自由匯率制度的政策效果與隔絕功能

Macroeconomic Policies and Insulation Properties under the Free Exchange Rate System

10.29628/AEP.201106.0004

曹添旺(Tien-Wang Tsaur)

自由匯率制度 ； 通貨替代 ； 匯率動態 ； 貨幣自主性 ； 外國通貨膨脹 ； 隔絕功能 ； Free exchange rate system ； Currency substitution ； Exchange rate dynamics ； Monetary independence ； Foreign inflation ； Insulation properties

經濟論文

39卷2期（2011 / 06 / 01）

91 - 123

繁體中文

本文將Chen (1973)自由匯率制度（即允許居民持有外幣的浮動匯率制度）的兩國模型簡約為小國的分析架構，藉此研究總體政策（包括財政政策和貨幣政策）及國外干擾對小型開放經濟產出與實質匯率的影響，並據以探討自由匯率制度的貨幣自主性、隔絕功能及其與通貨替代的關係。我們的分析發現：通貨替代程度、國外通貨膨脹率的大小、以及國外通貨需求的成本彈性等模型的結構參數，是影響本國政策效果、貨幣自主性與隔絕功能的判定因素。當國外通貨膨脹率恰為某一定值（從而貿易條件的變化對經常帳沒有影響），或兩種通貨獨立無關，則無論兩種通貨的替代彈性是大或小，本國皆具有貨幣自主性；在其他情況下，自由匯率制度下貨幣政策效果的大小，要看兩種通貨究竟是毛替代或毛補充而定，並非如Miles (1978)所謂：單憑通貨替代彈性的高低即可決定貨幣自主性的強弱。

This paper reduces Chen's (1973) two-country, two-money model to the conventional small-economy with currency substitution model to investigate the effects of macroeconomic policies and foreign inflation under the free exchange rate system (i.e., flexible exchange rates without restrictions on holding outer currencies). It has been shown that the relative magnitude among the currency substitution elasticity, the cost (interest) elasticity of holding currency, the foreign monetary growth rate, and trade elasticities determine critically the steady-state values and dynamic properties of real exchange rates. Given other relevant parameters, the relative value of the currency substitution elasticity to the currency cost (interest) elasticity rather than the absolute value of the currency substitution elasticity, in turn, is crucial in influencing the monetary independence and the insulation effect of the free exchange rate system. The results differ significantly from Miles's (1978) argument that ”the degree to which inflation will be transmitted between the countries will of course be proportional to the degree of substitution between currencies.”

