改良式管顧練習個案教學法對學生批判性思考意向與學習興趣的影響

The Effect of Adopting Case Method with the Modified Consulting Exercise on Students' Critical Thinking Disposition and Learning Interest

10.6226/NTUMR.202212_32(3).0002

陳玉麟(Yu-Lin Chen)；黃美珠(Mei-Chu Huang)

改良式管顧練習個案教學法 ； 批判性思考意向 ； 學習興趣 ； 管理會計 ； 技職教育 ； Case Method with the Modified Consulting Exercise ； critical thinking disposition ； learning interest ； managerial accounting ； technological and vocational education

臺大管理論叢

32卷3期（2022 / 12 / 01）

35 - 77

繁體中文;英文

本研究報導與分析一項教學實驗的結果。某科技大學修習管理會計的學生參與此項實驗並分派到下列三組之一：教師單向講授法（簡稱講授法）、傳統個案教學法與改良式管顧練習個案教學法。實驗結果發現，施以改良式管顧練習個案教學法，在學生批判性思考意向以及學習興趣之提升上，皆優於其餘兩種方法。然而，施以傳統個案教學法與施以講授法之間，並未發現顯著的差異。

This study reports and analyzes the results of a teaching experiment involving undergraduate students taking managerial accounting course at a university under the technological and vocational education system in Taiwan. The same instructor teaches the same course in three different teaching methods, namely lectures, traditional case method, and Case Method with the Modified Consulting Exercise (CMMCE). Our results indicate that adopting CMMCE improves students' learning effectiveness significantly in terms of critical thinking disposition and learning interest when compared with the other two conditions. However, we find no significant difference r between students taught in the traditional case method and in lectures.

