「組織內與組織間治理」的本質與策略意涵

Intra-and Inter-organizational Governance: The Nature and Strategic Implications

10.6226/NTURM2013.MAR.OG

莊正民(Cheng-Min Chuang)；方世杰(Shih-Chieh Fang)

組織治理 ； 雙元治理 ； 治理策略 ； organizational governance ； dual governance ； governance for strategy

臺大管理論叢

23卷S1期（2013 / 04 / 01）

1 - 24

繁體中文

有關「治理」的概念，一直都是組織研究學者持續關注的課題，治理問題之存在，本質上乃基於組織內與組織間分工、並進行交換與生產活動，所必然衍生之管理課題。唯由於「治理」所涉及之研究領域與課題極廣，長期以來組織研究學者對於此一概念之理論與實務意涵，尚未有一致之共識。建立在組織經濟學之基礎上，本文將以組織內與組織間之交換與生產活動為主軸，嘗試釐清組織研究學者所稱「組織治理」之本質與理論意涵。此外，本文亦將進一步以組織策略研究領域為例，論述「治理」之策略性觀點及其在策略課題研究之角色，進而簡要地概述本專刊所刊登五篇論文之組織治理議題的內涵與理論邏輯。最後，則針對專刊論文並未涉獵，唯對未來具潛力之研究議題，提出研究主題與方向上之建議與結論。

Regarding the idea of ”governance” is still attracting continuously concerns by researchers of organization studies. The existence of governance problems derived from the division of labor, exchange and production activities within and between organizations. Owing to the scope of governance related research fields and issues is broad, there is no consistent agreement about the theoretical and practical implications of governance for a long time. Based on organizational economics, this paper tries to clarify the nature and theoretical background of organization governance by the perspectives of exchange and production activities within and between organizations. Moreover, this paper further discusses the strategic perspectives of governance and the role of governance in strategy research to introduce the content and theoretical logics of organization governance issues in the five published paper of this special issue. Finally, we provide suggestions and conclusion for future studies.

