题名

建構綠色大眾運輸導向發展規劃模式來引導永續及緊湊的城市發展－以金門為例

并列篇名

Developing a Green TOD Planning Model to Promote Sustainable and Compact City Development - An Empirical Study of Kinmen

DOI

10.6128/CP.202206_49(2).0005

作者

吳綱立(Kang-Li Wu)

关键词

大眾運輸導向發展 ； 綠色大眾運輸導向發展 ； 公車捷運 ； 緊湊發展 ； 永續生態社區 ； 金門 ； Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) ； Green TOD ； Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) ； Compact development ； Sustainable and ecological communities ； Kinmen

期刊名称

都市與計劃

卷期/出版年月

49卷2期（2022 / 06 / 30）

页次

219 - 262

内容语文

繁體中文
中文摘要

本研究以供給導向（supply-oriented）的規劃觀點切入，嘗試整合大眾運輸導向發展（Transit-Oriented Development; TOD）理論與永續生態社區理論，進而建構出一套以BRT或輕軌為主要運具的綠色大眾運輸導向發展（Green TOD）規劃模式，以促進新興或轉型中城市區域的永續及緊湊發展。本文從TOD理論發展的批判性回顧開始，透過文獻與國際經驗的剖析，探討TOD在引導城市發展上所面臨的挑戰及潛力，並探討從TOD擴展到Green TOD的理論發展脈絡及關鍵內容，接著以正面臨城鎮化轉型發展及蛙躍式土地開發壓力的金門島嶼區域為例，系統性地探討Green TOD在引導永續及緊湊之城鎮化發展上的機會與挑戰。經由理論與文獻分析、案例分析、情境導向的預測分析、GIS空間分析、層級分析法等方法的綜合應用，本研究提出一套符合成本效益及永續與緊湊城市發展觀點的島嶼型Green TOD規劃模式，並透過配合Green TOD規劃的生態社區選址分析，對金門未來的人口分派進行模擬分析，最後亦探討落實此Green TOD模式的規劃策略及可優先執行的關鍵生態社區營造內容，以期能有助於TOD理論的拓展，並促進島嶼區域的永續及緊湊發展。
英文摘要

