亞洲城市房價基值與泡沫

Fundamental House Prices and Bubbles in Asian Cities

10.6128/CP.41.2.169

李美杏(Mei-Hsing Lee)；陳威廷(Wei-Ting Chen)；彭建文(Chien-Wen Peng)

追蹤資料分析法 ； 房價基值 ； 房價泡沫 ； Panel data analysis ； Fundamental house value ； House price bubble

都市與計劃

41卷2期（2014 / 06 / 30）

169 - 198

繁體中文

本文探討房價與市場經濟基本面之間的關係，採用追蹤資料分析法，以亞洲六大城市（台北、東京、首爾、香港、新加坡與上海）1995Q3~2011Q4為實證範圍，由各城市之總體經濟變數決定房價基值，最後，計算房屋基值與真實房價間的差異求得各城市房價泡沫的大小。實證結果顯示：房價基值受利率、可支配所得、國內生產毛額、消費者物價指數所影響；至2011年底台北、新加坡與香港房價泡沫比例約30%，上海與東京房價泡沫比例約10%，首爾之房價泡沫較不明顯。

This study examined whether there were existing house price bubbles via the differencebetween fundamental house values and actual house prices in six Asian cities (Taipei, Tokyo, Seoul,Hong Kong, Singapore and Shanghai) during the period 1995Q3-2011Q4. The fundamental housevalues in each city were calculated based on the long-run relationship between house prices andmacroeconomic variables. The empirical results revealed that fundamental house values were drivenby lending rate, disposable income, gross domestic product and consumer price index. Notably ahouse price bubble appeared to account for about 30% of the house prices in Taipei, Singapore andHong Kong as of the end of 2011. Furthermore, Shanghai and Tokyo also simultaneously had a houseprice bubble that represented about 10% of house prices. However, the house price bubble in Seoulwas not obvious.