1. 方世杰(2008)。知識管理研究之本質：組織知識的統治。組織與管理，1(2)，1-35。
   連結：
2. 方世杰、王怡人、程運瑤(2012)。組織間統治的一般性策略。東吳經濟商學學報，76，1-32。
   連結：
3. Commons, J. 1932. The problem of correlating law, economics, and ethics. Wisconsin Law Review, 8: 3-26.
4. Amin, A.,Cohendet, P.(2000).Organizational learning and governance through embedded practice.Journal of Management and Governance,4(1/2),93-116.
5. Andrews, K.(1971).The concepts of corporate strategy.Homewood, IL:Dow Jones-Irwin.
6. Ansoff, H. I.(1965).Corporate strategy.New York, NY:McGraw Hill.
7. Argyres, N. S.,Felin, T.,Foss, N.,Zenger, T.(2012).Organizational economics of capability and heterogeneity.Organization Science,23(5),1213-1226.
8. Argyres, N. S.,Zenger, T. R.(2012).Capabilities, transaction costs, and firm boundaries.Organization Science,23(6),1643-1657.
9. Augier, M.,Kreine, K.,March, J. G.(2000).Introduction: Some roots and branches of organizational economics.Industrial and Corporate Change,9(4),555-565.
10. Barney, J. B.(1991).Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage.Journal of Management,17(1),99-120.
11. Bowman, C.,Ambrosini, V.(2000).Value creation versus value capture: Towards a coherent definition of value in strategy.British Journal of Management,11(1),1-15.
12. Brandenburger, A. M.,Nalebuff, B. J.(1997).Co-optition.New York, NY:Double Day.
13. Brandenburger, A. M.,Stuart, H. W., Jr.(1996).Value-based business strategy.Journal of Economics & Management Strategy,5(1),5-24.
14. Bridoux, F.,Coeurderoy, R.,Durand, R.(2011).Heterogeneous motives and the collective creation of value.Academy of Management Review,36(4),711-730.
15. Brown, J. S.,Duguid, P.(2001).Knowledge and organization: A social-practice perspective.Organization Science,12(2),198-213.
16. Buckley, P. J.,Carter, M. J.(2003).Governing knowledge sharing in multinational enterprises.Management International Review,43(3),7-25.
17. Carroll, G. R.(1993).A sociological view on why firms differ.Strategic Management Journal,14(4),237-249.
18. Caves, R. E.(2000).Creative industries: Contracts between art and commerce.Cambridge, MA:Harvard University Press.
19. Chatain, O.(2010).Value creation, competition, and performance in buyersupplier relationships.Strategic Management Journal,32(1),76-102.
20. Chatain, O.,Zemsky, P.(2011).Value creation and value capture with frictions.Strategic Management Journal,32(11),1206-1231.
21. Chi, T.(1994).Trading in strategic resource: Necessary conditions, transaction cost problems and choice of exchange structure.Strategic Management Journal,15(4),271-290.
22. Clegg, S. R.(Ed.),Hardy, C.(Ed.),Nord, W. R.(Ed.)(1996).Handbook of organization studies.London, UK:Sage Publications.
23. Conner, K. R.(1991).A historical comparison of resource-based theory and five schools of thought within industrial organizational economics: Do we have a new theory of the firm?.Journal of Management,17(1),121-154.
24. Conner, K. R.,Prahalad, C. K.(1996).A resourcebased theory of the firm: Knowledge versus opportunism.Organization Science,7(5),477-501.
25. Cyert, R. M.,March, J. G.(1963).A behavioral theory of the firm.Englewood Cliffs, NJ:Prentice-Hall.
26. Dalton, D. R.,Daily, C. M.,Ellstrand, A. E.,Johnson, J. L.(1998).Meta-analytic reviews of board composition, leadership structure, and financial performance.Strategic Management Journal,19(3),269-290.
27. Davis, J. H.,Schoorman, F. D.,Donaldson, L.(1997).Toward a stewardship theory of management.Academy of Management Review,22(1),20-47.
28. Donaldson, T.(2012).The epistemic fault line in corporate governance.Academy of Management Review,37(2),256-271.
29. Dosi, G.,Levinthal, D. A.,Marengo, L.(2003).Bridging contested terrain: Linking incentive-based and learning perspectives on organizational evolution.Industrial and Corporate Change,12(2),413-436.
30. Dosi, G.,Marengo, L.(2000).On the tangled discourse between transaction cost economics and competence-based views of the firm: Some comments.Competence, governance, and entrepreneurship,New York, NY:
31. Dyer, J. H.(1996).Does governance matter? Keiretsu alliances and asset specificity as sources of Japanese competitive advantage.Organization Science,7(6),649-666.
32. Dyer, J. H.(1997).Effective interfirm collaboration: How firms minimize transaction costs and maximize transaction value.Strategic Management Journal,18(7),535-556.
33. Dyer, J. H.,Singh, H.(1998).The relational view: Cooperative strategy and sources of interorganizational competitive advantage.Academy of Management Review,23(4),660-679.
34. Dyer, J. H.,Singh, H.,Kale, P.(2008).Splitting the pie: Rent distribution in alliances and networks.Managerial and Decision Economics,29(2),137-148.
35. Filatotchev, I.,Wright, M.(2011).Agency perspectives on corporate governance of multinational enterprises.Journal of Management Studies,48(2),471-486.
