創意人才、創意產業與創業關聯之研究

Creative Class, Creative Industries and Entrepreneurship

10.6128/CP.202112_48(4).0002

蘇曉瑞(Hsiao-Jui Su)

創意人才 ； 創意產業 ； 創業 ； 空間迴歸 ； 分量迴歸 ； Creative class ； Creative industry ； Entrepreneurship ； Spatial regression ； Quantile regression

都市與計劃

48卷4期（2021 / 12 / 31）

377 - 405

繁體中文

創意人才近年來被視為創造區域經濟成長的重要因素，然而這項觀點仍存在爭議，因此部分研究改以創意產業為創意變數進行實證。本文認為創意人才與創意產業各自代表不同型態的創意變數，若是在實證研究上忽略其中一種變數將可能導致估計偏誤產生，因而本文嘗試同時考量兩種創意變數以估計對經濟成長的影響。因應經濟活動在空間分布的不均性與避免非空間性迴歸方法而產生偏誤問題，本文使用空間迴歸方法為基礎的分析方式。此外，本文將使用分量迴歸方法估計應變數在不同分位下受到創意變數的影響程度，進而能更仔細研究創意變數的影響。研究結果顯示，相較以往所使用的非空間模型，空間迴歸得出創意變數對經濟成長的影響程度確實減低，並且在控制熱點的情況下也使得創意變數的影響程度下降，最後分量迴歸的結果顯示了創意變數影響力將隨著應變數分量提升而增加。

The creative class has been shown to be a dominant factor in spurring regional economic growth. Still, there remains controversy with the theory; based on this, some studies turn the foci into the creative industry for further empirical research. We argue that the creative class and the creative industry could represent different aspect of creativity, and neglecting one of these factors could lead to estimation bias. Therefore, this study attempts to estimate the effect of creativity on economic growth by considering both factors. Our empirical model uses spatial regression as the base method because the spatial distribution of economic activity is uneven, leading to the danger of biased results from non-spatial regression. Furthermore, this study estimates the effect of creativity under different ratios of the dependent variable by using quantile regression method, enabling a thorough discussion of the impact effect. Empirical results show that considering the spatial effect decreases the impact effect of creativity on economic performance, and the impact effect of creativity decreases when the spatial hot spot variable is included. The marginal effect increases as the dependent variable increases under quantile regression.

