從空間規劃到區域治理：英國工黨時期區域規劃、組織與治理機制轉變的脈絡探討

From Spatial Planning to Regional Governance: A Contextual Study on Regional Planning, Organization and Governance Institution in the UK under New Labour

10.6128/CP.41.2.149

鄭安廷(An-Ting Cheng)

歐盟 ； 空間規劃 ； 規劃體系 ； 區域規劃 ； 區域治理 ； European Union ； Spatial planning ； Planning system ； Regional planning ； Regional governance

都市與計劃

41卷2期（2014 / 06 / 30）

149 - 167

繁體中文

空間規劃在過去二十餘年在歐洲聯盟（European Union）逐漸成為國土及區域發展的主流思想。而也因為歐盟對區域發展的高度關注帶動了國際空間規劃研究的興起，並進一步引發相當多國家對原有國土規劃體系乃至於城鄉治理體系的反思。做為歐盟主要會員國之一，英國過去十餘年在區域規劃以及治理議題上的論述及制度上的改變可以說是最為積極與劇烈。基於規劃界持續對於區域規劃與跨域治理制度整合的辯證與檢討，英國政府從90年代末期開始推動一連串的區域發展與治理制度的變革，這樣的趨勢在1997年工黨取得睽違十餘年的執政權後更加確立，而且改革幅度愈加明顯。為了呼應歐盟空間規劃的潮流，英國在工黨執政期間同樣出現了規劃體系與跨域治理同時並進的變革。然而傳統英國規劃體系與歐陸有相當大的差異性，不但存在於制度設計上也根植於政治文化中。基於從規劃到治理的制度性變革，本研究將探討兩點問題：一是規劃思潮的改變對於英國治理上的制度性效果；二是英國空間規劃在制度變革的過程當中是否能夠與原生制度鑲嵌。本論文由於受限於篇幅，將僅針對工黨時期英國區域治理變革為例，討論在歐盟空間規劃概念的演進所產生的政策效果脈絡下，英國規劃體系、組織與機制在近幾年所遭遇的困境以及與原有國家及地方規劃制度的互動與矛盾。

During the last two decades, spatial planning has assumed central role in European planning discourse. This phenomenon has also resulted in concerns regarding regional development, and has promoted studies on planning system and town and country governance. As a significant member of the European Union, the UK has witnessed a dramatic change in regional planning and governance institutions. Reflecting changes in other EU member states, the UK experienced a series of institutional changes involving both planning system and cross-boundary governance since the late 1990s, particularly after the Labour Party returned to power in 1997. This article aims to understand the influence of spatial planning on regional governance, and the engagement between the old and new spatial planning systems in the UK. Owing to limitations of space, this investigation only focuses on regional governance in transformation during the Labour Administration Period (1997-2010). This study introduces the difficulties that existed within the planning system, organizations and institutions, as well as institutional changes.

