強制汽車責任保險理賠風險分析－Malmquist指數之應用

A Risk Analysis of Compulsory Automobile Liability Insurance: An Application of Malmquist Productivity Index

10.29628/AEP.200806.0004

王雪屏(Hsueh-Ping Wang)；謝聰敏(Tsung-Min Hsieh)；張靜貞(Ching-Cheng Chang)；陸怡蕙(Yir-Hueih Luh)；徐世勳(Shih-Hsun Hsu)

強制汽車責任保險 ； 資料包絡分析法 ； Malmquist指數 ； 風險評估 ； Compulsory automobile liability insurance ； Data envelopment analysis ； Malmquist index ； Risk assessment

經濟論文

36卷2期（2008 / 06 / 01）

195 - 220

繁體中文

強制汽車責任保險屬強制性質之政策性保險，任何車輛都應納入投保範圍，並採「無過失主義」及「無盈無虧」方式經營，以所有車主繳納的保險費，承擔共同的理賠風險，然而目前相關文獻大多僅考量從人因素或從車因素，甚少從理賠風險的變動來源探討保費之合理性。本研究利用資料包絡分析法前緣的概念，以受測單位與風險前緣的相對距離作為度量其相對風險高低之依據，並利用Malmquist生產力指數易於拆解的優點，區別不同風險的來源，建立一新的汽車責任保險風險評估模式。本文先將總風險變動拆解為個別車種風險變動與行車風險變動，由於個別車種風險變動代表在固定風險前緣下，保險費收入不變而理賠金額增加，或是理賠金額不變但保險費收入減少之狀態，為了探討個別風險來源，本研究進一步將其區分為純車種風險及規模風險兩類。研究結果顯示，近五年汽車強制責任險的總風險呈微幅上升的趨勢，其主要來源是規模風險的增加，因此建議調降理賠金額與調高汽車使用燃料費，以降低風險，至於行車風險則呈現下降的現象，顯示政府修法以導正駕駛人的行車習慣已經達到某種程度的效果。

The compulsory automobile liability insurance is a mandatory government program in which all automobile owners are required to buy the policy under the no fault liability principle. The premiums are based on the goal of ”zero-profit-zero-loss” by spreading the risks among domestic co-insurers. Most literature evaluates the fairness of the premiums based on either the personal or vehicle factors, without due consideration of the dynamic relationship among various sources of risks and premium payments. This study integrates the concept of data envelopment analysis (DEA) and mean-variance portfolio frontier into a distance-function-based premium-indemnity efficient frontier. Premium (the insurance cost) is treated as an input while indemnity (the risk coverage) is treated as an output for each vehicle type. The efficient frontier is established to select the most preferred premium-indemnity combination among its boundary points by either maximizing total indemnities under given premiums or minimizing total premiums under given indemnities. The Malmquist index decomposition is then adopted to decompose the changes of total risks across two periods into the vehicle risk and travel risk components. The vehicle risk component measures the efficiency changes of the premium-indemnity combination and represents how much the risk coverage can be increased without changing the premium or how much the premium can be reduced without affecting the coverage. It can be further decomposed into changes of pure vehicle risk and scale risk. The empirical results indicate that the vehicle risk has increased over the past five years due to the sharp increase of scale risk, but travel risk has decreased at the same time due to better enforcement of safe driving habits. Therefore, a coupling of lower indemnity with higher fuel tax to reduce travel intensity is proposed as a policy solution to improve the efficiency of the compulsory insurance program.