1. 王居卿, Chu-Ching(2000)。影響訓練成效相關因素模式之實證研究：認知及多變量的觀點。臺大管理論叢，10(2)，135-166。
   連結：
2. 王瑤芬, Yao-Fen,陳素萍, Su-Ping,李宜靜, Yi-Ching(2016)。大學餐旅教育實施綠色餐飲課程之教學成效。課程與教學季刊，19(3)，165-204。
   連結：
3. 林建良, Chien-Liung,蔡俊彥, Chun-Yen(2020)。高中科技課程翻轉教學對學習知覺效果的性別差異。科學教育學刊，28(1)，1-23。
   連結：
4. 范凱棠, Kai-Tang,林昱成, Yu-Cheng(2011)。創造性問題解決個案教學法對管理會計教學成效之研究。會計評論，53，75-107。
   連結：
5. 徐綺穗, Chi-Sui(2012)。大學教學的創新模式－「行動－反思」教學對大學生學習成就、批判性思考意向及學業情緒影響之研究。課程與教學季刊，15(1)，119-150。
   連結：
6. 許艷, Yan,彭耀平, Yao-Ping,唐資文, Tzy-Wen,鄧天強,李慶章, Ching-Chang(2020)。以「察覺－動機－能力」觀點與「網絡關係觀點」初探「新南向政策」對企業國際化歷程之影響：以餐飲服務產業個案為例。臺大管理論叢，30(3)，1-44。
   連結：
7. 陳敦源, Don-Yun,許弘毅, Hung-Yi,史美強, Mei-Chiang,李翠萍, Tsuey-Ping,陳序廷, Shiu-Ting(2019)。個案教學是公共管理專業訓練的未來嗎？一個來自實驗研究的循證論述。文官制度季刊，11(4)，21-71。
   連結：
8. 陳麗華, Li-Hua,李涵鈺, Han-Yu,林陳涌, Chen-Yung(2004)。國內批判思考測驗工具及其應用之分析。課程與教學季刊，7(2)，1-24。
   連結：
9. 黃志雄, Chih-Hshing(2017)。翻轉教室模式在大學課程中的實踐與反思。師資培育與教師專業發展期刊，10(1)，1-30。
   連結：
10. 葉丙成, Ping-Cheng(2015)。如何確保翻轉教學的成功？ BTS 翻轉教學法。中等教育，66(2)，30-43。
    連結：
11. 鄭瑞洲, Jui-Chou,洪振方, Jeng-Fung,黃臺珠, Tai-Chu(2016)。透過情境興趣教學策略促進高一學生之遺傳學學習。科學教育學刊，24(2)，115-137。
    連結：
12. 鄭瑞洲, Jui-Chou,洪振方, Jeng-Fung,黃臺珠, Tai-Chu(2016)。透過情境興趣教學策略促進高一學生之遺傳學學習。科學教育學刊，24(2)，115-137。
    連結：
13. 鄭瑞洲, Jui-Chou,洪振方, Jeng-Fung,黃臺珠, Tai-Chu(2013)。採用多元教學策略的非制式奈米課程對國中生情境興趣之促進。教育實踐與研究，26(2)，1-28。
    連結：
14. 謝進昌, Jin-Chang(2012)。不同實驗設計之標準化平均數差異效果量整合探討。國立屏東教育大學學報：教育類，38，57-92。
    連結：
15. 顏信輝, Sin-Hui,杜榮瑞, Rong-Ruey(2008)。改良式結構性爭論教學法對會計學生溝通憂懼之影響：探索性研究。臺大管理論叢，19(1)，127-156。
    連結：
16. 羅寶鳳, Pao-Feng(2016)。學教翻轉：翻轉課堂的課程與教學。課程與教學季刊，19(4)，1-21。
    連結：
17. Anderson, L. W.,Krathwohl, D. R.,Airasian, P. W.,Cruikshank, K. A.,Mayer, R. E.,Pintrich, P. R.,Rath, J.,Wittrock, M. C.(2001).A Taxonomy for Learning, Teaching, and Assessing: A Revision of Bloom’s Taxonomy of Educational Objectives.New York, NY:Longman.
18. Barnes, L. B.,Christensen, C. R.,Hansen, A. J.(1994).Teaching and the Case Method: Text, Cases, and Readings.Boston, MA:Harvard Business School Press.
19. Bergmann, J.,Sams, A.(2012).Flip Your Classroom: Reach Every Student in Every Class Every Day.Washington, DC:International Society for Technology in Education.
20. Blumenthal, J.(1991).Use of the case method in MBA education.Performance Improvement Quarterly,4(1),5-13.
21. Chai, C. S.,Deng, F.,Tsai, P. S.,Koh, J. H. L.,Tsai, C. C.(2015).Assessing multidimensional students’ perceptions of twenty-first-century learning practices.Asia Pacific Education Review,16(3),389-398.
22. Chang, S. C.,Hsu, T. C.,Jong, M. S. Y.(2020).Integration of the peer assessment approach with a virtual reality design system for learning earth science.Computers & Education,146,Article 103758.
23. Chen, M. R. A.,Hwang, G. J.(2020).Effects of a concept mapping‐based flipped learning approach on EFL students’ English speaking performance, critical thinking awareness and speaking anxiety.British Journal of Educational Technology,51(3),817-834.
24. Clark, K. R.(2015).The effects of the flipped model of instruction on student engagement and performance in the secondary mathematics classroom.Journal of Educators Online,12(1),91-115.
25. Dean, K. L.,Fornaciari, C. J.(2002).How to create and use experiential case-based exercises in a management classroom.Journal of Management Education,26(5),586-603.
26. Duch, B. J.(2001).Models for problem-based instruction in undergraduate courses.The Power of Problem-Based Learning,Sterling, VA:
27. Ebbinghaus, H. 1913. Memory: A Contribution to Experimental Psychology. New York, NY: Teachers College, Columbia University.
28. Ennis, R. H.(1996).Critical thinking dispositions: Their nature and assessability.Informal Logic,18(2),165-182.
