經濟學術期刊的分等與台灣各經濟學系所的學術表現

Rankings of Economics Institutions in Taiwan and Journals

10.29628/AEP.200609.0004

曹添旺(Tien-Wang Tsaur)；管中閔(Chung-Ming Kuan)；郭炳伸(Biing-Shen Kuo)；張峯嘉(Feng-Jia Chang)；陳致綱(Jhih-Gang Chen)

引用次數 ； 期刊分等 ； 系所排名 ； Citations ； Journal ranking ； Department ranking

經濟論文

34卷3期（2006 / 09 / 01）

391 - 433

繁體中文

本文研究1996-2003年間台灣35個經濟學術單位之466位專任研究或教學人員的論文發表統計。除了依期刊資料庫別（SSCI、SCI、EconLit與TSSCI）進行數量分析外，亦嘗試由主、客觀之方法建置一套同時符合國際學術標準與配合國內學術發展的核心期刊名單與分等級群。同時，我們亦依據此一名單進行國內學術單位論文發表之質量分析。研究結果發現：一、不論依資料庫別或期刊等級進行分析，國際期刊發表之分佈呈現明顯偏態現象，即國內之學術研究工作過度依賴少數學術單位或個人；二、在本文研究樣本期間內，有超過五成的專任研究或教學人員未有任何重要學術期刊發表之經驗；三、相較於新加坡國立大學、香港中文大學、香港科技大學的經濟系所與北京大學中國經濟研究中心，國內僅專司研究的中研院經濟所與中研院社科所經濟組在整體學術表現上能與之相提並論。然而，國內教學單位之研究成果與該些華人系所仍存在一段不小的差距。

This study conducts a comprehensive ranking of academic institutions in Taiwan that produced scientific research from 1996 to 2003 in the commonly used economics journal indices. The output ranking is primarily based on a particular ranking of a set of core journals, a by-product from the study, which emphasizes citation information. Our investigations reveal that regardless of which index is employed, the distribution of the international publications are very left-skewed, implying a mass of the research generated by a small number of individuals or institutions; that more than 50% researchers displayed no record of publications during the sampled period; and that only the performance of two research units affiliated with the Academia Sinica was comparable to that of the economics departments in the Sino-Pacific region, but not that of the rest of the institutions engaged in teaching.