1. 曹添旺、黃俊傑(2005)。通貨替代、貿易彈性與實質匯率動態。經濟論文，33，175-200。
   連結：
2. Végh, C. A. (1989b), “Currency Substitution and the Optimal Inflation Tax under Labor Income Taxation,” Working Paper, International Monetary Fund.
3. Benhabib, J.,Perli, R.(1994).Uniqueness and Indeterminacy: On the Dynamics of Endogenous Growth.Journal of Economic Theory,63,113-142.
4. Bordo, M. D.,Choudhri, E. U.(1982).Currency Substitution and the Demand for Money: Some Evidence for Canada.Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking,14,48-57.
5. Calvo, G. A.(1985).Currency Substitution and the Real Exchange Rate: The Utility Maximization Approach.Journal of International Money and Finance,14,175-188.
6. Calvo, G. A.,Rodriguez, C.(1977).A Model of Exchange Rate Determination under Currency Substitution and Rational Expectation.Journal of Political Economy,85,617-625.
7. Caves, R. E.(ed.),Johnson, H. G.(ed.)(1968).Readings in International Economics.Homewood, IL:Irwin.
8. Chen, C. N.(1975).Fixed versus Flexible Exchange Rates: A Reservoir Simile.Journal of Monetary Economics,1,265-271.
9. Chen, C. N.(1973).Diversified Currency Holdings and Flexible Exchange Rates.Quarterly Journal of Economics,87,96-111.
10. Chen, C. N.,Tsaur, T. W.(1983).Currency Substitution and Foreign Inflation.Quarterly Journal of Economics,98,177-184.
11. Chen, C. N.,Tsaur, T. W.(1995).Foreign Monetary Shocks and Adjustments of Domestic Prices, Exchange Rates and Terms of Trade.Academia Economic Papers,23,25-42.
12. Chen, C. N.,Tsaur, T. W.(1992).Currency Substitution, Factor Demand Theory, and the Dynamics of Exchange Rates.Academia Economic Papers,20,313-335.
13. Chen, C. N.,Tsaur, T. W.,Chou, C. F.(1981).Gross Substitution, Gresham's Law, and Hayek's Free Currency System.Journal of Macroeconomics,3,547-557.
14. Chen, C. N.,Tsaur, T. W.,Liu, S. C.(1989).Foreign Inflation, Currency Substitution, and Terms of Trade Dynamics.Journal of Political Economy,97,955-964.
15. Devereux, M.,Purvis, D.(1990).Fiscal Policy and the Real Exchange Rate.European Economic Review,34,1201-1211.
16. Engel, C.(1989).The Trade Balance and Real Exchange Rate under Currency Substitution.Journal of International Money and Finance,8,47-58.
17. Freitas, M. L.,Veiga, F. J.(2006).Currency Substitution, Portfolio Diversification, and Money Demand.Canadian Journal of Economics,39,719-743.
18. Frenkel, J.,Mussa, M. L.(1985).Asset Markets, Exchange Rates and the Balance of Payments.NBER Working Paper,1287
19. Lapan, H. E.,Enders, W.(1983).Rational Expectations, Endogenous Currency Substitution, and Exchange Rate Determination.Quarterly Journal of Economics,98,427-439.
20. Liviatan, N.(1981).Monetary Expansion and Real Exchange Rate Dynamics.Journal of Political Economy,89,1218-1227.
21. McKinnon, R. I.(1982).Currency Substitution and Instability in the World Dollar Standard.American Economic Review,72,320-333.
22. Miles, M. A.(1978).Currency Substitution, Flexible Exchange Rate, and Monetary Independence.American Economic Review,68,428-436.
23. Mundell, R.(1969).Toward a Better International Monetary System.Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking,1,625-648.
24. Niehans, J.(1977).Exchange Rate Dynamics with Stock/Flow Interaction.Journal of Political Economy,85,1245-1257.
25. Park, W.(1987).Crawling Peg, Inflation Hedges and Exchange Rate Dynamics.Journal of International Economics,23,131-150.
26. Sahay, R.,Végh, C.(1996).Inflation and Stabilization in Transition Economies: An Analytical Interpretation of the Evidence.Journal of Policy Reform,1,75-108.
27. Uribe, M.(1999).Comparing the Welfare Costs and Initial Dynamics of Alternative Inflation Stabilization Policies.Journal of Development Economics,59,295-318.
28. van der Ploeg, F.(ed.)(1994).Handbook of International Macroeconomics.Cambridge, MA:Blackwell.
29. Végh, C. A.(1989).Government Spending and Inflationary Finance: A Public Finance Approach.International Monetary Fund Staff Papers,14,679-694.
30. Végh, C. A.(1989).The Optimal Inflation Tax in the Presence of Currency Substitution.Journal of Monetary Economics,24,139-146.
31. Végh, C. A.(1995).Inflationary Finance and Currency Substitution in a Public Finance Framework.Journal of International Money and Finance,14,679-693.
32. 曹添旺(1987)。通貨替代、通貨膨脹、匯率調整與貨幣中立性。經濟論文叢刊，15，367-398。
33. 劉大中、蔣碩傑、顧應昌、費景漢、邢慕寰、鄒至莊(1974)。今後台灣財經政策的研討。當前台灣經濟問題座談會，台北:
34. 劉遵義(2009)。貨幣替代。紀念陳昭南院士學術研討會，台北:
35. 賴景昌(1994)。國際金融理論：進階篇。台北:茂昌圖書有限公司。

1. 曹添旺、曹真睿(2013)。輸入性通貨膨脹與實質匯率動態。經濟論文叢刊，41(4)，403-441。
2. 曹添旺、胡玫英(2010)。關稅與實質匯率動態。經濟論文叢刊，38(4)，501-522。
3. 曹添旺、吳家瑋(2013)。考慮Tobin稅之通貨替代模型─實質匯率動態與匯率穩定。經濟論文，41(4)，559-596。