This study develops a Green TOD planning model with BRT and/or a light rail system as the main transportation mode by integrating the theory of Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) with the theory of sustainable and ecological communities based on a supply-oriented planning viewpoint, in order to promote the sustainable and compact development of emerging and transforming city-regions. Starting with a critical review of the development of TOD theory, and through the analysis of related literature and international experiences, this study explores the challenges and potentials of TOD in guiding city development as well as the theoretical development and key content of the expansion from TOD to Green TOD. This review is followed by an empirical case study using the Kinmen island region - a transforming island region facing the pressure of urbanization and leapfrogging land development - as the case setting to systematically investigate the opportunities and challenges of Green TOD in promoting sustainable and compact urbanization. Through the comprehensive application of theoretical and literature analysis, case studies, scenario-based forecasting, GIS spatial analysis, and analytic hierarchical analysis (AHP), this research proposes a Green TOD planning model that is in line with the concepts of cost-effective infrastructure investment and sustainable/compact city development. A scenario-based simulation analysis on the future population distribution of Kinmen is conducted in cooperation with the site selection of potential ecological communities along Green TOD corridors. Finally, this research explores several operational planning strategies for the implementation of the Green TOD model and related priority key ecological community construction elements. It is hoped that our research efforts can contribute to the development of TOD theory as well as promote the sustainable and compact development of island regions.
主题分类 工程學 > 土木與建築工程
工程學 > 市政與環境工程
参考文献
  1. 吳綱立(2006)。從西方近代都市設計思潮的發展看台灣都市設計專業的定位。建築學報，55，111-146。
    連結：
  2. 林世強(2013)。金門島嶼型災害特性及規模設定方法之探討。地理學報，69，1-24。
    連結：
  3. 林楨家,施亭伃(2007)。大眾運輸導向發展之建成環境對捷運運量之影響—臺北捷運系統之實證研究。運輸計劃季刊，36(4)，451-476。
    連結：
  4. 張學孔,呂英志(2009)。大眾運輸導向發展下運輸系統技術方案適用性之比較研究。都市與計劃，36(1)，51-79。
    連結：
  5. 郭幸萍,吳綱立(2013)。公私合夥觀點之古跡再利用委外經營決策影響因素之研究：多群體分析。建築學報，84，141-161。
    連結：
  6. Wikimedia Commons (2020a). The free media repository, Rouen TEOR route map ,File: Rouen-01.jpg , Wikimedia Commons, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Rouen-01.jpg/, July. 6, 2020.
  7. Wikimedia Commons (2020b). The free media repository, Almere public transport network map, File: Almere public transport network.svg, Wikimedia Commons, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Almere public transport network.svg, July. 12, 2020.
  8. Al-Harami, A.,Furlan, R.(2020).Qatar National Museum-Transit oriented development: The masterplan for the urban regeneration of a ‘green TOD’.Journal of Urban Management,9(1),115-136.
  9. Barton, H.(ed.)(2000).Sustainable Communities: The Potential for Eco-neighborhood.London:Earthscan.
  10. Bass, S.,Dalal-Calyton, B.(1995).Small Island and Sustainable Development.London:International Institute for Environment and Development.
  11. Beatley, T.(2001).Green Urbanism: Learning from European Cities.Washington:Island Press.
  12. Bernick, M.,Cervero, R.(1996).Transit Villages in the 21st Century.New York:McGraw-Hill.
  13. Bezai, N. E.,Medjdoub, B.,Al-Habaibeh, A.,Chalal, M. L.,Fadli, F.(2021).Future cities and autonomous vehicles: Analysis of the barriers to full adoption.Energy and Built Environment,2(1),65-81.
  14. Burby, R. J.(ed.)(1998).Cooperating with Nature: Confronting Natural Hazards with Land-Use Planning for Sustainable Communities.Washington, D.C.:Joseph Henry Press.
  15. Bus Planer (2017). CONNEXXION ALMERE , ALMERE public bus photo, Bus-planet, https://www.bus-planet.com/home/aworldofbuses/buses-in-europe/netherlands/nl-for mer-op/connexxion-almere/, Dec. 10, 2017.
  16. Calado, H.,Quintela, A.,Porteiro, J.(2007).Integrated coastal zone management strategies on small islands.Journal of Coastal Research,50,125-129.
  17. Calthorpe, P.(2011).Urbanism in the Age of Climate Change.Washington, D.C.:Island Press.
  18. Calthorpe, P.(1993).The Next American Metropolis: Ecology, Community, and the American Dream.New York:Princeton Architectural Press.
