老人醫療利用的價格效果－以921震災的自然實驗為例

The Price Effect of Medical Care Utilization for the Elderly: A Natural Experiment of the 921 Chi-Chi Earthquake

蔡偉德(Wei-Der Tsai)；陳芝嘉(Chih-Chia Chen)；余清祥(Jack C. Yue)

921震災 ； 老人醫療利用 ； 醫療價格彈性 ； 就醫免部分負擔 ； 非線性差異中之差異估計模型 ； 921 Earthquake ； Medical care utilization of elderly ； Price elasticity of medical care demand ； Copayment exemption ； Nonlinear difference-in-difference

經濟論文

42卷4期（2014 / 12 / 01）

599 - 645

繁體中文

本文利用民國88年921震災後，政府對災民發放921震災卡之免部分負擔的優惠為一自然實驗，以災區（南投縣及台中縣）原本即享有就醫免部分負擔的榮民榮眷、並具有災民身份者為控制組，同時以非災區（彰化及雲林縣）的榮民榮眷但非災民者、以及災區領有921震災健保卡之災民為兩個實驗組。將差異中之差異分析方法應用於非線性模型（負二項分配迴歸模型及二部模型），分析65歲以上老人之健保醫療利用的價格彈性。在控制時間趨勢與族群差異後，本文研究發現在相同的震災處置效果下，921震災健保卡之價格補貼顯著提升災民的門診醫療利用3.24次（男性樣本則為3.50次），門診價格彈性為－0.05（男性樣本為－0.06），但對住院醫療利用卻無明顯地影響，政府的免部分負擔政策期滿終止後，災民的門診醫療利用不再明顯地增加。在控制價格補貼的處置效果下，震災傷害提高老人門診醫療利用4.63次（男性樣本為4.55次），災後第一年的住院機率增加10.37%（男性樣本為12.58%），災後第二年增幅降為2.66%（男性樣本為3.29%），災後第三年則無顯著的變化，顯然震災傷害對老人醫療利用的影響大於價格補貼的效果。本文對老人醫療利用的估計結果，可提供政府對天然災害醫療救助補貼及控制老人醫療支出政策參考依據。

This study aims to analyze the effect of price changes on the medical care utilization of the elderly aged 65 and above. The 921 Chi-Chi earthquake occurred on September 21, 1999, and caused severe damage to the central part of Taiwan, especially Nantou and Taichung Counties. Immediately following the earthquake, Taiwan’s government provided medical aid to the victims via waiving the NHI copayments of ambulatory care for one year and of inpatient care for two years. We use the 921 earthquake as a natural experiment to investigate how the elderly reacted to the copayment exemption. By using the difference-in-difference in nonlinear regression specification, on one hand, we compare a group of veterans, who were victims and lived in the affected areas, with nonveteran victims, to identify the effect of price subsidization. On the other hand, we compared the victim veterans living in the affected area with the non-victim veterans living in the unaffected area to identify the impact of earthquake damage on the medical care utilization. Our empirical results show that the government copayment exemption policy increased the mean number of outpatient visits per person by 3.24 for all observations and 3.5 for the male sample, and had no effect on inpatient care either in the probability of hospitalization or length of stay after hospitalization. The earthquake resulted in an increase of 4.63 in the mean number of outpatient visits per person for all observations (4.55 for the male sample), and an increase of 10.37% and 2.66% in the likelihood of hospitalization roughly (12.58% and 3.29% for the male sample), respectively, in the first year and second year following the earthquake. The price elasticity of outpatient care for the elderly was about -0.05 for all observations and -0.06 for the male sample. Our empirical results provide some policy implications regarding the control of the growth of medical costs for the elderly.

