台灣地區居住滿意度影響因素之實證分析

Determinants of Residential Satisfaction: An Empirical Study in Taiwan

10.6128/CP.202009_47(3).0003

彭建文(Chien-Wen Peng)；李美杏(Mei-Hsing Lee)；陳冠儒(Kuan-Ju Chen)

居住滿意度 ； 住宅滿意度 ； 鄰里環境滿意度 ； 次序邏輯斯迴歸 ； Residential satisfaction ； Housing satisfaction ； Neighborhood satisfaction ； Ordered logistic regression

都市與計劃

47卷3期（2020 / 09 / 30）

243 - 270

繁體中文

台灣住宅市場同時存在高房價、高住宅自有率、以及高空屋率的矛盾現象，民眾在負擔高房價去擁屋下，居住滿意度的狀況與影響因素非常值得公私部門深入探討。本研究將居住滿意度區分為住宅滿意度與鄰里環境滿意度，並以「2015年住宅狀況抽樣調查」的14,275筆資料進行分析，實證顯示鄰里環境特徵對於居住滿意度的影響會大於住宅本身特徵，其中環境美化與管理維護滿意度、視野景觀滿意度是最重要的鄰里環境特徵。其次，建物是否為住宅專用、住宅類型、以及屋齡對居住滿意度有重要影響。第三、每人使用面積、房數、廳數、衛浴數、有冷氣空調、以及節能設施的種類數愈多會提高住宅滿意度。第四、住宅為自有、主要家計負責人的年齡愈大、平均每月經常性總收入愈高、以及近五年內有搬遷會提高住宅滿意度，但家庭屬性對於鄰里環境滿意度均無顯著影響。最後，無論是住宅或是鄰里環境滿意度，六都均較非六都為低，且鄰里環境滿意度較住宅滿意度更低，未來政府要提升民眾的居住滿意度應充分考量上述影響因素與地區差異。

The coexistence of high housing prices, a high homeownership rate, and a high vacancy rate in Taiwan's residential market, it could be described as irrational. Under the burden of high housing prices, it is worthwhile for the public and private sectors to explore the residents' satisfaction and influencing factors. Residential satisfaction can be classified as satisfaction with housing and satisfaction with neighborhood. This study employs 14,275 samples in ＂2015 Housing Conditions Sample Survey＂ to examine the determinants of housing satisfaction and neighborhood satisfaction, respectively. The empirical results reveal several interesting findings. Firstly, neighborhood characteristics had a larger influence compared to housing characteristics. Landscape of neighborhood and environmental decoration and management are the most two important variables affecting the residential satisfaction. Secondly, housing characteristics, such as usage for housing only, housing types, and age of structure significantly affect residential satisfaction. Thirdly, increases in living area per person, the number of rooms, the number of halls, the number of toilets, air conditioner, and the number of energy-efficient facility will increase housing satisfaction. Fourthly, housing ownership, age of the main family financial supporter, average regular monthly income of household, and recent relocation significantly affect housing satisfaction. However, the influences of family characteristics on neighborhood satisfaction are limited. Finally, housing satisfaction and neighborhood satisfaction are both lower in six municipalities comparing with the other non-municipalities, and the degree of neighborhood satisfaction is lower than housing satisfaction. To improve residential satisfaction, the government should consider the above influencing factors and regional differences in the future.