29. Erzurumlu, S. S.,Rollag, K.(2013).Increasing student interest and engagement with business cases by turning them into consulting exercises.Decision Sciences Journal of Innovative Education,11(4),359-381.
30. Facione, P. A.,Facione, N. C.(1992).The California Critical Thinking Disposition Inventory (CCTDI).Millbrae, CA:California Academic Press.
31. Facione, P. A.,Sánchez, C. A.,Facione, N. C.,Gainen, J.(1995).The disposition toward critical thinking.The Journal of General Education,44(1),1-25.
32. Halpern, D. F.(1988).Assessing student outcomes for psychology majors.Teaching of Psychology,15(4),181-186.
33. Hamdan, N., McKnight, P. E., McKnight, K., and Arfstrom, K. M. 2013. The flipped learning model: A white paper based on the literature review titled a review of flipped learning. Flipped Learning Network. https://flippedlearning.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/WhitePaper_FlippedLearning.pdf
34. Harackiewicz, J. M.,Barron, K. E.,Tauer, J. M.,Carter, S. M.,Elliot, A. J.(2000).Short-term and long-term consequences of achievement goals: Predicting interest and performance over time.Journal of Educational Psychology,92(2),316-330.
35. Herreid, C. F.(2004).Can case studies be used to teach critical thinking?.Journal of College Science Teaching,33(6),12-14.
36. Herreid, C. F.,Schiller, N. A.(2013).Case studies and the flipped classroom.Journal of College Science Teaching,42(5),62-66.
37. Hidi, S.,Renninger, K. A.(2006).The four-phase model of interest development.Educational Psychologist,41(2),111-127.
38. Hoffman, E. S.(2014).Beyond the flipped classroom: Redesigning a research methods course for e3 instruction.Contemporary Issues in Education Research,7(1),51-62.
39. Hudgins, B. B.,Riesenmy, M.,Ebel, D.,Edelman, S.(1989).Children’s critical thinking: A model for its analysis and two examples.The Journal of Educational Research,82(6),327-339.
40. Kriger, M. P.(1990).The art and power of asking questions.Organizational Behavior Teaching Review,14(1),131-142.
41. Lai, H. M.(2021).Understanding what determines university students’ behavioral engagement in a group-based flipped learning context.Computers & Education,173,Article 104290.
42. Lee, Y. H.(2018).Scripting to enhance university students’ critical thinking in flipped learning: Implications of the delayed effect on science reading literacy.Interactive Learning Environments,26(5),569-582.
43. Lin, H. C.,Hwang, G. J.,Chang, S. C.,Hsu, Y. D.(2021).Facilitating critical thinking in decision making-based professional training: An online interactive peer-review approach in a flipped learning context.Computers & Education,173,Article 104266.
44. Linnenbrink-Garcia, L.,Durik, A. M.,Conley, A. M.,Barron, K. E.,Tauer, J. M.,Karabenick, S. A.,Harackiewicz, J. M.(2010).Measuring situational interest in academic domains.Educational and Psychological Measurement,70(4),647-671.
45. Miller, J. S.(2004).Problem-based learning in organizational behavior class: Solving students’ real problems.Journal of Management Education,28(5),578-590.
46. Mitchell, M.(1993).Situational interest: Its multifaceted structure in the secondary school mathematics classroom.Journal of Educational Psychology,85(3),424-436.
47. Norris, S. P.,Ennis, R. H.(1989).The practitioners’guide to teaching thinking series: Evaluating critical thinking.Pacific Grove, CA:Midwest Publications.
48. O’Connor, T. J.,Ruchala, L.V.(1998).A model for small-group writing labs in an accounting curriculum.Issues in Accounting Education,13(1),93-111.
49. Paul, R. W.(1993).The logic of creative and critical thinking.American Behavioral Scientist,37(1),21-39.
50. Rebele, J. E.,St. Pierre, E. K.(2019).A commentary on learning objectives for accounting education programs: The importance of soft skills and technical knowledge.Journal of Accounting Education,48,71-79.