36. Fiss, P. C.(2007).A set-theoretic approach to organizational configurations.Academy of Management Review,32(4),1180-1198.
37. Foss, N.,Mahnke, V.(2000).Competence, governance, and entrepreneurship.New York, NY:Oxford University Press.
38. Foss, N.,Michailova, S.(2009).Knowledge governance: Processes and perspectives.New York, NY:Oxford University Press.
39. Ghoshal, S.,Moran, P.(1996).Bad for practice: a critique of the transaction cost theory.Academy of Management Review,21(1),13-47.
40. Grandori, A.(2001).Neither hierarchy nor identity: Knowledge-governance mechanisms and the theory of the firm.Journal of Management and Governance,5(3/4),381-399.
41. Grant, R. M.(1996).Toward a knowledge-based theory of the firm.Strategic Management Journal,17(7),109-122.
42. Gulati, R.,Singh, H.(1998).The architecture of cooperation: Managing coordination costs and appropriation concerns in strategic alliances.Administrative Science Quarterly,43(4),781-814.
43. Gulati, R.,Wang, L. O.(2003).Size of the pie and share of the pie: Implications of network embeddedness and business relatedness for value creation and value appropriation in joint ventures.The Governance of Relations in Markets and Organizations Research in the Sociology of Organizations,20,209-242.
44. Hambrick, D. C.,Werder, A.,Zajac, E. J.(2008).New directions in corporate governance research.Organization Science,19(3),381-385.
45. Heide, J. B.(1994).Interorganizational governance in marketing channels.Journal of Marketing,58(1),71-85.
46. Hillman, A. J.,Dalziel, T.(2003).Boards of directors and firm performance: Integrating agency and resource dependence perspectives.Academy of Management Review,28(3),383-396.
47. Hodgson, G. M.(1998).Competence and contract in the theory of the firm.Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization,35(2),179-201.
48. Hoetker, G.,Mellewigt, T.(2009).Choice and performance of governance mechanisms: Matching alliance governance to asset type.Strategic Management Journal,30(10),1025-1044.
49. Inkpen, A. C.,Currall, S. C.(2004).The coevolution of trust, control, and learning in joint ventures.Organization Science,15(5),586-599.
50. Jacobides, M. G.,Winter, S. G.(2005).The co-evolution of capabilities and transaction costs: Explaining the institutional structure of production.Strategic Management Journal,26(5),395-413.
51. Kim, W. C.,Mauborgne, R.(2004).Blue ocean strategy.Harvard Business Review,82(10),76-84.
52. Kivleniece, I.,Quelin, B. V.(2012).Creating and capturing value in public-private ties: A private actor's perspective.Academy of Management Review,37(2),272-299.
53. Kogut, B.,Zander, U.(1992).Knowledge of the firm, combinative capabilities, and the replication of technology.Organization Science,3(3),383-397.
54. Koschmann, M. A.,Kuhn, T. R.,Pfarrer, M. D.(2012).A communicative framework of value in cross-sector partnerships.Academy of Management Review,37(3),332-354.
55. Koza, M. P.,Lewin, A. Y.(1998).The coevolution of strategic alliances.Organization Science,9(3),255-264.
56. Langlois, R.,Foss, N. J.(1999).Capabilities and governance: The rebirth of production in the theory of economic organization.Kyklos,52(2),201-218.
57. Lavie, D.(2007).Alliance portfolios and firm performance: A study of value creation and appropriation in the U.S. software industry.Strategic Management Journal,28(12),1187-1212.
58. Lee, S. H.,Peng, M. W.,Barney, J. B.(2007).Bankruptcy law and entrepreneurship development: A real options perspective.Academy of Management Review,32(1),257-272.
59. Lepak, D. P.,Smith, K. G.,Taylor, M. S.(2007).Value creation and value capture: A multilevel perspective.Academy of Management Review,32(1),180-194.
60. Madhok, A.(2002).Reassessing the fundamentals and beyond: Ronald coase, the transaction cost and resource-based theories of the firm and the institutional structure of production.Strategic Management Journal,23(6),535-550.
61. Mahoney, J. T.(2005).Economic foundations of strategy.Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage Publications.
62. Mahoney, J. T.,McGahan, A. M.,Pitelis, C. N.(2009).The interdependence of private and public interests.Organization Science,20(6),1034-1052.
63. Makadok, R.,Coff, R.(2002).The theory of value and the value of theory: Breaking new ground versus reinventing the wheel.Academy of Management Review,27(1),10-13.
64. Mayer, K. J.,Salomon, R. M.(2006).Capabilities, contractual hazards, and governance: Integrating resource-based and transaction cost perspectives.Academy of Management Journal,49(5),942-959.
65. Meyer, A. D.,Tsui, A. S.,Hinings, C. R.(1993).Configurational approaches to organizational analysis.Academy of Management Review,36(6),1175-1195.