1. Banker, R. D.,A. Charnes,W. W. Cooper(1984).Some Models for Estimating Technical and Scale Inefficiencies in Data Envelopment Analysis.Management Science,30,1078-1092.
2. Bradbury, M. E.,P. Rouse(2002).An Application of Data Envelopment Analysis to the Evaluation of Audit.Abacus,38,263-279.
3. Briec, W.,K. Kerstens(2008).Multi-Horizon Markowitz Portfolio Performance Appraisals: A General Approach.Omega
4. Briec, W.,K. Kerstens,J. B. Lesourd(2004).Single Period Markowitz Portfolio Selection, Performance Gauging and Duality: A Variation on the Luenberger Shortage Function.Journal of Optimization Theory and Applications,120,1-27.
5. Briec, W.,K. Kerstens,O. Jokung(2007).Mean-Variable Portfolio Performance Gauging: A General Shortage Function and Dual Approach.Management Science,53,135-149.
6. Caves, D. W.,L. R. Christensen,W. E. Diewert(1982).The Economic Theory of Index Numbers of the Measurement of Input, Output and Productivity.Econometrica,50,1393-1414.
7. Charnes, A.,W. W. Cooper,A. Y. Lewin,R. C. Morey,J. Rausseau(1985).Sensitivity and Stability Analysis in DEA.Annals of Operations Research,2,139-156.
8. Charnes, A.,W. W. Cooper,E. Rhodes(1978).Measuring the Efficiency of Decision-Making Units.European Journal of Operations Research,2,429-444.
9. Coelli, T.,D. S. Prasada Rao,C. J. O`Donnell,G. E. Battese(2005).An Introduction to Efficiency and Productivity Analysis.New York:Springer.
10. Davutyan, N.,L. Kavut(2005).An Application of Data Envelopment Analysis to the Evaluation of Audit Risk: A Reinterpretation.Abacus,41,290-306.
11. Färe, R.,S. Grosskopf,M. Norris,Z. Zhant(1994).Productivity Growth, Technical Progress, and Efficiency Change in Industrialized Countries.The American Economic Review,84,66-83.
12. Färe, R.,S. Grosskopf,W. L. Weber(1989).Measuring School District Performance.Public Finance Quarterly,17,409-428.
13. Farrell, M. J.(1957).The Measurement of Productive Efficiency.Journal of the Royal Statistical Society,120,253-290.
14. Kroll, Y.,H. Levy,H. M. Markowtiz(1984).Mean-Variance versus Direct Utility Maximization.Journal of Finance,39,47-61.
15. Luenberger, D. G.(1995).Microeconomic Theory.New York:McGraw-Hill.
16. McGwin, G.,D. B. Brown(1999).Characteristics of Traffic Crashes among Young, Middle-Aged and Older Drivers.Accident Analysis and Prevention,31,181-198.
17. Metzger, L. M.(1994).Operational Auditing and DEA: Measuring Branch Office Efficiency.Internal Auditing,10,3-12.
18. Miltz, D.,G. J. Calomme,M. Willekens(1991).A Risk-Based Allocation of Internal Audit Time: A Case Study.Auditing: A Journal of Practice and Theory,10,49-61.
19. Sherman, H. D.(1984).Data Envelopment Analysis as a New Managerial Audit Methodology-Test and Evaluation.Auditing: A Journal of Practice and Theory,4,35-53.
20. Sloan, F. A.,P. B. Githens(1995).Drinking, Driving, and the Price of Automobile Insurance.Insurance: Mathematics and Economics,16,171-190.
21. Worthington, A. C.(2000).Technical Efficiency and Technological Changes in Australian Building Societies.Abacus,36,180-197.
22. 財團法人保險事業發展中心(2005)。強制汽車責任保險精算及研究發展工作小組九十四年度費率精算報告。台北:財團法人保險事業發展中心。
23. 張新立、吳宗修、王國川、葉純志、吳晉光(2000)。國內外道路交通安全講習教育制度之比較研究。交通部運輸研究所合作研究計畫。
24. 楊祥芝(1993)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。國立台灣大學財務金融學研究所。
25. 劉純之(1997)。汽車保險費率與獎懲制度。保險專刊，49，60-82。
26. 魏長賢(1995)。碩士論文(碩士論文)。逢甲大學統計與精算研究所。

1. 陳彥志,許文彥(2023)。行駛里程在遊覽車保險的定價。保險專刊，39(2)，137-159。
2. 許文彥(2019)。廣義線性模型在強制汽車責任保險的應用。保險專刊，35(4)，385-403。
3. 許文彥(2020)。廣義線性模型在自用小客貨車汽車車體損失保險訂價的應用。保險專刊，36(2)，159-187。
4. 黃台心、梁嘉惠、高棟梁、姜麗智(2010)。我國壽險業考慮準固定投入後的效率與生產力變動分析。東吳經濟商學學報，68，1-38。