1. 曹添旺、賴景昌、張峰嘉(2002)。台灣經濟學術單位在EconLit資料庫的學術表現。經濟論文，30，115-152。
   連結：
2. Arnold, T.,A.W. Bulter,T. F. Crack,A. Altintig(2003).Impact: What Influences Finance Research?.The Journal of Business,76,343-361.
3. Baltagi, B. H.(2003).Worldwide Institutional and Individual Rankings in Econometrics over the Period 1989-1999: An Update.Econometric Theory,19,165-224.
4. Baltagi, B. H.(1998).Worldwide Institutional Rankings in Econometrics: 1989-1995.Econometric Theory,14,1-43.
5. Brown, L. D.(1996).Influential Accounting Articles, Individuals, Ph.D. Granting Institutions and Faculties: A Citational Analysis.Accounting, Organizations and Society,21,723-754.
6. Brown, L. D.,R. J. Huefner(1994).The Familiarity with and Perceived Quality of Accounting Journals: Views of Senior Accounting Faculty in Leading U.S. MBA Programs.Contemporary Accounting Research,11,223-250.
7. Burton, M. P.,E. Phimister(1995).Core Journals: A Reappraisal of the Diamond List.The Economic Journal,105,361-373.
8. Coe, R. K.,I.Weinstock(1983).Evaluating the Finance Journals: The Department Chairperson's Perspective.Journal of Financial Research,6,345-349.
9. Combes, P.-P.,L. Linnemer(2001).La Publication d'Articles de Recherche en' Economie en France.Annales d'E'conomie et de Statistique,62,5-47.
10. Conroy, M. E.,R. Dusansky(1995).The Productivity of Economics Departments in the U.S.: Publications in the Core Journals.Journal of Economic Literature,33,1966-1971.
11. Coupé, T.(2001).Revealed Performances: Worldwide Rankings of Economists and Economics Departments.Working Paper, European Economic Association.
12. Diaz, J.,R. T. Black,J. Rabianski(1996).A Note on the Ranking of Real Estate Research Journals.Real Estate Economics,24,551-563.
13. Dusansky, R.,C. J. Vernon(1998).Ranking of U.S. Economics Departments.Journal of Economic Perspectives,12,157-170.
14. Extejt, M. M.,J. E. Smith(1990).The Behavioral Sciences and Management: An Evaluation of Relevant Journals.Journal of Management,16,539-551.
15. Graves, P.,J. Marchand,R. Thompson(1984).Economics Departmental Rankings: Reply and Errata.American Economic Review,74,834-836.
16. Holsapple, C. W.,L. E. Johnson,H. Manakyan,J. Tanner(1994).Business Computing Research Journals: A Normalized Citation Analysis.Journal of Management Information Systems,11,131-140.
17. Holsapple, C. W.,L. E. Johnson,H. Manakyan,J. Tanner(1993).A Citation Analysis of Business Computing Research Journal.Information and Management,25,231-244.
18. Jin, J. C.,L. Yau(1999).Research Productivity of the Economics Profession in East Asia.Economic Inquiry,37,706-710.
19. Jolly, S. A.,R. G. Schroeder,R. K. Spear(1995).An Empirical Investigation of the Relationship between Journal Quality Ratings and Promotion and Tenure Decisions.The Accounting Educators' Journal,7,47-68.
20. Kalaitzidakis P.,T. P. Mamuneas,T. Stengos(2003).Rankings of Academic Journals and Institutions in Economics.Journal of the European Economic Association,1,1346-1366.
21. Kalaitzidakis P.,T. P. Mamuneas,T. Stengos(1999).European Economics: An Analysis Based on Publications in the Core Journals.European Economic Review,43,1150-1168.
22. Laband, D. N.,M. J. Piette(1994).The Relative Impacts of Economics Journals: 1970-1990.Journal of Economic Literature,32,640-666.
23. Liebowitz, S. J.,J. C. Palmer(1984).Assessing the Relative Impacts of Economics Journals.Journal of Economic Literature,22,77-88.
24. Lubrano, M.,L. Bauwens,A. Kirman,C. Protopospescu(2003).Ranking Economics Departments in Europe: A Statistical Approach.Journal of the European Economic Association,1,1367-1401.
25. Mabry, R. H.,A. D. Sharplin(1985).The Relative Importance of Journals Used in Finance Research.Journal of Financial Research,8,287-296.
26. Oltheten, E.,N. Travlos,V. Theoharakis(2005).Faculty Perceptions and Readership Patterns of Finance Journals: A Global View.Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,40,223-239.
27. Scott, L. C.,P. M. Mitias(1996).Trends in Rankings of Economics Departments in the U.S.: An Update.Economic Inquiry,34,378-400.
28. Win, C. K.(1997).The Ranking of Construction Management Journals.Construction Management and Economics,15,387-398.
29. 朱敬一、許松根、于若蓉(1997)。國內經濟學相關期刊排序。國家科學委員會研究彙刊：人文及社會科學，7，445-473。
30. 許松根(1999)。經濟國際期刊的分等級群。國家科學委員會研究彙刊：人文及社會科學，9，505-521。

1. 蔡湘萍、俞明德、沈仰斌(2011)。台灣財金系所期刊著作表現之研究：2003-2008。財務金融學刊，19(1)，97-132。
2. 黃粲堯、曹添旺、吳俊彥、王泓仁(2014)。臺灣經濟學術單位近五年學術績效評估─前瞻式評比。人文及社會科學集刊，26(4)，555-582。
3. 黃粲堯、陳宜廷、曹添旺、張俊仁、林明仁、王泓仁(2013)。經濟學門學術期刊評比更新。經濟論文，41(3)，327-361。
4. 彭火樹、陳美惠、吳安妮、王泰昌(2016)。台灣會計學術單位期刊著作表現之再檢測。中華會計學刊，12(1)，115-192。
5. 楊浩彥,曹添旺,張俊仁,林常青,林明仁(2019)。經濟學門學術期刊評比更新：2019年。經濟論文叢刊，47(4)，503-542。
6. 袁易(2007)。建立對政治學門國際期刊的新共識。問題與研究，46(3)，173-204。