1. 張珩,邢志航(2004)。住宅特性與居住機能滿意程度關聯之研究－以公寓大廈式集合住宅為例。建築學報，47，89-106。
   連結：
2. 張景盛,陳素月,藍宜亭,黃俊英(2013)。高雄地區住宅特徵與住宅環境的重視程度對居住滿意度之影響。建築與規劃學報，14(1)，33-45。
   連結：
3. Altman, I.(ed.),Werner, C. H.(ed.)(1985).Home Environments.New York:Plenum Press.
4. Amérigo, M.,Aragonés, J. I.(1990).Residential satisfaction in council housing.Journal of Environmental Psychology,10(4),313-325.
5. Amérigo, M.,Aragonés, J. I.(1997).A theoretical and methodological approach to the study of residential satisfaction.Journal of Environmental Psychology,17(1),47-57.
6. Baillie, S. T.,Peart, V.(1992).Determinants of housing satisfaction for older married and unmarried women in Florida.Housing and Society,19(2),101-116.
7. Basolo, V.,Strong, D.(2002).Understanding the neighborhood: From residents’perceptions and needs to action.Housing Policy Debate,13(1),83-105.
8. Bonnes, M.,Bonaiuto, M.,Ercolani, A.(1991).Crowding and residential satisfaction in the urban environment: A contextual approach.Nvironment and Behavior,23(5),531-552.
9. Campbell, A.,Converse, P. E.,Rodgers, W.(1976).The Quality of American Life: Perceptions, Evaluations, and Satisfactions.New York:Russell Sage Foundation.
10. Chau, K. W.,Chin, T. L.(2003).A critical review of literature on the hedonic price model.International Journal for Housing Science and Its Applications,27(2),145-165.
11. Crull, S. R.,Bode, M. E.,Morris, E. W.(1991).Two tests of the housing adjustment model of residential mobility.Housing and Society,18(3),53-64.
12. Dahmann, D. C.(1985).Assessments of neighborhood quality in metropolitan America.Urban Affairs Quarterly,20(4),511-535.
13. Dekker, K.,de Vos, S.,Musterd, S.,van Kempen, R.(2011).Residential satisfaction in housing estates in European cities: A multi-level research approach.Housing Studies,26(4),479-499.
14. Fang, Y.(2006).Residential satisfaction, moving intention and moving behaviours: A study of redeveloped neighbourhoods in inner-city Beijing.Housing Studies,21(5),671-694.
15. Galster, G. C.(1985).Evaluating indicators for housing policy: Residential satisfaction vs marginal improvement priorities.Social Indicators Research,16(4),415-448.
16. Galster, G. C.(1987).Identifying the correlates of dwelling satisfaction: An empirical critique.Environment and Behavior,19(5),539-568.
17. Galster, G. C.,Hesser, G. W.(1981).Residential satisfaction: Compositional and contextual correlates.Environment and Behavior,13(6),735-758.
18. Gamble, A.,Gärling, T.(2012).The relationships between life satisfaction, happiness, and current mood.Journal of Happiness Studies,13(1),31-45.
19. Ha, M.,Weber, M. J.(1991).The determinants of residential environmental qualities and satisfaction: Effects of financing, housing programs and housing regulations.Housing and Society,18(3),65-76.
20. Hipp, J.(2010).What is the “neighbourhood” in neighbourhood satisfaction? Comparing the effects of structural characteristics measured at the micro-neighbourhood and tract levels.Urban Studies,47(12),2517-2536.
21. Li, S.,Song, Y.(2009).Redevelopment, displacement, housing conditions, and residential satisfaction: A study of Shanghai.Environment and Planning A,41(5),1090-1108.
22. Li, Z.,Wu, F.(2013).Residential satisfaction in china’s informal settlements: A case study of Beijing, Shanghai, and Guangzhou.Urban Geography,34(7),923-949.
23. Lu, M.(1998).Analyzing migration decision making: Relationships between residential satisfaction, mobility intentions, and moving behaviour.Environment and Planning A,30(8),1473-1495.
24. Lu, M.(1999).Determinants of residential satisfaction: Ordered logit vs. regression models.Growth and Change,30(2),264-287.
25. Miller, F. D.,Tsemberis, S.,Malia, G. P.,Grega, D.(1980).Neighborhood satisfaction among urban dwellers.Journal of Social Issues,36(3),101-117.
26. Mohan, J.,Twigg, L.(2007).Sense of place, quality of life and local socioeconomic context: Evidence from the survey of English housing, 2002/03.Urban Studies,44(10),2029-2045.
27. Mohit, M. A.,Ibrahim, M.,Rashid, Y. R.(2010).Assessment of residential satisfaction in newly designed public low-cost housing in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.Habitat International,34(1),18-27.
28. Morris, E. W.,Crull, S. R.,Winter, M.(1976).Housing norms, housing satisfaction and the propensity to move.Journal of Marriage and Family,38(2),309-320.
29. Parkes, A.,Kearns, A.(2003).Residential perceptions and housing mobility in Scotland: An analysis of the longitudinal Scottish house condition survey 1991-96.Housing Studies,18(5),673-701.
30. Parkes, A.,Kearns, A.,Atkinson, R.(2002).What makes people dissatisfied with their neighbourhoods?.Urban Studies,39(13),2413-2438.
31. Permentier, M.,Bolt, G.,van Ham, M.(2011).Determinants of neighbourhood satisfaction and perception of neighbourhood reputation.Urban Studies,48(5),977-996.
32. Sirmans, G. S.,Macpherson, D. A.,Zietz, E. N.(2005).The composition of hedonic pricing models.Journal of Real Estate Literature,13(1),1-44.
33. Speare, A.(1974).Residential satisfaction as an intervening variable in residential mobility.Demography,11(2),173-188.
34. Wang, D.,Li, S.(2004).Housing preferences in a transitional housing system: The case of Beijing, China.Environment and Planning A,36(1),69-87.
35. Wang, D.,Li, S.(2006).Socio-economic differentials and stated housing preferences in Guangzhou, China.Habitat International,30(2),305-326.
36. Wang, D.,Wang, F.(2016).Contributions of the usage and affective experience of the residential environment to residential satisfaction.Housing Studies,31(1),42-60.
37. Yang, Y.(2008).A tale of two cities: Physical form and neighborhood satisfaction in metropolitan Portland and Charlotte.Journal of the American Planning Association,74(3),307-323.
38. 內政部營建署（2017），「2015 年住宅狀況抽樣調查」，臺北：內政部營建署。
39. 江慧玲(2014)。桃園縣南崁地區居民的居住滿意度與地方認同之研究。北市教大社教學報，13，81-114。
40. 李佳燕(2014)。臺北市萬芳社區居民遷移動機與其居住滿意度之研究。北市教大社教學報，13，60-80。
41. 林毓英(2006)。臺北，臺北市立教育大學社會科教育研究所。
42. 張雅鳳(1993)。桃園，中原大學建築學系。
43. 陳怡瑞(2012)。臺南，崑山科技大學房地產開發與管理研究所。
44. 陳玫秀,林晏州(2007)。都市居住環境品質對居住滿意度之影響。造園景觀學報，12(4)，57-77。
45. 鄭洲楠(2005)。臺南，國立成功大學高階管理碩士在職專班。