  19. Cervero, R.(1998).The Transit Metropolis: A Global Inquiry.Washington, D.C.:Island Press.
  20. Cervero, R.,Dai, D.(2014).BRT TOD: Leveraging transit oriented development with bus rapid transit investments.Transport Policy,36,127-138.
  21. Cervero, R.,Ferrell, C.,Murphy, S.(2002).,Washington, D.C.:Transportation Research Board, National Research Council.
  22. Cervero, R.,Kockelman, K.(1997).Travel demand and the 3Ds: Density, diversity, and design.Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment,2(3),199-219.
  23. Cervero, R.,Landis, J.(1995).The transportation-land use connection still matters.Access,7,2-10.
  24. Cervero, R.,Murakami, J.(2008).,Institute of Transportation Studies, University of California Berkeley.
  25. Cervero, R.,Sullivan, C.(2011).Green TODs: Marrying transit-oriented development and green urbanism.International Journal of Sustainable Development & World Ecology,18(3),210-218.
  26. Cervero, R.,Wu, K. L.(1998).Sub-centering and commuting: Evidence from the San Francisco Bay area, 1980-90.Urban Studies,35(7),1059-1076.
  27. Cornet, H.,Stadler, S.,Kong, P.,Marinkovic, G.,Frenkler, F.,Sathikh, P. M.(2019).User-centred design of autonomous mobility for public transportation in Singapore.Transportation Research Procedia,41,191-203.
  28. Diemer, M. J.,Currie, G.,De Gruyter, C.,Hopkins, I.(2018).Filling the space between trams and place: Adapting the ‘Movement & Place’ framework to Melbourne's tram network.Journal of Transport Geography,70,215-227.
  29. Dittmar, H.,Ohland, G.(2004).The New Transit Town: Best Practice in Transit-Oriented Development.Washington, D.C.:Island Press.
  30. Dramsatd, W. E.,Olson, J. D.,Forman, R. T.(1996).Landscape Ecology Principles in Landscape Architecture and Land-Use Planning.Washington, D.C.:Island Press.
  31. Economist Intelligence Unit=EIU(2017).,Economist Intelligence Unit.
  32. Economist Intelligence Unit=EIU(2021).,Economist Intelligence Unit.
  33. Engwicht, D.(1992).Towards an Eco-city: Calming the Traffic.Sydney:Envirobook.
  34. Faisal, A.,Yigitcanlar, T.,Kamruzzaman, M.,Currie, G.(2019).Understanding autonomous vehicles: A systematic literature review on capability, impact, planning and policy.Journal of Transport and Land Use,12(1),45-72.
  35. Gardiner, K.,Heller, A.(2008).Green Design at Any Size: Urban Heat Island Effect & TOD.San Francisco:Kevin Gardiner & Associates.
  36. Hall, P.(1982).Great Planning Disasters.Berkeley:University of California Press.
  37. Hanson, S.(ed.)(1995).The Geography of Urban Transportation.New York:The Guilford Press.
  38. Hasan, U.,Whyte, A.,AI-Jassmi, H.(2019).A life-cycle decision-making framework to assess the need for autonomous mobility.Transportation Research Procedia,42,32-43.
  39. Hess, A. L.(1990).Overview: Sustainable development and environmental management of small islands.Sustainable Development and Environmental Management of Small Islands,Paris:
  40. Huang, W.,Wey, W. M.(2019).Green urbanism embedded in TOD for urban built environment planning and design.Sustainability,11(19),5293.
  41. Jacobson, J.,Forsyth, A.(2008).Seven American TODs: Good practices for urban design in Transit-Oriented Development projects.Journal of Transportation and Land Use,1(2),51-88.
  42. Jeffrey, D.,Boulangé, C.,Giles-Corti, B.,Washington, S.,Gunn, L.(2019).Using walkability measures to identify train stations with the potential to become transit oriented developments located in walkable neighbourhoods.Journal of Transport Geography,76,221-231.
  43. Kuzio, J.(2021).Autonomous vehicles and paratransit: Examining the protective framework of the Americans with Disabilities Act.Case Studies on Transport Policy,9(3),1130-1140.
  44. Leatherman, S. P.,Beller-Simms, N.(1997).Sea-level rise and small island states: An overview.Journal of Coastal Research,24,1-16.
  45. Lindau, L. A.,Hidalgo, D.,Facchini, D.(2010).Curitiba, the cradle of bus rapid transit.Built Environment,36(3),274-282.
  46. Liu, H.(2020).Robot Systems for Rail Transit Applications.Oxford:Elsevier.
  47. Lynott, J.,Zimmerman, M.,Happ, P.(2017).Communities Are Embracing Development Near Transit: A Snapshot of Transit-Oriented Development Support Across the United States.Washington:AARP Public Policy Institute.