66. Miller, D.(1996).Configurations revisited.Strategic Management Journal,17(7),505-512.
67. Monge, P. R.,Fulk, J.,Kalman, M. E.,Flanagin, A. J.,Parnassa, C.,Rumsey, S.(1998).Production of collective action in alliance-based interorganizational communication and information systems.Organization Science,9(3),411-433.
68. Nelson, R. R.,Winter, S. G.(1982).An evolutionary theory of economic change.Cambridge, MA:Belknap Press.
69. Nickerson, J. A.,Zenger, T.(2004).A knowledge-based theory of the firm: The problem-solving perspective.Organization Science,15(6),617-632.
70. Nooteboom, B.(2004).Governance and competence: How can they be combined?.Cambridge Journal of Economics,28(4),505-525.
71. Parkhe, A.(1993).Strategic alliance structuring: A game theoretic and transaction cost examination of interfirm cooperation.Academy of Management Journal,36(4),794-829.
72. Parvinen, P.,Tikkanen, H.(2007).Incentives asymmetries in the mergers and acquisitions process.Journal of Management Studies,44(5),759-787.
73. Penrose, E. T.(1959).The theory of the growth of the firm.Oxford, UK:Basil Blackwood.
74. Peteraf, M. A.(1993).The cornerstones of competitive advantage: A resource-based view.Strategic Management Journal,14(3),179-192.
75. Peteraf, M. A.,Barney, J. B.(2003).Unraveling the resource-based tangle.Managerial and Decision Economics,24(4),309-323.
76. Pitelis, C. N.(2009).The co-evolution of organizational value capture, value creation and sustainable advantage.Organization Studies,30(10),1115-1139.
77. Pitelis, C. N.,Teece, D. J.(2009).The (new) nature and essence of the firm.European Management Review,6(1),5-15.
78. Porter, M. E.(1980).Competitive strategy.New York, NY:Free Press.
79. Porter, M. E.(1985).Competitive advantage: Creating and sustaining superior performance.New York, NY:Free Press.
80. Powell, W. W.,Kogut, K. W.,Smith-Doerr, L.(1996).Interorganizational collaboration and locus of innovation: Networks of learning in biotechnology.Administrative Science Quarterly,41(1),285-307.
81. Rangan, S.,Samii, R.,Van Wassenhove, L. N.(2006).Constructive partnerships: When alliances between private firms and public actors can enable creative strategies.Academy of Management Review,31(3),738-751.
82. Rindfleisch, A.,Heide, J. B.(1997).Transaction cost analysis: Past, present, and future applications.Journal of Marketing,61(4),30-54.
83. Rufín, C.,Rivera-Santos, M.(2012).Between commonweal and competition: Understanding the governance of public-private partnerships.Journal of Management,38(5),1634-1654.
84. Santos, F. M.,Eisenhardt, K. M.(2005).Organizational boundaries and theories of organization.Organization Science,16(5),491-508.
85. Sobrero, M.,Schrader, S.(1998).Structuring inter-firm relationships: A metaanalytic approach.Organization Studies,19(4),585-615.
86. Subramani, M. R.,Venkatraman, N.(2003).Safeguarding investments in asymmetric interorganizational relationships: Theory and evidence.Academy of Management Journal,46(1),46-62.
87. Szulanski, G.(1996).Exploring internal stickiness: Impediments to the transfer of best practice within the firm.Strategic Management Journal,17(Winter),27-43.
88. Tsoukas, H.(1994).Book reviews: Sociology and organization theory: Positivism, paradigms, and postmodernity.Journal of Management Science,31(2),287-291.
89. Wang, L.,Zajac, E. J.(2007).Alliance or acquisition? A dyadic perspective on interfirm resource combinations.Strategic Management Journal,28(13),1291-1317.
90. Wassmer, U.,Dussauge, P.(2011).Value creation in alliance portfolios: The benefits and costs of network resource interdependencies.European Management Review,8(1),47-64.
91. Williamson, O. E.(1999).Strategy research: Governance and competence perspectives.Strategic Management Journal,20(12),1087-1108.
92. Williamson, O. E.(2005).The economics of governance.American Economic Review,95(2),1-18.
93. Williamson, O. E.(1985).The economic institutions of capitalism.New York, NY:Free Press.
94. Williamson, O. E.(1991).Comparative economic organization: An analysis of discrete structural alternatives.Administrative Science Quarterly,36(2),269-296.
95. Wolter, C.,Veloso, F.(2008).The effects of innovation on vertical structure: Perspectives on transaction costs and competences.Academy of Management Review,33(3),586-605.
96. Zajac, E. J.,Olsen, C. P.(1993).From transaction cost to transactional value analysis: Implications for the study of interorganizational strategies.Journal of Management Studies,30(1),131-145.
97. Zenger, T. R.,Felin, T.,Bigelow, L.(2011).Theories of the firm-market boundary.The Academy of Management Annals,5(1),89-133.
98. 莊正民、方世杰(2005)。策略觀點之組織間關係管理的研究。關係管理研究，創刊號，85-114。

1. 嚴玉華、方世杰、嚴玉華、方世杰、嚴玉華、方世杰(2014)。資訊揭露透明度與醫院治理效能：一代健保與二代健保比較研究。臺灣公共衛生雜誌，33(2)，131-147。
2. 楊舒蜜、周家慧、方世榮、方世杰(2015)。競合關係的關係學習與關係利益：關係張力之調節。組織與管理，8(2)，1-41。