1. Deportment for Communities and Local Government (2008). Models for Sub-Regional Spatial Planning, London: Department for Communities and Local Government..
2. Albrechts, L.,Alden, J.,Da Rosa Pires, A.(2001).The Changing Institutional Landscape of Planning.Aldershot:Ashgate.
3. Alden, J.(1999).Scenarios for the nature of British planning system: The need for a national spatial planning framework.Town Planning Review,70(3),385-407.
4. Amin, A.(2002).Spatialities of globalisation.Environment and Planning A,34(3),385-399.
5. Bache, I.,Bristow, G.(2003).Devolution and the gate-keeping role of the core executive: The struggle for European funds.British Journal of Politics and International Relations,5(3),405-427.
6. Benyon, J(2000).Urban Policy and Politics in Britain.London:Macmillan Press.
7. Bianconi, M.,Gallent, N.,Greatbach, I.(2006).The changing geography of subregional planning in England.Environment and Plannin C: Government and Poliy,24(3),317-330.
8. Boland, P.(1999).Merseyside and objective 1 status, 1994-1999: Implications for the next programming period.Regional Studies,33(8),788-792.
9. Brenner, N.(2003).Metropolitan institutional reform and the rescaling of the state space in contemporary Western Europe.European Urban and Regional Studies,10(4),297-324.
10. Brenner, N.(2001).The limits to scale? Methodological reflections on scalar structuration.Progress in Human Geography,25(4),591-614.
11. Carley, M.,Christie, I.(1998).Managing Sustainable Development.London:Earthscan.
12. Clark, G.,Huxley, J.,Mountford, D.(2010).Organising Local Economic Development: The Role of Development Agencies and Companies.Paris:OECD.
13. Davies, H. W. E.(1994).Towards a European planning system?.Planning Practice and Research,9(1),63-69.
14. Davies, H. W. E.,Edward, D.(1989).Planning Control in Western Europe.London:HMSO.
15. Davoudi, S.(2003).European briefing: Polycentricity in European spatial planning: From an analytical tool to a normative agenda.European Planning Studies,11(8),979-999.
16. Deas, L.,Lord, A.(2009).From a new regionalism to an unusual regionalism? The emergence of non-standard regional spaces and lessons for the territorial reorganisation of the state.Urban Studies,43(10),1847-1877.
17. Faludi, A.(2009).A turning point in the development of European spatial planning? The 'territorial agenda of the european union' and the 'first action programme'.Progress in Planning,71(1),1-42.
18. Fit, J.,Kragt, K.(1994).The long road to European spatial planning: A matter of practice and mission.Tidjschrift voor Economische on Sociale Geografie,85(5),461-465.
19. Friedman, J.(2004).Strategic spatial planning and the longer range.Planning Theory and Practice,5(1),49-67.
20. Giannakourou, G.(1996).Towards a European spatial planning policy: Theoretical dilemmas and institutional implications.European Planning Studies,4(5),595-613.
21. Harris, N.,Hooper, A.,Bishop, K.(2002).Constructing the practice of spatial planning: A national spatial planning framework for Wales.Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy,20(4),555-572.
22. Healey, P.(ed.)(1994).Newcastle upon Tyne: Department of Town and Country Planning.Newcastle:University of Newcastle upon Tyne.
23. Healey, P.(ed.),Khakee, A.(ed.),Motte, A.(ed.),Needharm, B.(ed.)(1997).Making Strategic Spatial Plans.London:UCL Press.
24. Healey, P.(ed.),Khakee, A.(ed.),Motte, A.(ed.),Needharm, B.(ed.)(1997).Making Strategic Spatial Plans: Innovation in Europe.London:UCL Press.
25. HM Treasury(2007).Review of Sub-national Economic Development and Regeneration.London:HM Treasury.
26. Keating, M.(1997).The invention of regions: Political restructuring and territorial government in Western Europe.Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy,15(4),383-398.
27. Lovering, J.(1999).Theory led by policy: The inadequacies of the 'new regionalism' (illustrated from the case of Wales).International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,23(2),379-395.
28. Madanipour, A.(ed.),Hall, A.(ed.),Healey, P.(ed.)(2001).The Governance of Place: Space and Planning Processes.Aldershot:Ashgate.
29. Morgan, K.(1997).The learning region: Institutions, innovation and regional renewal.Regional Studies,31(5),491-503.
30. Nadin, V.(2007).The emergence of the spatial planning approach in England.Planning Practice and Research,22(1),43-62.
31. Newman, P.,Thornley, A.(1996).Urban Planning in Europe. International Competition, National Systems and Planning Projects.London:Routledge.
32. Office of the Deputy Prime Minister(2006).State of the English Cities.Lodon:HMSO.
33. Office of the Deputy Prime Minister(2004).Planning Policy Statement 11: Local Development Framework.Lodon:HMSO.
34. Office of the Deputy Prime Minister(2006).,Lodon:HMSO.
35. Office of the Deputy Prime Minister(2004).Planning Policy Statement 11: Regional Spatial Strategies.Lodon:HMSO.
36. Organization for Economic Co-Operationa and Development(2006).DECE Territorial Reviews: Compotitive Cities in the Global Economy.Paris:OECD.
37. Peck, J.(ed.),Yeung, H. W. C.(ed.)(2003).Remaking the Global Economy.London:Sage.
38. Phelps, N. A.,Tewdwr-Jones, M.(2000).Scratching the surface of collaboration and associative governance: Identifying the diversity of social action in institutional capacity building.Environment and Planning A,32(1),111-130.
39. Rivolin, U. J.,Faludi, F.(2005).The hidden face of European spatial planning: Innovation in Governance.European Planning Studies,13(2),195-215.
40. Rodriguez-Pose, A.(2005).Report to the DFID Urban and Rural Change TeamReport to the DFID Urban and Rural Change Team,London:Department for International Development.
41. Salet, W.,Faludi, A.(2000).The Revival of Spatial Strategic Planning,Amsterdam:
42. Scott, A.(2001).Globalization and the rise of city-regions.European Planning Studies,9(7),813-826.
43. Stead, D.,Nadin, V.(1999).Environmental resources and energy in the United Kingdom: The potential role of a national spatial planning framework.Town Planning Review,70(3),339-362.
44. Swyngedouw, E.(2004).Globalisation or 'glocalisation'? Networks, territories and rescaling.Cambridge Review of International Affairs,17(1),25-48.
45. Tewdwr-Jones, M.,McNeill, D.(2000).The politics of city-region planning and governance.European Urban and Regional Studies,7(2),119-134.
46. Town and County Planning Association(2011).Policy Analysis of Housing and Planning Reform.London:Town and County Planning Association.
47. Vigar, G.,Healey, P.,Hull, A.,Davoudi, S.(2000).Planning, Governance and Spatial Strategy: An Institutional Analysis.London:Macmillan.
48. Williams, R. H.(1996).European Union Spatial Policy and Planning.London:Chapman.
49. Wong, C.,Ravetz, J.,Turner, J.(2000).The UK Spatial Planning Framework.London:Royal Town Planning Institute.
50. 鄭安廷(2009)。空間規劃─全球化化潮下區域治理的解決方案？。台灣公共行政與公共事務系所聯合會（TASPAA）論文集，高雄:
51. 鄭安廷(2010)。行政區域整併為強化區域治理效能的唯一選擇？從英國區域政府政策的轉變看行政區變革的挑戰。台灣公共行政與公共事務系所聯合會（TASPAA）論文集，高雄:

1. 鄭安廷、陳一夫、林建元(2015)。跨域治理模式的建構與評估。都市與計劃，42(2)，153-170。