產品差異下的垂直整合分析

Vertical Integration under Product Differentiation

10.29628/AEP.200412.0003

王光正(Kuang-Cheng Andy Wang)；林俊宏(Chun-Hung A. Lin)；柯美如(Mei-Ju Ko)

垂直整合 ； 市場封殺 ； 連續雙佔 ； Vertical integration ； Market foreclosure ； Successive duopoly

經濟論文

32卷4期（2004 / 12 / 01）

573 - 603

繁體中文

本文以一連續雙佔模型(successive duopoly model)，分析當最終財商品異質下，垂直整合對中間財市場、最終財市場、獨立上游廠所面對的市場規模越小或兩商品的替代性越強時，垂直整合後，越不可能發生中間財的市場封殺(market foreclosure)，獨立下游廠的產量也越可能增加，而此最終財價格也越可能下降。第二，若垂直整合後未發生中間財的市場封殺，獨立上游廠的利潤必定下降。第三，當兩最終財商品為(完全)替代關係時，垂直整合仍可能使獨立下游廠利潤增加；當兩最終財商品為互補關係時，垂直整合仍可能使獨立下游廠利潤減少。第四、垂直整合的進行可能造成社會福利下降。

This paper uses a successive duopoly model, under the condition of product differentiation, to analyze the impacts of vertical integration on intermediate goods market and final goods market. It also discusses how vertical integration affects the upstream and downstream firms and social welfare. We find the following results. First, the smaller the market size which the nonintegrated downstream firm faces and the more substitutable the two final products are, the less possible it is to encounter market foreclosure after vertical integration. Thus, the production of a non-integrated downstream firm will be larger and the price of final goods will be lower. Second, if market foreclosure for intermediate goods does not happen after vertical integration, the profit of a non-integrated upstream firm will decrease. Third, it is possible for the profit of a non-integrated downstream firm to in crease after vertical integration if the two final goods are (perfect) substitutes; it is possible for the profit of non-integrated downstream firms to decrease after vertical integration if the two final goods are complements. Fourth, it is also possible for social welfare to decrease if the vertical integration takes place.

1. 吳世傑、黃鴻(2002)。關稅調升理論之經濟分析。經濟論文，30(2)，409-442。
   連結：
2. Abiru, M.,B. Nahata,S. Raychaudhuri,M. Waterson(1998).Equilibrium Structures in Vertical Oligopoly.Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization,37(4),463-480.
3. Chang, M.-H.(1992).Exclusive Dealing Contracts in a Successive Duopoly with Side Payments.Southern Economic Journal,59(2),180-198.
4. Damania, D.(1996).The Scope for Collusion and Competition in a Regulated Vertically Integrated Industry.Bulletin of Economic Research,48(3),253-264.
5. Greenhut, M. L.,H. Ohta(1979).Vertical Integration of Successive Oligopolists.American Economic Review,69(1),137-141.
6. Grossman, G. M,E. Helpman(1999).Incomplete Contracts and Industrial Organization.NBER Working Paper: 7303,7303,42.
7. Hamilton, J. L.,I. E. Mqasqas(1997).Direct Vertical Integration Strategies.Southern Economic Journal,64(1),220-234.
8. Hart, O.(1995).Firms, Contracts and Financial Structure.New York:Oxford University Press.
9. Higgins, R. S.(1999).Competitive Vertical Foreclosure.Managerial and Decision Economics,20(4),229-237.
10. Ishikawa, J.,B. J. Spencer(1999).Rent-Shifting Export Subsidies with an Inported Intermediate Product.Journal of Industrial Economics,48(2),199-232.
11. Lin, Y. J.(1988).Oligopoly and Vertical Integration: Note.American Economic Review,78(1),251-254.
12. Ordover, J. A.,G. Saloner,S. C. Salop(1990).Equilibrium Vertical Foreclosure.American Economic Review,80(1),127-142.
13. Salinger, M. A.(1988).Vertical Mergers and Market Foreclosure.Quarterly Journal of Economics,103(2),345-356.
14. Schmallensee, R.,R. D. Willig(1989).Handbook of Industrial Organization, Amsterdam.Netherlands:Elsevier Science Publishers Co. Press.
15. Schrader, A.,S. Martin(1998).Vertical Market Participation.Review of Industrial Organization,13(3),321-331.
16. Spencer, B. J.,R. W. Jones(1991).Vertical Foreclosure and International Trade Policy.Review of Economic Studies,58,153-170.
17. Spencer, B. J.,R. W. Jones(1992).Trade and Protection in Vertically Related Markets.Journal of International Economics,32,31-55.
18. Spengler, J.(1950).Vertical Integration and Antitrust Policy.Journal of Political Economy,58,347-352.
19. Weston, J. F.,K. S. Chung,J. A. Siu(1998).Takeovers, Restructuring, and Corporate Governance.New Jersey:Prentice-Hall Inc. Press.
20. 中華徵信所(1987)。臺灣地區產業年報(1987)—石化業。台北:中華徵信所企業股份有限公司。
21. 王光正、吳世傑(2003)。台灣經濟學會2003年會論文。
22. 吳大任、吳威達(1999)。上下游雙邊寡佔時垂直限制行為之規範。經濟論文叢刊，27(2)，159-184。
23. 張順教(2003)。高科技產業經濟分析。台北:雙葉書廊有限公司。

1. 溫偉任,黃文嫻,李文傑(2020)。Welfare-Improving Vertical Mergers in the Presence of Downstream Product Differentiation。經濟論文，48(4)，445-473。
2. (2024)。To Merge or to Help Related Firms Merge? Vertical Mergers in Cournot Oligopolies with Complementary Inputs。經濟論文，52(1)，1-35。