  48. Marshall, S.(1999).Restraining mobility while maintaining accessibility: An impression of the city of sustainable growth.Built Environment,25(2),168-179.
  49. Metro of Rouen (2020), Metro of Rouen transport route map, Metro of Rouen, https://mapametro.com/en/france/rouen/rouen-metro-map.htm/, June. 7, 2020.
  50. Moughtin, C.(1996).Urban Design: Green Dimensions.Oxford:Department of Urban Design, University of Norttingham.
  51. Mouratidis, K.,Cobeña Serrano, V.(2021).Autonomous buses: Intentions to use, passenger experiences, and suggestions for improvement.Transportation Research Part F: Traffic Psychology and Behaviour,76,321-335.
  52. Nesheli, M. M.,Li, L.,Palm, M.,Shalaby, A.(2021).Driverless shuttle pilots: Lessons for automated transit technology deployment.Case Studies on Transport Policy,9(2),723-742.
  53. Newman, P.(1992).The compact city: An Australian perspective.Built Environment,18(4),285-300.
  54. Newman, P.,Beatley, T.,Boyer, H.(2009).Resilient Cities: Responding to Peak Oil and Climate Change.Washington, DC:Island Press.
  55. Pickrell, D.(1989).Urban Rail Transit Projects: Forecast versus Actual Ridership and Costs.Cambridge, MA:Volpe Center, US Department of Transportation.
  56. Rau, A.,Tian, L.,Jain, M.,Xie, M.,Liu, T.,Zhou, Y.(2019).Dynamic autonomous road transit (DART) for use-case capacity more than bus.Transportation Research Procedia,41,812-823.
  57. Roseland, M.(1992).Toward Sustainable Communities: A Resource Book for Municipal and Local Government.Ottawa:The National Round Table on the Environment and the Economy.
  58. Saaty, T. L.(1980).The Analytic Hierarchy Process.New York:McGraw-Hill.
  59. Southworth, M.(2005).Designing the walkable city.Journal of Urban Planning and Development,131(4),246-257.
  60. Sun, S.,Wong, Y. D.,Liu, X.,Rau, A.(2020).Exploration of an integrated automated public transportation system.Transportation Research Interdisciplinary Perspectives,8,100275.
  61. Suzuki, H.,Cervero, R.,Iuchi, K.(2013).Transforming Cities with Transit: Transit and Land-Use Integration for Sustainable Urban Development.Washington, D.C.:World Bank.
  62. U.S. Department of Transportation=US DOT(1989).A Guide to Land Use and Public Transportation.Washington:US Department of Transportation.
  63. Urban Redevelopment Authority of Singapore (2020). Planning, A Singapore Government Agency Website, http://www.ura.gov.sg/corporate/planning, June. 6. 2020.
  64. Van der Ryn, S.,Calthorpe, P.(1986).Sustainable Communities: A New Design Synthesis for Cities, Suburbs and Towns.San Francisco:Sierra Club Book.
  65. Webber, M. W.(1976).The BART Experience-what Have We Learned?.Berkeley:Institute of Urban and Regional Development, UC Berkeley.
  66. Wheeler, S.(2004).Planning for Sustainability: Creating Livable, Equitable, and Ecological Communities.New York:Routledge.
  67. Wu, K. L.(2017).,Taipei:Ministry of Science and Technology of Taiwan.
  68. Yang, K.,Pojani, D.(2017).A decade of transit oriented development policies in Brisbane, Australia: Development and land-use impacts.Urban Policy and Research,35(3),347-362.
  69. Zuk, M.,Carlton, I.(2015).Equitable Transit Oriented Development.Washington, D.C.:The Poverty & Race Research Action Council=PRRAC.
  70. 丁川,吳綱立,林姚宇(2015)。美國 TOD 理念發展背景及歷程解析。城市規劃，39(5)，89-96。
  71. 內政部建築研究所(2012).綠建築評估手冊—社區類.臺北:內政部建築研究所.
  72. 王祝根,昆廷 ‧ 史蒂文森,李曉蕾(2018)。墨爾本人性化城市設計 30 年發展歷程解讀。國際城市規劃，33(2)，111-119。
  73. 吳綱立(2019).CFD 模擬分析應用於建築及城市通風設計.臺北:五南圖書公司.
  74. 吳綱立(2009).永續生態社區規劃設計的理論與實踐.臺北:詹氏書局.
  75. 吳綱立(1998)。大眾捷運系統對都會區發展之影響：加州舊金山灣區捷運（BART）與台北捷運經驗的啟示。第三屆海峽兩岸都市（新市鎮）公共工程學術暨實務研討會論文集，臺北:
  76. 吳綱立,Cervero, R.,蔡育新(2002)。大眾運輸導向發展理念整合於都市發展管理之研究：美國經驗與台灣經驗之比較。中華民國運輸學會第 17 屆論文研討會光碟版論文集，臺北:
  77. 吳綱立,王成芳(2016)。大眾捷運系統能引導都市及區域發展嗎—美國加州舊金山灣區捷運（BART）與都市發展 40 年經驗的回顧及其對中國的啟示。住宅學會年會論文集
  78. 吳綱立,徐肇章,李子耀(2009).高雄市區鐵路地下化站區新生地都市設計開發策略規劃案總結報告書.高雄:高雄市政府.
  79. 吳綱立,單樑(2014)。,黑龍江:哈工大—伯克利大學聯合可持續城市發展研究中心。
  80. 宋俊煥、出口敦(2013)。TOD の観点からみた東京 30KM 圏鉄道駅周辺地区の評価と類型。日本建築學會計畫系論文集，78(684)，413-420。
  81. 那霸空港（2020），那霸空港單軌捷運路線圖，「那霸空港網站」，https://www.naha-airport.co.jp/zh-hant/access/monorail，2020 年 6 月 12 日。
  82. 林國顯,蘇振維,呂怡青,劉昭榮,張學孔,洪鈞澤,鄭永祥,賴勇成,孫以濬(2010).研提推動大眾捷運系統建設與營運永續發展機制之研究.臺北:交通部運輸研究所.
  83. 林憲德(2011).亞洲觀點的綠色建築.臺北:詹氏書局.
  84. 金門縣政府(2011).金門縣概念性總體規劃報告.金門:金門縣政府.
  85. 科進栢誠工程顧問公司(2020)。科進栢誠工程顧問公司（2020），「臺南市先進運輸系統第一期藍線綜合規劃及環境影響評估 ( 第一階段 ) 技術報告」，臺南：臺南市政府。
  86. 張學孔(2020)。高齡智慧行動之數位生活環境發展景。國土及公共治理季刊，8(1)，68-79。
print cancel