台灣地區企業信用評分系統的建置、驗證和比較

Developing, Validating, and Comparing Credit Scoring Systems in Taiwan

10.29628/AEP.200612.0004

鍾經樊(Ching-Fan Chung)；黃嘉龍(Jia-Long Huang)；黃博怡(Bor-Yi Huang)；謝有隆(Yiu-Long Hsieh)

信用評分 ； 驗證統計量 ； 變量轉換與篩選 ； 評分模型建置與驗證 ； Credit scoring ； Statistical validation ； Variable transformation and selection ； Credit scorecard development and validation

經濟論文

34卷4期（2006 / 12 / 01）

541 - 590

繁體中文

本文根據台灣新報資料庫所載數千家公開發行企業的三年財務報表資料，估計以違約與否為應變量、財務比例為解釋變量的Logit迴歸模型，並根據估計結果建置適用於企業信貸的信用評分卡。本文除詳細描述信用評分卡的建置過程外，特別強調信用評分卡雖可視為一個預測虛擬變量的計量經濟模型，但卻又和典型的實證經濟研究有很大的不同，這是因為不論在估計Logit模型之前還是在獲得迴歸係數之後，都必須採行諸多繁複的操作和分析，尤其重要的是建置信用評分卡前一定要保留部分樣本以驗證信用評分卡的預測績效。本文根據十多項驗證統計量統建模樣本之後的兩年資料來評估信用評分卡的預測績效，並證明我們所建置的信用評分卡在所有的績效指標上都優於台灣經濟新報所發佈的法本評等。在2006年底實施「新巴賽爾資本協定」的前夕，不論是對即將採行內部評等法以衡量信用風險的銀行，還是對政府金融監理機關，本文都有很適時的實用價值。白經濟學理來說，信用評分模型的發展有助於解決借貸市場中先天存在之訊息不對稱所造成的逆選擇和道德危機問題，從而增加借貸市場供給和需求兩方面的效率，更進而影響貨幣政策傳導機制，深具政策意義。

Using financial report data of thousands of public-issued companies over three years drawn from the TEJ (Taiwan Economic Journal) database, we develop credit scorecards for business landing based on the estimates of a Logit regression model. This paper emphasizes that the in-depth analysis and transformation of the original data before the estimation as well as testing and validation of the estimated model are much more important in developing credit scorecards than in a typical empirical econometric analysis. In particular, reserving a large percentage of data for the validation purpose is absolutely necessary when developing credit scorecards. Using two additional years of data as the validation sample, we show that our credit scorecards perform much better than the basic credit rating provided by the TEJ in terms of several performance statistics. Before implementing the new Basel Capital Accord at the end of 2006, this paper presents a timely contribution to both the banks which intend to adopt internal rating based approach and the governmental agencies which regulate the banking industry in managing credit risks.