1. 許績天、韓幸紋、連賢明、羅光達(2011)。部分負擔調整對醫療利用的衝擊─以2005年政策調整為例。台灣衛誌，30，326-335。
   連結：
2. 韓幸紋、連賢明(2008)。降低部分負擔對幼兒醫療利用的影響─以北市兒童補助計畫為例。經濟論文叢刊，36，589-623。
   連結：
3. Ai, C.,Norton, E. C.(2003).Interaction Terms in Logit and Probit Models.Economics Letters,80,123-129.
4. Athey, S.,Imbens, G. W.(2006).Identification and Inference in Nonlinear Difference-in-Differences Models.Econometrica,74(2),431-497.
5. Bird, C. E.,Shugarman, L. R.,Lynn, J.(2002).Age and Gender Differences in Health Care Utilization and Spending for Medicare Beneficiaries in Their Last Years of Life.Journal of Palliative Medicine,5(5),705-712.
6. Buchmueller, T. C.,Couffinhal, A.,Grignon, M.,Perronnin, M.(2004).Access to Physician Services: Does Supplemental Insurance Matter? Evidence from France.Health Economics,13,667-687.
7. Cameron, A. C.,Gelbach, J. B.,Moller, D. L.(2006).NBER Technical Working Paper, No. 327NBER Technical Working Paper, No. 327,未出版
8. Cameron, A. C.,Trivedi, P. K.(1998).Regression Analysis of Count Data.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
9. Cameron, A. M.,Patricia, K.,Anita, K.,Teresa, M.(1998).Sex Differences in the Use of Health Care Services.New England Journal of Medicine,338,1678-1683.
10. Chandra, A.,Gruber, J.,McKnight, R.(2010).Patient Cost-Sharing and Hospitalization Offsets in the Elderly.American Economic Review,100(1),193-213.
11. Duan, N.,Manning, W. G.,Morris, C. N.,Newhouse, J. P.(1983).A Comparison of Alternative Models for the Demand for Medical Care.Journal of Business & Economic Statistics,1(2),115-126.
12. Hurd, M. D.,McGarry, K.(1997).Medical Insurance and Use of Health Care Services by the Elderly.Journal of Health Economics,16,129-154.
13. King, G.(1988).Statistical Models for Political Science Event Counts: Bias in Conventional Procedures and Evidence for the Exponential Poisson Regression Model.American Journal of Political Science,32(3),838-863.
14. Kondo, M.,Hoshi, S. L.,Okubo, I.(2009).Does Subsidy Work? Price Elasticity of Demand for Influenza Vaccination among the Elderly in Japan.Health Policy,91(3),269-276.
15. Liang, N. J.,Shih, Y. T.,Shih, F. Y.,Wu, H. M.,Wang, H. J.,Shi, S. F.,Liu, M. Y.,Wang, B.(2001).Disaster Epidemiology and Medical Response in the Chi-Chi Earthquake in Taiwan.Annals of Emergency Medicine,38(5),549-555.
16. Liu, L. F.,Tian, W. H.,Yao, H. P.(2012).Utilization of Health Care Services by Elderly People with National Health Insurance in Taiwan: The Heterogeneous Health Profile Approach.Health Policy,108,246-255.
17. Manning, W. G.,Newhouse, J. P.,Duan, N.(1987).Health Insurance and the Demand for Medical Care: Evidence from Randomized Experiment.American Economic Review,77(3),251-277.
18. Meyer, B. D.(1995).Natural and Quasi-Experiments in Economics.Journal of Business & Economic Statistics,13(2),151-161.
19. Mullahy, J.(1999).NBER Technical Working Paper, No. 245NBER Technical Working Paper, No. 245,未出版
20. Schellhorn, M.(2001).The Effect of Variable Health Insurance Deductibles on the Demand for Physician Visits.Health Economics,10(5),441-456.
21. van Vliet, R. C. J. A.(2004).Deductibles and Health Care Expenditures: Empirical Estimates of Price Sensitivity Based on Administrative Data.International Journal of Health Care Finance and Economics,4,283-305.
22. Wooldridge, J. M.(2013).Introductory Econometrics: A Modern Approach.Mason, OH:South-Western Cengage Learning.
23. 李丞華、周穎政(2000)。中央健康保險局研究計畫中央健康保險局研究計畫,未出版
24. 洪錦墩、郭慈安、李卓倫、陳文意、黃光華、施雅文(2010)。老年人於全民健康保險中醫門診醫療服務之利用分析。台灣老人保健學刊，6，136-157。

1. 陳麗旭,張景福(2023)。公共基礎建設對廠商生產力的影響：以921地震的自然試驗為例。經濟研究，59(2)，215-260。