator model is better than the social-dimension model. This study has implications for theorizing community attachment, and responds to previous research by demonstrating that attachment influences the attitudes toward protected areas.

1. 李俊豪(2010)。臺灣居民之社區意識─系統模式之分析。都市與計劃，37(2)，209-231。
   連結：
2. 周家雯、蘇文瑜(2008)。居民社區依附與其觀光衝擊認知關係之研究。運動休閒餐旅研究，3(1)，117-140。
   連結：
3. 林嘉男、許毅璿(2007)。人與環境關係之論述：釐清「地方感」、「地方依附」與「社區依附」在環境研究上的角色。環境教育研究，5(1)，41-71。
   連結：
4. 洪立三、許嘉恩(2010)。交界帶的政治生態學：居民對關渡自然公園作為「資源」與「地方」的看法。地理學報，60，1-22。
   連結：
5. 社團法人臺北市野鳥學會（2007）， 成立宗旨， 「關渡自然公園」，http://www.gd-park.org.tw/e/e2.htm，(2007年6月9日)。
6. 臺北市北投區戶政事務所（2011）， 人口統計， 「臺北市北投區戶政事務所」，http://www.pthr.taipei.gov.tw/np.asp?ctNode=2311&mp=102131，(2011年5月3日)。
7. Altman, I.(ed.),Mow, S. M.(ed.)(1992).Place Attachment.New York:Plenum Press.
8. Balram, S.,Dragićević, S.(2005).Attitudes toward urban green spaces: Integrating questionnaire survey and collaborative GIS techniques to improve attitude measurements.Landscape and Urban Planning,71(2-4),147-162.
9. Baron, R. A.,Byrne, D.(2000).Social Psychology.Boston:Allyn and Bacon.
10. Beckley, T. M.,Stedman, R. C.,Wallace, S. M.,Ambard, M.(2007).Snapshots of what matters most: Using resident-employed photography to articulate attachment of place.Society and Natural Resources,20(10),913-929.
11. Bonaiuto, M.,Carrus, G.,Martorella, H.,Bonnes, M.(2002).Local identity process and environmental attitudes in land use changes: The case of natural protected areas.Journal of Economic Psychology,23(5),631-653.
12. Brehm, J. M.,Eisenhauer, B. W.,Krannich, R. S.(2006).Community attachments as predictors of local environmental concern: The case for multiple dimensions of attachment.American Behavioral Scientist,50(2),142-165.
13. Carrus, G.,Bonaiuto, M.,Bonnes, M.(2005).Environmental concern, regional identity, and support for protected areas in Italy.Environment and Behavior,37(2),237-257.
14. Cihar, M.,Stankova, J.(2006).Attitudes of stakeholders towards the Podyji/Thaya River Basin National Park in the Czech Republic.Journal of Environmental Management,81(3),273-285.
15. Clark, J. K.,Stein, T. V.(2003).Incorporating the natural landscape with an assessment of community attachment.Forest Science,49(6),867-876.
16. Cuba, L.,Hummon, D. M.(1993).A place to call home: Identification with dwelling, community, and region.The Sociological Quarterly,34(1),111-131.
17. Dudley, N.,Guja, B.,Jackson, B.,Jeanrenaud, J.P.,Oviedo, G.,Phillips, A.,Rosabel, P.,Stolton, S.,Wells, S.(1999).Challenges for protected areas in the 21st century.Partnership for Protection: New Strategies for Planning and Management for Protected Area,London:
18. Giuliani, M. V.(2003).Theory of attachment and place attachment.Psychological Theories for Environmental Issues,Surrey:
19. Goudy, W. J.(1990).Community attachment in rural region.Rural Sociology,55(2),178-198.
20. Graybill, F. A.,Iyer, H. K.(1994).Regression Analysis: Concepts and Applications, Belmont.Calif.:Duxbury Press.
21. Heidmets, M.,Raudsepp, J. S.(2001).A conceptual framework for studying environmental mentality and behavior.Trames,5(3),198-210.