1. Chen, M. C.,Patel, K.(2002).An empirical analysis of determination of house prices in the Taipei area.Taiwan Economic Review,30(4),563-595.
   連結：
2. 王景南、葉錦徽、林宗漢(2011)。台灣房市存在價格泡沫嗎？。經濟論文，39(1)，61-89。
   連結：
3. 王景南、葉錦徽、林宗漢(2011)。台灣房市存在價格泡沫嗎？。經濟論文，39(1)，61-89。
   連結：
4. 張金鶚、陳明吉、鄧筱蓉、楊智元(2009)。台北市房價泡沫知多少？房價 VS. 租金與房價 VS. 所得。住宅學報，18(2)，1-22。
   連結：
5. Abraham, J. M.,Hendershott, H. P.(1996).Bubble in metropolitan housing markets.Journal of Housing Research,7(2),191-207.
6. Anari, A.,Kolari, J.(2002).House prices and inflation.Real Estate Economics,30(1),67-84.
7. Black, A.,Fraser, P.,Hoesli, M.(2006).House prices, fundamentals and bubbles.Journal of Business Finance & Accounting,33(9),1535-1555.
8. Blanchard, O. J.,Fisher, S.(1989).Lecture on Macroeconomic.Cambridge:MIT Press.
9. Bond, M.T.,Seiler, M. J.(1998).Real estate returns and inflation: An added variable approach.Journal of Real Estate Research,15(3),327-338.
10. Bourassa, S. C.,Hendershott, P. H.,Murphy, J.(2001).Further evidence on the existence of housing market bubbles.Journal of Property Research,18(1),1-19.
11. Brounen, D.,Eichholtz, P.,Theebe, M. A. J.,Straetmans S.(2013).Inflation protection from homeownership: Long-run evidence 1811-2008.Real Estate Economics
12. Chan, H.,Lee, S.,Woo, K.(2001).Detecting rational bubbles in the residential housing markets of Hong Kong.Economic Modeling,18(1),61-73.
13. Chen, N. K.(2001).Asset price fluctuations in Taiwan: Evidence from stock and real estate prices 1973 to 1992.Journal of Asian Economics,12(2),215-232.
14. Fama, E. F.,Schwert, G. W.(1977).Asset returns and inflation.Journal of Financial Economics,5(2),115-146.
15. Fernández-Kranz, D.,Hon, M. T.(2006).A cross-section analysis of the income elasticity of housing demand in Spain: Is there a real estate bubble?.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,32(4),449-470.
16. Glindro, E.,Subhanij, T.,Szeto, J.,Zhu, H.(2011).Determinants of house prices in nine Asia-Pacific economies.International Journal of Central Banking,7(3),163-204.
17. Green, R.(2002).Stock prices and house prices in California: New evidence of a wealth effect?.Regional Science and Urban Economics,32(6),775-783.
18. Gyourko, J.,Linneman, P.(1988).Owner-occupied homes, income- producing properties, and REITs as inflation hedges: Empirical findings.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,4(1),347-372.
19. Hamilton, J. D.(1985).Uncovering financial market expectations of inflation.Journal of Political Economy,93(6),1224-1241.
20. Hausman, J. A.(1978).Specification tests in econometrics.Econometric,46(6),1251-1271.
21. Hui, E.,Yue, S.(2006).Housing price bubbles in Hong Kong, Beijing and Shanghai: A comparative study.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,33(4),299-327.
22. Kakes, J.,Van Den End, J. W.(2004).Do stock prices affect house prices? Evidence for the Netherlands.Applied Economics Letters,11(12),741-744.
23. Kim, K. H.,Suh, S. H.(1993).Speculation and price bubbles in the Korean and Japanese real estate markets.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics,6(1),73-87.
24. Koetter, M.,Poghosyan, T.(2010).Real estate prices and bank stability.Journal of Banking and Finance,34(6),1129-1138.
25. Levin, A.,Lin, C. F.,Chu, C.(2002).Unit root tests in panel data: Asymptotic and finite-sample properties.Journal of Econometrics,101(1),1-24.
26. Lin, T. C.,Lin, Z.(2011).Are stock and real estate markets integrated? An empirical study of six Asian economies.Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,19(5),571-585.
27. Malpezzi, S.(1999).A simple error correction model of house prices.Journal of Housing Economics,8(1),27-62.
28. Okunev, J.,Wilson, P.,Zurbruegg, R.(2002).Relationships between Australian real estate and stock market prices: A case of market inefficiency.Journal of Forecasting,21(3),181-192.
29. Rubens, J. H.,Bond, M. T.,Webb, J. R.(1989).The inflation-hedging effectiveness of real estate.Journal of Real Estate Research,4(2),45-55.
30. Sing, T. F.,Low, Y.(2000).The inflation-hedging characteristics of real estate and financial assets in Singapore.Journal of Real Estate Portfolio Management,6(4),373-386.
31. Stiglitz, J. E.(1990).Symposium on bubbles.Journal of Economic Perspectives,4(2),13-18.
32. Xiao, Q.,Tan, G. K. R.(2007).Signal extraction with kalman filter: A study of the Hong Kong property price bubbles.Urban Studies,44(4),865-888.
33. 周世賢(1994)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立台灣大學商學系。
34. 林秋瑾(1996)。台灣區域性住宅價格模式之建立。政大地政學報，21(2)，20-49。
35. 林祖嘉、林素菁(1996)。台灣地區住宅價格的泡沫現象。台灣經濟學會年會論文集，台北:
36. 林慧芬(2008)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。逢甲大學財務金融學系。
37. 洪亦彬(1996)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立中興大學統計學系。
38. 馬毓駿(2010)。博士論文(博士論文)。國立政治大學經濟學系。
39. 張金鶚、楊宗憲(1999)。台北市成屋價格泡沫知多少？。中華民國住宅學會第九屆年會論文集，台北:
40. 彭建文(2000)。博士論文(博士論文)。國立政治大學地政學系。
41. 黃佩玲(1994)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立政治大學地政系。

1. 陳建新,許義忠,何姗嬬(2022)。囤房稅能降低房價所得比嗎？合成控制法的應用。臺灣土地研究，25(2)，121-155。
2. 陳明吉、朱芳妮(2018)。從行為經濟學看台灣不動產市場：羅伯特．席勒教授來台演講之省思與啟示。住宅學報，27(2)，111-128。
3. 紀博棟(2016)。簽署ECFA前後臺灣重要經貿數據之變化。中國地方自治，69(3)，31-59。
4. 梁仁旭、吳孟璇(2016)。台北市高房價成因剖析─以租價關係、總體因素與預期因素探討。土地經濟年刊，27，53-81。
5. (2024)。自住與非自住之房屋稅率差異對房價之影響－差異中之差異法的應用。住宅學報，33(2)，27-62。