1. 陳業寧、王衍智、許鴻英(2004)。台灣企業財務危機之預測－信用評分法與選擇權評價法孰優？。風險管理學報，6，155-179。
   連結：
2. 鍾經樊(2005)。評分系統的驗證。未發表論文。
   連結：
3. Altman, E. I.(1968).Financial Ratios, Discriminant Analysis and the Prediction of Corporate Bankruptcy.Journal of Finance,123,589-609.
4. Altman, E. I.,P. Narayanan(1997).An International Survey of Business Failure Classification Models.Financial Markets, Institutions and Instruments,6,1-57.
5. Bailey, M.(2004).Consumer Credit Quality: Underwriting, Scoring, Fraud Prevention and Collections.London:White Box.
6. Bailey, M.(2004).Credit Scoring: The Principles and Practicalities.London:White Box.
7. Basel Committee on Banking Supervision(2005).Studies on the Validation of Internal Rating Systems.Working Paper, No. 14.
8. Bluhm, C.,L. Overbeck,C. Wagner(2003).An Introduction to Credit Risk Modeling.Boca Raton, FL:Chapman and Hall/CRC.
9. Boyes, W. J.,D. L. Hoffman,S. A. Low(1989).An Econometric Analysis of the Bank Credit Scoring Problem.Journal of Econometrics,40,3-14.
10. Cover, T. M.,J. A. Thomas(1991).Elements of Information Theory.New York:Wiley.
11. de Servigny, A.,O. Renault(2004).Measuring and Managing Credit Risk.New York:McGraw-Hill.
12. Dwyer, D. W.(2005).Examples of Overfitting Encountered When Building Private Firm Default Prediction Models.one report from Moody's KMV.
13. Falkenstein, E.,L. V. Carty,A. Boral(2000).RiskCalc for Private Companies: Moody's Default Model.one report from Moody's Investors Service.
14. Hanley, J. A.,B. J. McNeil(1982).The Meaning and Use of the Area under an ROC Curve.Radiology,143,29-36.
15. Hosmer, D. W.,S. Lemeshow(2000).Applied Logistic Regression.New York:Wiley.
16. Jappelli, T.,M. Pagano(1993).Information Sharing in Credit Markets.Journal of Finance,48,1693-1718.
17. Jappelli, T.,M. Pagano(2002).Information Sharing, Lending and Defaults: Cross-Country Evidence.Journal of Banking and Finance,26,2023-2054.
18. Klein, D. B.(1992).Promise Keeping in the Great Society: A Model of Credit Information Sharing.Economics and Politics,4,117-136.
19. Mays, E.(2001).Handbook of Credit Scoring.New York:AMACOM.
20. Mays, E.(1998).Credit Risk Modeling: Design and Application.New York:AMACOM.
21. Mester, L. J.(1997).What's the Point of Credit Scoring?.Business Review,September,3-16.
22. Ohlson, J. M.(1980).Financial Ratios and the Probabilistic Prediction of Bankruptcy.Journal of Accounting Research,18,109-131.
23. Padilla, A. J.,M. Pagano(1997).Endogenous Communication among Lenders and Entrepreneurial Incentives.Review of Financial Studies,10,205-236.
24. Padilla, A. J.,M. Pagano(2000).Sharing Default Information as a Borrower Discipline Device.European Economic Review,44,1951-1980.
25. Pepe, M. S.(2003).The Statistical Evaluation of Medical Tests for Classification and Prediction.Oxford:Oxford University Press.
26. Roszbach, K.(2004).Bank Lending Policy, Credit Scoring, and the Survival of Loans.Review of Economics and Statistics,86,946-958.
27. Sobehart, J. R.,S. C. Keenan,R. M. Stein(2000).Benchmarking Quantitative Default Risk Models: A Validation Methodology.one report from Moody's Investors Service.
28. Swets, J.(1988).Measuring the Accuracy of Diagnostic Systems.Science,240,1285-1293.
29. Thomas, L. C.,D. B. Edelman,J. N. Crook(2002).Credit Scoring and Its Applications.Philadelphia, PA:SIAM.
30. Vercammen, J. A.(1995).Credit Bureau Policy and Sustainable Reputation Effects in Credit Markets.Economica,62,461-478.
31. 丁正中(2004)。消費金融信用風險研究－信用評分概述。信用資訊，4，1-32。
32. 阮正治、江景清(2004)。台灣企業信用評分模型建置與驗證。信用資訊，4，1-16。

1. 鄧家駒、鄭宇庭、蔡紋琦、林孟寬(2013)。企業信用評等模型－以營造業為例。數據分析，8(3)，71-90。
2. 李堅明、江振興(2011)。綠色信用評等機制與融資決策模式。台灣金融財務季刊，12(4)，43-69。
3. 蘇志雄、陳冠宇(2009)。應用資料採礦技術建置台灣中小企業電子業信用評等模型。數據分析，4(5)，23-54。
4. (2011)。綠色信用評等機制與融資決策模式。台灣金融財務季刊，12(4)，43-69。