22. Hidalgo, M. C.,Hernández, B.(2001).Place attachment: Conceptual and empirical questions.Journal of Environmental Psychology,21(3),273-281.
23. Kasarda, J. D.,Janowitz, M.(1974).Community attachment in mass society.American Sociological Review,39,328-339.
24. Kyle, G. T.,Graefe, A. R.,Manning, R. E.,Bacon, J.(2003).An examination of the relationship between leisure activity involvement and place attachment among hikers along the Appalachian Trail.Journal of Leisure Research,35(3),249-273.
25. McNeely, J. A.(1994).Lessons from the past: Forests and biodiversity.Biodiversity and Conservation,3(1),3-20.
26. Mehta, J. N.,Heinen, J. T.(2001).Does community-based conservation shape favorable attitudes among locals? An empirical study from Nepal.Environmental Management,28(2),165-177.
27. Payton, M. E.,Fulton, D. C.,Anderson, D. H.(2005).Influence of place attachment and trust on civic action: A study at Sherburne National Wildlife Refuge.Society and Natural Resources,18(6),511-528.
28. Raymond, C. M.,Brown, G.,Weber, D.(2010).The measurement of place attachment: Personal, community, and environmental connections.Journal of Environmental Psychology,30(4),422-434.
29. Relph, E. C.(1976).Place and Placelessness.London:Pion Limited.
30. Scannell, L.,Gifford, R.(2010).Defining place attachment: A tripartite organizing framework.Journal of Environment Psychology,30(1),1-10.
31. Trakolis, D.(2001).Local people's perceptions of planning and management issues in Prespes Lakes National Park, Greece.Journal of Environmental Management,61(3),227-241.
32. Trakolis, D.(2001).Perceptions, preference, and reactions of local inhabitants in Vikos-Aoos National Park, Greece.Environmental Management,28(5),665-676.
33. Trentelman, C. K.(2009).Place attachment and community attachment: A primer grounded in the lived experience of a community sociologist.Society and Natural Resources,22(3),191-210.
34. Tuan, Y.(1977).Space and Place: Perspective of Experience.Minneapolis:University of Minnesota Press.
35. Tuan, Y.(1975).Place: An experiential perspective.Geographical Review,65(2),151-165.
36. Vorkinn, M.,Riese, H.(2001).Environmental concern in a local context: The significance of place attachment.Environment and Behavior,33(2),249-263.
37. Walpole, M. J.,Goodwin, H. J.(2001).Local attitudes toward conservation and tourism around Komodo National Park, Indonesia.Environmental Conservation,28(2),160-166.
38. Williams, D. R.,Stewart, S.(1998).Sense of place: An elusive concept that is finding a home in ecosystem management.Journal of Forestry,96(5),18-23.
39. Williams, D. R.,Vaske, J. J.(2003).The measurement of place attachment: Validity and generalization of a psychometric approach.Forest Science,49(6),830-840.
40. Xu, J.,Chen, L.,Lu, Y.,Fu, B.(2006).Local people's perceptions as decision support for protected area management in Wolong Biosphere Reserve, China.Journal of Environmental Management,78(4),362-372.
41. 吳明隆(2007)。SPSS操作與應用：問卷設計分析實務。臺北:五南。
42. 邱皓政(2006)。量化研究與統計分析─SPSS中文視窗版資料分析範例解析。臺北:五南。
43. 盧道杰(2004)。臺灣現地保育的治理─1990年以來一些新興個案的回顧。臺大實驗林研究報告，18(1)，13-27。

1. Kao, Yu-Hui(2019).An Exploratory Analysis of the Perception of Community Boundaries and Community Attachment: Taipei City as an Example.國家與社會,21,91-118.
2. 陳姿宏、張梨慧、杜佩蘭(2015)。地方依附對觀光發展認知影響之探討—金門出生者與非金門出生者。戶外遊憩研究，28(4)，103-139。