1. Aage, T.,Belussi, F.(2008).From fashion to design: Creative networks in industrial districts.Industry and Innovation,15(5),475-491.
2. Anselin, L.(1988).Spatial Econometrics: Methods and Models.Dordrecht:Springer.
3. Anselin, L.(1995).Local indicators of spatial association-LISA.Geographical Analysis,27(2),93-115.
4. Anselin, L.,Bera, A. K.,Florax, R.,Yoon, M. J.(1996).Simple diagnostic tests for spatial dependence.Regional Science and Urban Economics,26(1),77-104.
5. Armington, C.,Acs, Z. J.(2002).The determinants of regional variation in new firm formation.Regional Studies,36(1),33-45.
6. Audretsch, D. B.,Belitski, M.(2013).The missing pillar: The creativity theory of knowledge spillover entrepreneurship.Small Business Economics,41(4),819-836.
7. Barro, R. J.(1991).Economic growth in a cross section of countries.The Quarterly Journal of Economics,106(2),407-443.
8. Becker, G. S.(1964).Human Capital.New York:Columbia University Press.
9. Benhabib, J.,Spiegel, M. M.(1994).The role of human capital in economic development: Evidence from aggregate cross-country data.Journal of Monetary Economics,34(2),143-173.
10. Boschma, R. A.,Fritsch, M.(2009).Creative class and regional growth: Empirical evidence from seven European countries.Economic Geography,85(4),391-423.
11. Bosma, N.,Content, J.,Sanders, M.,Stam, E.(2018).Institutions, entrepreneurship, and economic growth in Europe.Small Business Economics,51(2),483-499.
12. Buenstorf, G.,Klepper, S.(2009).Heritage and agglomeration: The Akron type cluster revisited.The Economic Journal,119(537),705-733.
13. Cerina, F.,Mureddu, F.(2014).Is agglomeration really good for growth? Global efficiency, interregional equity and uneven growth.Journal of Urban Economics,84,9-22.
14. Cliff, A. D.,Ord, J. K.(1973).Spatial Autocorrelation.London:Pion.
15. Crespo-Cuaresma, J.,Foster, N.,Stehrer, R.(2011).Determinants of regional economic growth by quantile.Regional Studies,45(6),809-826.
16. DCMS(2016).Creative Industries Economic Estimates.London:Department for Culture, Media and Sport.
17. Diodato, D.,Neffke, F.,O'Clery, N.(2018).Why do industries coagglomerate? How Marshallian externalities differ by industry and have evolved over time.Journal of Urban Economics,106,1-26.
18. Evans, G.(2009).Creative cities, creative spaces and urban policy.Urban Studies,46(5-6),1003-1040.
19. Faggian, A.,Partridge, M.,Malecki, E. J.(2017).Creating an environment for economic growth: Creativity, entrepreneurship or human capital?.International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,41(6),997-1009.
20. Florida, R.(2002).The Rise of the Creative Class: And How It Is Transforming Work, Leisure, Community, and Everyday Life.New York:Basic Books.
21. Florida, R.(2005).The Flight of the Creative Class.New York:Harper Collins.
22. Florida, R.(2004).The Rise of the Creative Class.New York:Basic Books.
23. Florida, R.,Mellander, C.(2010).There goes the metro: How and why bohemians, artists and gays affect regional housing values.Journal of Economic Geography,10(2),167-188.
24. Florida, R.,Mellander, C.,Stolarick, K.(2008).Inside the black box of regional development-human capital, the creative class and tolerance.Journal of Economic Geography,8(5),615-649.
25. Fornahl, D.,Schaffer, A.,Siegele, J.(2009).Regional per capita-income–The importance of region-specific production factors.Swiss Journal of Economics and Statistics,145(2),155-185.
26. Gabe, T. M.,Colby, K.,Bell, K. P.(2007).Creative occupations, county-level earnings and the US rural-urban wage gap.Canadian Journal of Regional Science,3,343-410.
27. Getis, A.,Ord, J. K.(1992).The analysis of spatial association by the use of distance statistic.Geographical Analysis,24,189-206.
28. Glaeser, E. L.(2005).Review of Richard Florida’s the rise of the creative class.Regional Science and Urban Economics,35(5),593-596.
29. Glaeser, E. L.,Mare, D. C.(2001).Cities and skills.Journal of Labor Economics,19(2),316-342.
30. Koenker, R.(2005).Quantile Regression.New York:Cambridge University Press.
31. Koenker, R.,Bassett, G.(1978).Regression quantiles.Econometrica,46(1),33-50.
32. Lazzeretti, L.,Innocenti, N.,Capone, F.(2017).The impact of related variety on the creative employment growth.The Annals of Regional Science,58(3),491-512.
33. Lee, N.(2014).The creative industries and urban economic growth in the UK.Environment and Planning A,46(2),455-470.
34. Lucas, R. J.(1988).On the mechanics of economic development.Journal of Monetary Economics,22(1),3-42.
35. Mankiw, N. G.,Romer, D.,Weil, D. N.(1992).A contribution to the empirics of economic growth.Quarterly Journal of Economics,107(2),407-437.
36. Marlet, J.,Woerkens, C. V.(2007).The Dutch creative class and how it fosters urban employment growth.Urban Studies,44(13),2605-2626.
37. Marrocu, E.,Paci, R.(2012).Education or creativity: What matters most for economic performance?.Economic Geography,88(4),369-401.
38. Marshall, A.(1961).Principles of Economics.New York:Macmillan Co..
39. McGranahan, D. A.,Wojan, T. R.,Lambert, D. M.(2011).The rural growth trifecta: Outdoor amenities, creative class and entrepreneurial context.Journal of Economic Geography,11(3),529-557.
40. McGranahan, D.,Wojan, T.(2007).Recasting the creative class to examine growth processes in rural and urban counties.Regional Studies,41(2),197-216.
41. Mellander, C.,Florida, R.(2011).Creativity, talent, and regional wages in Sweden.The Annals of Regional Science,46(3),637-660.
42. Nathan, M.(2007).The wrong stuff? Creative class theory and economic performance in UK cities.Canadian Journal of Regional Science,3,433-450.
43. Parajuli, J.,Haynes, K. E.(2017).Panel data models of new firm formation in New England.Region,4(3),65.
44. Piergiovanni, R.,Carree, M. A.,Santarelli, E.(2012).Creative industries, new business formation, and regional economic growth.Small Business Economics,39(3),539-560.
45. Rigby, D. L.,Essletzbichler, J.(2002).Agglomeration economies and productivity differences in US cities.Journal of Economic Geography,2(4),407-432.
46. Scott, A.(2006).Entrepreneurship, innovation and industrial development: Geography and the creative field revisited.Small Business Economics,26(1),1-24.
47. Stam, E.,de Jong, J. P. J.,Marlet, G.(2008).Creative industries in the Netherlands: Structure, development, innovativeness and effects on urban growth.Geografiska Annaler: Series B, Human Geography,90(2),119-132.
48. Stolarick, K.,Lobo, J.,Strumsky, D.(2011).Are creative metropolitan areas also entrepreneurial?.Regional Science Policy and Practice,3(3),271-286.
49. Tobler, W. R.(1970).A computer movie simulating urban growth in the Detroit region.Economic geography,46(1),234-240.
50. Tomaney, J.,Bradley, D.(2007).The economic role of mobile professional and creative workers and their housing and residential preferences: Evidence from North East England.Town Planning Review,78(4),511-530.
51. Unger, J. M.,Rauch, A.,Frese, M.,Rosenbusch, N.(2011).Human capital and entrepreneurial success: A meta-analytical review.Journal of Business Venturing,26(3),341-358.
52. Wojan, T. R.,Lambert, D. M.,McGranahan, D. A.(2007).Emoting with their feet: Bohemian attraction to creative milieu.Journal of Economic Geography,7(6),711-736.
53. Yu, W.,Hong, J.,Zhu, Y.,Marinova, D.,Guo, X.(2014).Creative industry clusters, regional innovation and economic growth in China.Regional Science Policy & Practice,6(4),329-348.