51. Renninger, K. A.(Ed.),Hidi, S.(Ed.),Krapp, A.(Ed.)(1992).The Role of Interest in Learning and Development.Hillsdale, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc..
52. Renninger, K. A.,Hidi, S.(2002).Student interest and achievement: Developmental issues raised by a case study.Development of Achievement Motivation,New York, NY:
53. Schwartz, T. A.(2014).Flipping the statistics classroom in nursing education.Journal of Nursing Education,53(4),199-206.
54. Shiffler, R. E.(1988).Maximum Z score and outliers.The American Statistician,42(1),79-80.
55. Siegel, H.(1980).Critical thinking as an educational ideal.The Educational Forum,45(1),7-23.
56. Siegel, H.(1988).Rationality and epistemic dependence.Educational Philosophy and Theory,20(1),1-6.
57. Stout, D. E.(1996).Experiential evidence and recommendations regarding case-based teaching in undergraduate cost accounting.Journal of Accounting Education,14(3),293-317.
58. Strelan, P.,Osborn, A.,Palmer, E.(2020).The flipped classroom: A meta-analysis of effects on student performance across disciplines and education levels.Educational Research Review,30,Article 100314.
59. Sun, Z.,Xie, K.(2020).How do students prepare in the pre-class setting of a flipped undergraduate math course? A latent profile analysis of learning behavior and the impact of achievement goals.The Internet and Higher Education,46,Article 100731.
60. Sun, Z.,Xie, K.,Anderman, L. H.(2018).The role of self-regulated learning in students’ success in flipped undergraduate math courses.The Internet and Higher Education,36,41-53.
61. Tabachnick, B. G.,Fidell, L. S.(2013).Using Multivariate Statistics.Boston, MA:Pearson Education.
62. Tan, H. C.(2019).Using a structured collaborative learning approach in a case-based management accounting course.Journal of Accounting Education,49,Article 100638.
63. Tiwari, A.,Lai, P.,So, M.,Yuen, K.(2006).A comparison of the effects of problem‐based learning and lecturing on the development of students’ critical thinking.Medical Education,40(6),547-554.
64. Wolcott, S. K.,Baril, C. P.,Cunningham, B. M.,Fordham, D. R.,St. Pierre, K.(2002).Critical thought on critical thinking research.Journal of Accounting Education,20(2),85-103.
65. Wolcott, S. K.,Sargent, M. J.(2021).Critical thinking in accounting education: Status and call to action.Journal of Accounting Education,56,Article 100731.
66. Wynn-Williams, K.,Beatson, N.,Anderson, C.(2016).The impact of unstructured case studies on surface learners: A study of second-year accounting students.Accounting Education,25(3),272-286.
67. Yeh, Y. C.(2012).A co-creation blended KM model for cultivating critical-thinking skills.Computers & Education,59(4),1317-1327.
68. Yin, R. K.(1994).Discovering the future of the case study method in evaluation research.Evaluation Practice,15(3),283-290.
69. 司徒達賢, Dah-Hsian(2015).司徒達賢談個案教學：聽說讀想的修鍊.臺北,臺灣=Taipei, Taiwan:天下文化出版=Commonwealth Publishing Co., Ltd.
70. 肖澤忠, Ze-Zhong,周齊武, Chee-Wu,杜榮瑞, Rong-Ruey(2006)。臺灣會計教育之探討（四）－會計畢業生的知識技能與社會期待差距－加強產學溝通降低期待差距。會計研究月刊，242，74-82。
71. 周齊武, Chee-Wu,何莉芸, Joanna(1992)。整體架構在會計教育上的重要性及其培養。會計研究月刊，81，74-82。
72. 邱皓政, Haw-Jeng(2019).量化研究與統計分析：SPSS 與 R 資料分析範例解析.臺北,臺灣=Taipei, Taiwan:五南圖書出版股份有限公司=Wu-Nan Book Inc..
73. 許淑蓮, Sheila,林惠賢, Huey-Shyan,李明儀, Ming-Yi(2000)。技職體系二年制護理系學生批判思考能力之評估。醫學教育，4(4)，466-476。
74. 黃政傑, Jenq-Jye(2014)。翻轉教室的理念、問題與展望。臺灣教育評論月刊，3(12)，161-186。
75. 黃國禎, Gwo-Jen,伍柏翰, Po-Han,朱蕙君, Hui-Chun,葉丙成, Ping-Cheng,楊韶維, Shao-Wei,許庭嘉, Ting-Chia,王秀鶯, Xiu-Ying,洪駿命, Jun-Ming(2018).翻轉教室：理論,策略與實務.臺北,臺灣=Taipei, Taiwan:高等教育=Higher Education Press.
76. 楊雅婷, Ya-Ting(2005)。,未出版
77. 葉玉珠, Yu-Chu(1999)。代理（課）教師批判思考教學專業知識、個人教學效能及教學行為之現況及關係之研究。國立政治大學學報，78，55-84。
78. 劉常勇, Chang-Yung(1998)。管理教育中的個案教學。教育研究資訊，6(2)，101-114。